Late-entry commercial thinning effects on Pinus banksiana: growth, yield, and stand dynamics in Québec, Canada

Abstract

We studied late-entry commercial thinning effects on growth, yield, and regeneration in a 48-year-old jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.) stand. Applied thinning intensities were 27, 32, and 47% of merchantable basal area (BA) excluding skidding trails. After 15 years, mean diameter at breast height of surviving trees in the 47% BA removal increased by 4.9 cm (25%) compared to the unthinned control. The 47% BA removal also increased gross merchantable volume (GMV) tree⁻¹ by 46% compared to the control. The 27% BA removal had twice as much GMV ha⁻¹ compared to the 47% BA removal after 15 years. Moreover, cumulative GMV ha⁻¹ was much higher in the 27% BA removal than in the unthinned control. The highest thinning intensity produced larger trees on average, while the lowest thinning intensity maximized volume production per hectare. Maintenance of acceptable growing stock throughout the 15-year period in the 27% BA removal could provide other ecosystem functions such as biodiversity enhancement or wildlife habitat by delaying senescence. Regeneration data showed that a shift in species composition occurred in the understory. After 15 years, the understory was dominated by black spruce (Picea mariana (Mill.) B.S.P.), white birch (Betula papyrifera Marsh.), and trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.). If regenerating jack pine is an objective after final overstory removal, additional efforts will be needed to re-establish this species.

Keywords

Jack pine / Commercial thinning / Stand yield / Succession / Delayed senescence / Tree regeneration

References

[1] Ares A, Neill AR, Puettmann KJ. Understory abundance, species diversity and functional attribute response to thinning in coniferous stands. For Ecol Manag, 2010, 260: 1104-1113.

[2] Arseneault D, Sirois L. The millennial dynamics of a boreal forest stand from buried trees. J Ecol, 2004, 92: 490-504.

[3] Barbour RJ, Fayle DCF, Chauret G, Cook J, Karsh MB, Ran S. Breast-height relative density and radial growth in mature jack pine (Pinus banksiana) for 38 years after thinning. Can J For Res, 1994, 24: 2439-2447.

[4] Bataineh MM, Kenefic LS, Weiskittel AR, Wagner RG, Bissette JC. Influence of partial harvesting and site factors on the abundance and composition of natural regeneration in the Acadian Forest of Maine, USA. For Ecol Manag, 2013, 306: 96-106.

[5] Béland M, Bergeron Y, Zarnovican R. Harvest treatment, scarification and competing vegetation affect jack pine establishment on three soil types of boreal mixed wood of northwestern Quebec. For Ecol Manag, 2003, 174: 477-493.

[6] Béland M, Lussier J-M, Bergeron Y, Longpré M-H, Béland M. Structure, spatial distribution and competition in mixed jack pine (Pinus banksiana) stands on clay soils of eastern Canada. Ann For Sci, 2003, 60: 609-617.

[7] Béland M, Camels S, Bergeron Y. Natural regeneration of jack pine on clay soils following harvesting and site preparation: seventh-year results. For Chron, 2010, 86: 423-433.

[8] Bell FW, Dacosta J, Penner M, Morneault A, Stinson A, Towill B, Luckai NJ, Winters J. Longer-term volume trade-offs in spruce and jack pine plantations following various conifer release treatments. For Chron, 2011, 87: 235-250.

[9] Bella IE, De Franceschi JP (1974) Commercial thinning improves growth of Jack pine. Canadian Forest Service, Department of Environment, North Forest Research Centre, Inf Rep NOR-X-112

[10] Bergeron Y, Dubuc D. Succession in the southern part of the Canadian boreal forest. Vegetatio, 1989, 79: 51-63.

[11] Chun YM, Choi YD. Structure, species composition, and soil characteristics in a chronosequence of jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.) stands on the southern shore of Lake Michigan. Am Midl Nat, 2012, 168: 408-426.

[12] Drössler L, Nilsson U, Lundqvist L. Simulated transformation of even-aged Norway spruce stands to multi-layered forests: an experiment to explore the potential of tree size differentiation. Forestry, 2014, 87: 239-248.

[13] Fortin M, DeBlois J, Bernier S, Blais G. Mise au point d’un tarif de cubage général pour les forêts québécoises: une approche pour mieux évaluer l’incertitude associée aux prévisions. For Chron, 2007, 83: 754-765.

[14] Fortin M, Bernier S, Saucier J-P, Labbé F (2009) Une relation hauteur-diamètre tenant compte de l’influence de la station et du climat pour 20 espèces commerciales du Québec. [A height–diameter relationship that takes into account the influence of site conditions and climate for 20 commercial species of Québec]. Government of Québec, Ministry of Natural Resources, Forest Research Branch, General Technical Report 153

[15] Friedman SK, Reich PB. Regional legacies of logging: departure from presettlement forest conditions in northern Minnesota. Ecol Appl, 2005, 15: 726-744.

[16] Gauthier M-M, Tremblay S. Precommercial thinning as a silvicultural option for treating very dense conifer stands. Scand J For Res, 2018, 33: 446-454.

[17] Gauthier M-M, Barrette M, Tremblay S. Commercial thinning to meet wood production objectives and develop structural heterogeneity: a case study in the spruce-fir forest, Quebec, Canada. Forests, 2015, 6: 510-532.

[18] Goudiaby V, Brais S, Grenier Y, Berninger F. Thinning effects on jack pine and black spruce photosynthesis in eastern boreal forests of Canada. Silva Fenn, 2011, 45: 595-609.

[19] Goudiaby V, Brais S, Berninger F, Schneider R. Vertical patterns in specific volume increment along stems of dominant jack pine (Pinus banksiana) and black spruce (Picea mariana) after thinning. Can J For Res, 2012, 42: 733-748.

[20] Greene DF, Zasada JC, Sirois L, Kneeshaw D, Morin H, Charron I, Simard M-J. A review of the regeneration dynamics of North American boreal forest tree species. Can J For Res, 1999, 29: 824-839.

[21] Kenkel NC. Pattern of self-thinning in jack pine: testing the random mortality hypothesis. Ecology, 1988, 69: 1017-1024.

[22] Kenkel NC, Hendrie MLI, Bella IE. A long-term study of Pinus banksiana population dynamics. J Veg Sci, 1997, 8: 241-254.

[23] Krause C, Laplante S, Plourde P-Y. Transversal tracheid dimension in thinned black spruce and jack pine stands in the boreal forest. Scand J For Res, 2011, 26: 477-487.

[24] Lanner RM. On the insensitivity of height growth to spacing. For Ecol Manag, 1985, 13: 143-148.

[25] Lichter J. Plant succession and forest development on coastal Lake Michigan sand dunes. Ecol Monogr, 1998, 68: 487-510.

[26] Man R, Rice JA, MacDonald GB. Long-term response of planted conifers, natural regeneration, and vegetation to harvesting, scalping, and weeding on a boreal mixedwood site. For Ecol Manag, 2009, 258: 1225-1234.

[27] Man R, Rice JA, MacDonald GB. Early effects of pre- and post-harvest herbicide application and partial cutting in regenerating aspen–jack pine mixtures in northeastern Ontario. Can J For Res, 2011, 41: 1082-1090.

[28] MRN (2003) [Ministère des Ressources Naturelles] Avis scientifique: Éclaircie commerciale pour le groupe de production prioritaire SEPM. [Scientific notice: Commercial thinning for the spruce, pine, fir, and larch production group]. Government of Québec, Québec

[29] MRNFPQ (2004) [Ministère des Ressources naturelles, de la Faune et des Parcs du Québec] Détermination de l’âge approximatif d’entrée en sénescence des principaux peuplements forestiers à l’aide des placettes-échantillons temporaires. Suivi d’une analyse comparative. [Determination of the approximate age of entry into senescence of forest stands using temporary sample plots—follow-up to a comparative analysis]. Government of Québec, Québec

[30] Olson MG, Meyer SR, Wagner RG, Seymour RS. Commercial thinning stimulates natural regeneration in spruce-fir stands. Can J For Res, 2014, 44: 173-181.

[31] Pelletier G, Pitt DG. Silvicultural responses of two spruce plantations to midrotation commercial thinning in New Brunswick. Can J For Res, 2008, 38: 851-867.

[32] Pothier D, Savard F (1998) Actualisation des tables de production pour les principales espèces forestières du Québec. [Updated production tables for Québec’s main forest tree species]. Government of Québec, Québec

[33] Ruel J-C. Understanding windthrow: silvicultural implications. For Chron, 1995, 71: 434-445.

[34] Schneider R, Zhang ZY, Swift DE, Bégin J, Lussier J-M. Predicting selected wood properties of jack pine following commercial thinning. Can J For Res, 2008, 38: 2030-2043.

[35] Sharma M, Zhang SY. Stand density management diagram for jack pine stands in Eastern Canada. North J Appl For, 2007, 24: 22-29.

[36] Smirnova E, Bergeron Y, Brais S. Influence of fire intensity on structure and composition of jack pine stands in the boreal forest of Quebec: live trees, understory vegetation and dead wood dynamics. For Ecol Manag, 2008, 255: 2916-2927.

[37] Soucy M, Lussier J-M, Lavoie L. Long-term effects of thinning on growth and yield of an upland black spruce stand. Can J For Res, 2012, 42: 1669-1677.

[38] Sullivan TP, Sullivan DS. Acceleration of old-growth structural attributes in lodgepole pine forest: tree growth and stand structure 25 years after thinning. For Ecol Manag, 2016, 365: 96-106.

[39] Tarroux E, DesRochers A, Krause C. Effect of natural root grafting on growth response of jack pine (Pinus banksiana) after commercial thinning. For Ecol Manag, 2010, 260: 526-535.

[40] Tong QJ, Zhang SY. Impact of initial spacing and precommercial thinning on jack pine tree growth and stem quality. For Chron, 2005, 81: 418-428.

[41] Tong QJ, Zhang SY, Thompson M. Evaluation of growth response, stand value and financial return for pre-commercially thinned jack pine stands in northwestern Ontario. For Ecol Manag, 2005, 209: 225-235.

[42] Tremblay S, Laflèche V (2013) Résultats 5 ans après traitement dans les placettes du réseau de la mesure des effets réels de l’éclaircie commerciale en peuplements résineux. [Five year effects of commercial thinning in a plot network located in conifer stands]. Government of Québec, Ministry of Natural Resources, Forest Research Branch, General Technical Report 166

[43] Waters I, Kembel SW, Gingras J-F, Gray JM. Short-term effects of cut-to-length versus full-tree harvesting on conifer regeneration in jack pine, mixedwood, and black spruce forests in Manitoba. Can J For Res, 2004, 34: 1938-1945.

[44] Westfall PH, Tobias RD, Wolfinger RD. Multiple comparisons and multiple tests using SAS, 2011 2 Cary: SAS Institute 625

[45] Zhang SY, Chauret G, Swift DE, Duchesne I. Effects of precommercial thinning on tree growth and lumber quality in a jack pine stand in New Brunswick, Canada. Can J For Res, 2006, 36: 945-952.