Effects of tree diversity on insect herbivory

Abstract

Tree diversity has long been considered a key driver of insect herbivory in forest ecosystems. However, studies have given contradictory results: increased tree diversity can have positive, negative or neutral effects on insect herbivory. Since many issues can complicate the tree-herbivore interactions, the descriptor ‘tree diversity’ per se actually has only limited explanatory power for insect herbivory. Particularly, in addition to the direct bottom-up effects on insect herbivores, tree diversity may have stronger indirect top-down effects via natural enemies of insect herbivores. However, most research has addressed only direct bottom-up impacts. In fact, insect herbivory is the result of complex interactions (food webs) among all the species in a community. Although it is hard to integrate all functionally important species and dynamic information into food webs, the effects of tree diversity on insect herbivory are highly dependent on the dominant species at different trophic levels. It is important and practical to simultaneously consider the characteristics of main trees, herbivores, and natural enemies when attempting to predict the overall effects of forest tree diversity on insect herbivory. In order to ensure comparability between studies, it is necessary to classify them according to the descriptors of insect herbivory and tree diversity, and to compare results within each category. These measures might enhance our understanding of the mechanisms by which tree diversity drives insect herbivory and, in turn, help to develop sustainable pest management strategies for forests.

Keywords

Enemy diversity / Food webs / Sustainable pest management / Tree diversity / Tree-herbivore interactions

References

[1] Abdala-Roberts L, Mooney KA, Quijano-Medina T, Campos-Navarrete MJ, González-Moreno A, Parra-Tabla V. Comparison of tree genotypic diversity and species diversity effects on different guilds of insect herbivores. Oikos, 2015, 124: 1527-1535.

[2] Barbosa VS, Leal IR, Iannuzzi L, Almeida-Cortez J. Distribution pattern of herbivorous insects in a remnant of Brazilian Atlantic Forest. Neotrop Entomol, 2005, 34: 701-711.

[3] Barbosa P, Hines J, Kaplan I, Martinson H, Szczepaniec A, Szendrei Z. Associational resistance and associational susceptibility: having right or wrong neighbors. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst, 2009, 40: 1-20.

[4] Barton KE, Valkama E, Vehviläinen H, Ruohomäki K, Knight TM, Koricheva J. Additive and non-additive effects of birch genotypic diversity on arthropod herbivory in a long-term field experiment. Oikos, 2015, 124: 697-706.

[5] Belovsky GE, Slade JB. Insect herbivory accelerates nutrient cycling and increases plant production. Proc Natl Acad Sci, 2000, 97: 14412-14417.

[6] Berlow EL, Neutel A-M, Cohen JE, de Ruiter PC, Ebenman B, Emmerson M, Fox JW, Jansen VAA, Iwan Jones J, Kokkoris GD Interaction strengths in food webs: issues and opportunities. J Anim Ecol, 2004, 73: 585-598.

[7] Bommarco R, Banks JE. Scale as modifier in vegetation diversity experiments: effects on herbivores and predators. Oikos, 2003, 102: 440-448.

[8] Brezzi M, Schmid B, Niklaus PA, Schuldt A. Tree diversity increases levels of herbivore damage in a subtropical forest canopy: evidence for dietary mixing by arthropods?. J Plant Ecol, 2017, 10: 13-27.

[9] Carrasco D, Larsson MC, Anderson P. Insect host plant selection in complex environments. Curr Opin Insect Sci, 2015, 8: 1-7.

[10] Castagneyrol B, Giffard B, Péré C, Jactel H. Plant apparency, an overlooked driver of associational resistance to insect herbivory. J Ecol, 2013, 101: 418-429.

[11] Castagneyrol B, Jactel H, Vacher C, Brockerhoff EG, Koricheva J, Cadotte M. Effects of plant phylogenetic diversity on herbivory depend on herbivore specialization. J Appl Ecol, 2014, 51: 134-141.

[12] Castagneyrol B, Giffard B, Valdés-Correcher E, Hampe A. Tree diversity effects on leaf insect damage on pedunculate oak: the role of landscape context and forest stratum. Forest Ecol Manag, 2019, 433: 287-294.

[13] Conner LG, Bunnell MC, Gill RA. Forest diversity as a factor influencing Engelmann spruce resistance to beetle outbreaks. Can J For Res, 2014, 44: 1369-1375.

[14] Doi H, Kambach S, Kühn I, Castagneyrol B, Bruelheide H. The impact of tree diversity on different aspects of insect herbivory along a global temperature gradient: a meta-analysis. PLoS ONE, 2016, 11: e0165815.

[15] Dyer LA, Richards LA, Short SA, Dodson CD. Effects of CO₂ and temperature on tritrophic interactions. PLoS ONE, 2013, 8: e62528.

[16] Ferrari J, Darby AC, Daniell TJ, Godfray HCJ, Douglas AE. Linking the bacterial community in pea aphids with host-plant use and enemy resistance. Ecol Entomol, 2004, 29: 60-65.

[17] Finch S, Collier RH. Host-plant selection by insects—a theory based on ‘appropriate/inappropriate landings’ by pest insects of cruciferous plant. Entomol Exp Appl, 2000, 96: 91-102.

[18] Frost CJ, Hunter MD. Insect canopy herbivory and frass deposition affect soil nutrient dynamics and export in oak mesocosms. Ecology, 2004, 85: 3335-3347.

[19] Frost CJ, Hunter MD. Insect herbivores and their frass affect Quercus rubra leaf quality and initial stages of subsequent litter decomposition. Oikos, 2008, 117: 13-22.

[20] Gilbert GS, Magarey R, Suiter K, Webb CO. Evolutionary tools for phytosanitary risk analysis: phylogenetic signal as a predictor of host range of plant pests and pathogens. Evol Appl, 2012, 5: 869-878.

[21] Gómez JM, Verdú M, Perfectti F. Ecological interactions are evolutionarily conserved across the entire tree of life. Nature, 2010, 465: 918-921.

[22] Gravel D, Albouy C, Thuiller W. The meaning of functional trait composition of food webs for ecosystem functioning. Philos Trans R Soc B Biol Sci, 2016, 371: 20150268.

[23] Haase J, Castagneyrol B, Cornelissen JHC, Ghazoul J, Kattge J, Koricheva J, Scherer-Lorenzen M, Morath S, Jactel H. Contrasting effects of tree diversity on young tree growth and resistance to insect herbivores across three biodiversity experiments. Oikos, 2015, 124: 1674-1685.

[24] Harvey KJ, Nipperess DA, Britton DR, Hughes L. Australian family ties: does a lack of relatives help invasive plants escape natural enemies?. Biol Invasions, 2012, 14: 2423-2434.

[25] Hochwender CG, Sork VL, Marquis RJ. Fitness consequences of herbivory on Quercus alba. Am Midl Nat, 2003, 150: 246-253.

[26] Ives AR, Cardinale BJ, Snyder WE. A synthesis of subdisciplines: predator–prey interactions, and biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. Ecol Lett, 2004, 8: 102-116.

[27] Jactel H, Brockerhoff EG. Tree diversity reduces herbivory by forest insects. Ecol Lett, 2007, 10: 835-848.

[28] Jactel H, Menassieu P, Vetillard F, Gaulier A, Samalens JC, Brockerhoff EG. Tree species diversity reduces the invasibility of maritime pine stands by the bast scale, Matsucoccus feytaudi (Homoptera: Margarodidae). Can J For Res, 2006, 36: 314-323.

[29] Jonsson M, Kaartinen R, Straub CS. Relationships between natural enemy diversity and biological control. Curr Opin Insect Sci, 2017, 20: 1-6.

[30] Kaitaniemi P, Riihimäki J, Koricheva J, Vehviläinen H. Experimental evidence for associational resistance against the European pine sawXy in mixed tree stands. Silva Fenn, 2007, 41: 259-268.

[31] Karban R. Associational resistance for mule’s ears with sagebrush neighbors. Plant Ecol, 2007, 191: 295-303.

[32] Karban R, Shiojiri K, Ishizaki S, Wetzel WC, Evans RY. Kin recognition affects plant communication and defence. Proc Biol Sci, 2013, 280: 1-5.

[33] Karlsen SR, Odland A, Jepsen JU, Ims RA, Elvebakk A. Outbreaks by canopy-feeding geometrid moth cause state-dependent shifts in understorey plant communities. Oecologia, 2013, 173: 859-870.

[34] Koricheva J, Gange AC, Jones T. Effects of mycorrhizal fungi on insect herbivores: a meta-analysis. Ecology, 2009, 90: 2088-2097.

[35] le Mellec A, Gerold G, Michalzik B. Insect herbivory, organic matter deposition and effects on belowground organic matter fluxes in a central European oak forest. Plant Soil, 2011, 342: 393-403.

[36] Letourneau DK, Jedlicka JA, Bothwell SG, Moreno CR. Effects of natural enemy biodiversity on the suppression of arthropod herbivores in terrestrial ecosystems. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst, 2009, 40: 573-592.

[37] López-Villamor A, Carreño S, López-Goldar X, Suárez-Vidal E, Sampedro L, Nordlander G, Björklund N, Zas R. Risk of damage by the pine weevil Hylobius abietis in southern Europe: effects of silvicultural and landscape factors. Forest Ecol Manag, 2019, 444: 290-298.

[38] Maas B, Karp DS, Bumrungsri S, Darras K, Gonthier D, Huang JCC, Lindell CA, Maine JJ, Mestre L, Michel NL Bird and bat predation services in tropical forests and agroforestry landscapes. Biol Rev, 2016, 91: 1081-1101.

[39] Macfadyen S, Gibson R, Polaszek A, Morris RJ, Craze PG, Planqué R, Symondson WOC, Memmott J. Do differences in food web structure between organic and conventional farms affect the ecosystem service of pest control?. Ecol Lett, 2009, 12: 229-238.

[40] Mauchline AL, Osborne JL, Martin AP, Poppy GM, Powell W. The effects of non-host plant essential oil volatiles on the behaviour of the pollen beetle Meligethes aeneus. Entomol Exp Appl, 2005, 114: 181-188.

[41] McCann K. Protecting biostructure. Nature, 2007, 446: 29.

[42] Metcalfe DB, Crutsinger GM, Kumordzi BB, Wardle DA. Nutrient fluxes from insect herbivory increase during ecosystem retrogression in boreal forest. Ecology, 2016, 97: 124-132.

[43] Mishra M, Lomate PR, Joshi RS, Punekar SA, Gupta VS, Giri AP. Ecological turmoil in evolutionary dynamics of plant–insect interactions: defense to offence. Planta, 2015, 242: 761-771.

[44] Moen J, Mooney KA, Pratt RT, Singer MS. The tri-trophic interactions hypothesis: interactive effects of host plant quality, diet breadth and natural enemies on herbivores. PLoS ONE, 2012, 7: e34403.

[45] Mooney KA. Tritrophic effects of birds and ants on a canopy food web, tree growth, and phytochemistry. Ecology, 2007, 88: 2005-2014.

[46] Moreira X, Abdala-Roberts L, Rasmann S, Castagneyrol B, Mooney KA. Plant diversity effects on insect herbivores and their natural enemies: current thinking, recent findings, and future directions. Curr Opin Insect Sci, 2016, 14: 1-7.

[47] Murakami M, Wada N. Difference in leaf quality between canopy trees and seedlings affects migration and survival of spring-feeding moth larvae. Can J For Res, 1997, 27: 1351-1356.

[48] Ness JH, Rollinson EJ, Whitney KD. Phylogenetic distance can predict susceptibility to attack by natural enemies. Oikos, 2011, 120: 1327-1334.

[49] Ødegaard F, Diserud OH, Østbye K. The importance of plant relatedness for host utilization among phytophagous insects. Ecol Lett, 2005, 8: 612-617.

[50] Otway SJ, Hector A, Lawton JH. Resource dilution effects on specialist insect herbivores in a grassland biodiversity experiment. J Anim Ecol, 2005, 74: 234-240.

[51] Parent CE, Agashe D, Bolnick DI. Intraspecific competition reduces niche width in experimental populations. Ecol Evol, 2014, 4: 3978-3990.

[52] Parker JD, Burkepile DE, Lajeunesse MJ, Lind EM. Phylogenetic isolation increases plant success despite increasing susceptibility to generalist herbivores. Divers Distrib, 2012, 18: 1-9.

[53] Pearse IS, Hipp AL. Phylogenetic and trait similarity to a native species predict herbivory on non-native oaks. Proc Natl Acad Sci, 2009, 106: 18097-18102.

[54] Plath M, Dorn S, Barrios H, Riedel J, Mody K. Associational resistance and associational susceptibility: specialist herbivores show contrasting responses to tree stand diversification. Oecologia, 2012, 169: 477-487.

[55] Root RB. Organization of a plant-arthropod association in simple and diverse habitats: the fauna of collards (Brassica oleracea). Ecol Monogr, 1973, 43: 95-124.

[56] Rosado-Sanchez S, Parra-Tabla V, Betancur-Ancona D, Moreira X, Abdala-Roberts L. Effects of tree species diversity on insect herbivory and leaf defences in Cordia dodecandra. Ecol Entomol, 2018, 43: 703-711.

[57] Rosenblatt AE, Schmitz OJ. Interactive effects of multiple climate change variables on trophic interactions: a meta-analysis. Clim Change Responses, 2014, 1: 1-10.

[58] Russell EP. Enemies hypothesis: a review of the effect of vegetational diversity on predatory insects and parasitoids. Environ Entomol, 1989, 18: 590-599.

[59] Schuldt A, Baruffol M, Böhnke M, Bruelheide H, Härdtle W, Lang AC, Nadrowski K, Von Oheimb G, Voigt W, Zhou H Tree diversity promotes insect herbivory in subtropical forests of south-east China. J Ecol, 2010, 98: 917-926.

[60] Schuldt A, Bruelheide H, Härdtle W, Assmann T, Li Y, Ma K, von Oheimb G, Zhang J, Austin A. Early positive effects of tree species richness on herbivory in a large-scale forest biodiversity experiment influence tree growth. J Ecol, 2015, 103: 563-571.

[61] Sobek S, Scherber C, SteVan-Dewenter I, Tscharntke T. Sapling hcrbivory, invertebrate herbivores and predators across a natural tree diversity gradient in Germany’S largest connected deciduous forest. Oecologia, 2009, 160: 279-288.

[62] Stoepler TM, Rehill B, Thompson K. Forest habitat, not leaf phenotype, predicts late-season folivory of Quercus alba saplings. Funct Ecol, 2012, 26: 1205-1213.

[63] Tack AJM, Roslin T. The relative importance of host-plant genetic diversity in structuring the associated herbivore community. Ecology, 2011, 92: 1594-1604.

[64] Umapathy G, Maguire DY, Buddle CM, Bennett EM. Within and among patch variability in patterns of insect herbivory across a fragmented forest landscape. PLoS ONE, 2016, 11: e0150843.

[65] Underwood N. Density dependence in insect performance within individual plants: induced resistance to Spodoptera exigua in tomato. Oikos, 2010, 119: 1993-1999.

[66] Utsumi S, Ando Y, Craig TP, Ohgushi T. Plant genotypic diversity increases population size of a herbivorous insect. Proc R Soc B Biol Sci, 2011, 278: 3108-3115.

[67] Valdés-Correcher E, van Halder I, Barbaro L, Castagneyrol B, Hampe A. Insect herbivory and avian insectivory in novel native oak forests: divergent effects of stand size and connectivity. For Ecol Manag, 2019, 445: 146-153.

[68] Vehviläinen H, Koricheva J, Ruohomäki K, Johansson T, Valkonen S. Effects of tree stand species composition on insect herbivory of silver birch in boreal forests. Basic Appl Ecol, 2006, 7: 1-11.

[69] Vehviläinen H, Koricheva J, Kai R. Tree species diversity influences herbivore abundance and damage: meta-analysis of long-term forest experiments. Oecologia, 2007, 152: 287-298.

[70] Vidal MC, Sendoya SF, Oliveira PS. Mutualism exploitation: predatory drosophilid larvae sugar-trap ants and jeopardize facultative ant-plant mutualism. Ecology, 2016, 97: 1650-1657.

[71] Vidal MC, Murphy SM, Scherber C. Bottom-up vs top-down effects on terrestrial insect herbivores: a meta-analysis. Ecol Lett, 2018, 21: 138-150.

[72] Weiblen GD, Webb CO, Novotny V, Basset Y, Miller SE. Phylogenetic dispersion of host use in a tropical insect herbivore community. Ecology, 2006, 87: S62-S75.

[73] Wiens JJ, Ackerly DD, Allen AP, Anacker BL, Buckley LB, Cornell HV, Damschen EI, Jonathan Davies T, Grytnes JA, Harrison SP Niche conservatism as an emerging principle in ecology and conservation biology. Ecol Lett, 2010, 13: 1310-1324.

[74] Wright J, Castagneyrol B, Lagache L, Giffard B, Kremer A, Jactel H. Genetic diversity increases insect herbivory on oak saplings. PLoS ONE, 2012, 7: e44247.

[75] Zvereva EL, Zverev V, Kozlov MV. Little strokes fell great oaks: minor but chronic herbivory substantially reduces birch growth. Oikos, 2012, 121: 2036-2043.