Effects of personal heating on thermal comfort: A review

Abstract

Personal conditioning system (PCS) is receiving considerable attention due to its energy-saving potential and the ability to satisfy individual comfort requirements. As a part of PCS, personal heating systems can maintain human thermal comfort in cold environments, which leads to their potential role of important heating mode in cold winter, especially in the Hot Summer and Cold Winter regions of China. In order to better promote the development and application of personal heating systems, this paper reviews the published studies. Personal heating systems can be divided into four types based on the mode of heat transfer: conductive, convective, radiative and combinative type. Characteristics of each category and respective devices are introduced. Furthermore, identifying the effects of personal heating on thermal comfort and the models for predicting or evaluating thermal comfort during local heating. This paper would provide users with a guideline for choosing suitable heating equipment during winter.

Keywords

personal conditioning system / personal heating / thermal comfort / evaluation models / built environment

References

[1] DavidJ. Under floor air conditioning [J]. Journal of the Chartered Institution of Building Services, 1984, 8: 29-34

[2] SodecF, CraigR. The underfloor air supply system—The European experience[J]. ASHRAE Transaction, 1990, 96: 690-695

[3] SodecFAir distribution systems report No. 3554A[R], 1984, Aachen, West Germany, Krantz GmbH&Co

[4] BarkerC, AnthonyG, WatersR, et al.Lloyd’s of London, air conditioning: Impact on the built environment [M], 1987, New York, Nichols Publishing Company

[5] van HoofJ. Forty years of Fanger’s model of thermal comfort: Comfort for all? [J]. Indoor Air, 2008, 18(3): 182-201

[6] HuizengaC, AbbaszadehS, ZagreusL, et al.. Air quality and thermal comfort in office buildings: Results of a large indoor environmental quality survey [J]. Center for the Built Environment, 2006, 3: 393-397

[7] HoytT, ArensE, ZhangH. Extending air temperature setpoints: Simulated energy savings and design considerations for new and retrofit buildings [J]. Building and Environment, 2015, 88: 89-96

[8] BAUMAN F, CARTER T, BAUGHMAN A. Field study of the impact of a desktop task/ambient conditioning system in office buildings 1998.

[9] ZhangH, ArensE, ZhaiY. A review of the corrective power of personal comfort systems in non-neutral ambient environments [J]. Building and Environment, 2015, 91: 15-41

[10] SchiavonS, MelikovA K. Energy-saving strategies with personalized ventilation in cold climates [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2009, 41(5): 543-550

[11] ZhangH, ArensE, TaubM, et al.. Using footwarmers in offices for thermal comfort and energy savings [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2015, 104: 233-243

[12] LiuH, WuY, LiB, et al.. Seasonal variation of thermal sensations in residential buildings in the Hot Summer and Cold Winter zone of China [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2017, 140: 9-18

[13] CuiY, DaY, ChenC F. Exploring the factors and motivations influencing heating behavioral patterns and future energy use intentions in the hot summer and cold winter climate zone of China [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2017, 153: 99-110

[14] ShahzadS, CalautitJ K, CalautitK, et al.. Advanced personal comfort system (APCS) for the workplace: A review and case study [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2018, 173: 689-709

[15] GodithiS B, SachdevaE, GargV, et al.. A review of advances for thermal and visual comfort controls in personal environmental control (PEC) systems [J]. Intelligent Buildings International, 2019, 11(2): 75-104

[16] WarthmannA, WölkiD, MetzmacherH, et al.. Personal climatization systems—A review on existing and upcoming concepts [J]. Applied Sciences, 2018, 9(1): 35

[17] RawalR, SchweikerM, KazanciO B, et al.. Personal comfort systems: A review on comfort, energy, and economics [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2020, 214: 109858

[18] VeselýM, ZeilerW. Personalized conditioning and its impact on thermal comfort and energy performance—A review [J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2014, 34401-408

[19] BrooksJ E, ParsonsK C. An ergonomics investigation into human thermal comfort using an automobile seat heated with encapsulated carbonized fabric (ECF) [J]. Ergonomics, 1999, 42(5): 661-673

[20] YangH, CaoB, ZhuY. Study on the effects of chair heating in cold indoor environments from the perspective of local thermal sensation [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2018, 18016-28

[21] ZhangY F, WyonD P, FangL, et al.. The influence of heated or cooled seats on the acceptable ambient temperature range [J]. Ergonomics, 2007, 50(4): 586-600

[22] DengQ, WangR, LiY, et al.. Human thermal sensation and comfort in a non-uniform environment with personalized heating [J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2017, 578: 242-248

[23] PasutW, ZhangH, ArensE, et al.. Effect of a heated and cooled office chair on thermal comfort [J]. HVAC&R Research, 2013, 19(5): 574-583

[24] PasutW, ZhangH, ArensE, et al.. Energy-efficient comfort with a heated/cooled chair: Results from human subject tests [J]. Building and Environment, 2015, 84: 10-21

[25] HeY, WangX, LiN, et al.. Heating chair assisted by leg-warmer: A potential way to achieve better thermal comfort and greater energy conservation in winter [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2018, 158: 1106-1116

[26] LuoM, ArensE, ZhangH, et al.. Thermal comfort evaluated for combinations of energy-efficient personal heating and cooling devices [J]. Building and Environment, 2018, 143: 206-216

[27] VeselýM, MolenaarP, VosM, et al.. Personalized heating-Comparison of heaters and control modes [J]. Building and Environment, 2017, 112: 223-232

[28] ChoiK, ChungH, LeeB, et al.. Clothing temperature changes of phase change material-treated warm-up in cold and warm environments [J]. Fibers and Polymers, 2005, 6(4): 343-347

[29] SongW, WangF, ZhangC, et al.. On the improvement of thermal comfort of university students by using electrically and chemically heated clothing in a cold classroom environment [J]. Building and Environment, 2015, 94: 704-713

[30] WangF, GaoC, KuklaneK, et al.. A review of technology of personal heating garments [J]. International Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergonomics, 2010, 16(3): 387-404

[31] MADSEN T. Individually controlled local heating [C]//Proceedings of Roomvent 2002. Copenhagen, 2002: 285–288.

[32] NevesS F, CoutoS, CamposJ B L M, et al.. Advances in the optimisation of apparel heating products: A numerical approach to study heat transport through a blanket with an embedded smart heating system [J]. Applied Thermal Engineering, 2015, 87: 491-498

[33] WangD, ChenP, LiuY, et al.. Heat transfer characteristics of a novel sleeping bed with an integrated hot water heating system [J]. Applied Thermal Engineering, 2017, 113: 79-86

[34] ZhuangZ, LiY, ChenB, et al.. Chinese Kang as a domestic heating system in rural Northern China—A review [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2009, 41(1): 111-119

[35] LinL Y, WangF, KuklaneK, et al.. A laboratory validation study of comfort and limit temperatures of four sleeping bags defined according to EN 13537 (2002) [J]. Applied Ergonomics, 2013, 44(2): 321-326

[36] SongW F, ZhangC J, LaiD D, et al.. Use of a novel smart heating sleeping bag to improve wearers’ local thermal comfort in the feet [J]. Scientific Reports, 2016, 6: 19326

[37] ZhangC, RenC, LiY, et al.. Designing a smart electrically heated sleeping bag to improve wearers’ feet thermal comfort while sleeping in a cold ambient environment [J]. Textile Research Journal, 2017, 87(10): 1251-1260

[38] Udayraj, LiZ, KeY, et al.. A study of thermal comfort enhancement using three energy-efficient personalized heating strategies at two low indoor temperatures [J]. Building and Environment, 2018, 1431-14

[39] RantanenJ, VuorelaT, KukkonenK, et al.. Improving human thermal comfort with smart clothing [C]. 2001 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, 2001, Tucson, AZ, USA, IEEE, 795800

[40] ZhangH, ArensE, HuizengaC, et al.. Thermal sensation and comfort models for non-uniform and transient environments, part III: Whole-body sensation and comfort [J]. Building and Environment, 2010, 45(2): 399-410

[41] ZhangH, ArensE, HuizengaC, et al.. Thermal sensation and comfort models for non-uniform and transient environments, part II: Local comfort of individual body parts [J]. Building and Environment, 2010, 45(2): 389-398

[42] ZhangH, ArensE, HuizengaC, et al.. Thermal sensation and comfort models for non-uniform and transient environments, part I: Local comfort of individual body parts [J]. Building and Environment, 2010, 45(2): 380-388

[43] HuizengaC, ZhangH, ArensE, et al.. Skin and core temperature response to partial- and whole-body heating and cooling [J]. Journal of Thermal Biology, 2004, 29(7–8): 549-558

[44] ChludzińskaM, BogdanA. The effect of temperature and direction of airflow from the personalised ventilation on occupants’ thermal sensations in office areas [J]. Building and Environment, 2015, 85: 277-286

[45] KaczmarczykJ, MelikovA, SlivaD. Effect of warm air supplied facially on occupants’ comfort [J]. Building and Environment, 2010, 45(4): 848-855

[46] MelikovA, IvanovaT, StefanovaG. Seat headrest-incorporated personalized ventilation: Thermal comfort and inhaled air quality [J]. Building and Environment, 2012, 47: 100-108

[47] REN Yu-ting, LIN Duan-mu, QUAN Jin. Equivalent temperature based comfort zone study under task/ambient conditioning system [C]//The 14th International Conference of Indoor Air Quality and Climate. 2016: 1–9.

[48] KongM, DangT Q, ZhangJ, et al.. Micro-environmental control for efficient local heating: CFD simulation and manikin test verification [J]. Building and Environment, 2019, 147: 382-396

[49] ENOMOTO H, KUMAMOTO T, TOCHIHARA Y. Effects of lower body warming on physiological and psychological responses of humans [C]//3rd Int Conf Environ Ergon ICEE. 2009: 578.

[50] DuC, LiuH, LiC, et al.. Demand and efficiency evaluations of local convective heating to human feet and low body parts in cold environments [J]. Building and Environment, 2020, 171: 106662

[51] JinQ, LiX, LinD, et al.. Predictive model of local and overall thermal sensations for non-uniform environments [J]. Building and Environment, 2012, 51330-344

[52] JinQ, LinD, ZhangH, et al.. Thermal sensations of the whole body and head under local cooling and heating conditions during step-changes between workstation and ambient environment [J]. Building and Environment, 2011, 46(11): 2342-2350

[53] YamashitaK, MatsuoJ, TochiharaY, et al.. Thermal sensation and comfort during exposure to local airflow to face or legs [J]. Journal of Physiological Anthropology and Applied Human Science, 2005, 24(1): 61-66

[54] ZhangH, ArensE, KimD, et al.. Comfort, perceived air quality, and work performance in a low-power task-ambient conditioning system [J]. Building and Environment, 2010, 45(1): 29-39

[55] de KORTE E M, KUIJT-EVERS L F M, SPIEKMAN M, et al. Evaluating comfort levels of a workstation with an individually controlled heating and lighting system [M]. Springer-Verlag, 2013: 213–222.

[56] YanJ, LiN, ZhouL, et al.. Influence of workstation radiant heating terminal on local and overall thermal sensation of human body [J]. Heating Ventilating & Air Conditioning, 2018, 48(8): 22-29

[57] de KorteE M, SpiekmanM, Hoes-VanO L, et al.. Personal environmental control: Effects of pre-set conditions for heating and lighting on personal settings, task performance and comfort experience [J]. Building and Environment, 2015, 86: 166-176

[58] FodaE, SirénK. Design strategy for maximizing the energy-efficiency of a localized floor-heating system using a thermal manikin with human thermoregulatory control [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2012, 51: 111-121

[59] ArensE, ZhangH, HuizengaC. Partial- and whole-body thermal sensation and comfort—Part I: Non-uniform environmental conditions [J]. Journal of Thermal Biology, 2006, 31: 53-59

[60] ArensE, ZhangH, HuizengaC. Partial- and whole-body thermal sensation and comfort—Part II: Non-uniform environmental conditions [J]. Journal of Thermal Biology, 2006, 31: 60-66

[61] LiN, YanJ, HeY, et al.. Analysis on thermal comfort and energy saving of the screen type radiant heating terminal [J]. Journal of Safety and Environment, 2018, 18: 2-8

[62] HeY, LiN, ZhangW, et al.. Thermal comfort of sellers with a kind of traditional personal heating device (Huotong) in marketplace in winter [J]. Building and Environment, 2016, 106: 219-228

[63] HeY, LiN, ZhouL, et al.. Thermal comfort and energy consumption in cold environment with retrofitted Huotong (warm-barrel) [J]. Building and Environment, 2017, 112: 285-295

[64] MelikovA K, KnudsenG L. Human response to an individually controlled microenvironment [J]. HVAC&R Research, 2007, 13(4): 645-660

[65] WatanabeS, MelikovA K, KnudsenG L. Design of an individually controlled system for an optimal thermal microenvironment [J]. Building and Environment, 2010, 45(3): 549-558

[66] TsuzukiK, ArensE A, BaumanF S, et al.. Individual thermal comfort control with desk-mounted and floor-mounted task/ambient conditioning (TAC) systems [J]. Ensemble, 2013, 15: 250-260

[67] WangL, TianY, KimJ, et al.. The key local segments of human body for personalized heating and cooling [J]. Journal of Thermal Biology, 2019, 81: 118-127

[68] WangL, YinH, DiY, et al.. Human local and total heat losses in different temperature [J]. Physiology & Behavior, 2016, 157: 270-276

[69] OiH, YanagiK, TabataK, et al.. Effects of heated seat and foot heater on thermal comfort and heater energy consumption in vehicle [J]. Ergonomics, 2011, 54(8): 690-699

[70] CharkoudianN. Skin blood flow in adult human thermoregulation: How it works, when it does not, and why [J]. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 2003, 78(5): 603-612

[71] MELIKOV A K, LANGKILDE G, RASMUSSEN L W. Human response to local heating for use in connection with low enthalpy ventilation [C]//Proceeding of Room Vent. 1998: 315–321.

[72] MELIKOV A K, LYUBENOVA V S, SKWARCZYNSKI M, et al. Impact of air temperature, relative humidity, air movement and pollution on eye blinking [C]//Proceeding of Indoor Air 2011. Austin, 2011: 970.

[73] YangY, LiB, LiuH, et al.. Experimental research of improvement on human comfort by warm airflow in cold environment [J]. Journal of Central South University (Science and Technology), 2012, 43(10): 4142-4147(in Chinese)

[74] ParkinsonT, de DearR. Thermal pleasure in built environments: Spatial alliesthesia from air movement [J]. Building Research & Information, 2017, 45(3): 320-335

[75] de DearR. Revisiting an old hypothesis of human thermal perception: Alliesthesia [J]. Building Research & Information, 2011, 39(2): 108-117

[76] AttiaM. Thermal pleasantness and temperature regulation in man [J]. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 1984, 8(3): 335-342

[77] ChengY, NiuJ, GaoN. Thermal comfort models: A review and numerical investigation [J]. Building and Environment, 2012, 47: 13-22

[78] ZHANG H. Human thermal sensation and comfort in transient and non-uniform thermal environments [D]. University of California at Berkeley, 2003: 415

[79] LiJ, LiN, HeY, et al.. Local thermal comfort with electric heating cushions and foot warmers [J]. Heating Ventilating & Air Conditioning, 2018, 48(8): 60-67

[80] TanakaM, YamazakiS, OhnakaT, et al.. Physiological reactions to different vertical (head-foot) air temperature differences [J]. Ergonomics, 1986, 29(1): 131-143

[81] BohgakiK, ImagawaN, ItohH, et al.. The effects of vertical air temperature defferences on thermal comfort and physiological responses [J]. Journal of Architecture, Planning and Environmental Engineering (Transactions of AIJ), 1990, 417: 31-42

[82] LiuW, LianZ, DengQ, et al.. Evaluation of calculation methods of mean skin temperature for use in thermal comfort study [J]. Building and Environment, 2011, 46(2): 478-488

[83] ZhangY, ZhaoR. Effect of local exposure on human responses [J]. Building and Environment, 2007, 42(7): 2737-2745

[84] MatsunagaK, SudoF, TanabeS I, et al.Evaluation and measurement of thermal comfort in the vehicles with a new thermal manikin [C], 1993, 400 Commonwealth Drive, Warrendale, PA, United States, SAE International

[85] JinQStudy on thermal sensation during step-change in non-uniform thermal environment [D], 2012, Dalian, Dalian University of Technology(in Chinese)

[86] TanC, LiN, HeY. Influences of foot heating on human body’s overall and local thermal sensation in non-uniform environment [J]. Heating Ventilating & Air Conditioning, 2018, 48(8): 35-41

[87] ZhangC, LaiD, LuY, et al.. Smart heating sleeping bags for improving wearers’ thermal comfort at the feet [J]. Extreme Physiology & Medicine, 2015, 4(S1): A92

[88] JazizadehF, JungW. Personalized thermal comfort inference using RGB video images for distributed HVAC control [J]. Applied Energy, 2018, 220: 829-841

[89] SimS Y, KohM J, JooK M, et al.. Estimation of thermal sensation based on wrist skin temperatures [J]. Sensors (Basel, Switzerland), 2016, 16(4): 420

[90] GhahramaniA, CastroG, Becerik-GerberB, et al.. Infrared thermography of human face for monitoring thermoregulation performance and estimating personal thermal comfort [J]. Building and Environment, 2016, 1091-11

[91] KimJ, ZhouY, SchiavonS, et al.. Personal comfort models: Predicting individuals’ thermal preference using occupant heating and cooling behavior and machine learning [J]. Building and Environment, 2018, 12996-106

[92] WuZ, LiN, PengJ, et al.. Using an ensemble machine learning methodology-Bagging to predict occupants’ thermal comfort in buildings [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2018, 173: 117-127

[93] KatićK, LiR, VerhaartJ, et al.. Neural network based predictive control of personalized heating systems [J]. Energy and Buildings, 2018, 174: 199-213

[94] ZHOU G, MELIKOV A. Equivalent frequency—A new parameter for description of frequency characteristics of airflow fluctuations [C]//Proceedings of Roomvent. 2002: 357–360.

[95] ZHOU G, MELIKOV A, FANGER P. Impact of equivalent frequency on the sensation of draught [C]//Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference on Air Distribution in Rooms, Roomvent 2002. Copenhagen, Denmark, 2002.

[96] KimJ, BaumanF, RafteryP, et al.. Occupant comfort and behavior: High-resolution data from a 6-month field study of personal comfort systems with 37 real office workers [J]. Building and Environment, 2019, 148: 348-360

[97] ShahzadS, CalautitJ K, AquinoA I, et al.. A user-controlled thermal chair for an open plan workplace: CFD and field studies of thermal comfort performance [J]. Applied Energy, 2017, 207: 283-293

[98] WANG Z, LUO M. The effect of a low-energy wearable thermal device on human comfort [C]//The 15th Conference of the International Society Indoor Air Quality & Climate. Philadelphia, PA, USA: 2018. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/5f2876gr(2018).

[99] ZhangH, HuizengaC, ArensE, et al.. Thermal sensation and comfort in transient non-uniform thermal environments [J]. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 2004, 92(6): 728-733

[100] WangD, ZhangH, ArensE, et al.. Observations of upper-extremity skin temperature and corresponding overall-body thermal sensations and comfort [J]. Building and Environment, 2007, 42(12): 3933-3943

[101] van OEFFELEN L, JACOBS P, van ZUNDERT K. Personal heating: Is it comfortable and can it save energy? [C]//12th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate 2011. Austin, TX, 2011: 3017.