Effects of land use changes for ecological restoration on soil moisture on the Chinese Loess Plateau: a meta-analytical approach

Abstract

Soil moisture is an important resource for plant growth on the arid and semi-arid Loess Plateau of China where the “Grain for Green” project was launched in 1999, but there has been no systematic evaluation of soil moisture from the effects of ecological restoration at a regional scale. We systematically assessed 63 published studies during 2000–2015, including 2050 observations at 68 sites on the Loess Plateau with the aim of determining soil moisture changes and the factors influencing those changes. We found that, after land use conversion, soil moisture decreased by 17% in the upper 100 cm soil layer and that tree plantations and shrub lands appeared to cause soil moisture depletion which became increasingly serious with soil depth. The decrease of soil moisture was significantly influenced by the planting species in all restoration types (tree plantations, shrub lands, and grasslands). We also found that tree plantations and grasslands converted from farmlands consumed more soil moisture than from wasteland (including bare land, abandoned land and wild grasslands). Artificial restoration led to significant soil moisture reduction, but natural restoration had little effect on soil moisture. Therefore, natural restoration should be an alternative restoration practice on the Loess Plateau. These results will provide helpful information for artificial afforestation and planning ecological restoration campaigns for policy makers on water-limited regions.

Keywords

Soil moisture / Ecological restoration / Land conversion / Vegetation type / Artificial afforestation

References

[1] Berndtsson R, Nodomi K, Yasuda H, Persson T, Chen HS, Jinno K. Soil water and temperature patterns in an arid desert dune sand. J Hydrol, 1996, 185: 221-240.

[2] Brocca L, Hasenauer S, Lacava T, Melone F, Moramarco T, Wagner W, Dorigo W, Matgen P, Martínez-Fernández J, Llorens P, Latron J, Martin C, Bittelli M. Soil moisture estimation through ASCAT and AMSR-E sensors: an intercomparison and validation study across Europe. Remote Sens Environ, 2011, 115: 3390-3408.

[3] Cantón Y, Solé-Benet A, Domingo F. Temporal and spatial patterns of soil moisture in semiarid badlands of SE Spain. J Hydrol, 2004, 285: 199-214.

[4] Cao SX, Chen L, Yu XX. Impact of China’s Grain for Green Project on the landscape of vulnerable arid and semi-arid agricultural regions: a case study in northern Shaanxi Province. J Appl Ecol, 2009, 46: 536-543.

[5] Chen LD, Huang ZL, Gong J, Fu BJ, Huang YL. The effect of land cover/vegetation on soil water dynamic in the hilly area of the loess plateau, China. CATENA, 2007, 70: 200-208.

[6] Chen HS, Shao MA, Li YY. Soil desiccation in the Loess Plateau of China. Geoderma, 2008, 143: 91-100.

[7] Chen LD, Wang JP, Wei W, Fu BJ, Wu DP. Effects of landscape restoration on soil water storage and water use in the Loess Plateau Region, China. For Ecol Manag, 2010, 259: 1291-1298.

[8] Cheng XR, Huang MB, Shao MA, Warrington DN. A comparison of fine root distribution and water consumption of mature Caragana korshinkii Kom grown in two soils in a semiarid region, China. Plant Soil, 2009, 315: 149-161.

[9] Chirino E, Bonet A, Bellot J, Sánchez JR. Effects of 30-year-old Aleppo pine plantations on runoff, soil erosion, and plant diversity in a semi-arid landscape in south eastern Spain. CATENA, 2006, 65: 19-29.

[10] Deng L, Yan WM, Zhang YW, Shangguan ZP. Severe depletion of soil moisture following land-use changes for ecological restoration: evidence from northern China. For Ecol Manag, 2016, 366: 1-10.

[11] Feng ZM, Yang YZ, Zhang YQ, Zhang PT, Li YQ. Grain-for-green policy and its impacts on grain supply in West China. Land Use Policy, 2005, 22: 301-312.

[12] Feng XM, Fu BJ, Piao SL, Wang S, Ciais P, Zeng ZZ, Lü YH, Zeng Y, Li Y, Jiang XH, Wu BF. Revegetation in China’s Loess Plateau is approaching sustainable water resource limits. Nat Clim Change, 2016, 6: 1019-1022.

[13] Fu BJ, Wang J, Chen LD, Qiu Y. The effects of land use on soil moisture variation in the Danangou catchment of the Loess Plateau, China. CATENA, 2003, 54: 197-213.

[14] Gao X, Wu P, Zhao X, Wang J, Shi Y. Effects of land use on soil moisture variations in a semi-arid catchment: implications for land and agricultural water management. Land Degrad Dev, 2014, 25: 163-172.

[15] Gao XD, Zhao XN, Wu PT, Brocca L, Zhang BQ. Effects of large gullies on catchment-scale soil moisture spatial behaviors: a case study on the Loess Plateau of China. Geoderma, 2016, 261: 1-10.

[16] Gao XD, Li HC, Zhao XN, Ma W, Wu PT. Identifying a suitable revegetation technique for soil restoration on water-limited and degraded land: considering both deep soil moisture deficit and soil organic carbon sequestration. Geoderma, 2018, 319: 61-69.

[17] Hedges LV, Gurevitch J, Curtis PS. The meta-analysis of response ratios in experimental ecology. Ecology, 1999, 80: 1150-1156.

[18] Hu CJ, Fu BJ, Liu GH, Jin TT, Guo L. Vegetation patterns influence on soil microbial biomass and functional diversity in a hilly area of the Loess Plateau, China. J Soils Sediments, 2010, 10: 1082-1091.

[19] Hu W, Shao MA, Han FP, Reichardt K, Tan J. Watershed scale temporal stability of soil water content. Geoderma, 2010, 158: 181-198.

[20] Jia YH, Shao MA. Temporal stability of soil water storage under four types of revegetation on the northern Loess Plateau of China. Agric Water Manag, 2013, 117: 33-42.

[21] Jia XX, Shao MA, Wei XR, Wang YQ. Hillslope scale temporal stability of soil water storage in diverse soil layers. J Hydrol, 2013, 498: 254-264.

[22] Jia XX, Shao MA, Zhu YJ, Luo Y. Soil moisture decline due to afforestation across the Loess Plateau, China. J Hydrol, 2017, 546: 113-122.

[23] Jian SQ, Zhao CY, Fang SM, Yu K. Effects of different vegetation restoration on soil water storage and water balance in the Chinese Loess Plateau. Agric For Meteorol, 2015, 206: 85-96.

[24] Jiao JY, Zhang ZG, Bai WJ, Jia YF, Wang N. Assessing the ecological success of restoration by afforestation on the Chinese Loess Plateau. Restor Ecol, 2012, 20: 240-249.

[25] Jin TT, Fu BJ, Liu GH, Wang Z. Hydrologic feasibility of artificial forestation in the semi-arid Loess Plateau of China. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci, 2011, 15: 2519-2530.

[26] Johnson DW, Curtis PS. Effects of forest management on soil C and N storage: meta analysis. For Ecol Manag, 2001, 140: 227-238.

[27] Kou M, Garcia-Fayos P, Hu S, Jiao JY. The effect of Robinia pseudoacacia afforestation on soil and vegetation properties in the Loess Plateau (China): a chronosequence approach. For Ecol Manag, 2016, 375: 146-158.

[28] Li Z, Liu WZ, Zhang XC, Zheng FL. Impacts of land use change and climate variability on hydrology in an agricultural catchment on the Loess Plateau of China. J Hydrol, 2009, 377: 35-42.

[29] Liu WZ, Zhang XC, Dang TH, Ouyang Z, Li Z, Wang J, Wang R, Gao CQ. Soil water dynamics and deep soil recharge in a record wet year in the southern Loess Plateau of China. Agric Water Manag, 2010, 97: 1133-1138.

[30] Lu M, Zhou XH, Yang Q, Li H, Luo YQ, Fang CM, Chen JK, Yang X, Li B. Responses of ecosystem carbon cycle to experimental warming: a meta-analysis. Ecology, 2013, 94: 726-738.

[31] Meerveld H, McDonnell J. On the interrelations between topography, soil depth, soil moisture, transpiration rates and species distribution at the hillslope scale. Adv Water Resour, 2006, 29: 293-310.

[32] Normile D. Getting at the roots of killer dust storms. Science, 2007, 317: 314-316.

[33] Nunez-Mir GC, Iannone BV III, Curtis K, Fei SL. Evaluating the evolution of forest restoration research in a changing world: a “big literature” review. N For, 2015, 46: 669-682.

[34] Porto P, Walling DE, Callegari G. Investigating the effects of afforestation on soil erosion and sediment mobilisation in two small catchments in Southern Italy. CATENA, 2009, 79: 181-188.

[35] Powers JS, Corre MD, Twine TE, Veldkamp E. Geographic bias of field observations of soil carbon stocks with tropical land-use changes precludes spatial extrapolation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2011, 108: 6318-6322.

[36] Qiu Y, Fu BJ, Wang J, Chen LD. Spatial variability of soil moisture content and its relation to environmental indices in a semi-arid gully catchment of the Loess Plateau, China. J Arid Environ, 2001, 49: 723-750.

[37] Rodriguez-Iturbe I, D’odorico P, Porporato A, Ridolfi L. On the spatial and temporal links between vegetation, climate, and soil moisture. Water Resour Res, 1999, 35: 3709-3722.

[38] Shangguan ZP. Soil desiccation occurrence and its impact on forest vegetation in the Loess Plateau of China. Int J Sustain Dev World Ecol, 2007, 14: 299-306.

[39] Venkatesh B, Lakshman N, Purandara B, Reddy V. Analysis of observed soil moisture patterns under different land covers in Western Ghats, India. J Hydrol, 2011, 397: 281-294.

[40] Wang YQ, Shao MA, Shao HB. A preliminary investigation of the dynamic characteristics of dried soil layers on the Loess Plateau of China. J Hydrol, 2010, 381: 9-17.

[41] Wang L, Wei SP, Horton R, Shao MA. Effects of vegetation and slope aspect on water budget in the hill and gully region of the Loess Plateau of China. CATENA, 2011, 87: 90-100.

[42] Wang S, Fu BJ, Gao GY, Yao XL, Zhou J. Soil moisture and evapotranspiration of different land cover types in the Loess Plateau, China. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci, 2012, 16: 2883-2892.

[43] Wang S, Fu BJ, Gao GY, Liu Y, Zhou J. Responses of soil moisture in different land cover types to rainfall events in a re-vegetation catchment area of the Loess Plateau, China. CATENA, 2013, 101: 122-128.

[44] Yang L, Wei W, Chen LD, Mo BR. Response of deep soil moisture to land use and afforestation in the semi-arid Loess Plateau, China. J Hydrol, 2012, 475: 111-122.

[45] Yang L, Wei W, Chen LD, Chen WL, Wang JL. Response of temporal variation of soil moisture to vegetation restoration in semi-arid Loess Plateau, China. CATENA, 2014, 115: 123-133.

[46] Yang L, Chen LD, Wei W. Effects of vegetation restoration on the spatial distribution of soil moisture at the hillslope scale in semi-arid regions. CATENA, 2015, 124: 138-146.

[47] Yang Y, Dou YX, Liu D, An SS. Spatial pattern and heterogeneity of soil moisture along a transect in a small catchment on the Loess Plateau. J Hydrol, 2017, 550: 466-477.