Planting advanced-generation seedlings improves growth and survival by mitigating competitive vegetation pressure

Abstract

Planting genetically improved, fast-growing tree seedlings is gaining importance as a strategy to enhance forest productivity and reduce labor requirements during plantation establishment. In this study, we evaluated the early growth and survival of advanced-generation Cryptomeria japonica seedlings compared to conventional stock, under varying planting densities and cultivation methods. A field experiment was conducted over 5 years using container-grown and bare-root seedlings derived from first- and second-generation plus trees, alongside traditional seedlings. The results showed that advanced-generation seedlings exhibited higher growth in tree height, stem diameter, and crown development than traditional seedlings, particularly when planted as container stock. These seedlings also had higher survival rates, likely due to their rapid initial height growth, which reduced the risks of accidental damage during weeding operations. Wider planting intervals increased the risk of man-made injury and seedling mortality, while faster-growing seedlings were more likely to escape from competing vegetation. Our findings highlight the potential of improved seedling stock to enhance early plantation success and reduce management inputs in the critical establishment phase of forestry.

Keywords

Tree breeding / Planting density / Seedling survival / Competition / Weeding

References

[1] BatesD, MächlerM, BolkerB, WalkerS. Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4. J Stat Softw, 2015, 67: 1-48

[2] BerheDH, GideyT, GebregziabherD, et al.. Seedling survival and plantation success in the drylands of Northern Ethiopia. Discov Agric, 2024, 2: 6

[3] BinkleyD, CampoeOC, AlvaresC, CarneiroRL, CegattaÍ, StapeJL. The interactions of climate, spacing and genetics on clonal Eucalyptus plantations across Brazil and Uruguay. For Ecol Manage, 2017, 405: 271-283

[4] BolkerBM, BrooksME, ClarkCJ, GeangeSW, PoulsenJR, StevensMHH, WhiteJSS. Generalized linear mixed models: a practical guide for ecology and evolution. Trends Ecol Evol, 2009, 24: 127-135

[5] Bündnis Entwicklung Hilft/IFHV (2024). WordRiskReport 2024. Berlin: Bündnis Entwicklung Hilft, Berlin, Germany, 2024. https://weltrisikobericht.de/

[6] ChenF-W, XuJ, WangJ, LiZ, WuY. Do rising labour costs promote technology upgrading? A novel theoretical hypothesis of an inverted U-shaped relationship. Struct Chang Econ Dyn, 2023, 66: 327-341

[7] Christensen (2023) Ordinal - Regression Models for Ordinal Data. R package version 2019.12−10. https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=ordinal

[8] DaumT, BaudronF, BirnerR, QaimM, GrassI. Addressing agricultural labour issues is key to biodiversity-smart farming. Biol Cons, 2023, 284, ArticleID: 110165

[9] EgusaT, KumagaiT, ShiraishiN. Carbon stock in Japanese forests has been greatly underestimated. Sci Rep, 2020, 10: 7895

[10] FernándezMJ, BarroR, PérezJ, CiriaP. Production and composition of biomass from short rotation coppice in marginal land: a 9-year study. Biomass Bioenergy, 2020, 134, ArticleID: 105478

[11] Forestry Agency (2021) Annual Report on Forest and Forestry in Japan for FY 2020; Forestry Agency, Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries of Japan: Tokyo, Japan, 2021

[12] FoxJ, WeisbergS An R Companion to Applied Regression, 2019 3 Thousand Oaks Sage

[13] FukumotoK, OtaT, MizoueN, YoshidaS, TeraokaY, KajisaT. The effect of weeding frequency and timing on the height growth of young sugi (Cryptomeria japonica) in southwestern Japan. J For Res, 2017, 22(3): 204-207

[14] FukumotoK, OtaT, MizoueN, IwanagaF, YoshidaS, TeraokaY, KajisaT. Effect of weeding frequency, slope aspect and initial tree density on the mortality and accidental cutting of planted Sugi (Cryptomeria Japonica) trees: a case study in the Kagoshima University Research Forest, southwestern Japan. Jpn J For Plann, 2017, 51: 1-7 in Japanese

[15] GabiraMM, GironaMM, DesRochersA, KratzD, da SilvaRBG, DuarteMM, de AguiarNS, WendlingI. The impact of planting density on forest monospecific plantations: an overview. For Ecol Manag, 2023, 534, ArticleID: 120882

[16] GardinerES, PoudelKP, LeiningerTD, SouterRA, RousseauRJ, DahalB. Early dynamics of carbon accumulation as influenced by spacing of a Populus deltoides planting. Forests, 2024, 15: 226

[17] GISD (2024) Global invasive species database: 100 of the world’s worst invasive alien species. http://www.iucngisd.org/gisd/100_worst.php

[18] HagerHA, RyanGD, KovacsHM, NewmanJA. Effects of elevated CO₂ on photosynthetic traits of native and invasive C3 and C4 grasses. BMC Ecol, 2016, 16: 28

[19] HarataniH, ItoS, NakayamaH, YamagishiK, YamagawaH, MizokuchiT, HirataR. Difference in suppression effect on Sugi planted trees between miscanthus- and deciduous-tree-dominated vegetation. J Jpn For Soc, 2023, 105: 147-153 in Japanese

[20] Hilbert DR, Roman LA, Koeser AK, Vogt J, van Doorn NS (2019) Urban tree mortality: a literature review. Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 45(5): 167–200. Available at: https://www.fs.usda.gov/nrs/pubs/jrnl/2019/nrs_2019_hilbert_001.pdf

[21] Hong GH, Schneider T (2020) Shrinkonomics: lessons from Japan. Finance and Development 2020(03): 20−23. Available at: https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2020/03/shrinkanomics-policy-lessons-from-japan-on-population-aging-schneider

[22] HoshizakiK, TakahashiS, TanakaH, OkiS, MatsushitaM. Stochasticity of individual competition and local matchup inequality for saplings in a niche-structured forest. Ecology, 2022, 103, ArticleID: e3624

[23] ItoS, HirataR, YamagishiK, MizokuchiT, YamagawaH. Reducing weeding period by utilizing large cuttings from ‘Specified Mother Tree’ of Japanese cedar. J Jpn For Soc, 2023, 105: 245-251 in Japanese

[24] Japan Meteorological Agency (2024) Overview of Japan’s climate. Accessed 2024/12/30 https://www.data.jma.go.jp/cpd/longfcst/en/tourist_japan.html

[25] KabeyaD, UtsugiH, KitaK, OguraA, TanakaH. The performance of containerized tree seedlings after outplantings evaluated from multi-site data set. J Jpn For Soc, 2016, 98: 214-222 in Japanese

[26] KijidaniY, TsuyamaT, OdaH, HirataR, ItohS. Wood density and microfibril angle from pith to bark of a sugi cultivar (Cryptomeria japonica, Japanese cedar, Tosaaka) grown in a Nelder plot. J Wood Sci, 2022, 68: 57

[27] KuznetsovaA, BrockhoffPB, ChristensenRHB. lmerTest package: tests in linear mixed effects models. J Stat Softw, 2017, 82(13): 1-26

[28] MasakiT, OguroM, YamashitaN, OtaniT, UtsugiH. Reforestation following harvesting of conifer plantations in Japan: current issues from silvicultural and ecological perspectives. Reforesta, 2017, 3: 125-142

[29] MatsushitaM. Past, present and future of forest tree breeding in Japan: (2) Japanese cedar – 3. The breeding strategy, and the selection of first- and next-generation plus trees of Japanese cedar. For Gene Tree Breed, 2023, 12: 157-162 in Japanese

[30] MatsushitaM. Advantages and disadvantages of planting seedlings and cuttings vary with environments: Japanese cedar seedlings achieve greater growth and survival rates but inferior stem forms than cuttings. For Ecol Manag, 2025, 579, ArticleID: 122495

[31] MatsushitaM, TakataK, HitsumaG, YagihashiT, NoguchiM, ShibataM, MasakiT. A novel growth model evaluating age–size effect on long-term trends in tree growth. Funct Ecol, 2015, 29: 1250-1259

[32] MatsushitaM, HiraokaY, TanakaI, OnodaY. Variation among Japanese cedar clones in crown architecture and growth sensitivity to competition. Jpn For Soc Cong, 2022, 133: 155 in Japanese

[33] MizukiI, IshikawaY, HoshizakiK, TakakaiK, MatsushitaM, MakitaA. Effects of soil depth and moisture, light, and neighborhood competition on the diameter growth in an old growth Japanese cedar (Cryptomeria japonica) stand, Akita, Japan. J Jpn For Soc, 2016, 98: 101-107 in Japanese

[34] NaganoS, HiraoT, TakashimaT, MatsushitaM, MishimaK, TakahashiM, IkiT, IshiguriF, HiraokaY. SNP genotyping with target Amplicon sequencing using a multiplexed primer panel and its application to genomic prediction in Japanese cedar, Cryptomeria japonica (Lf) D. Don. Forests, 2020, 11(9): 898

[35] OhiraM, MatsushitaM. Effects of fertilization level on the growth of Cryptomeria japonica container seedlings. J Jpn for Soc, 2019, 101: 109-114 in Japanese

[36] PintoJR, MarshallJD, DumroeseRK, DavisAS. Establishment and growth of container seedlings for reforestation: a function of stocktype and edaphic conditions. Forest Ecol Manag, 2011, 261: 1876-1884

[37] R Core Team (2024) A language and environment for statistical computing. R version 4.4.1. In: R Found Stat Comput Vienna, Austria

[38] RameshK, MatloobA, AslamF, FlorentineSK, ChauhanBS. Weeds in a changing climate: vulnerabilities, consequences, and implications for future weed management. Front Plant Sci, 2017, 8: 95

[39] RutledgeBT, CannonJB, McintyreRK, HollandAM, JackSB. Tree, stand, and landscape factors contributing to hurricane damage in a coastal plain forest: post-hurricane assessment in a longleaf pine landscape. For Ecol Manag, 2021, 481, ArticleID: 118724

[40] SatoY, FukatsuE, HiraokaY, WatanabeA, TakahashiM. The effect of genotype and planting density on the growth patterns and selection of local varieties of Sugi (Cryptomeria japonica). J Jpn For Soc, 2016, 98: 45-52 in Japanese

[41] ShihCY, YenTM, WangYN. Comparison of various growth functions for predicting long-term stand development associated with different initial spacing in 64-year-old Japanese cedar (Cryptomeria japonica (L.f.) D. Don) plantations. Ann For Res, 2021, 64: 87-97

[42] SongL, BoithiasL, SengtaheuanghoungO, OeurngC, ValentinC, SouksavathB, SounyafongP, de RouwA, SoulileuthB, SilveraN, LattanavongkotB, PierretA, RibolziO. Understory limits surface runoff and soil loss in teak tree plantations of northern Lao PDR. Water, 2020, 12(9): 2327

[43] SzatniewskaJ, ZavadilovaI, NezvalO, KrejzaJ, PetrikP, ČaterM, StojanovićM. Species-specific growth and transpiration response to changing environmental conditions in floodplain forest. For Ecol Manag, 2022, 516, ArticleID: 120248

[44] TakahashiM, MiuraM, FukatsuE, HiraokaY, KuritaM. Research and project activities for breeding of Cryptomeria japonica D. Don in Japan. J For Res, 2023, 28: 83-97

[45] TakahashiY, MatsushitaM, TamuraA, OhiraM, TakahashiM. Age trends in genetic parameters and genetic gains of growth traits in multiple progeny test sites of hinoki cypress (Chamaecyparis obtusa). J For Res, 2023, 29: 103-111

[46] TsurusakiY, YamagawaH, ItoS, ShigenagaH, SasakiS. Criterion for the need to weed on Sugi (Cryptomeria japonica) plantations varies according to competing vegetation types. J Jpn For Soc, 2020, 102: 225-231 in Japanese

[47] WilsonER, VitolsKC, ParkA. Root characteristics and growth potential of container and bare-root seedlings of red oak (Quercus rubra L.) in Ontario Canada. New For, 2007, 34: 163-176

[48] YamagawaH, ShigenagaH, ArakiMGNH. Effects of initial size and surrounding weed trees on height growth of planted Sugi (Cryptomeria japonica) trees in Kyushu, Japan. J Jpn For Soc, 2016, 98: 241-246 in Japanese

[49] ZavadilováI, SzatniewskaJ, StojanovićM, FleischerP, VágnerL, PavelkaM, PetríkP. The effect of thinning intensity on sap flow and growth of Norway spruce. J For Sci, 2023, 69: 205-216

[50] ZavadilováI, SzatniewskaJ, PetríkP, MauerO, PokornýR, StojanovićM. Sap flow and growth response of Norway spruce under long-term partial rainfall exclusion at low altitude. Front Plant Sci, 2023, 14: 1089706

[51] ZhaoD, KaneM, TeskeyR, FoxTR, AlbaughTJ, AllenHL, RubilarR. Maximum response of loblolly pine plantations to silvicultural management in the southern United States. For Ecol Manag, 2016, 375: 105-111

[52] ZhouX, ZhuH, WenY, GoodaleUM, LiX, YouY, YeD, LiangH. Effects of understory management on trade-offs and synergies between biomass carbon stock, plant diversity and timber production in eucalyptus plantations. For Ecol Manag, 2018, 410: 164-173

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

Northeast Forestry University