Expansion of traditional land-use and deforestation: a case study of an adat forest in the Kandilo Subwatershed, East Kalimantan, Indonesia

Abstract

Deforestation issues are more problematic when indigenous (adat) communities, living within a forest, have lived there for many generations. These adat communities, who employ traditional land-use, are frequently accused of encroaching on the forest. To understand existing and future trends in the spatial patterns of the expansion of traditional land-use and deforestation, we conducted a case study in the Kandilo Subwatershed using mixed methods with image interpretation, spatial modelling and sociocultural surveys to examine the interrelationships between physical conditions, community characteristics and traditional land-use expansion. We investigated community characteristics through household interviews, communication with key informants, and discussions with focus groups. By using an area production model, we were able to analyze the effect of improved farming systems, policy intervention and law enforcement on traditional land-use expansion and deforestation. Based on our examination of a 20-year period of traditional land-use activities in adat forests, the evidence indicated that the steeper the slope of the land and the farther the distance from the village, the lower the rate of deforestation. Our study found that customary law, regulating traditional land-use, played an important role in controlling deforestation and land degradation. We conclude that the integration of land allocation, improved farming practices and enforcement of customary law are effective measures to improve traditional land productivity while avoiding deforestation and land degradation.

Keywords

Adat people / Agriculture expansion / Area production model (APM) / Customary law / Deforestation / Traditional land-use

References

[1] Adams C, Chamlian Munari L, Vliet N, Sereni Murrieta R, Piperata B, Futemma C, Spressola-Prado V. Diversifying incomes and losing landscape complexity in Quilombola shifting cultivation communities of the atlantic rainforest (Brazil). Hum Ecol, 2013, 41(1): 119-137.

[2] Akinyemi FO. An assessment of land-use change in the Cocoa Belt of south-west Nigeria. Int J Remote Sens, 2013, 34(8): 2858-2875.

[3] Angelsen A, Kaimowitz D. Agricultural technology and forests: a recapitulation Agricultural technologies and tropical deforestation, 2001, Wallingford: CABI Publishing 383 402

[4] Araujo C, Bonjean CA, Combes JL, Motel PC, Reis EJ (2010) Does land tenure insecurity drive deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon? CERDI, Etudes et Documents (vol E 2010.13): CERDI

[5] Ato VA (1996) Prediction of deforestation using area production model (Master Thesis), International Institute of Aerospace Survey and Earth Science (ITC), Enschede, The Netherlands

[6] Avoided Deforestation Partners (2009) REDD methodological module “Location and quantification of the threat of unplanned baseline deforestation” version 1.0, April 2009. Avoided Deforestation Partners.org

[7] Badan Planologi Kehutanan (2007) Identifikasi Desa Dalam Kawasan Hutan 2007. Kerjasama Pusat Rencana dan Statistik Kehutanan, Departemen Kehutanan dengan Direktorat Statistik Pertanian, Badan Pusat Statistik, Jakarta

[8] Bakker L (2008) “Can We Get Hak Ulayat?”: land and community in Pasir and Nunukan, East Kalimantan. Center for Southeast Asia Studies. Center for Southeast Asia Studies, UC Berkeley. Retrieved from: http://escholarship.org/uc/item/5pj3z2jr

[9] BAPPEDA Kalimantan Timur. Rencana Pembangunan Jangka Panjang Daerah Propinsi Kalimantan Timur 2008, 2008, Samarinda: BAPPEDA Kalimantan Timur.

[10] BAPPENAS (2005) Proyeksi Pertumbuhan Penduduk Indonesia 2000–2025. Jakarta: Badan Perencanaan Pembangunan Nasional, Badan Pusat Statistik, dan United Nation Population Fund

[11] Barbier EB. Explaining agricultural land expansion and deforestation in developing countries. Am J Agric Econ, 2004, 86(5): 1347-1353.

[12] Blaser J (2010) Forest law compliance and governance in tropical countries: a region-by-region assessment of the status of forest law compliance and governance in the tropics, and recommendations for improvement. FAO and ITTO

[13] Boafo J (2013) The impact of deforestation on forest livelihoods in Ghana. Backgrounder Africaportal. http://www.africaportal.org/sites/default/files/Africa%20Portal%20Backgrounder%20No.%2049.pdf. Cited 24 Agustus 2014

[14] Bottazzi P, Dao H. On the road through the Bolivian Amazon: a multi-level land governance analysis of deforestation. Land Use Policy, 2013, 30(1): 137-146.

[15] Boucher D, Elias P, Lininger K, May-Tobin C, Roquemore S, Saxon E. The root of the problem: what’s driving tropical deforestation today?, 2011, Cambridge: Tropical Forest and Climate Initiative, Union of Concerned Scientists.

[16] BPS Kabupaten Pasir. Kabupaten Pasir Dalam Angka 2011, 2011, Tanah Grogot: Badan Pusat Statistik Kabupaten Pasir.

[17] Branca G, McCarthy N, Lipper L, Jolejole MC. Climate-smart agriculture: a synthesis of empirical evidence of food security and mitigation benefits from improved cropland management Mitigation of Climate Change in Agriculture Series 3, 2011, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

[18] Brown D, Schreckenberg K (1998) Shifting cultivators as agents of deforestation: assessing the evidence. Nat Resour Perspect 29:1–14

[19] Butt S. Traditional land rights before the Indonesian Constitutional Court. LEAD J, 2014, 10(1): 59-73.

[20] Cahyadi F (2014) Indigenous people as victim of law on the prevention and eradication of forest destruction. http://www.aman.or.id/en/2014/11/21/indigenous-people-as-victim-of-law-on-on-the-prevention-and-eradication-of-forest-destruction/Cited. 15 Jan 2015

[21] Carr D. Farm households and land use in a core conservation zone of the Maya Biosphere Reserve, Guatemala. Hum Ecol, 2008, 36(2): 231-248.

[22] Chi V, Rompaey A, Govers G, Vanacker V, Schmook B, Hieu N. Land transitions in Northwest Vietnam: an integrated analysis of biophysical and socio-cultural factors. Hum Ecol, 2013, 41(1): 37-50.

[23] Chomitz KM, Buys Piet, De Luca Giacomo, Thomas TS, Wertz-Kanounnikoff S. At loggerheads? Agricultural expansion, poverty reduction, and environment in the tropical forests. A World Bank Policy Research Report, 2007, Washington, DC: The World Bank.

[24] Chun J. A legal approach to induce the traditional knowledge of forest resources. For Policy Econ, 2014, 38: 40-45.

[25] Damnyag L, Saastamoinen O, Blay D, Dwomoh FK, Anglaaere LCN, Pappinen A. Sustaining protected areas: identifying and controlling deforestation and forest degradation drivers in the Ankasa Conservation Area, Ghana. Biol Conserv, 2013, 165: 86-94.

[26] Direktorat Jenderal Planologi Kehutanan. Identifikasi Desa Dalam Kawasan Hutan 2009, 2009, Jakarta: Kerjasama Departemen Kehutanan dengan Badan Pusat Statistik.

[27] Entwisle B, Rindfuss RR, Walsh SJ, Page PH. Population growth and its spatial distribution as factors in the deforestation of Nang Rong, Thailand. Geoforum, 2008, 39(2): 879-897.

[28] Epule ET, Peng C, Lepage L, Chen Z. Policy options towards deforestation reduction in Cameroon: an analysis based on a systematic approach. Land Use Policy, 2014, 36: 405-415.

[29] FAO (2011) The state of the world’s land and water resources for food and agriculture (SOLAW)—managing systems at risk. Summary Report. Rome and Earthscan, London. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations

[30] Fearnside PM. Land-tenure issues as factors in environmental destruction in Brazilian Amazonia: the case of Southern Pará. World Dev, 2001, 29(8): 1361-1372.

[31] Foley JA, DeFries R, Asner GP, Barford C, Bonan G, Carpenter SR, Chapin FS, Coe MT, Daily GC, Gibbs HK, Helkowski JH, Holloway T, Howard EA, Kucharik CJ, Monfreda C, Patz JA, Prentice IC, Ramankutty N, Snyder PK. Global consequences of land use. Science, 2005, 309(5734): 570-574.

[32] Forest Science Division. The area production model (APM) in numerical and spatial context: case studies and exercises, 2001, Enschede: Forest Science Division, International Institute for Aerospace Survey and Earth Science.

[33] Gaveau DLA, Linkie M, Suyadi Levang P, Leader-Williams N. Three decades of deforestation in southwest Sumatra: effects of coffee prices, law enforcement and rural poverty. Biol Cons, 2009, 142(3): 597-605.

[34] Geist HJ, Lambin EF. Proximate causes and underlying driving forces of tropical deforestation: tropical forests are disappearing as the result of many pressures, both local and regional, acting in various combinations in different geographical locations. Bioscience, 2002, 52(2): 143-150.

[35] Gonzales Bernaldez F (1991) Ecological consequences of the abandonment of traditional land use systems in central Spain. In: Baudry J, Bunce RGH (eds) Land abandonment and its role in conservation. CIHEAM, Zaragoza, pp 23–29

[36] Grogan K, Birch-Thomsen T, Lyimo J. Transition of shifting cultivation and its impact on people’s livelihoods in the Miombo Woodlands of Northern Zambia and South-Western Tanzania. Hum Ecol, 2013, 41(1): 77-92.

[37] Hamzah H. Modeling of tropical forest conversion to oil palm expansion using area production model: a case study of Nyuatan watershed, 2012, Enschede: University of Twente Faculty of Geo-Information and Earth Observation (ITC).

[38] Hariyadi B, Ticktin T. From shifting cultivation to Cinnamon agroforestry: changing agricultural practices among the Serampas in the Kerinci Seblat National Park, Indonesia. Hum Ecol, 2012, 40(2): 315-325.

[39] Hartanto H, Rangan H, Thorburn C, Kull C (2008) Strategic engagement and dynamic adaptation: customary forest management in Keribci, Central Sumatra, Indonesia. Paper presented at the 12th Biennial Conference of the International Association for the Study of Commons, England

[40] Heinimann A, Hett C, Hurni K, Messerli P, Epprecht M, Jorgensen L, Breu T. Socio-economic perspectives on shifting cultivation landscapes in Northern Laos. Hum Ecol, 2013, 41(1): 51-62.

[41] Heryani E, Grant C (2004) Land administration in Indonesia. Paper presented at the 3rd FIG regional conference, Jakarta, Indonesia

[42] Holdershaw J, Gendall P (2008, 9–11 July 2008) Understanding and predicting human behaviour. Paper presented at the ANZCA08: communication conference: power & place, Wellington, New Zealand

[43] Hussin YA, Bode J, Gier AD (1995) The crystal globe: a GIS-based operational area production model. Paper presented at the 16th Asian conference on remote sensing, Suranaree University of Technology, Nakhon Ratchasima, Thailand

[44] IWGIA (2011) Update 2011—Indonesia. The Indigenous World > Asia. http://www.iwgia.org/regions/asia/indonesia/43-eng-regions/asia/871-update-2011-indonesia. Cited 31 March 2015

[45] Jakeman T, Chen S, Newham L, Pollino C. Allan C, Stankey G. Modelling and Adaptive Environmental Management. Adaptive environmental management, 2009, Dordrecht: Springer 173 187

[46] Kementerian Kehutanan. Statistik Kehutanan 2010, 2011, Jakarta: Kementerian Kehutanan.

[47] Kinnaird MF, Sanderson EW, O’Brien TG, Wibisono HT, Woolmer G. Deforestation trends in a tropical landscape and implications for endangered large mammals Tendencias de Deforestación en un Paisaje Tropical y Sus Implicancias para Mamíferos Grandes en Peligro. Conserv Biol, 2003, 17(1): 245-257.

[48] Lambin EF, Meyfroidt P. Land use transitions: socio-ecological feedback versus socio-economic change. Land Use Policy, 2010, 27(2): 108-118.

[49] Lininger K. Boucher D, Elias P, Lininger K, May-Tobin C, Roquemore S, Saxon E. Small-scale farming and shifting cultivation. The root of the problem what’s driving tropical deforestation today?, 2011, Cambridge: Union of Concerned Scientists 89 94

[50] Lu M. Do people move when they say they will? Inconsistencies in individual migration behavior. Popul Environ, 1999, 20(5): 467-488.

[51] Mattsson E, Persson UM, Ostwald M, Nissanka SP. REDD + readiness implications for Sri Lanka in terms of reducing deforestation. J Environ Manag, 2012, 100: 29-40.

[52] May-Tobin C (2011) Small-scale farming and shifting cultivation. The root of the problem: What’s driving tropical deforestation today? Tropical Forest and Climate Initiative, Union of Concerned Scientists, Cambridge, pp 89–94

[53] Mertens B, Sunderlin WD, Ndoye O, Lambin EF. Impact of macroeconomic change on deforestation in South Cameroon: integration of household survey and remotely-sensed data. World Dev, 2000, 28(6): 983-999.

[54] Mertz O. Trends in shifting cultivation and the REDD mechanism. Curr Opin Environ Sustain, 2009, 1(2): 156-160.

[55] Mulyoutami E, Rismawan R, Joshi L. Local knowledge and management of simpukng (forest gardens) among the Dayak people in East Kalimantan, Indonesia. For Ecol Manag, 2009, 257(10): 2054-2061.

[56] Ochoa-Gaona S. Traditional land-use systems and patterns of forest fragmentation in the highlands of Chiapas, Mexico. Environ Manag, 2001, 27(4): 571-586.

[57] Ochoa-Gaona S, González-Espinosa M. Land use and deforestation in the highlands of Chiapas, Mexico. Appl Geogr, 2000, 20(1): 17-42.

[58] Palm CA, Smukler SM, Sullivan CC, Mutuo PK, Nyadzi GI, Walsh MG. Identifying potential synergies and trade-offs for meeting food security and climate change objectives in sub-Saharan Africa. Proc Natl Acad Sci., 2010

[59] Pasgaard M. The challenge of assessing social dimensions of avoided deforestation: examples from Cambodia. Environ Impact Assess Rev, 2013, 38: 64-72.

[60] Pedoman Penentuan Daya Dukung Lingkungan Hidup dalam Penataan Ruang Wilayah, Permen No. 17 Tahun 2009 Stat (2009)

[61] Perez-Verdin G, Kim YS, Hospodarsky D, Tecle A. Factors driving deforestation in common-pool resources in northern Mexico. J Environ Manag, 2009, 90(1): 331-340.

[62] Pfeffer MJ, Schlelhas JW, DeGloria SD, Gomez J. Population, conservation, and land use change in Honduras. Agr Ecosyst Environ, 2005, 110(1–2): 14-28.

[63] Plieninger T, Höchtl F, Spek T. Traditional land-use and nature conservation in European rural landscapes. Environ Sci Policy, 2006, 9(4): 317-321.

[64] Pouliot M, Treue T, Obiri BD, Ouedraogo B. Deforestation and the limited contribution of forests to rural livelihoods in West Africa: evidence from Burkina Faso and Ghana. Ambio, 2012, 41(7): 738-750.

[65] Purnamasari RS. Dynamics of small-scale deforestation in Indonesia: examining the effects of poverty and socio-economic development, 2010, Rome: Paper presented at the XIII World Forestry Congress.

[66] Ratnasari (2013, Juni 2013). Pengelolaan DAS Berbasis Masyarakat. Buletin RMI 10–11

[67] Rudel TK, Defries R, Asner GP, Laurance WF. Changing drivers of deforestation and new opportunities for conservation. Conserv Biol, 2009, 23(6): 1396-1405.

[68] Rudel TK, Schneider L, Uriarte M. Forest transitions: an introduction. Land Use Policy, 2010, 27(2): 95-97.

[69] Sandewall M, Nilsson NE. The area production model: a tool and concept for sustainable land-use and forest-resource management. J Environ Manag, 2001, 62(4): 415-427.

[70] Sasaoka M, Laumonier Y. Suitability of local resource management practices based on supernatural enforcement mechanisms in the local social-cultural context. Ecol Soc., 2012

[71] Sawathvong S. Experiences from developing an integrated land-use planning approach for protected areas in the Lao PDR. For Policy Econ, 2004, 6(6): 553-566.

[72] Seidenberg C, Mertz O, Kias MB. Fallow, labour and livelihood in shifting cultivation: implications for deforestation in northern Lao PDR. Dan J Geogr, 2003, 103(2): 71-80.

[73] Shearman PL, Ash J, Mackey B, Bryan JE, Lokes B. Forest conversion and degradation in Papua New Guinea 1972–2002. Biotropica, 2009, 41(3): 379-390.

[74] Suhari I (2015) Perbaikan Statistik Beras. 29 Mei 2015. https://indonesiana.tempo.co/read/41871/2015/05/29/iswadi.didi/perbaikan-statistik-beras

[75] Susana, Ochoa-Gaona. Traditional land-use systems and patterns of forest fragmentation in the highlands of Chiapas, Mexico. Environ Manag, 2011, 27(4): 571-586.

[76] Tachibana T, Nguyen TM, Otsuka K. Agricultural Intensification versus extensification: a case study of deforestation in the Northern-Hill Region of Vietnam. J Environ Econ Manag, 2001, 41(1): 44-69.

[77] Tomich TP, van Noordwjik M, Budidarsono S, Gillison AN, Kusumanto T, Murdiyarso D, Stolle F, Fagi AM (2001) Agricultural intensification, deforestation, and the environment: assessing tradeoffs in Sumatra, Indonesia. Tradeoffs or synergies? Agricultural intensification, economic development, and the environment. CAB International, Wallingford, pp 221–244

[78] Tropenbos International Indonesia (2006) Penilaian Ekonomi Sumberdaya Hutan Lindung Gunung Lumut, Kabupaten Paser, Kalimantan Timur (vol TE-06/TBI Indonesia/05-I). Tropenbos International Indonesia dan Greenomics Indonesia, Bogor

[79] Verburg PH, Rounsevell MDA, Veldkamp A. Scenario-based studies of future land use in Europe. Agric Ecosyst Environ, 2006, 114(1): 1-6.

[80] Wangpakapattanawong P, Kavinchan N, Vaidhayakarn C, Schmidt-Vogt D, Elliott S. Fallow to forest: applying indigenous and scientific knowledge of swidden cultivation to tropical forest restoration. For Ecol Manag, 2010, 260(8): 1399-1406.

[81] Wätzold F, Dreschsler M, Amstrong CW, Baumgärtner S, Grim V, Huth A, Wissel C. Ecological-economic modeling for biodiversity management: potential, pitfalls, and prospects. Conserv Biol, 2006, 20(4): 1034-1041.

[82] Wijaya T (2014). Indonesia Darurat Masyarakat Adat. Kenapa? http://www.mongabay.co.id/2014/10/01/indonesia-darurat-masyarakat-adat-kenapa/. Cited 31 Maret 2015

[83] Wollenberg E, Edmunds D, Buck L. Anticipating change: scenarios as a tool for adaptive forest management: a guide, 2000, Bogor: CIFOR.

[84] Xiao YQ, Wei LJ, Zhou RJ. Simulating deforestation of Nepal by area production model. J For Res, 2001, 12(1): 47-50.

[85] Yanuariadi T (1999) Sustainable land allocation: GIS-based decision support for industrial forest plantation development in Indonesia. (PhD Dissertation), Wageningen, Enschede, The Netherlands. (ITC Publication Series, No. 71 (Dissertation No. 59))

[86] Yasmi Y, Kelley L, Enters T (2010) Conflict over forests and land in Asia, Impact, causes and management. The Centre for People and Forests, RECOFTC, Bangkok, p 22