Responses of intra-annual runoff to forest recovery patterns in subtropical China

Abstract

Forest recovery plays a critical role in regulating eco-hydrological processes in forested watersheds. However, characteristics of the intra-annual runoff variation associated with different forest recovery patterns remain poorly understood. In this study, three forest change periods were identified, the baseline period (1961–1985), reforestation period (1986 − 2000) and fruit tree planting period (2001–2016). We selected the magnitude of seasonal runoff (wet and dry seasons) and distribution characteristics, i.e., non-uniformity coefficient (C _v), complete accommodation coefficient (C _r), concentration ratio (C _n), concentration period (C _d), absolute variation ratio (ΔR) and relative variation ratio (C _max). The pair-wise approach evaluated the intra-annual runoff variation characteristics between forest change periods. Results indicate that reforestation decreased wet season runoff and increased dry season runoff. In contrast, fruit tree planting increased wet season runoff and had no significant effect on dry season runoff. For intra-annual runoff distribution characteristics, reforestation significantly reduced the C _v, C _r, C _n and C _max. Distribution of the intra-annual runoff in the fruit tree planting period was not significantly different from the baseline. We concluded that reforestation reduced the occurance of extreme water conditions in wet and dry seasons and effectively increased the stability of the intra-annual runoff. In contrast, fruit tree planting increased instability and fluctuation of the intra-annual runoff after reforestation. The characteristics of the intra-annual runoff to fruit tree planting was similar to those of the baseline. Therefore, adopting fruit tree planting practices to regulate intra-annual runoff characteristics may not be a practical approach, and impacts of different reforestation practices should be ascertained in our study region. The implications of this study should guide regional land–water management, and this study adds to the understanding of the impacts gained in forest cover on hydrology.

Keywords

Intra-annual runoff variation / Seasonal runoff / Forest recovery / Reforestation / Fruit tree planting

References

[1] Alber M. A conceptual model of estuarine freshwater inflow management. Estuaries, 2002, 25: 1246-1261.

[2] Balota EL, Machineski O, Honda C, Yada IFU, Barbosa GMC, Nakatani AS, Coyne MS. Response of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi in different soil tillage systems to long-term swine slurry application. Land Degrad Dev, 2016, 27: 1141-1150.

[3] Cerdà A. Seasonal changes of the infiltration rates in a Mediterranean scrubland on limestone. J Hydrol, 1997, 198: 209-225.

[4] Costa MH, Botta A, Cardille JA. Effects of large-scale changes in land cover on the discharge of the Tocantins river. Southeastern Amazonia J Hydrol, 2003, 283(1–4): 206-217.

[5] David JS, Henriques MO, David TS, Tomé J, Ledger DC. Clear cutting effects on streamflow in coppiced Eucalyptus globulus stands in Portugal. J Hydrol, 1994, 162: 143-154.

[6] Ding WF, Huang CH. Effects of soil surface roughness on interrill erosion processes and sediment particle size distribution. Geomorphology, 2017, 295: 801-810.

[7] Du J, Niu JZ, Gao ZL, Chen XW, Zhang LT, Li X, Doorn NSV, Luo ZT, Zhu ZJ. Effects of rainfall intensity and slope on interception and precipitation partitioning by forest litter layer. CATENA, 2019, 172: 711-718.

[8] Duan LL, Cai TJ. Changes in magnitude and timing of high flows in large rain-dominated watersheds in the cold region of North-Eastern China. Water, 2018 10 11 1658

[9] Duan LL, Man XL, Barret LK, Cai TJ, Li Q. Distinguishing streamflow trends caused by changes in climate, forest cover, and permafrost in a large watershed in northeastern China. Hydrol Process, 2017, 31(10): 1938-1951.

[10] Dung BX, Gomi T, Miyata S, Sidle R. Peak flow responses and recession flow characteristics after thinning of Japanese cypress forest in a headwater catchment. Hydrol Res Lett, 2012, 6: 35-40.

[11] Feng XM, Fu BJ, Lu N, Zeng Y, Wu BF. How ecological restoration alters ecosystem services: an analysis of carbon sequestration in China's Loess Plateau. Sci Rep, 2013, 3: 2846.

[12] Geng XJ, Zhou XC, Yin GD, Hao FH, Zhang X, Hao ZC, Singh VP, Fu YSH. Extended growing season reduced river runoff in Luanhe River basin. J Hydrol, 2020, 582: 124538.

[13] Gerten D, Rost S, Bloh VW, Lucht W. Causes of change in 20th century global river discharge. Geophys Res Lett, 2008 35 20 L20405

[14] Gu Y, Lin J, Wang XL, Zhang XJ. Trend of annual runoff for major rivers in China under climate change. J Pro Eng, 2012, 28: 564-568.

[15] Hou YP, Zhang MF, Meng ZZ, Liu SR, Sun PS, Yang TL. Assessing the impact of forest change and climate variability on dry season runoff by an improved single watershed approach: a comparative study in two large watersheds. China For, 2018, 9: 46.

[16] Kendall M. Rank Correlation Measures, 1975, Charles Griffin: London, UK 202

[17] Li Q, Wei XH, Yang X, Giles-Hansen K, Zhang MF, Liu WF. Topography significantly influencing low flows in snow-dominated watersheds. Hydrol Earth Syst Sc, 2018, 20(3): 1-25.

[18] Li Q, Wei XH, Zhang MF, Liu WF, Fan HB, Zhou GY, Giles-Hansen K, Liu SR, Wang Y. Forest cover change and water yield in large forested watersheds: a global synthetic assessment. Ecohydrol, 2017

[19] Li Q, Wei XH, Zhang MF, Liu WF, Giles-Hansen K, Wang Y. The cumulative effects of forest disturbance and climate variability on streamflow components in a large forest-dominated watershed. J Hydrol, 2018, 557: 448-459.

[20] Lin BQ, Chen XW, Yao HX, Chen Y, Liu MB, Gao L, James AL. Analyses of land use change impacts on catchment runoff using different time indicators based on SWAT model. Ecol Indic, 2015, 58: 55-63.

[21] Lin KR, Lin YQ, Xu YM, Chen XH, Chen L, Singh VP. Inter- and intra- annual environmental flow alteration and its implication in the Pearl River Delta, South China. J Hydro-Environ Res, 2017, 15: 27-40.

[22] Liu WF, Wei XH, Li Q, Fan HB, Duan HL, Wu JP, Giles-Hansen K, Zhang H. Hydrological recovery in two large forested watersheds of southeastern China: the importance of watershed properties in determining hydrological responses to reforestation. Hydrol Earth Syst Sc, 2016, 20(12): 4747-4756.

[23] Liu WF, Wei XH, Liu SR, Liu YQ, Fan HB, Zhang MF, Yin JM, Zhan MJ. How do climate and forest changes affect long-term streamflow dynamics? A case study in the upper reach of Poyang River basin. Ecohydrol, 2015, 8(1): 46-57.

[24] Liu WF, Wei XH, Fan HB, Guo XM, Liu YQ, Zhang MF, Li Q. Response of flow regimes to deforestation and reforestation in a rain-dominated large watershed of subtropical China. Hydrol Process, 2015, 29: 5003-5015.

[25] Liu YQ, Guo XM, Huang XS, Tu CQ. Studies on the models of management of tangerineyard in low hilly land in the south of Jiangxi Province. Acta Agriculturae Universitis Jiangxiensis, 1998, 20(1): 96-101.

[26] Ma ZM, Kang SZ, Zhang L, Tong L, Su XL. Analysis of impacts of climate variability and human activity on streamflow for a river basin in arid region of northwest China. J Hydrol, 2008, 352(3–4): 239-249.

[27] Mann H. Non-parametric tests against trend. Econometrica, 1945, 13: 245-259.

[28] Qin LH, Zhou JX, Li XY, Zeng QH. Attribution analysis of changes in runoff in the upstream of the Miyun Reservoir. Acta Ecol Sin, 2018, 38(6): 1941-1951.

[29] Ren K, Huang SZ, Huang Q, Wang H, Leng GY. Environmental flow assessment considering inter- and intra-annual streamflow variability under the context of non-stationarity. Water, 2018 10 12 1737

[30] Richter BD, Baumgartner JV, Powell J, Braun DP. A method for assessing hydrologic alteration within ecosystems. Conserv Biol, 1996, 10(4): 1163-1174.

[31] Robinson M, Dupeyrat A. Effects of commercial timber harvesting on streamflow regimes in the Plynlimon catchments, mid-Wales. Hydrol Process, 2010, 19: 1213-1226.

[32] Shen WJ, Peng SL, Zhou GY, Lin YB, Li ZA. Ecohydrological functions of litter in man-made Acacia Mangium and Pinus elliotii plantations. Acta Ecol Sin, 2001, 21: 846-850.

[33] Shui JG, Zhou QK, Liao GQ, Cha ZX. Study on regulating and controlling loss by runoff on red soil hilly orchards by application of gramoxone and glyphosate. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2003, 15(1): 23-27.

[34] Sileshi R, Pitt R, Clark S, Christian C. Laboratory and field studies of soil characteristics of proposed stormwater bioinfiltration sites. Proc Water Environ Fed, 2012, 5: 241-250.

[35] Spearman C. Demonstration of formulae for true measurement of correlation. Am J Psychol, 1907, 33: 55-62.

[36] Stednick JD. Monitoring the effects of timber harvest on annual water yield. J Hydrol, 1996, 176(1–4): 79-95.

[37] Toohey RC, Boll J, Brooks ES, Jones JR. Effects of land use on soil properties and hydrological processes at the point, plot, and catchment scale in volcanic soils near Turrialba, Costa Rica. Geoderma, 2018, 315: 138-148.

[38] Wang XJ, Zhang JY, Cai HJ, ElMahdi A, Ali M, He RM, Guan TS. Spatio-temporal characteristics and driving forces of annual runoff changes in northwest of China – taking the example of Yulin city. Urban Water J, 2011, 8(5): 309-323.

[39] Wang XX, Shen HT, Li XuY, Jing F. Concepts, processes and quantification methods of the forest water conservation at the multiple scales. Acta Ecol Sin, 2013, 33(4): 1019-1030.

[40] Wei XH, Li Q, Zhang MF, Giles-Hansen K, Liu WF, Fan HB, Wang Y, Zhou G, Piao S, Liu SR. Vegetation cover—another dominant factor in determining global water resources in forested regions. Glob Change Biol, 2018, 24: 786-795.

[41] Wei Y, Jiao J, Zhao G, Zhao H, He Z, Mu X. Spatial-temporal variation and periodic change in streamflow and suspended sediment discharge along the mainstream of the Yellow River during 1950–2013. CATENA, 2016, 140: 105-115.

[42] Xu ZP, Liu WF, Wei XH, Fan HB, Ge YZ, Chen GP, Xu J. Contrasting differences in responses of streamflow regimes between reforestation and fruit tree planting in a subtropical watershed of China. Forests, 2019 10 3 212

[43] Yu XN, Huang YM, Li EG, Li XY, Guo WH. Effects of rainfall and vegetation to soil water input and output processes in the Mu Us Sandy Land, northwest China. CATENA, 2018, 161: 96-103.

[44] Yu ZX, Sun G, Cai T, Hallema DW, Daun LL. Water yield responses to gradual changes in forest structure and species composition in a subboreal watershed in Northeastern China. Forests, 2019 10 3 211

[45] Zhang MF, Liu N, Harper R, Li Q, Liu K, Wei XH, Ning DY, Hou YP, Liu SR. A global review on hydrological responses to forest change across multiple spatial scales: Importance of scale, climate, forest type and hydrological regime. J Hydrol, 2016, 546: 44-59.

[46] Zhang MF, Wei XH, Sun PS, Liu SR. The effect of forest harvesting and climatic variability on runoff in a large watershed: the case study in the Upper Minjiang River of Yangtze River basin. J Hydrol, 2012, 464–465: 1-11.

[47] Zhao LS, Hou R, Wu FQ, Keesstra SD. Effect of soil surface roughness on infiltration water, ponding and runoff on tilled soils under rainfall simulation experiments. Soil Till Res, 2018, 179: 47-53.

[48] Zhou GY, Wei XH, Luo Y, Zhang MF, Li YL, Q Y, Liu HG, Wang CL,. Forest recovery and river discharge at the regional scale of Guangdong province. China Water Resour Res, 2010, 46: W09503.