Performance of fluoride and boron compounds against drywood and subterranean termites and decay and mold fungi

Abstract

Sodium fluoride (NaF) and disodium octaborate tetrahydrate (DOT) are well-known fungicides for preventing and remediating decay in wood and wood structures, due to their excellent diffusion properties in wood. The efficacy of both compounds against drywood termites is, however, inadequately studied; there is a lack of information on the development of proper protection and control methods against drywood termites using these diffusible chemicals. In this study, the threshold values of fluoride and boron against drywood and subterranean termites and decay and mold fungi were assessed in laboratory conditions. Treated Cryptomeria japonica D. Don (sugi) sapwood specimens with four different concentrations of NaF and DOT applied by either dipping or vacuum processes were subjected to attack by drywood termites, Incisitermes minor (Hagen) for 6 weeks. Treated specimens were also tested against subterranean termites, Coptotermes formosanus Shiraki for 3 weeks. Laboratory decay and mold resistance tests were then performed to determine the efficacy of the compounds against fungal attack. Results showed 80% or greater drywood termite mortality in wood specimens treated with NaF at a retention level of 1.7 kg m⁻³ or more. In DOT treated groups, higher retention levels (greater than 6.8 kg m⁻³) were needed to reach up to 80% or more termite mortality. In general, weight losses in NaF-treated specimens were slightly lower than those in DOT-treated ones. Retention levels of around 1.2 kg m⁻³ for NaF and 1.6 kg m⁻³ for DOT were high enough to reach the JIS K 1571 threshold requirement of weight loss less than 3% in subterranean termite resistance tests. Slightly higher termite mortality values were seen in the DOT than NaF treatments at respective retention levels. In decay resistance tests, no weight losses were seen at a NaF retention level of 2.3 kg m⁻³; however, a retention level of nearly 4 kg m⁻³ for DOT was needed for complete protection against both test fungi. In most cases, lower weight losses were obtained in NaF-treated specimens when compared to DOT. In mold resistance tests, neither NaF nor DOT at even the highest retention level was able to completely inhibit mold growth on the surfaces of treated specimens.

Keywords

NaF / DOT / Remedial treatments / Termites / Fungi

References

[1] ASTM D4445-10. Annual book of American Society for testing materials (ASTM) standards, 2012, Pennsylvania: West Conshohocken.

[2] AWPA U1-12. Use category system: user specification for treated wood, 2012, Birmingham: American Wood Protection Association (AWPA) Inc..

[3] Barnes HM, Amburgey TL, Williams LH, Morrell JJ (1989) Borates as wood preserving compounds: the status of research in the United States. International Research Group on Wood Preservation. Document no. IRG/WP, 3542

[4] BS EN 117. Wood preservatives–determination of toxic values against Reticulitermes species (European termites) (Laboratory method), 2005, London: BSI Standards.

[5] Clausen CA, Yang VW (2003) Mold inhibition on unseasoned southern pine. International Research Group on Wood Preservation. Document no. IRG/WP, 03–10465

[6] Clausen CA, Yang VW. Azole-based antimycotic agents inhibit mold growth on unseasoned pine. Int Biodeterior Biodegrad, 2005, 55(2): 99-102.

[7] Clausen CA, Yang VW. Protecting wood from mould, decay, and termites with multi-component biocide systems. Int Biodeterior Biodegrad, 2007, 59(1): 20-24.

[8] Drysdale JA (1994) Boron treatments for the preservation of wood: A review of efficacy data for fungi and termites. International Research Group on Wood Preservation. Document no: IRG/WP, 94-30037

[9] Ferster B, Scheffrahn RH, Thomas EM, Scherer PN. Transfer of toxicants from exposed nymphs of the drywood termite Incisitermes snyderi (Isoptera: Kalotermitidae) to unexposed nest-mates. J Econ Ent, 2001, 94(1): 215-222.

[10] Findlay WPK. The toxicity of borax to wood-rotting fungi. Timber Technol Mach Woodwork, 1953, 61(2168): 275-276.

[11] Freeman MH, McIntyre CR, Jackson RE. A critical and comprehensive review of boron in wood preservation. Proc Am Wood Protect Assoc (AWPA), 2009, 105: 279-294.

[12] Freitag C, Morrell JJ. Development of threshold values for boron and fluoride in non-soil contact applications. For Prod J, 2005, 55(4): 97-101.

[13] Harrow KM. Toxicity of water soluble preservatives to wood destroying fungi. New Zealand J Sci Technol, 1950, B31(5): 14-19.

[14] Indrayani Y (2007) The invasive dry-wood termite, Incisitermes minor (Hagen), in Japan: infestation, feeding ecology and control strategies. Departmental Bulletin Paper, Kyoto University Kurenai Research Information Repository—Abstracts for PhD for Graduate School of Agriculture Issue Date: 2007–08, pp 34–35

[15] Indrayani Y, Yoshimura T, Fujii Y, Yanase Y, Okahisa Y, Imamura Y. Survey on the infestation of Incisitermes minor (Hagen) in Kansai and Hokuriku areas. Jpn J Environ Entomol Zool, 2004, 15: 261-268.

[16] Indrayani Y, Yoshimura T, Imamura Y (2005) Wood preferences of dry-wood termite Incisitermes minor (Hagen) (Isoptera: Kalotermitidae) to Japanese and U.S. Timbers. In Proceedings of the 6th international wood science symposium, Bali, Indonesia, August 29–31, 2005, p 3

[17] Indrayani Y, Yoshimura T, Yanase Y, Imamura Y. Feeding responses of the western dry-wood termite Incisitermes minor (Hagen) (Isoptera: Kalotermitidae) against ten commercial timbers. J Wood Sci, 2007, 53(3): 239-248.

[18] JIS K 1517. Test methods for determining the effectiveness of wood preservatives and their performance requirements (in Japanese), 2010, Tokyo: Japanese Standard Association.

[19] Kartal SN, Yoshimura T. Borates: a natural way to protect wood against termites. Jan Termit Control Assoc, 2016, 1(165): 7-10.

[20] Kartal SN, Shinoda K, Imamura Y. Laboratory evaluation of boron-containing quaternary ammonia compound, didecyl dimethyl ammonium tetrafluoroborate (DBF) for inhibition of mold and stain. Holz Roh Werkst, 2005, 63(1): 73-77.

[21] Klyosov AA. Wood-plastic composites, 2007, Hoboken: Wiley 698

[22] Laks PE, Vehring JK, Verhey SA, Richter DL (2005) Effect of manufacturing variables on mold susceptibility of wood-plastic composites. In Eighth international conference on wood fiber-plastic composites (and Other Natural Fibers). Forest Products Society, Madison, WI, May 23–25

[23] Lebow S, Anthony RW (2012) Guide for use of wood preservatives in historic structures. General Technical Report FPL-GTR-217. Madison, WI: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory, p 59

[24] Lloyd JD, Dickinson DJ, Murphy RJ (1990) The Probable Mechanisms of action of boric acid and borates as wood preservatives. International Research Group on Wood Preservation. Document no. IRG/WP, 1450

[25] Micales-Glaeser JA, Lloyd JD, Woods TL (2004) Efficacy of didecyl dimethyl ammonium chloride (DDAC), disodium octaborate tetrahydrate (DOT), and chlorothalonil (CTL) against common mold fungi. International Research Group on Wood Preservation. Document no. IRG/WP, 04-30338

[26] Muhcu D, Terzi E, Kartal SN, Yoshimura T. Biological performance, water absorption, and swelling of wood treated with nano-particles combined with the application of Paraloid B72^®. J For Res, 2017, 28(2): 381-394.

[27] Ohmura W, Momohara I, Makita A (2011) Evaluation of wood preservatives against the drywood termite, Incisitermes minor (Hagen) (II)—Performance of impregnated woods after weathering. 木材保存 (Wood Preservation) 37(6): 273–278. https://doi.org/10.5990/jwpa.37.273 (in Japanese)

[28] Pan C, Wang C. Sodium fluoride for protection of wood against field populations of subterranean termites. J Econ Entomol, 2015, 108(4): 2121-2124.

[29] Pan C, Ruan G, Chen H, Zhang D. Toxicity of sodium fluoride to subterranean termites and leachability as a wood preservative. Eur J Wood Prod, 2015, 73: 97-102.

[30] Schoeman MW, Lloyd JD (1998) International standardization: a hypothetical case study with stand-alone borate wood preservatives. International Research Group on Wood Preservation Document no. IRG/WP 98-20147

[31] Tascioglu C, Umemura K, Kusuma SS, Yoshimura T. Potential utilization of sodium fluoride (NaF) as a biocide in particleboard production. J Wood Sci, 2017, 63(6): 652-657.

[32] Terzi E, Kartal SN, Gerardin P, Ibanez CM, Yoshimura T. Biological performance of particleboard incorporated with boron minerals. J For Res, 2017, 28(1): 195-203.

[33] Williams LH, Amburgey TL. Integrated protection against lyctid beetle infestations. IV. Resistance of boron-treated wood (Virola spp) to insect and fungal attack. For Prod J, 1987, 37(2): 10-17.

[34] Yoshimura T. Strategies towards the integrated management of the invasive dry-wood termite, Incisitermes minor. Mokuzai Gakkaishi, 2011, 57(6): 329-339.