Survivorship, attained diameter, height and volume of three Paulownia species after 9 years in the southern Appalachians, USA

Abstract

Little is known of the tree and stand dynamics of varied species of planted Paulownia left unmanaged until harvest in the southeastern United States. We sought to remedy this lack of information needed by land managers to make informed decisions by investigating differences in survivorship, attained diameter breast height (DBH), diameter at ground level, total height, tree volume and stand-level volume yields of planted P. elongata, P. fortunei, and P. tomentosa in the cool-moist environment of the southern Appalachian Mountains. After 9 years, combined-species survivorship was only 27.3%. Low survivorship was likely related to several inclement weather events. P. fortunei was significantly smaller in DBH and total height. Three combined-species stem (bole) volume models were developed as functions of (1) DBH squared, (2) the product DBH squared and total height, and (3) the product diameter ground line squared and total height. Mean total volume production of unmanaged stands was greatest for P. elongata and P. fortunei 4 years after planting; by the 9th year, total volume of P. elongata was greater than the other two species. Results of our study provide managers information on productivity of three species of Paulownia that can be used for estimating plantation yields.

Keywords

Diameter / Tree height / Stand structure / Stem volume / Paulownia

References

[1] Ayan S, Sivacioglu A, Bilir N. Growth variation of Paulownia Sieb and Zucc species and origins at the nursery stage in Kastamonu-Turkey. J Environ Biol, 2006, 27(3): 499-504.

[2] Beckjord PR. Preliminary spacing trials of Paulownia tomentosa. Tree Plant Notes, 1991, 34: 34-35.

[3] Beckjord PR, McIntosh MS. Paulownia tomentosa: effects of fertilization and coppicing in plantation management. South J Appl For, 1983, 7: 81-85.

[4] Bergmann BA. Five years of Paulownia field trials in North Carolina. New Forest, 2003, 25: 185-199.

[5] Clatterbuck WK, Hodges DG. Tree crops for marginal farmland—Paulownia. PB1465, 2004, Knoxville: The University of Tennessee Agricultural Extension Service.

[6] Donald DGM. Paulownia—the tree of the future?. S Afr For J, 1990, 154: 94-98.

[7] Dong H, van Buijtenen JP. A Paulownia seed source trial in east Texas and its implications to species introduction. South J Appl For, 1994, 18: 65-67.

[8] Garcia-Morote FA, Lopez-Serrano FR, Martinez-Garcia E, Andres-Abellan M, Dadi T, Candel D, Rubio E, Lucas-Borja ME. Stem biomass production of Paulownia elongata ×  P. fortunei under low irrigation in a semi-arid environment. Forests, 2014, 5: 2505-2520.

[9] Hardie I, Kundt J, Miyasaka E. Economic feasibility of U.S. Paulownia plantations. J Forest, 1989, 87: 19-24.

[10] Jiang Z, Huang S, Han Y, Zhao J, Fu J. Physiological response of CU and CU mine tailing remediation of Paulownia fortunei (Seem) Hemsl. Ecotoxicology, 2012, 21: 759-767.

[11] Johnson J, Mitchem D, Kreh R. Establishing royal paulownia on the Virginia Piedmont. New For., 2003, 25: 11-23.

[12] Kays J, Johnson D, Stringer JW. How to produce and market Paulownia, 1998, Maryland: University of Maryland Cooperative Extension Service 22

[13] Kozak A, Munro DD, Smith JHG. Taper functions and their application in forest inventory. For Chronical, 1969, 45: 278-283.

[14] Madejon P, Xiong J, Cabrera F, Madejon E. Quality of trace element contaminated soils amended with compost under fast growing tree Paulownia fortunei plantation. J Environ Manage, 2014, 144: 176-185.

[15] Madejon P, Dominguez MT, Diaz MJ, Madejon E. Improving sustainability in the remediation of contaminated soils by the use of compost and energy valorization by Paulownia fortunei. Sci Total Environ, 2016, 539: 401-409.

[16] McNab WH, Berg EC, Suratt AE (2018) Nine-year results from a Paulownia field trial of three species in the southern Appalachians. In: Kirschman JE (eds) Proceedings of the nineteenth biennial southern silvicultural research conference. General Technical Report SRS-234. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Asheville, pp 420–424

[17] Melhuish JHJ, Gentry CE, Beckjord PR. Paulownia tomentosa seedling growth at differing levels of pH, nitrogen, and phosphorus. J Environ Hortic, 1990, 8: 205-207.

[18] Mitchem DO, Johnson E, Kreh RE (2002). Response of planted royal Paulownia to weed control treatments after coppice. In: Outcalt KW (eds) Proceedings of the eleventh biennial southern silvicultural research conference. General Technical Report SRS-48. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Asheville, pp 276–278

[19] Mueller JP, Luginbuhl JM, Bergmann BA. Establishment and early growth characteristics of six Paulownia genotypes for goat browse in Raleigh, NC, USA. Agrofor Syst, 2001, 52: 63-72.

[20] Puxeddu M, Marras G, Murino G. Paulownia tree planting in Sardinia (Italy) and its evaluation for agroforestry systems and sustainable land use. J Environ Sci Eng, 2012, B1: 1192-1195.

[21] Royall D. A fifty-year record of historical sedimentation at Deer Lake, North Carolina. Prof Geogr, 2003, 55(3): 356-371.

[22] SAS Institute, Inc.. The statistical analysis system, SAS version 9.4, 2013, Cary: SAS Institute Inc..

[23] Snow WA. Ornamental, crop, or invasive? The history of the empress tree (Paulownia) in the USA. For Trees Livelihoods, 2015, 24(2): 85-96.

[24] Sun D, Dickinson GR. A screening trial of 28 species conducted on non-saline and saline soils in dry tropical northeast Australia. J Sustain For, 1997, 5: 1-13.

[25] Tang RC, Carpenter SB, Wittwer RF, Graves DH. Paulownia—a crop tree for wood products and reclamation of surface-mined land. South J Appl For, 1980, 4: 19-24.

[26] Turner GD, Lau RR, Young DR. Effect of acidity on germination and seedling growth of Paulownia tomentosa. J Appl Ecol, 1988, 25: 561-567.

[27] Westfall JA, Scott CT. Taper models for commercial tree species in the northeastern United States. For Sci, 2010, 56: 515-528.

[28] Williams CE. Age, structure and importance of naturalized Paulownia tomentosa in a central Virginia streamside forest. Castanea, 1993, 58: 243-249.

[29] Woodall CW, Heath LS, Domke GM, Nichols M (2011) Methods and equations for estimating aboveground volume, biomass and carbon for trees in the U.S. forest inventory, 2010. General Technical Report NRS-88. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Newtown Square, 30 p

[30] Wu L, Wang B, Qiao J, Zhou H, Wen R, Xue J, Li A. Effects of trunk-extension pruning at different intensities on the growth and trunk form of Paulownia fortunei. For Ecol Manag, 2014, 327: 128-135.

[31] Yadav NK, Vaidya BN, Henderson K, Lee JF, Stewart WM, Dhekney SA, Joshee N. A review of Paulownia biotechnology: a short rotation, fast growing multipurpose bioenergy tree. Am J Plant Sci, 2013, 4: 2070-2082.

[32] Zhu ZH, Chao CJ, Lu XY, Xiong YG. Paulownia in China: cultivation and utilization, 1986, Canada: Asian Network for Biological Science & International Development Research Centre.