Crack stop holes in steel bridge decks: Drilling method and effects

Abstract

Force analysis using a compact tension model, as recommended by ASTM, was carried out on a crack stop hole. The stress before, and after, drilling the hole was compared in terms of stress concentration and stress gradient. The optimum drilling location and diameter were studied through analysis of different locations and diameters. By analyzing the effects of flank holes and an additional hole, drilling advice was proposed and fatigue testing of the cracks in a steel bridge deck with a crack stop hole was conducted. The results show that the stress at the crack tip with a crack stop hole decreased, and the major principal stress around the hole was distributed accordingly. The optimum position of the crack stop hole centre was where the centre of the crack stop hole was situated behind the crack and the hole edge coincided with the crack tip. Therefore, hole diameters larger than 8 mm, or those weakening the section by 10%, were suggested as the best diameters. In terms of multi-hole crack stopping, a flank hole was not recommended. The optimum horizontal position of flank holes was at a distance of 1/4 of a single hole diameter from, and in front of, the single hole. Besides, the experiment showed that crack stop hole could only prevent cracks from growing and had no influence on crack growth rate.

Keywords

steel bridge deck / fatigue crack / stop hole / drilling method / hole position

References

[1] MikiC. Fatigue damage in orthotropic steel bridge decks and retrofit works [J]. International Journal of Steel Structures, 2006, 6(4): 255-267

[2] ConnorR J, FisherJ WResults of field measurements on the williamsburg bridge orthotropic deck-final report [R], 2001, Bethtehem, PA, Lehigh University

[3] FisherJ W, RoyS. Fatigue of steel bridge infrastructure [J]. Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 2011, 7(7): 457-475

[4] ChoiJ H, KimD H. Stress characteristics and fatigue crack behaviour of the longitudinal rib-to-cross beam joints in an orthotropic steel deck [J]. Advances in Structural Engineering, 2008, 11(2): 189-198

[5] MakabeC, KaitoN, FerdousM S. Method of arresting crack growth for application at a narrow working space [J]. Mechanical Engineering Journal, 2014, 1(6): 1-12

[6] WangY-l, PanQ-l, WeiL-l, LiB, WangYing. Fracture toughness and fatigue crack growth analysis of 7050-T7451 alloy thick plate with different thicknesses [J]. Journal of Central South University, 2014, 21(8): 2977-2983

[7] WuH, ImadA, BenseddiqN, CastroJ T P D, MeggiolaroM A. On the prediction of the residual fatigue life of cracked structures repaired by the stop-hole method [J]. International Journal of Fatigue, 2010, 32(4): 670-677

[8] CrainJ S, SimmonsG G, BennettC R, BarrettgonzalezR, MatamorosA B, RolfeS T. Development of a technique to improve fatigue lives of crack-stop holes in steel bridges [J]. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2010, 2200: 69-77

[9] HeS-y, ChenL-j, DuH-zeng. Effectiveness varying in dimension of crack-stopping holes [J]. Journal of Civil Aviation University of China, 2004, 22(3): 29-31

[10] SongP S, ShiehY L. Stop drilling procedure for fatigue life improvement [J]. International Journal of Fatigue, 2004, 26(12): 1333-1339

[11] YaS, YamadaK, IshikawaT. Fatigue evaluation of rib-to-deck welded joints of orthotropic steel bridge deck [J]. Japan Bridge Engineering, 2011, 16(4): 492-499

[12] AyatollahiM R, RazaviS M J, ChamaniH R. Fatigue life extension by crack repair using stop-hole technique under pure mode-I and pure mode-II loading conditions [J]. Procedia Engineering, 2014, 74: 18-21

[13] AyatollahiM R, RazaviS M J, YahyaM Y. Mixed mode fatigue crack initiation and growth in a CT specimen repaired by stop hole technique [J]. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 2015, 145: 115-127

[14] FanniM, FoudaN, ShabaraM A N, AwadM. New crack stop hole shape using structural optimizing technique [J]. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, 2015, 6(3): 987-999

[15] ShinC S, WangC M, SongP S. Fatigue damage repair: a comparison of some possible methods [J]. International Journal of fatigue, 1996, 18(96): 535-546

[16] AyatollahiM R, RazaviS M J, ChamaniH R. A numerical study on the effect of symmetric crack flank holes on fatigue life extension of a SENT specimen [J]. Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures, 2014, 37(10): 1153-1164

[17] MakabeC, MurdaniA, KuniyoshiK, IreiY, SaimotoA. Crack-growth arrest by redirecting crack growth by drilling stop holes and inserting pins into them [J]. Engineering Failure Analysis, 2009, 16(1): 475-483

[18] MurdaniA, MakabeC, SaimotoA, IreiY, MiyazakiT. Stress concentration at stop-drilled holes and additional holes [J]. Engineering Failure Analysis, 2008, 15(7): 810-819

[19] MurdaniA, MakabeC, SaimotoA, KondouR. A crack-growth arresting technique in aluminum alloy [J]. Engineering Failure Analysis, 2008, 15(4): 302-310

[20] MurdaniA, MakabeC, SaimotoA, MiyazakiT, KondouR. A new proposal for retarding fatigue crack reinitiation and growth from crack-tip introduced stop-drilled hole by providing additional holes [J]. Journal of the Society of Materials Science Japan, 2007, 56(12): 1139-1144

[21] IshikawaT, MatumotoR, HattoriA, KawanoH, YamadaK. Reduction of stress concentration at edge of stop hole by closing crack surface [J]. Journal of the Society of Materials Science, 2013, 62(1): 33-38

[22] ASTM E2472-06. Standard test method for determination of resistance to stable crack extension under low constraint conditions [S]. 2007.