The influence of environment on the development of Abies alba and Quercus robur seedlings in montane acidophilous spruce forests

Abstract

The conversion of Norway spruce stands into mixed-species forests is currently one of the most pressing challenges to ensure the stability of forest ecosystems in Central Europe. Recently, direct seeding as a method of artificial regeneration and species (re-)introduction has received increased attention in forestry. Considering that environmental conditions have a strong influence on the growth performance of direct-seeded plants, we investigated how differences in soil and environmental conditions affect the growth performance of silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) and pedunculate oak (Quercus robur L.) seedlings. Our study focused on closed-canopy and open-canopy (canopy removal) Norway spruce stands in a low mountain forest in central Germany. Our data indicates that the growth performance of A. alba and Q. robur seedlings is mainly influenced by the availability of photosynthetically active radiation (PAR). The growth of A. alba increased with a higher PAR-ratio, whereas the photosynthetic efficiency, as measured by F_v/F_m (chlorophyll fluorescence), showed sensitivity to it. Conversely, the growth performance of Q. robur showed a linear increase with light availability. Nutrient availability was the second most important factor, while soil pH alone showed no significant effect. The volumetric water content showed no direct effect, though drought appeared to reduce growth. The results stress that A. alba is sensitive to abrupt changes in the light regime at this early stage of development, highlighting the key role of canopy longevity in facilitating growth. Q. robur, on the other hand, appears to be well suited to sites at high risk of canopy loss due to disturbance or where the canopy has previously been removed.

Keywords

Microsite / Soil nutrients / Leaf nutrients / Forest conversion / Canopy cover / Chlorophyll fluorescence

References

[1] Alongi F, Petrík P, Ruehr NK. Drought and heat stress interactions modify photorespiration and hydrogen peroxide content in Silver fir. Tree Physiol, 2024

[2] Ammer C. Growth and biomass partitioning of Fagus sylvatica L. and Quercus robur L. seedlings in response to shading and small changesin the R/FR-ratio of radiation. Ann for Sci, 2003, 60(2): 163-171

[3] Annighöfer P, Beckschäfer P, Vor T, Ammer C. Regeneration patterns of European oak species (Quercus petraea (Matt.) Liebl., Quercus robur L.) in dependence of environment and neighborhood. PLoS ONE, 2015, 10(8 e0134935

[4] Aussenac G. Ecology and ecophysiology of circum-Mediterranean firsin the context of climate change. Ann for Sci, 2002, 59(8): 823-832

[5] Balandier P, Frochot H, Sourisseau A. Improvement of direct tree seeding with cover crops in afforestation: microclimate and resource availability induced by vegetation composition. For Ecol Manage, 2009, 257(8): 1716-1724

[6] Barrow NJ, Hartemink AE. The effects of pH on nutrient availability depend on both soils and plants. Plant Soil, 2023, 487(1): 21-37

[7] Blume, HP, Brümmer GW, Horn R, Kandeler E, Kögel-Knabner I, Kretzschmar R et al. (2010) Lehrbuch der Bodenkunde. 16. Auflage. Heidelberg: Spektrum Akademischer Verlag (Springer eBook Collection)

[8] Boeing F, Rakovec O, Kumar R, Samaniego L, Schrön M, Hildebrandt A, Rebmann C, Thober S, Müller S, Zacharias S, Bogena H, Schneider K, Kiese R, Attinger S, Marx A. High-resolution drought simulations and comparison to soil moisture observations in Germany. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci, 2022, 26(19): 5137-5161

[9] Čater M, Batič F. Groundwater and light conditions as factors in the survival of pedunculate oak (Quercus robur L.) seedlings. Eur J Forest Res, 2006, 125(4): 419-426

[10] Čater M, Adamič PC, Dařenova E. Response of beech and fir to different light intensities along the Carpathian and Dinaric Mountains. Front Plant Sci, 2024, 15: 1380275

[11] Chakraborty D, Móricz N, Rasztovits E, Dobor L, Schueler S. Provisioning forest and conservation science with high-resolution maps of potential distribution of major European tree species under climate change. Ann for Sci, 2021, 78(2 26

[12] Colombo C, Palumbo G, He JZ, Pinton R, Cesco S. Review on iron availability in soil: interaction of Fe minerals, plants, and microbes. J Soils Sediments, 2014, 14(3): 538-548

[13] Dănescu A, Kohnle U, Bauhus J, Weiskittel A, Albrecht AT. Long-term development of natural regeneration in irregular, mixed stands of silver fir and Norway spruce. For Ecol Manage, 2018, 430: 105-116

[14] Dinca L, Marin M, Radu V, Murariu G, Drasovean R, Cretu R, Georgescu L, Timiș-Gânsac V. Which are the best site and stand conditions for silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) located in the Carpathian mountains?. Diversity, 2022, 14(7 547

[15] Dobrowolska D, Bončina A, Klumpp R. Ecology and silviculture of silver fir (Abies albaMill.): a review. J Forest Res, 2017, 22(6326-335

[16] Dusan R, Stjepan M, Igor A, Jurij D. Gap regeneration patterns in relationship to light heterogeneity in two old-growth beech–fir forest reserves in South East Europe. Forestry, 2007, 80(4): 431-443

[17] Dyderski MK, Paź S, Frelich LE, Jagodziński AM. How much does climate change threaten European forest tree species distributions?. Glob Change Biol, 2018, 24(3): 1150-1163

[18] Filipiak M, Iszkuło G, Korybo J (2005a) Relation between photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) and growth of silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) seedlings in a forest stand dominated by spruce [Picea albies (L.)H.Karst.] in the Sudety Mts (SW Poland). In Polish journal of ecology. Available online at https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Relation-between-photosynthetic-photon-flux-density-Filipiak-Iszku%C5%82o/93947db7e172d9d6ed23717af906d65d9dba1ed3

[19] Filipiak M, Komisarek J, Nowiński M (2005b): Natural regeneration of the European silver fir in the sudety mountains on soils with different particle size distribution. In Dendrobiology. Available online at https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Natural-regeneration-of-the-European-silver-fir-in-Filipiak-Komisarek/b8f85165c5a594cd69b532f86a50dceddda1f7c1

[20] GDI-Th (2025) DGM: Höhendaten des Thüringer Landesamtes für Bodenmanagement und Geoinformation in 1x1km Kacheln. Erfurt: Kompetenzzentrum Geodateninfrastruktur Thüringen (GDI-Th). Available online at https://geoportal.thueringen.de/gdi-th/download-offene-geodaten/download-hoehendaten, checked on 26 May 2025

[21] Gillon D, Houssard C, Joffre R (1999) Using near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy to predict carbon nitrogen and phosphorus content in heterogeneous plant material Oecologia 118(2):173–182. https://doi.org/10.1007/s004420050716

[22] Götmark F, Schott KM, Jensen AM. Factors influencing presence–absence of oak (Quercus spp.) seedlings after conservation-oriented partial cutting of high forests in Sweden. Scand J for Res, 2011, 26(2): 136-145

[23] Grossnickle SC, Ivetić V. Direct seeding in reforestation—a field performance review. Reforesta, 2017, 4: 94-142

[24] Hättenschwiler S. Tree seedling growth in natural deep shade: functional traits related to interspecific variation in response to elevated CO₂. Oecologia, 2001, 129(1): 31-42

[25] Hickler T, Vohland K, Feehan J, Miller PA, Smith B, Costa L, Giesecke T, Fronzek S, Carter TR, Cramer W, Kühn I, Sykes MT. Projecting the future distribution of European potential natural vegetation zones with a generalized, tree species-based dynamic vegetation model. Glob Ecol Biogeogr, 2012, 21(1): 50-63

[26] Hinze J, Albrecht A, Michiels HG. Climate-adapted potential vegetation: a European multiclass model estimating the future potential of natural vegetation. Forests, 2023, 14(2): 239

[27] Huang WW, Fonti P, Larsen JB, Ræbild A, Callesen I, Pedersen NB, Hansen JK. Projecting tree-growth responses into future climate: a study case from a Danish-wide common garden. Agric for Meteorol, 2017, 247: 240-251

[28] Huth F, Wehnert A, Tiebel K, Wagner S. Direct seeding of silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) to convert Norway spruce (Picea abies Mill.) forests in Europe: a review. For Ecol Manage, 2017, 403: 61-78

[29] Jensen AM, Löf M. Effects of interspecific competition from surrounding vegetation on mortality, growth and stem development in young oaks (Quercus robur). For Ecol Manag, 2017, 392: 176-183

[30] Jensen AM, Götmark F, Löf M. Shrubs protect oak seedlings against ungulate browsing in temperate broadleaved forests of conservation interest: a field experiment. For Ecol Manage, 2012, 266: 187-193

[31] John A, Pradhan K, Case MJ, Ettinger AK, Hille Ris Lambers J. Forest canopy cover affects microclimate buffering during an extreme heat event. Environ Res Commun, 2024, 6(9 091015

[32] Johnson DM, McCulloh KA, Reinhardt K (2011) The Earliest stages of tree growth: development, physiology and impacts of microclimate. In : size- and age-related changes in tree structure and function. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 65–87. Available online at https://link.springer.com/chapter/https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-1242-3_3

[33] Koch O, de Avila AL, Heinen H, Albrecht AT. Retreat of major European tree species distribution under climate change—minor natives to the rescue?. Sustainability, 2022, 14(95213

[34] Konôpková A, Kurjak D, Kmeť J, Klumpp R, Longauer R, Ditmarová Ľ, Gömöry D. Differences in photochemistry and response to heat stress between silver fir (Abies alba Mill.) provenances. Trees, 2018, 32(173-86

[35] Konôpková A, Pšidová E, Kurjak D, Stojnić S, Petrík P, Fleischer P, Kučerová J, Ježík M, Petek A, Gömöry D, Kmeť J, Longauer R, Ditmarová Ľ. Photosynthetic performance of silver fir (Abies alba) of different origins under suboptimal growing conditions. Funct Plant Biol, 2020, 47(11): 1007-1018

[36] Kučeravá B, Dobrovolný L, Remeš J. Responses of Abies alba seedlings to different site conditions in Picea abies plantations. Dendrobiology, 2012, 69: 49-58

[37] Kuznetsova A, Brockhoff PB, Christensen RHB. lmerTest package: tests in linear mixed effects models. J Stat Soft, 2017, 82(13): 1-26

[38] Löf M, Castro J, Engman M, Leverkus AB, Madsen P, Reque JA, Villalobos A, Gardiner ES. Tamm review: direct seeding to restore oak (Quercus spp.) forests and woodlands. For Ecol Manag, 2019, 448: 474-489

[39] MacKenzie AR, Ullah S, Foyer CH. Building forests for the future. Food Energy Secur, 2024, 13(2 e518

[40] Moser B, Walthert L, Metslaid M, Wasem U, Wohlgemuth T. Spring water deficit and soil conditions matter more than seed origin and summer drought for the establishment of temperate conifers. Oecologia, 2017, 183(2): 519-530

[41] Netherer S, Lehmanski L, Bachlehner A, Rosner S, Savi T, Schmidt A, Huang JB, Paiva MR, Mateus E, Hartmann H, Gershenzon J. Drought increases Norway spruce susceptibility to the Eurasian spruce bark beetle and its associated fungi. New Phytol, 2024, 242(3): 1000-1017

[42] Pardos M, del Río M, Pretzsch H, Jactel H, Bielak K, Bravo F, Brazaitis G, Defossez E, Engel M, Godvod K, Jacobs K, Jansone L, Jansons A, Morin X, Nothdurft A, Oreti L, Ponette Q, Pach M, Riofrío J, Ruíz-Peinado R, Tomao A, Uhl E, Calama R. The greater resilience of mixed forests to drought mainly depends on their composition: analysis along a climate gradient across Europe. For Ecol Manage, 2021, 481 118687

[43] Petriţan AM, von Lüpke B, Petriţan IC. Influence of light availability on growth, leaf morphology and plant architecture of beech (Fagus sylvatica L.), maple (Acer pseudoplatanus L.) and ash (Fraxinus excelsior L.) saplings. Eur J Forest Res, 2009, 128(1): 61-74

[44] Pinto PE, Gégout JC, Hervé JC, Dhôte JF. Respective importance of ecological conditions and stand composition on Abies alba Mill. dominant height growth. Forest Ecol Manage, 2008, 255: 619-629

[45] Prananto JA, Minasny B, Weaver T (2020) Chapter one−near infrared (NIR) spectroscopy as a rapid and cost-effective method for nutrient analysis of plant leaf tissues. In: Advances in agronomy. Elsevier, pp 1–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/bs.agron.2020.06.001

[46] R Core Team (2024): R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria: R foundation for statistical computing. Available online at https://www.R-project.org/

[47] Reich PB, Ellsworth DS, Walters MB. Leaf structure (specific leaf area) modulates photosynthesis–nitrogen relations: evidence from within and across species and functional groups. Funct Ecol, 1998, 12(6): 948-958

[48] Reif A, Gärtner S. Die natürliche Verjüngung der laubabwerfenden Eichenarten Stieleiche (Quercus robur L.) und Traubeneiche (Quercus petraea Liebl.) - eine Literaturstudie mit besonderer Berücksichtigung der Waldweide. Waldökologie Online, 2007, 5: 79-116

[49] Renaud V, Innes JL, Dobbertin M, Rebetez M. Comparison between open-site and below-canopy climatic conditions in Switzerland for different types of forests over 10 years (1998–2007). Theor Appl Climatol, 2011, 105(1): 119-127

[50] Robakowski P, Antczak P. Ability of silver fir and European beech saplings to acclimate photochemical processes to the light environment under different canopies of trees. Pol J Ecol, 2008, 56: 3-16

[51] Robakowski P, Montpied P, Dreyer E. Plasticity of morphological and physiological traits in response to different levels of irradiance in seedlings of silver fir (Abies alba Mill). Trees, 2003, 17(5): 431-441

[52] Robakowski P, Pietrzak T, Kowalkowski W, Małecki G. Survival, growth and photochemical efficiency of silver fir seedlings produced with different technologies. New for, 2021, 52(6): 1055-1077

[53] Rosas T, Mencuccini M, Barba J, Cochard H, Saura-Mas S, Martínez-Vilalta J. Adjustments and coordination of hydraulic, leaf and stem traits along a water availability gradient. New Phytol, 2019, 223(2): 632-646

[54] Rout GR, Sahoo S. Role of iron in plant growth and metabolism. Rev Agric Sci, 2015, 3: 1-24

[55] Sardans J, Alonso R, Janssens IA, Carnicer J, Vereseglou S, Rillig MC, Fernández-Martínez M, Sanders TGM, Peñuelas J. Foliar and soil concentrations and stoichiometry of nitrogen and phosphorous across European Pinus sylvestris forests: relationships with climate, N deposition and tree growth. Funct Ecol, 2016, 30(5): 676-689

[56] Senf C, Buras A, Zang CS, Rammig A, Seidl R. Excess forest mortality is consistently linked to drought across Europe. Nat Commun, 2020, 11: 6200

[57] Sevillano I, Short I, Grant J, O’Reilly C. Effects of light availability on morphology, growth and biomass allocation of Fagus sylvatica and Quercus robur seedlings. For Ecol Manag, 2016, 374: 11-19

[58] Szymura T, Dunajski A, Aman I, Makowski M, Szymura M. The spatial pattern and microsites requirements of Abies alba natural regeneration in the Karkonosze Mountains. Dendrobiology, 2007, 58: 51-57

[59] Thomas FM, Gausling T. Morphological and physiological responses of oak seedlings (Quercus petraea and Q. robur) to moderate drought. Ann for Sci, 2000, 57(4): 325-333

[60] Urbansky ET, Schock MR. Understanding, deriving, and computing buffer capacity. J Chem Educ, 2000, 77(12): 1640

[61] Vacek Z, Vacek S, Cukor J. European forests under global climate change: review of tree growth processes, crises and management strategies. J Environ Manage, 2023, 332 117353

[62] Valladares F, Chico J, Aranda I, Balaguer L, Dizengremel P, Manrique E, Dreyer E. The greater seedling high-light tolerance of Quercus robur over Fagus sylvatica is linked to a greater physiological plasticity. Trees, 2002, 16(6395-403

[63] Vandenberghe C, Freléchoux F, Buttler A. The influence of competition from herbaceous vegetation and shade on simulated browsing tolerance of coniferous and deciduous saplings. Oikos, 2008, 117(3): 415-423

[64] Vitasse Y, Bottero A, Cailleret M, Bigler C, Fonti P, Gessler A, Lévesque M, Rohner B, Weber P, Rigling A, Wohlgemuth T. Contrasting resistance and resilience to extreme drought and late spring frost in five major European tree species. Glob Change Biol, 2019, 25(11): 3781-3792

[65] Wickham H, Averick M, Bryan J, Chang W, McGowan L, François R, Grolemund G, Hayes A, Henry L, Hester J, Kuhn M, Pedersen T, Miller E, Bache S, Müller K, Ooms J, Robinson D, Seidel D, Spinu V, Takahashi K, Vaughan D, Wilke C, Woo K, Yutani H. Welcome to the tidyverse. J Open Source Softw, 2019, 4(43 1686

[66] Wyka T, Robakowski P, Zytkowiak R. Acclimation of leaves to contrasting irradiance in juvenile trees differing in shade tolerance. Tree Physiol, 2007, 27(9): 1293-1306

Funding

Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena (1010)

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)