Review of oxidant resistant coating on graphite substrate of HTR fuel element

Abstract

The core components of HTR mainly consist of graphite, which is an excellent solid moderating material and structure material with good irradiation performance. However, graphite is easier to be oxidized at high temperature. It is important to improve the anti-oxidation performance of graphite substrate to enhance the safety of HTR. Anti-oxidation coating has been proved that it can effectively improve the oxidation resistance of graphite substrate. The selection of coating includes the coating materials system and the preparation techniques. In addition, attention also should be paid to the anti-oxidation mechanism. SiC based coating system is most commonly used in HTR and some other coating systems such as zirconium compounds coating, noble metal coating also can be used in nuclear. However, some coating systems are not suitable in HTR because the elements contained cannot be used in high irradiation environment. The emphasis is on the antioxidant mechanism of different coating systems. Some anti-oxidation coating techniques for graphite substrate are also reviewed in this paper, such as PC, CVD, PS and slurry. Finally, the existing problems of the oxidation resistance coating are proposed and an outlook is made for the development of the protection coating system for graphite substrate used in nuclear.

Keywords

graphite / coating / nuclear / oxidation / mechanism

References

[1] ShibataT J, SumitaJ Y, TadaT, SawaK. Development of non-destructive evaluation methods for degradation of HTGR graphite components[J]. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 2008, 381(1): 204-209 2

[2] BoehmH P. Surface oxides on carbon and their analysis: A critical assessment [J]. Carbon, 2002, 40(2): 145-149

[3] DzyadikevichY V, OliinikV E. Films for protecting graphite materials from oxidation (review) [J]. Powder Metallurgy and Metal Ceramics, 1996, 35(3): 150-153 4

[4] JinH, MengS-h, ZhangX-h, ZengQ-x, NiuJ-hong. Effects of oxidation temperature, time, and ambient pressure on the oxidation of ZrB₂-SiC-graphite composites in atomic oxygen [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2016, 36(8): 1855-1861

[5] LiL, LiH-j, YinX-m, ChuY-h, ChenX, FuQ-gang. Oxidation protection and behavior of in-situ zirconium diboride-silicon carbide coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2015, 645: 164-170

[6] ChengL-f, XuY-d, ZhangL-t, GaoRong. Effect of glass sealing on the oxidation behavior of three dimensional C/SiC composites in air [J]. Carbon, 2001, 39(8): 1127-1133

[7] KrisztinaL, EtelkaT, KatalinJ. Effect of activation on the surface chemistry of carbons from polymer precursors [J]. Carbon, 2001, 39(8): 1217-1228

[8] LuW-m, ChungD D L. Oxidation protection of carbon materials by acid phosphate impregnation [J]. Carbon, 2002, 40(8): 1249-1254

[9] MckeeD W. Effect of adsorbed phosphorus oxychloride on the oxidation behavior of graphite [J]. Carbon, 1972, 10: 491-497

[10] JaroslawW, AgnieszkaJ, TomaszC, AndrzejO. Surface modification of graphene oxide nanoplatelets and its influence on mechanical properties of alumina matrix composites [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2017, 37(4): 1587-1592

[11] ChengE T. Concentration limits of natural elements in low activation fusion materials [J]. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 1998, 258: 1767-1772

[12] RajuK, YoonD-Hyok. Sintering additives for SiC based on the reactivity: A review [J]. Ceramics International, 2016, 42(16): 17947-17962

[13] SunC, LiH-j, FuQ-g, ZhangJ-p, PengHan. Double SiC coating on carbon/carbon composites against oxidation by a two-step method [J]. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China, 2013, 23(7): 2107-2112

[14] YaoD-j, LiH-j, Wuh, FuQ-g, QiangX-fa. Ablation resistance of ZrC/SiC gradient coating for SiC-coated carbon/carbon composites prepared by supersonic plasma spraying [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2016, 36(15): 3739-3746

[15] ZhanngY-l, LiH-j, FuQ-g, LiK-z, WeiJ, WangP-yun. A C/SiC gradient oxidation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2006, 201(6): 3491-3495

[16] ZhangY-l, LiH-j, YaoX-y, LiK-z, ZhangS-yang. C/SiC/Si-Mo-B/glass multilayer oxidation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2011, 206(2): 492-496 3

[17] ZhangY-l, LiH-j, LiK-z, FeiJ, ZengX-rong. C/SiC/Si-Mo-Cr multilayer coating for carbon/carbon composites for oxidation protection [J]. New Carbon Materials, 2012, 27(2): 105-109

[18] LiT, LiH-j, ShiX-h, ChengJ, LiuLei. Mo-Si-Al-C multiphase oxidation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Applied Surface Science, 2013, 276: 154-158

[19] MaC, LiH-j, WuH, FuQ-g, SunC, ShiX-h, ZhangY-l, ZhangZ-z, TaoJ, HanZ-hai. Mullite oxidation resistant coating for SiC-coated carbon/carbon composites by supersonic plasma spraying [J]. Journal of Materials Science & Technology, 2013, 29(1): 29-33

[20] HuangJ-f, LiH-j, ZengX-r, XiongX-b, LiK-zhi. Influence of preparation technology on the microstructure and anti-oxidation property of SiC-Al₂O₃-mullite multi-coatings for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Applied Surface Science, 2006, 252(12): 4244-4249

[21] HuC-l, PangS-y, TangS-f, YangZ, WangS-j, ChengH-ming. Long-term oxidation behavior of carbon/carbon composites with a SiC/B₄C-B₂O₃-SiO₂-AhO₃ coating at low and medium temperatures [J]. Corrosion Science, 2015, 94: 452-458

[22] CairoC A A, GracaM L A, SilvaC R M, BressianiJ C. Functionally gradient ceramic coating for carbon-carbon antioxidation protection [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2001, 21(3): 325-329

[23] RenX-r, LiH-j, FuQ-g, LiK-zhi. Oxidation protective TaB₂-SiC gradient coating to protect SiC-Si coated carbon/carbon composites against oxidation [J]. Composites Part B: Engineering, 2014, 66: 174-179

[24] WangY-j, LiH-j, FuQ-g, WuH, YaoD-j, LiH-liang. SiC/H_fC/SiC ablation resistant coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2012, 206(19): 3883-3887 20

[25] WenG, SuiS H, SongL, WangX Y, XiaL. Formation of ZrC ablation protective coatings on carbon material by tungsten inert gas cladding technique [J]. Corrosion Science, 2010, 52(9): 3018-3022

[26] SunW, XiongX, HuangB-y, LiG-d, ZhangH-b, ChenZ-k, ZhengX-lin. ZrC ablation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Carbon, 2009, 47(14): 3368-3371

[27] MorimotoT, OguraY, KondoM, UedaT. Multilayer coating for carbon-carbon composites [J]. Carbon, 1995, 33(4): 351-357

[28] ZhouP, LiuX-x, ZhaoH-s, LiZ-q, ZhengZ-j, ZhangK-h, LiuBing. Micro four-layer SiC coating on matrix graphite spheres of HTR fuel elements by two-step pack cementation [J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 2016, 99(11): 3525-3532

[29] ZhouP, ZhengZ-j, LiuR-z, LiuX-x, LiuM-l, WangT-w, LiZ-q, ShaoY-l, ZhaoH-s, LiuBing. Dual layer SiC coating on matrix graphite sphere prepared by pack cementation and fluidized-bed chemical vapor deposition [J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 2017, 100(8): 3415-3424

[30] LiL, LiH-j, LinH-j, ZhuangL, WangS-l, FengT, YaoX-y, FuQ-gang. Comparison of the oxidation behaviors of SiC coatings on C/C composites prepared by pack cementation and chemical vapor deposition [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2016, 302: 56-64

[31] TangC-h, GuanJie. Improvement in oxidation resistance of the nuclear graphite by reaction-coated SiC coating [J]. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 1995, 224(1): 103-108

[32] ZhuQ-s, QiuX-l, MaC-wen. Oxidation resistant SiC coating for graphite materials [J]. Carbon, 1999, 37(9): 1475-1484

[33] FuZ-q, TangC-h, LiangT-xiang. Structure of SiC coatings from polycarbosilane on graphite for fuel element matrix of high temperature gas-cooled reactor [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2006, 200(12): 3950-395413

[34] FuQ-g, LiH-j, ShiX-h, LiK-z, SunG-dong. Silicon carbide coating to protect carbon/carbon composites against oxidation [J]. Scripta Materialia, 2005, 52(9): 923-927

[35] FuQ-g, LiH-j, ShiX-h, LiaoX-l, LiK-z, HuangMin. Microstructure and anti-oxidation property of CrSi₂-SiC coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Applied Surface Science, 2006, 252(10): 3475-3480

[36] ZhaoJ, GuoQ-g, ShiJ-l, ZhaiG-t, LiuLang. SiC/Si-MoSi₂ oxidation protective coatings for carbon materials [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2006, 201(3): 1861-1865 4

[37] LiH-j, FengT, FuQ-g, WuH, ShenX-tao. Oxidation and erosion resistance of MoSi₂-CrSi₂-Si/SiC coated C/C composites in static and aerodynamic oxidation environment [J]. Carbon, 2010, 48(5): 1636-1642

[38] FangH-t, ZhuJ-c, YinZ-d, JeonJ-h, HahnY-dong. A Si-Mo fused slurry coating for oxidation protection of carbon-carbon composites [J]. Journal of Materials Science Letters, 2001, 20: 175-177

[39] HennigeV D, HausseltJ, Ritzhaupt-KleisslH J, WindmannT. Shrinkage-free ZrSiO₂-ceramics: Characterisation and application [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 1999, 19: 2901-2908

[40] SunC, LiH-j, LuoH-j, XieJ, ZhangJ-p, FuQ-gang. Effect of Y₂O₃ on the oxidation resistant of ZrSiO₄/SiC coating prepared by supersonic plasma spraying technique for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2013, 235: 127-133

[41] KaiserA, LobertM, TelleRainer. Thermal stability of zircon (ZrSiO₄) [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2008, 28(11): 2199-2211

[42] LangM, ZhangF-x, LianJ, TrautmannC, NeumannR, EWING RodneyC. Irradiation-induced stabilization of zircon (ZrSiO₄) at high pressure [J]. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 2008, 269(1): 291-295 2

[43] PourasadJ, EhsaniN, VALEFI Zia KHALIFESOLTANI SayedAli. Preparation of a nanostructured SiC-ZrO₂ coating to improve the oxidation resistance of graphite [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2017, 323: 58-64

[44] DongZ J, LiuS X, LiX K, WestwoodA, YuanG M, CuiZ W, CongY. Influence of infiltration temperature on the microstructure and oxidation behavior of SiC-ZrC ceramic coating on C/C composites prepared by reactive melt infiltration [J]. Ceramics International, 2015, 41(1): 797-811

[45] WangS-l, LiK-z, LiH-j, ZhangY-lei. Microstructure and ablation resistance of ZrC nanostructured coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Materials Letters, 2013, 107: 99-102

[46] WangS-l, LinK-z, LiH-j, ZhangY-l, FengTao. Structure evolution and ablation behavior of ZrC coating on C/C composites under single and cyclic oxyacetylene torch environment [J]. Ceramics International, 2014, 40(10): 16003-16014

[47] WangP, ZhouS-b, ZhangX-h, GuiK-x, LiY-x, AnJ-d, HanW-bo. Thermal cycling and oxidation resistance of B modified ZrB₂-SiC coatings on SiC coated graphite [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2015, 280: 330-337

[48] JalilP, NaserEhsani. In-situ synthesis of SiC-ZrB₂ coating by a novel pack cementation technique to protect graphite against oxidation [J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2017, 690: 692-698

[49] YaoX-y, LiH-j, ZhangY-l, WuH, QiangX-fa. A SiC-Si-ZrB₂ multiphase oxidation protective ceramic coating for SiC-coated carbon/carbon composites [J]. Ceramics International, 2012, 38(3): 2095-2100

[50] WangP, HanW-b, ZhangX-h, LiN, ZhaoG-d, ZhouS-bao. (ZrB₂-SiC)/SiC oxidation protective coatings for graphite materials [J]. Ceramics International, 2015, 41(5): 6941-6949

[51] LiS-b, LuZ-l, GaoJ-q, JinZ-hao. A study on the cycling oxidation behavior of mullite-coated silicon carbide [J]. Materials Chemistry and Physics, 2003, 78(3): 655-659

[52] LiuW-z, XiaoP, LiZ, HongW, LuoH, YuX-y, LiY, ChenW-bo. Microstructure and oxidation behavior of sol-gel mullite coating on SiC-coated carbon/carbon composites [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2015, 35(14): 3789-3796

[53] YangX, SuZ-a, HuangQ-z, ChaiL-yuan. Preparation and oxidation resistance of mullite/SiC coating for carbon materials at 1150 °C [J]. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China, 2012, 22(12): 2997-3002

[54] JacobsonN S. Corrosion of silicon-based ceramics in combustion environments [J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 1993, 76(1): 3-28

[55] WangK-t, CaoL-y, HuangJ-y, FeiJie. A mullite/SiC oxidation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 2013, 33(1): 191-198

[56] FuQ-g, LiH-j, LiK-z, ShiX-h, HuangMin. A SiC/glass oxidation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites for application at 1173 K [J]. Carbon, 2007, 45(4): 892-894

[57] HuangJ-f, LiH-j, ZengX-r, LiK-z, XiongX-b, HuangM, ZhangX-l, LiuY-lou. A new SiC/yttrium silicate/glass multi-layer oxidation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Carbon, 2004, 42(11): 2356-2359

[58] WanF, LuoF, ZhouY-y, ZhouW-c, ZhuD-mei. A glass coating for SiC fiber reinforced aluminum phosphate matrix (SiC_f/AlPO₄) composites for high-temperature absorbing wave applications [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2015, 264: 9-16

[59] HuangJ-f, ZhangY-l, ZhuK-j, LiC-y, CaoL-y, ZhouL, OuyangH-b, ZhangB-y, HaoW, YaoC-yan. Microstructure and oxidation protection of borosilicate glass coating prepared by pulse arc discharge deposition for C/C composites [J]. Ceramics International, 2015, 41(3): 4662-4667

[60] FuQ-g, LiH-j, ShiX-h, LiK-z, WeiJ, HuangMin. Oxidation protective glass coating for SiC coated carbon/carbon composites for application at 1773 K [J]. Materials Letters, 2006, 60(3): 431-434

[61] FuQ-g, LiH-j, ShiX-h, LiK-z, WangC, HuangMin. Double-layer oxidation protective SiC/glass coatings for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2006, 200(11): 3473-3477

[62] WangS-q, ZengF-h, LiY, GuY, ZhangF-q, XiongXiang. Oxidation mechanism of SiC-zirconia-glass ceramic coated carbon/carbon composites at 1123–1273 K [J]. Materials Research Bulletin, 2017, 91: 189-196

[63] BrandlW, GrabkeH J, TomaD, KrugerJ. The oxidation behaviour of sprayed MCrAlY coatings [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 1996, 86–87: 41-47

[64] TimothyJ F, CurtisE J, KelvinT Higa. Inhibition of oxide formation on aluminum nanoparticles by transition metal coating [J]. Chem Mater, 2005, 17(16): 4086-4091

[65] ZhangY, FranklinN W, ChenR J, DaiH J. Metal coating on suspended carbon nanotubes and its implication to metal-tube interaction [J]. Chemical Physics Letters, 2000, 331(1): 35-41

[66] HuangM, LiK-z, LiH-j, FuQ-g, SunG-dong. Double-layer oxidation protective SiC/Cr-Al-Si coating for carbon-carbon composites [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2007, 201(18): 7842-7846

[67] ShiX-h, WangC-c, LinH-j, HuoC-x, JinX-x, ShiG-g, DongK-yuan. Oxidation resistance of a La-Mo-Si-O-C coating prepared by supersonic atmosphere plasma spraying on the surface of SiC-coated C/C composites [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2016, 300: 10-18

[68] LiK-z, HouD-s, LiH-j, FuQ-g, JiaoG-sheng. Si-W-Mo coating for SiC coated carbon/carbon composites against oxidation [J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2007, 201(24): 9598-9602

[69] LiuR-z, LiuB, ZhangK-h, LiuM-l, ShaoY-l, TangC-he. High temperature oxidation behavior of SiC coating in TRISO coated particles [J]. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 2014, 453(1–3): 107-114

[70] ZhaoH-s, FuZ-q, TangC-h, LiuX-x, LiZ-q, ZhangK-hong. Study of SiC/SiO₂ oxidation-resistant coatings on matrix graphite for HTR fuel element [J]. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 2014, 271: 217-220

[71] FuZ-q, TangC-h, LiangT-x, RobinJ-Charles. Oxidation of SiC and decomposition of SiO₂ at low partial pressure of oxygen in He-O2 system [J]. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 2004, 234(1–3): 45-49

[72] FuZ-q, WangC-b, TangC-h, ZhaoH-s, RobinJ-Charles. Oxidation behaviors of SiO₂/SiC coated matrix graphite of high temperature gas-cooled reactor fuel element [J]. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 2013, 265: 867-871

[73] LiG-d, XiongX, HuangK-long. Ablation mechanism of TaC coating fabricated by chemical vapor deposition on carbon-carbon composites [J]. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China, 2009, 19: s689-s695

[74] WangS-l, KeZ-l, HeJ-l, YuL-z, WeiY-zhang. Ablation behavior of CVD-ZrC coating under oxyacetylene torch environment with different heat fluxes [J]. International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2015, 48: 108-114

[75] ZhangB, HuangJ-f, OuyangH-b, CaoL-y, LiC-yan. A mullite oxidation protective coating on SiC coated carbon/carbon composites by hot dipping [J]. Ceramics International, 2016, 42(15): 17932-17935

[76] HuangJ-f, ZengX-r, LiH-j, XiongX-b, HuangMin. Mullite-Al₂O₃-SiC oxidation protective coating for carbon/carbon composites [J]. Carbon, 2003, 41(14): 2825-2829

[77] ZhouP, LiZ-q, ZhaoH-s, ZhangK-h, LiuX-x, LiuBing. Sintering of SiC coating layer on graphite spheres prepared by pack cementation [J]. Key Engineering Materials, 2016, 697: 807-813

[78] ChengL F, XuY-d, ZhangL-t, YinX-wei. Preparation of an oxidation protection coating for C/C composites by low pressure chemical vapor deposition [J]. Carbon, 2000, 38: 1493-1498

[79] ChoyK L. Chemical vapour deposition of coatings [J]. Progress in Materials Science, 2003, 48(2): 57-170

[80] NarushimaT, GotoT, IguchiY, HiraiT. High-temperature oxidation of chemically vapor-deposited silicon-carbide in wet oxygen at 1823 to 1923 K [J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 1990, 73: 3580-3584

[81] LuoZ, ZhouX-g, YuJ-shan. High-tomperature mechanical properties of thermal barrier coated SiC/SiC composites by PIP process with a new precursor polymer [J]. Surface and Coating Technology, 2014, 258: 146-153

[82] YangX, HuangQ-z, ZouY-h, ChangX, SuZ-a, ZhangM-y, XieZ-yong. Anti-oxidation behavior of chemical vapor reaction SiC coatings on different carbon materials at high temperatures [J]. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China, 2009, 19(5): 1044-1050

[83] LiuR-z, LiuM-l, ChangJ-x, ShaoY-l, LiuBing. An improved design of TRISO particle with porous SiC inner layer by fluidized bed-chemical vapor deposition [J]. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 2015, 467: 917-926

[84] LiuR-z, LiuM-l, WangZ-l, ShaoY-l, ChangJ-x, LiuB, WangY-xin. Preparation of fine grained SiC layer by fluidized bed chemical vapor deposition with pulsed propylene [J]. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 2016, 99(6): 1870-1873

[85] NiuF-x, WangY-x, AbbasI, FuS-l, WangC-guo. A MoSi₂-SiOC-Si₃N₄/SiC anti-oxidation coating for C/C composites prepared at relatively low temperature [J]. Ceramics International, 2017, 43(3): 3238-3245

[86] ChenZ, WuW-p, ChenZ-f, CongX-n, QiuJ-lian. Microstructural characterization on ZrC doped carbon/carbon composites [J]. Ceramics International, 2012, 38(1): 761-767

[87] YangY, LiK-z, ZhaoZ-g, LiH-jun. Ablation resistance of HfC-SiC coating prepared by supersonic atmospheric plasma spraying for SiC-coated C/C composites [J]. Ceramics International, 2016, 42(4): 4768-4774

[88] HuC, NiuY-r, HuangS-s, LiH, RenM-s, ZengY, ZhengX-b, SunJ-liang. In-situ fabrication of ZrB₂-SiC/SiC gradient coating on C/C composites [J]. Journal of Alloys and Compounds, 2015, 646: 916-923

[89] NiuY-r, ZhengX-b, DingC-x, LiH, HuC, RenM-s, SunJ-liang. Microstructure characteristics of silicon carbide coatings fabricated on C/C composites by plasma spraying technology [J]. Ceramics International, 2011, 37(5): 1675-1680

[90] WuW-p, ChenZ-f, ChengH, WangL-b, ZhangYing. Tungsten and iridium multilayered structure by DGP as ablation-resistance coatings for graphite [J]. Applied Surface Science, 2011, 257(16): 7295-7304

[91] FilipescuM, VelisaG, IonV, AndreiA, ScinteeN, IonescuP, StanciuS G, PantelicaD, DinescuM. Silicon carbide thin films as nuclear ceramics grown by laser ablation [J]. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 2011, 416(1): 18-21 2