3-D numerical modelling of Domino failure of hard rock pillars in Fetr6 Chromite Mine, Iran, and comparison with empirical methods

Abstract

Fetr6 is an underground mine using the stope-and-pillar mining method. As there was some evidence regarding pillar failure in this mine, improving works such as roof support and replacing existing pillars with concrete pillars (CP) were carried out. During the construction of the second CP, in the space between the remaining pillars, one of the pillars failed leading to the progressive failure of other pillars until 4 000 m² of mine had collapsed within a few minutes. In this work, this phenomenon is described by applying both numerical and empirical methods and the respective results are compared. The results of numerical modelling are found to be closer to the actual condition than those of the empirical method. Also, a width-to-height (W/H) ratio less than 1, an inadequate support system and the absence of a detailed program for pillar recovery are shown to be the most important causes of the Domino failure in this mine.

Keywords

hard rock / Domino failure / numerical modelling / empirical method / stope / pillar / extraction ratio / W/H ratio

References

[1] ZIPF R K. Toward pillar design to prevent collapse of room and pillar mines [R]. NIOSH — Spokane Research Laboratory, 2011.

[2] SWANSON P L, BOLER F. The magnitude 5.3 seismic event and collapse of the solvay trona mine: Analysis of pillar/floor failure stability [R]. U S Bureau of Mines OFR 86-95, 1995.

[3] ZipfR. K.HustrulidW., BullockR. L.. Pillar design to prevent collapse of room-and-pillar mines, [M]. Underground mining methods handbook, 1982Littleton, COSociety for Mining, Metallurgy, and Exploration

[4] BryanA., BryanJ. G., FoucheJ.. Some problems of strata control and support in pillar workings [J]. The Mining Engineer, 1966, 123: 238-254

[5] SheoreyP. R., BaratD., MukherjeeK. P., PrasadR. K., DasM. N., BanerjeeG., DasK.. Application of the yield pillar technique for successful depillaring under stiff strata [J]. Int J of Rock Mech and Min Sci & Geomech, 1995, 32(7): 699-708

[6] GALVIN J. A review of coal pillar design in australia [C]// Proceedings of the Workshop on Coal Pillar Mechanics and Design, Santa Fe: US Bureau of Mines Inform. 1992: 196–213.

[7] ZIPF R K, SWANSON P L. Description of a Large Catastrophic Failure in a South western Wyoming Trona Mine, Paper in Rock Mechanics for Industry [C]// Proceedings of the 37th U S Rock Mechanics Symposium, Balkema, 1999:293–298.

[8] FARYAB COMPANY Ltd. Fetr-6 underground mine design, Technical report [R]. 2008.

[9] BrownE. T.Rock characterization testing and monitoring, ISRM suggested methods [M], 1981New YorkPergamon Press

[10] BieniawskiZ. T.Engineering Rock Mass Classification [M], 1989New YorkJ. Willey

[11] ITASCA Consulting Group, Verification Problems & Example Applications, 3-Dec, ver 2.0 [EB/OL], www.itascacg.com, 1999.

[12] BieniawskiZ. T.HartmanH. L.. Ground control. Mining Engineering Handbook, 19922nd edLittleton, COSociety for Mining, Metallurgy, and Exploration897-937

[13] HoekE., BrownE. T.Underground excavations in rock [M], 1980LondonInstitution of Mining and Metallurgy527

[14] EsterhuizenG. S., DolinarD. R., EllenbergerJ. L.. Pillar strength in underground stone mines in the united states [J]. International Journal of Rock Mechanics & Mining Sciences, 2011, 48: 42-50

[15] WhittakerB. N., ReddishD. J.Subsidence, occurrence, prediction and control [M], 1989WalthamElsevier Science Publishers173-201

[16] ESTERHUIZEN G S, DOLINAR D R; ELLENBERGER J L, PROSSER L J. Pillar and roof span design guidelines for underground stone mines [R]. Department Of Health And Human Services, NIOSH, IC 9526, 2011.

[17] GONZALEZ-NICIEZAL C, LVAREZ-FERNANDEZ M I A, MENENDEZ-DIAZ A, LVAREZ-VIGIL A E A. A comparative analysis of pillar design method and its application to marble mines [J]. Rock Mech. Rock Eng, 2006.

[18] BieniawskiZ. T.. The effect of specimen size on compressive strength of coal [J]. Int J of Rock Mech And Min Sci, 1968, 5: 325-335

[19] MalanD. F., NapierJ. A. L.. The design of stable pillars in the bushveld complex mines: A problem solved? [J]. The Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, 2011, 111: 821-836

[20] FarmerI. W.HartmanH. L.. Room and pillar mining [M]. Mining Engineering Handbook, 19922nd edLittleton, COSociety for Mining, Metallurgy, and Exploration1681-1701

[21] BradyB. H. G., BrownE. T.Rock mechanics for underground mining [M], 1993BostonKluwer Academic Pub571