Temporal shifts in the importance of environmental factors and management interventions among species in the early stages of forest restoration

Abstract

Both abiotic conditions and management influence the success of forest restoration. Despite growing interest and practical effort in restoring degraded forest landscapes, understanding of how disparate factors, such as terrain, soil conditions, climate and silvicultural treatments, directly or collectively control species performance and shape community recovery remains limited. In this study, we assessed how topography and management intervention affect seedling survival and growth in the early stages of restoration. To do so, we established seven experimental plots, each measuring 20 m × 20 m (400 m²) subdivided into 48 subplots, in coarse, anthropogenic grassland on a mid-elevation mountain slope in Hong Kong, and planted a total of 3975 native tree seedlings belonging to 12 tree species within them. To characterise topography, we modelled the elevation, slope, convexity and aspect of each subplot. Two types of tree guard (enclosed blue plastic sleeve and open yellow mesh), two types of fertiliser (organic and inorganic) and cardboard weeding mats were used to assess the impact of management interventions on the establishment of the seedlings. Survivorship, height and basal diameter were measured at 1, 2 and 4 years after planting. We used generalised linear models to examine the effect of these factors and their interactions on seedling survival, and we applied linear models and hierarchical partitioning to explore their relative importance in determining the relative growth rate (RGR) of each species. The most parsimonious models were selected using the Akaike Information Criterion. Survivorship was 98.1%, 95.2% and 86.4% across all plots in the first, second and fourth year, respectively. On average, topographic and management variables explained 1.48–3.34% of total variation in RGR, respectively, for all species. The models revealed that type of tree guard, aspect and elevation were the most important factors explaining RGR and survival. Results of hierarchical partitioning by species and growth period showed that the key determinants of performance vary by species and shift over the course of early seedling establishment, emphasising the importance of both spatial and temporal scales in the restoration of degraded tropical forests. Our findings support the use of enclosed tree guards and fertiliser to improve survivorship and growth across a range of broadleaved Asiatic species. All potential limiting factors pertaining to both site factors and management, as well as their interactions, should be considered in restoration planning to maximise restoration success.

Keywords

Tree planting / Relative growth rate / Survivorship / Native species / South China

References

[1] Abbas S, Nichol JE, Fischer GA. Mapping and assessment of impacts of cold and frost on secondary forest in the marginally tropical landscape of Hong Kong. Agric For Meteor, 2017, 232: 543-549

[2] Abiem I, Kenfack D, Chapman HM (2023) Assessing the impact of abiotic and biotic factors on seedling survival in an African montane forest. Front For Glob Change 6:1108257. https://doi.org/10.3389/ffgc.2023.1108257

[3] Aerts R, Honnay O. Forest restoration, biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. BMC Ecol, 2011, 11: 29

[4] Albrecht C, Contreras Z, Wahl K, Sternberg M, Christoffersen B. Winners and losers in dryland reforestation: species survival, growth, and recruitment along a 33-year planting chronosequence. Restor Ecol, 2022, 30(4 e13559

[5] Aronson J, Goodwin N, Orlando L, Eisenberg C, Cross AT. A world of possibilities: six restoration strategies to support the United Nation’s Decade on ecosystem restoration. Restor Ecol, 2020, 28(4): 730-736

[6] Arroyo-Rodríguez V, Melo FPL, Martínez-Ramos M, Bongers F, Chazdon RL, Meave JA, Norden N, Santos BA, Leal IR, Tabarelli M. Multiple successional pathways in human-modified tropical landscapes: new insights from forest succession, forest fragmentation and landscape ecology research. Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc, 2017, 92(1326-340

[7] Atkinson J, Bonser SP. “Active” and “passive” ecological restoration strategies in meta-analysis. Restor Ecol, 2020, 28(5): 1032-1035

[8] Atkinson J, Freudenberger D, Dwyer JM, Standish RJ, Moles AT, Bonser SP. Plant size and neighbourhood characteristics influence survival and growth in a restored ex-agricultural ecosystem. Ecol Solut Evid, 2022, 3(1 e12131

[9] Barbosa R de S, Pereira GFM, Ribeiro SS, et al (2021) Key species selection for forest restoration after bauxite mining in the Eastern Amazon. Ecol Eng 162:106190. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2021.106190

[10] Banin LF, Raine EH, Rowland LM, Chazdon RL, Smith SW, Rahman NEB, Butler A, Philipson C, Applegate GG, Petter Axelsson E, Budiharta S, Chua SC, Cutler MEJ, Elliott S, Gemita E, Godoong E, Graham LLB, Hayward RM, Hector A, Ilstedt U, Jensen J, Kasinathan S, Kettle CJ, Lussetti D, Manohan B, Maycock C, Ngo KM, O’Brien MJ, Osuri AM, Reynolds G, Sauwai Y, Scheu S, Silalahi M, Slade EM, Swinfield T, Wardle DA, Wheeler C, Yeong KL, Burslem DFRP. The road to recovery: a synthesis of outcomes from ecosystem restoration in tropical and sub-tropical Asian forests. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci, 2022, 378: 20210090

[11] Bartholomew DC, Mosyaftiani A, Morgan B, Shah T, Shaw K, Stillman C, Baldwin K, Baqueiro LHR, Birkinshaw C, Breman E, Jr GD, Fereira MP, Flowers C, Gichira A, Jenkins J, Kindt R, Molin PG, Mungai T, Musa MAS, Ramahefamanana N, Smith PP, Gann GD (2024) The global biodiversity standard: manual for assessment and best practices. Botanic Gardens Conservation International & Society for Ecological Restoration, Richmond (GB), UK & SER Washington, D.C

[12] Bentos TV, Nascimento HEM, Williamson GB. Tree seedling recruitment in Amazon secondary forest: importance of topography and gap micro-site conditions. For Ecol Manag, 2013, 287: 140-146

[13] Berkowitz AR, Canham CD, Kelly VR. Competition vs facilitation of tree seedling growth and survival in early successional communities. Ecology, 1995, 76(4): 1156-1168

[14] Bhadouria R, Tripathi S, Srivastava P, Singh P. Handbook of research on the conservation and restoration of tropical dry forests, 2019, Hershey, IGI Global

[15] Brancalion PHS, Campoe O, Mendes JCT, Noel C, Moreira GG, van Melis J, Stape JL, Guillemot J. Intensive silviculture enhances biomass accumulation and tree diversity recovery in tropical forest restoration. Ecol Appl, 2019, 29(2 e01847

[16] Brancalion PHS, Viani RAG, Calmon M, Carrascosa H, Rodrigues RR. How to organize a large-scale ecological restoration program? The framework developed by the Atlantic forest restoration pact in Brazil. J Sustain For, 2013, 32(7): 728-744

[17] Burnham KP, Anderson DR. Multimodel inference: understanding AIC and BIC in model selection. Sociol Methods Res, 2004, 33: 261-304

[18] Callaway RM, Walker LR. Competition and facilitation: a synthetic approach to interactions in plant communities. Ecology, 1997, 78: 8

[19] Cao HL, Wu LF, Wang ZG, Huang ZL, Lin L, Wei SG, Lian JY, Ye WH. Dinghushan lower subtropical forest dynamics plot: tree species and their distribution patterns, 2013, Beijing, China Forestry Publishing House

[20] Cardoso FCG, Capellesso ES, de Britez RM, Inague G, Marques MCM. Landscape conservation as a strategy for recovering biodiversity: Lessons from a long-term program of pasture restoration in the southern Atlantic Forest. J Appl Ecol, 2022, 59(9): 2309-2321

[21] Castillo-Díaz D, Chen HY, Harrison RD, Wen B, Goodale UM. Seedling emergence and environmental filters determine Ficus recruitment in a subtropical landscape. For Ecol Manag, 2021, 497 119536

[22] Castro J, Zamora R, Hódar JA, Gómez JM. Use of shrubs as nurse plants: a new technique for reforestation in Mediterranean Mountains. Restor Ecol, 2002, 10(2297-305

[23] Cavin L, Mountford EP, Peterken GF, Jump AS. Extreme drought alters competitive dominance within and between tree species in a mixed forest stand. Funct Ecol, 2013, 27(6): 1424-1435

[24] Chau KC, Marafa LM. Vegetation chronosequence in Hong Kong: soil properties and successional development. Singap J Trop Geogr, 1999, 20(1): 24-35

[25] Chazdon RL, Gutierrez V, Brancalion PHS, Laestadius L, Guariguata MR. Co-creating conceptual and working frameworks for implementing forest and landscape restoration based on core principles. Forests, 2020, 11(6): 706

[26] Chazdon RL, Falk DA, Banin LF, Wagner M, Wilson SJ, Grabowski RC, Suding KN. The intervention continuum in restoration ecology: rethinking the active–passive dichotomy. Restor Ecol, 2021, 32(8 e13535

[27] Chen BX, Coggins C, Minor J, Zhang YQ. Fengshui forests and village landscapes in China: geographic extent, socioecological significance, and conservation prospects. Urban For Urban Green, 2018, 31: 79-92

[28] Chong ML, Yeung HY, Hon KK. Study of extreme cold surges in Hong Kong. Meteorology, 2023, 2(152-71

[29] Chu WH. Conservation of terrestrial biodiversity in Hong Kong, 1998, China, The University of Hong Kong

[30] Corlett RT. Environmental forestry in Hong Kong: 1871–1997. For Ecol Manag, 1999, 116(1–3): 93-105

[31] Cornelissen JHC. Aboveground morphology of shade-tolerant Castanopsis fargesii saplings in response to light environment. Int J Plant Sci, 1993, 154(4): 481-495

[32] de Castro AF, Boanares D, de Medeiros Sarmento PS, Caldeira CF, Michelan TS, Ramos SJ, Gastauer M. Fertilization during mineland rehabilitation may shift competitive outcomes toward invasive species. Restor Ecol, 2024, 32(4 e14108

[33] Di Sacco A, Hardwick KA, Blakesley D, Brancalion PHS, Breman E, Rebola LC, Chomba S, Dixon K, Elliott S, Ruyonga G, Shaw K, Smith P, Smith RJ, Antonelli A. Ten golden rules for reforestation to optimize carbon sequestration, biodiversity recovery and livelihood benefits. Glob Chang Biol, 2021, 27(7): 1328-1348

[34] Ding ZW, Li RN, O’Connor P, Zheng H, Huang BB, Kong LQ, Xiao Y, Xu WH, Ouyang ZY. An improved quality assessment framework to better inform large-scale forest restoration management. Ecol Indic, 2021, 123 107370

[35] Dollery R, Bowie MH, Dickinson NM. Tree guards and weed mats in a dry shrubland restoration in New Zealand. Ecol Manag Restor, 2018, 19(3): 259-263

[36] Dorji T, Facelli JM, Norbu T, Delean S, Brookes JD. Tree shelters facilitate brown oak seedling survival and establishment in a grazing-dominant forest of Bhutan, Eastern Himalaya. Restor Ecol, 2020, 28(5): 1145-1157

[37] Dubois MR, Chappelka AH, Robbins E, Somers G, Baker K. Tree shelters and weed control: effects on protection, survival and growth of cherrybark oak seedlings planted on a cutover site. New For, 2000, 20(2): 105-118

[38] Engelbrecht BMJ, Comita LS, Condit R, Kursar TA, Tyree MT, Turner BL, Hubbell SP. Drought sensitivity shapes species distribution patterns in tropical forests. Nature, 2007, 447(7140): 80-82

[39] Esri (2019) ArcGIS Desktop 10.7. Redlands, CA: Environmental Systems Research Institute.

[40] Fan BH, Tao WH, Qin GH, Hopkins I, Zhang Y, Wang QJ, Lin H, Guo L. Soil micro-climate variation in relation to slope aspect, position, and curvature in a forested catchment. Agric For Meteor, 2020, 290 107999

[41] Fang JY, Li YD, Zhu B, Liu GH, Zhou GY. Community structures and species richness in the montane rain forest of Jianfengling, Hainan Island, China. Biodivers Sci, 2004, 12(1): 29-43

[42] Fenner M. Seedlings. New Phytol, 2008, 106: 35-47

[43] Frelich LE, Sugita S, Reich PB, Davis MB, Friedman SK. Neighbourhood effects in forests: implications for within-stand patch structure. J Ecol, 1998, 86(1): 149-161

[44] Fremout T, Gutiérrez-Miranda CE, Briers S, Marcelo-Peña JL, Cueva-Ortiz E, Linares-Palomino R, de Los Ángeleslatorre-Cuadros M, Chang-Ruíz JC, Villegas-Gómez TL, Acosta-Flota AH, Plouvier D, Atkinson R, Charcape-Ravelo M, Aguirre-Mendoza Z, Muys B, Thomas E. The value of local ecological knowledge to guide tree species selection in tropical dry forest restoration. Restor Ecol, 2021, 29(4): e13347

[45] Gann GD, McDonald T, Walder B, Aronson J, Nelson CR, Jonson J, Hallett JG, Eisenberg C, Guariguata MR, Liu JG, Hua FY, Echeverría C, Gonzales E, Shaw N, Decleer K, Dixon KW. International principles and standards for the practice of ecological restoration. Second edition. Restor Ecol, 2019, 27: S1-S46

[46] Grömping U. Relative importance for linear regression in R: the package relaimpo. J Stat Soft, 2006, 17(11-27

[47] Grossnickle S. Seedling establishment on a forest restoration site. Reforesta, 2018, 6: 110-139

[48] Guariguata MR, Ostertag R. Neotropical secondary forest succession: changes in structural and functional characteristics. For Ecol Manag, 2001, 148(1–3): 185-206

[49] Hau BCH, Corlett RT. Factors affecting the early survival and growth of native tree seedlings planted on a degraded hillside grassland in Hong Kong. China Restor Ecol, 2003, 11(4): 483-488

[50] Holl KD. van Andel J, Aronson J. Restoration of tropical forests. Restoration Ecology, 20121Wiley103114

[51] Holl KD. Restoring tropical forests from the bottom up. Science, 2017, 355(6324): 455-456

[52] Holl KD, Aide TM. When and where to actively restore ecosystems?. For Ecol Manag, 2011, 261(10): 1558-1563

[53] Holl KD, Brancalion PHS. Tree planting is not a simple solution. Science, 2020, 368(6491): 580-581

[54] Hong Kong Observatory (2023) Climate of Hong Kong. https://www.hko.gov.hk/en/cis/climahk.htm

[55] Hooper ER, Legendre P, Condit R. Factors affecting community composition of forest regeneration in deforested, abandoned land in Panama. Ecology, 2004, 85(12): 3313-3326

[56] Hu Q, Wu D (2008) Flora of Hong Kong. Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department, Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Hong Kong SAR, China

[57] Jellinek S, Haslem A, O’Brien T, Bennett AF. Evaluating restoration outcomes: trial of a community-based monitoring protocol. Ecol Manag Restor, 2021, 22(3): 284-287

[58] Johnson DJ, Beaulieu WT, Bever JD, Clay K. Conspecific negative density dependence and forest diversity. Science, 2012, 336(6083): 904-907

[59] Kang J, Ding XG, Ma HY, Dai ZM, Li XC, Huang JG. Characteristics and risk of forest soil heavy metal pollution in western Guangdong province. China Forests, 2022, 13(6): 884

[60] Kauano ÉE, Cardoso FCG, Torezan JMD, Marques MCM. Micro-and meso-scale factors affect the restoration of Atlantic forest. Nat Con, 2013, 11(2145-151

[61] Khurana E, Singh JS. Ecology of seed and seedling growth for conservation and restoration of tropical dry forest: a review. Environ Conserv, 2001, 28(1): 39-52

[62] Kovács B, Tinya F, Németh C, Ódor P. Unfolding the effects of different forestry treatments on microclimate in oak forests: results of a 4-yr experiment. Ecol Appl, 2020, 30(2 e02043

[63] Ladd B, Larsen JR, Bonser SP. Effect of two types of tree guards (with and without weed control) on tree seedling establishment. Ecol Manag Restor, 2010, 11(1): 75-76

[64] Lai PCC, Wong BSF. Effects of tree guards and weed mats on the establishment of native tree seedlings: implications for forest restoration in Hong Kong. China Restor Ecol, 2005, 13(1): 138-143

[65] Lal R. Restoring soil quality to mitigate soil degradation. Sustainability, 2015, 7(5): 5875-5895

[66] Lands Department, The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (2017) Digital Terrain Model (DTM)

[67] Lázaro-González A, Andivia E, Hampe A, Hasegawa S, Marzano R, Santos AMC, Castro J, Leverkus AB. Revegetation through seeding or planting: a worldwide systematic map. J Environ Manag, 2023, 337 117713

[68] Lee KWK, Cheuk ML, Fischer GA, Gale SW. Can disparate shared social values benefit the conservation of biodiversity in Hong Kong’s sacred groves?. Hum Ecol, 2023, 51(5): 1021-1032

[69] LeFevre ME, Churchill DJ, Larson AJ, Jeronimo SMA, Bass J, Franklin JF, Kane VR. Evaluating restoration treatment effectiveness through a comparison of residual composition, structure, and spatial pattern with historical reference sites. For Sci, 2020, 66(5): 578-588

[70] Li Y, Schuldt A, Ebeling A, Eisenhauer N, Huang YY, Albert G, Albracht C, Amyntas A, Bonkowski M, Bruelheide H, Bröcher M, Chesters D, Chen J, Chen YN, Chen JT, Ciobanu M, Deng XL, Fornoff F, Gleixner G, Guo LD, Guo PF, Heintz-Buschart A, Klein AM, Lange M, Li S, Li Q, Li YB, Luo AR, Meyer ST, von Oheimb G, Rutten G, Scholten T, Solbach MD, Staab M, Wang MQ, Zhang NL, Zhu CD, Schmid B, Ma KP, Liu XJ. Plant diversity enhances ecosystem multifunctionality via multitrophic diversity. Nat Ecol Evol, 2024, 8(11): 2037-2047

[71] Li Z, Lin W, Guan Z, et al.. Tree growth and mortality of secondary evergreen broadleaved and temperate coniferous forests and their drivers along elevation gradients in subtropical mountain of China. J For Res, 2024, 36: 17

[72] Lin TC, Aaron Hogan J, Chang CT. Tropical cyclone ecology: a scale-link perspective. Trends Ecol Evol, 2020, 35(7): 594-604

[73] Löf M, Madsen P, Metslaid M, Witzell J, Jacobs DF. Restoring forests: regeneration and ecosystem function for the future. New For, 2019, 50(2139-151

[74] Londe V, Turini Farah F, Ribeiro Rodrigues R, Roberto Martins F. Reference and comparison values for ecological indicators in assessing restoration areas in the Atlantic Forest. Ecol Indic, 2020, 110 105928

[75] Loureiro N, Mantuano D, Manhães A, Sansevero J. Use of the trait-based approach in ecological restoration studies: a global review. Trees, 2023, 37(5): 1287-1297

[76] Lu Y, Ranjitkar S, Harrison RD, Xu JC, Ou XK, Ma XL, He J. Selection of native tree species for subtropical forest restoration in southwest China. PLoS ONE, 2017, 12(1 e0170418

[77] Marafa L. Integrating natural and cultural heritage: the advantage of feng shui landscape resources. Int J Herit Stud, 2003, 9(4): 307-323

[78] Mariotti B, Maltoni A, Jacobs DF, Tani A. Tree shelters affect shoot and root system growth and structure in Quercus robur during regeneration establishment. Eur J For Res, 2015, 134(4): 641-652

[79] Martins KG, Marques MCM, dos Santos E, Marques R. Effects of soil conditions on the diversity of tropical forests across a successional gradient. For Ecol Manag, 2015, 349: 4-11

[80] Meli P, Martínez-Ramos M, Rey-Benayas JM, Carabias J. Combining ecological, social and technical criteria to select species for forest restoration. Appl Veg Sci, 2014, 17(4): 744-753

[81] Metcalfe DJ, Bradford MG, Ford AJ. Cyclone damage to tropical rain forests: Species- and community-level impacts. Austral Ecol, 2008, 33(4): 432-441

[82] Midway S, Robertson M, Flinn S, Kaller M. Comparing multiple comparisons: practical guidance for choosing the best multiple comparisons test. PeerJ, 2020, 8 e10387

[83] Mirzabaev A, Wuepper D. Economics of ecosystem restoration. Annu Rev Resour Econ, 2023, 15: 329-350

[84] Nagamatsu D, Seiwa K, Sakai A. Seedling establishment of deciduous trees in various topographic positions. J Veg Sci, 2002, 13(1): 35-44

[85] O’Brien MJ, Escudero A. Topography in tropical forests enhances growth and survival differences within and among species via water availability and biotic interactions. Funct Ecol, 2022, 36(3): 686-698

[86] Oliet JA, Jacobs DF. Microclimatic conditions and plant morpho-physiological development within a tree shelter environment during establishment of Quercus ilex seedlings. Agric For Meteor, 2007, 144(1–2): 58-72

[87] Oliet JA, Planelles R, Artero F, Jacobs DF. Nursery fertilization and tree shelters affect long-term field response of Acacia salicina Lindl. planted in Mediterranean semiarid conditions. For Ecol Manag, 2005, 215(13): 339-351

[88] Oliet JA, Puértolas J, Valenzuela P, Vázquez de Castro A. Light transmissivity of tree shelters interacts with site environment and species ecophysiology to determine outplanting performance in Mediterranean climates. Land, 2021, 10(7): 753

[89] Padilla FM, Pugnaire FI. The role of nurse plants in the restoration of degraded environments. Front Ecol Environ, 2006, 4(4196-202

[90] R Core Team (2024) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria.

[91] Ritter E, Dalsgaard L, Einhorn KS. Light, temperature and soil moisture regimes following gap formation in a semi-natural beech-dominated forest in Denmark. For Ecol Manag, 2005, 206(1–3): 15-33

[92] Robinson D, Hayes A, Couch S (2024) broom: convert statistical objects into tidy tibbles

[93] Rodrigues RR, Lima RAF, Gandolfi S, Nave AG. On the restoration of high diversity forests: 30 years of experience in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest. Biol Conserv, 2009, 142(6): 1242-1251

[94] Sanjeewani N, Samarasinghe D, Jayasinghe H, Ukuwela K, Wijetunga A, Wahala S, De Costa J. Variation of floristic diversity, community composition, endemism, and conservation status of tree species in tropical rainforests of Sri Lanka across a wide altitudinal gradient. Sci Rep, 2024, 14(1): 2090

[95] Siqueira DP, Ford C, Lloyd A, et al.. Container size and site quality affect survival and early growth performance of New Zealand native tree species. J For Res, 2025

[96] Scott VH. Reducing single-use plastics in forestry. Scott For, 2023, 77: 24-27

[97] Sharew H, Hairston-Strang A. A comparison of seedling growth and light transmission among tree shelters. North J Appl For, 2005, 22(2102-110

[98] Stange R, Kathleen L, Shea EE. Effects of Deer browsing, fabric mats, and tree shelters on Quercus rubra seedlings. Restor Ecol, 1998, 6(1): 29-34

[99] Sweeney BW, Czapka SJ. Riparian forest restoration: why each site needs an ecological prescription. For Ecol Manag, 2004, 192(2–3): 361-373

[100] Tang T, Zhang NL, Bongers FJ, Staab M, Schuldt A, Fornoff F, Lin H, Cavender-Bares J, Hipp AL, Li S, Liang Y, Han BC, Klein AM, Bruelheide H, Durka W, Schmid B, Ma KP, Liu XJ. Tree species and genetic diversity increase productivity via functional diversity and trophic feedbacks. Elife, 2022, 11 e78703

[101] Temperton VM, Buchmann N, Buisson E, Durigan G, Kazmierczak Ł, Perring MP, de Sá DM, Veldman JW, Overbeck GE. Step back from the forest and step up to the Bonn challenge: how a broad ecological perspective can promote successful landscape restoration. Restor Ecol, 2019, 27(4): 705-719

[102] Tucker NIJ, Elliott S, Holl KD, Zahawi RA (2023) Restoring tropical forests: lessons learned from case studies on three continents. In: Ecological restoration. Springer, pp 63–101. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-25412-3_3

[103] Turchetto F, Araujo MM, Tabaldi LA, Griebeler AM, Rorato DG, Berghetti ÁLP, Barbosa FM, Santos de Lima M, Costella C, Sasso VM. Intensive silvicultural practices drive the forest restoration in southern Brazil. For Ecol Manag, 2020, 473 118325

[104] Valladares F, Laanisto L, Niinemets Ü, Zavala MA. Shedding light on shade: ecological perspectives of understorey plant life. Plant Ecol Divers, 2016, 9(3): 237-251

[105] Wallace KJ, Clarkson BD, Farnworth B. Restoration trajectories and ecological thresholds during planted urban forest successional development. Forests, 2022, 13(2): 199

[106] Werden LK, Holl KD, Rosales JA, Sylvester JM, Zahawi RA. Effects of dispersal- and niche-based factors on tree recruitment in tropical wet forest restoration. Ecol Appl, 2020, 30(7 e02139

[107] Wickham H. ggplot2: elegant graphics for data analysis, 2016, Cham, New York, Springer

[108] Williams LJ, Paquette A, Cavender-Bares J, Messier C, Reich PB. Spatial complementarity in tree crowns explains overyielding in species mixtures. Nat Ecol Evol, 2017, 1(463

[109] Winkler DE, Garbowski M, Kožić K, Ladouceur E, Larson J, Martin S, Rosche C, Roscher C, Slate ML, Korell L. Facilitating comparable research in seedling functional ecology. Meth Ecol Evol, 2024, 15(3464-476

[110] Wu Y, Ou GL, Lu TF, Huang TB, Zhang XL, Liu ZH, Yu ZB, Guo BB, Wang E, Feng ZH, Luo HB, Lu C, Wang LG, Xu WH. Improving aboveground biomass estimation in lowland tropical forests across aspect and age stratification: a case study in Xishuangbanna. Remote Sens, 2024, 16(7): 1276

[111] Xing FW, Ng SC, Chau LKC. Gymnosperms and angiosperms of Hong Kong. Mem Hong Kong Nat Hist Soc, 2000, 23: 21-135

[112] Xu H, Li YD, Liu SR, Zang RG, He FL, Spence JR. Partial recovery of a tropical rain forest a half-century after clear-cut and selective logging. J Appl Ecol, 2015, 52(41044-1052

[113] Ye X, Bu W, Hu X, et al.. Species divergence in seedling leaf traits and tree growth response to nitrogen and phosphorus additions in an evergreen broadleaved forest of subtropical China. J For Res, 2023, 34: 137-150

[114] Yu LJ, Zhong SY, Qiu YB, Liang X. Trend in short-duration extreme precipitation in Hong Kong. Front Environ Sci, 2020, 8 581536

[115] Zhao ML, Pan B, Tan YH, Corlett RT. Winners and losers among tree species in Xishuangbanna: which traits are most important?. Sci Bull, 2015, 60(10): 916-924

[116] Zhu H, Roos M. The tropical flora of southern China and its affinity to Indo-Malesian flora. Telopea, 2004, 10: 639-648

[117] Zhu Y, Mi XC, Ren HB, Ma KP. Density dependence is prevalent in a heterogeneous subtropical forest. Oikos, 2010, 119(1): 109-119

[118] Zhu HL, Zhang JL, Cheuk ML, Hau BCH, Fischer GA, Gale SW. Monoculture plantations impede forest recovery: evidence from the regeneration of lowland subtropical forest in Hong Kong. Front For Glob Change, 2023, 6: 1098666

[119] Zuur AF, Ieno EN, Walker N, Saveliev AA, Smith GM. Mixed effects models and extensions in ecology with R, 2009, New York, Springer

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)