A Design Approach to Assess Effects of Non-Contact Underwater Explosions on Naval Composite Vessels

Abstract

Despite the non-contact underwater explosion phenomena (UNDEX) have been studied for decades and several numerical methods have been proposed in literature, its effects on military structures, especially composite ones, are even nowadays matter of research. In early design phases, it is not always possible to verify the shock resistance of hull structures modelling the whole phenomenon, in which fluid, gas and solid properties must be properly set in a fully coupled fluid-structure interaction (FSI) numerical model. These ones are extremely complex to set, computationally demanding and certainly not suitable for everyday design practice. In this paper, a simplified finite element (FE) model, easy to use in an early design phase, is proposed. Both, the structure and the fluid are simulated. In this approximation, the fluid behaviour is simplified, using special finite elements, available in a commercial software environment. This choice reduces the computational time and numerical efforts avoiding the problem of combining computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and FE domains and equations in a fully coupled fluid-structure interaction model. A typical parallel body block of a minesweeper is modelled, using two-dimensional multi-layered shell elements to properly account for the composite materials behaviour. For the fluid instead, three dimensional volumetric elements, directly coupled to the structural elements, are placed. In addition, the same calculation is performed, modelling separately fluid in the CFD environment and structures in the finite element one. Thus, realizing a fully coupled fluid-structure interaction model. The results obtained by applying both numerical models are compared with the structural response measured on board of a composite ship during a full-scale shock test. The simplified proposed procedure provides results in satisfactory agreement with experiments, allowing the validation of the model. Approximations are discussed and differences with the real phenomenon and fully coupled CFD+FE method are shown, providing a better understanding of the phenomena. Eventually, the modelling strategy has been considered a valuable and cost-effective tool for the concept and preliminary design of composite structures subject to underwater explosions.

Keywords

Underwater explosions / Shock resistance / Composites / Fluid-structure interaction / Experimental analysis / Numerical simulation / Vulnerability / Preliminary design

References

[] ADINA. . Theory and Modeling Guide, Volumes I–III, 2015 Watertown ADINA R & D, Inc.

[] Arora H, Hooper P, Dear J. The effects of air and underwater blast on composite sandwich panels and tubular laminate structures. Experimental Mechanics, 2012, 52(1): 59-81,

[] Barrè S, Chotard T, Benzeggagh ML. Comparative study of strain rate effects on mechanical properties of glass fibre reinforced thermoset matrix composites. Composites Part A, 1996, 27A: 1169-1181,

[] Bathe KJ. . Finite element procedures, 2014 Watertown Bathe KJ

[] Bathe KJ, Zhang H, Ji S. Finite element analysis of fluid flows fully coupled with structural interactions. Computers & Structures, 1999, 72: 1-16,

[] Batra RC, Hassan NM. Response of fiber reinforced composites to underwater explosive loads. Composites Part B, 2007, 38: 448-468,

[] Clough RW, Penzien J. . Dynamics of structures, 1995 Berkeley Computer & Structures inc.

[] Cole RH (1914) Underwater explosions. Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution

[] Costanzo FA (2010) Underwater Explosion Phenomena and Shock Physics. Society for Experimental Mechanics Inc

[] Dvorkin E, Bathe KJ. A continuum mechanics based four-node shell element for general nonlinear Analysis. Engineering Computations, 1984, 1: 77-88,

[] Ewins DJ. . Modal Testing: Theory, Practice and Application, 2000 Hertfordshire Research Studies Press LTD

[] Felippa CA, DeRuntz JA. Acoustic fluid volume modeling by the displacement potential formulation, with emphasis on the wedge element. Computers & Structures, 1991, 41(4): 669-686,

[] Gaiotti M, Rizzo CM. Finite element modeling strategies for sandwich composite laminates under compressive loadings. Ocean Engineering, 2013, 63: 44-51,

[] Gaiotti M, Rizzo CM, Branner K, Berring P. A high order Mixed Interpolation Tensorial Components (MITC) shell element approach for modeling the buckling behavior of delaminated composites. Composite Structures, 2014, 108: 657-666,

[] Gannon L. Simulation of underwater explosions in close-proximity to a submerged cylinder and a free-surface or rigid boundary. Journal of Fluids and Structures, 2019, 87: 189-205,

[] Geers TL. Doubly asymptotic approximation for transient motions of submerged structures. J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 1978, 64(5): 1500-8,

[] Geers TL. Residual potential and approximate method for three-dimensional fluid structure interaction problems. J. Acoust. Soc. Am., 1971, 49(5): 1505-10, Part 2

[] Geers TL, Hunter KS (2002) An integrated wave-effects model for an underwater explosion bubble. Acoustical Society of America. https://doi.org/10.1121/1.1458590

[] Gong Y, Zhang W, Du Z. Damage mechanisms of a typical simplified hull girder with thinner plates subjected to near-field underwater explosions. Ocean Engineering, 2023, 285(2): 115403,

[] Green Associates E (1999) Marine Composites. Eric Greene Associates

[] Halpin JC, Nicolais L (1971) Materiali compositi: relazioni tra proprietà e struttura. Ingegnere Chimico Italiano

[] Keil AH (1961) The Response of Ships to Underwater Explosions. Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers

[] Kong X, Gao H, Jin Z, Zheng C, Wang Y. Predictions of the responses of stiffened plates subjected to underwater explosion based on machine learning. Ocean Engineering, 2023, 283: 115216,

[] Latourte F, Gregoire D, Zenkert D, Wei X, Espinosa HD (2011) Failure mechanisms in composite panels subjected to under water impulsive loads. J. Mech. Phys. Solids. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmps.2011.04.013

[] LeBlanc J, Shukla A. Dynamic response and damage evolution in composite material subjected to underwater loading: experimental and computational comparisons. Composite Structures, 2010, 92: 2421-2430,

[] Li L, Airaudo FN, Löhner R. Study of underwater explosion near rigid cylinder column with numerical method. Ocean Engineering, 2023, 270: 113294,

[] Liang C, Tai Y. Shock responses of a surface ship subjected to noncontact underwater explosions. Ocean Engineering, 2006, 33: 748-772,

[] Mannacio F (2023) The effect of underwater explosion on a mine countermeasures vessel: structural response and material design. PhD Thesis. University of Genoa

[] Mannacio F, Barbato A, Gaiotti M, Rizzo CM, Venturini M (2021) Analysis of the underwater explosion shock effects on a typical naval ship foundation structure: experimental and numerical investigation. MARSTRUCT 2021 Congress. 7–9 June 2021. Trondheim. https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003230373-8

[] Mannacio F, Barbato A, Di Marzo F, Gaiotti M, Rizzo CM, Venturini M. Shock effects of underwater explosion on naval ship foundations: Validation of numerical models by dedicated tests. Ocean Engineering, 2022, 253: 111290,

[] Mair HU. Benchmarks for submerged structure response to underwater explosions. Shock and Vibration, 1999, 6: 169-181,

[] Mariperman. . Relazione n. 02747, 1988 La Spezia Commissione Permanente per gli Esperimenti del Materiale da Guerra

[] ME’scope VES. . Tutorial Manual. Volume IA, 2014 Scotts Valley Vibrant Technology, Inc.

[] MIL-S-901-D (1989) Shock tests, h. i. (high-impact) shipboard machinery, equipment, and systems, requirements. United States Department of Defense

[] Ming FR, Zhang AM, Xue YZ, Wang SP. Damage characteristics of ship structures subjected to shockwaves of underwater contact explosions. Ocean Engineering, 2016, 117: 359-38,

[] NAV-30-A001 (1986) Norme per l’esecuzione delle prove d’urto su macchinari ed apparecchiature di bordo. Ministero della Difesa, Istituto Poligrafico dello Stato

[] NAVSEA 0908-LP-000-3010, Rev. 1 (1995) Shock Design Criteria for Surface Ships. Naval Sea Systems Command

[] Petralia S. . Compendio di esplosivistica, 2000 La Spezia MARIPERMAN

[] Scavuzzo RJ, Pusey HC (2002) Naval Shock Analysis and Design. The Shock and Vibration Analysis Center. HI-TEST Laboratories, Inc

[] Smith C. S (1990) Design of Marine Structures in Composite Materials. Elsevier, Applied Science

[] SMM/CN 300 DVD (1978) Criteri e metodi per il proporzionamento e la qualificazione antiurto dei componenti destinati alle Unità navali. Stato Maggiore Marina. Istituto Poligrafico dello Stato

[] Sommerfeld M, Müller HM. Experimental and numerical studies of shock wave focusing in water. Experiments in Fluids, 1988, 6: 209-216,

[] STANAG 4141 (1976) Shock testing of equipment for surface ships. NATO Standardization Agreement

[] Sussman T, Sundqvist J. Fluid-structure interaction analysis with a subsonic potential-based fluid formulation. Computers & Structures, 2003, 81: 949-962,

[] Swisdak MM Jr. . Explosion effects and properties. Part II. Explosion effects in water, 1978 Silver Spring Md Naval Surface Weapons Center White Oak Lab,

[] Szturomski B (2015) The effect of an underwater explosion on a ship. Scientific Journal of Polish Naval Academy. https://doi.org/10.5604/0860889X.1172074

[] Tran P, Wua C, Saleh M, Neto LB, Nguyen-Xuan H, Ferreira AJM. Composite structures subjected to underwater explosive loadings: a comprehensive review. Composite Structures, 2021, 263: 113684,

[] Vannucchi de Camargo F (2019) Survey on Experimental and Numerical Approaches to Model Underwater Explosions. Journal of Marine Science and Engineering. https://doi.org/10.3390/jmse7010015

[] Wei X, Tran P, De Vaucorbeil A, Ramaswamy RB, Latourte F, Espinosa HD. Three-dimensional numerical modeling of composite panels subjected to underwater blast. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 2013, 61: 1319-1336,

[] Welsh L, Harding J. Effect of strain rate on the tensile failure of woven reinforced polyester resin composites. Journal de Physique Colloques, 1985, 46(C5): 405-414

[] Zhang A, Shi-Min L, Pu C, Shuai L, Yun-Long L. A unified theory for bubble dynamics. Physics of Fluids, 2023, 35(3): 033323,

[] Zhang H, Bathe KJ (2001) Direct and Iterative Computing of Fluid Flows fully Coupled with Structures. Computational Fluid and Solid Mechanics. KJ Bathe. Elsevier Science

[] Zhang Y, Liu L, Wang J, Tang K, Ma T. Study on the impact characteristics of underwater explosion bubble jets induced by plate structure. Ocean Engineering, 2022, 266: 112641,

[] Zong Z, Zhao Y, Li H. A numerical study of whole ship structural damage resulting from close-in underwater explosion shock. Marine Structures, 2013, 31: 24-43,