Response of species and stand types to snow/wind damage in a temperate secondary forest, Northeast China

Abstract

Snow/wind damage is one of the important natural disturbances in forest ecosystems, especially in a montane secondary forest. However, the effects of snow/wind damage remain unclear which affects the management of these forests. Therefore, we investigated the responses of species, individual tree traits and stand structure to snow/wind damage in a montane secondary forest. Results show that, amongst the canopy trees, Betula costata exhibited the most uprooting, bending and overall damage ratio (the number of damaged stems to the total number of stems in a plot); Quercus mongolica showed the highest breakage ratio and Fraxinus mandshurica and Juglans mandshurica the least overall damage ratios. Among the subcanopy trees, Carpinus cordata, Acer mono, Acer tegmentosum and Acer pseudo-sieboldianum showed the least uprooting and breakage, and the most bending damage. A. pseudo-sieboldianum demonstrated the lowest breakage and highest bending damage ratios. These findings indicate that different species have various sensitivities to snow/wind damage. Larger trees (taller, wider crowns) tend to break and become uprooted, while smaller trees are bent or remain undamaged, suggesting that tree characteristics significantly influence the types of damage from snow and wind. Stands of Q. mongolica and B. costata had the highest damage ratios, whereas A. pseudo-sieboldianum had the lowest snapping ratio. In summary, the severity and type of snow/wind damage are related to individual tree attributes and stand-level characteristics. Therefore, selection of suitable species (e.g., shorter, smaller with deep root systems, hard wood, bending resistance and compression resistance) and appropriate thinning are recommended for planting in the montane secondary forests.

Keywords

Cover type / Montane secondary forests / Storm damage / Tree species

References

[1] Achim A, Ruel JC, Gardiner BA, Laflamme G, Meunier S. Modelling the vulnerability of balsam fir forests to wind damage. For Ecol Manag, 2005, 204: 37-52.

[2] Baker WL, Flaherty PH, Lindemann JD, Veblen TT, Eisenhart KS, Kulakowski DW. Effect of vegetation on the impact of a severe blowdown in the Southern Rocky Mountains, USA. For Ecol Manag, 2002, 154: 63-75.

[3] Beatty SW. Influence of microtopography and canopy species on spatial patterns of forest understory plants. Ecology, 1984, 65: 1406-1419.

[4] Blennow K, Andersson M, Sallnäs O, Olofsson E. Climate change and the probability of wind damage in two Swedish forests. For Ecol Manag, 2010, 259: 818-830.

[5] Cao KF, Chang J. The ecological effects of an unusual climatic disaster: the destruction to forest ecosystems by the extremely heavy glaze and snow storms occurred in early 2008 in southern China. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2010, 34: 123-124.

[6] Chen XQ, Wu SR. International measures and experiences on coping with frozen hazard on forests. For Econ, 2008, 7: 76-80.

[7] Chiba Y. Modelling stem breakage caused by typhoons in plantation Cryptomeria japonica forests. For Ecol Manag, 2000, 135: 123-131.

[8] Ciftci C, Arwade SR, Kane B, Brena SF. Analysis of the probability of failure for open-grown trees during wind storms. Probab Eng Mech, 2014, 37: 41-50.

[9] Coutts MP. Root architecture and tree stability. Plant Soil, 1983, 71: 171-188.

[10] Cremer KW, Borough CJ, Mckinnell FH, Carter PR. Effects of stocking and thinning on wind damage in plantations. N Z J For Sci, 1982, 12: 244-268.

[11] Darwin AT, Ladd D, Galdins R, Contreras TA, Fahrig L. Response of forest understory vegetation to a major ice storm. J Torrey Bot Soc, 2004, 131: 45-52.

[12] Du YJ, Mi XC, Liu XJ, Ma KP. The effects of ice storm on seed rain and seed limitation in an evergreen broad-leaved forest in east China. Acta Oecol, 2012, 39: 87-93.

[13] Emanuel KA. The dependence of hurricane intensity on climate. Nature, 1987, 326: 483-485.

[14] Everham EM, Brokaw NVL. Forest damage and recovery from catastrophic wind. Bot Rev, 1996, 62: 113-185.

[15] Frey W, Thee P. Avalanche protection of windthrow areas: a ten year comparison of cleared and uncleared starting zones. For Snow Landsc Res, 2002, 77: 89-107.

[16] Gardiner B, Byrne K, Hale S, Kamimura K, Mitchell SJ, Peltola H, Ruel JC. A review of mechanistic modelling of wind damage risk to forests. Forestry, 2008, 81: 447-463.

[17] Gray WM. Strong association between West African rainfall and US landfall of intense hurricanes. Science, 1990, 249: 1251-1256.

[18] Guo SH, Xue L. Effects of ice-snow damage on forests. Acta Ecol Sin, 2012, 32: 5242-5253.

[19] Hales TC, Cole-Hawthorne C, Lovell L, Evans SL. Assessing the accuracy of simple field based root strength measurements. Plant Soil, 2013, 372: 553-565.

[20] Hao ZQ, Yu DY, Yang XM, Ding ZH. α diversity of communities and their variety along altitude gradient on northern slope of Changbai Mountain. Chin J Appl Ecol, 2002, 13: 785-789.

[21] Hao ZQ, Guo SL, Ye J. Canonical correspondence analysis on relationship of woody plants with their environments on the northern slope of Changbai Mountain. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2003, 27: 733-741.

[22] Hlásny T, Křítek Š, Holuša J, Trombik J, Urbaňcová U. Snow disturbances in secondary Norway spruce forests in Central Europe: regression modeling and its implications for forest management. For Ecol Manag, 2011, 262: 2151-2161.

[23] Hou YZ. Review on forest conservation questions and tendency. World For Res, 1992, 5: 1-6.

[24] Jalkanen A, Mattila U. Logistic regression models for wind and snow damage in northern Finland based on the National Forest Inventory data. For Ecol Manag, 2000, 135: 315-330.

[25] Jones HG. Plants and microclimate. A quantitative approach environmental plant physiology, 1983, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 121 122

[26] Karlsson K, Novell L. Modelling survival probability of individual trees in Norway spruce stands under different thinning regimes. Can J For Res, 2005, 35: 113-121.

[27] Kauppi PE, Ausubel JH, Fang JY, Mather AS, Sedjo RA, Waggoner PE. Returning forests analyzed with the forest identity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2006, 103: 17574-17576.

[28] Kilpeläinen A, Gregow H, Strandman H, Kellomäki S, Venäläinen A, Peltola H. Impacts of climate change on the risk of snow-induced forest damage in Finland. Clim Change, 2010, 99: 193-209.

[29] Klopcic M, Poljanec A, Gartner A, Boncina A. Factors related to natural disturbances in mountain Norway spruce (Picea abies) forests in the Julian Alps. Ecoscience, 2009, 16: 48-57.

[30] Li XF, Zhu JJ, Wang QL, Liu ZG, Hou CS, Yang HJ. Snow/wind damage in natural secondary forests in Liaodong mountainous regions of Liaoning Province. Chin J Appl Ecol, 2004, 15: 941-946.

[31] Li XF, Zhu JJ, Wang QL, Liu ZG. Forest damage induced by wind/snow: a review. Acta Ecol Sin, 2005, 25: 149-157.

[32] Li XF, Zhu JJ, Jia Y, Liu J, Li N, Li FQ. Formation process of extraordinarily serious snowstorm and its induced damage in 2007 in Liaoning Province. Chin J Ecol, 2007, 26: 1250-1258.

[33] Liang JP, Wang AM, Liang SF. Disturbance and forest regeneration. For Res, 2002, 15: 490-498.

[34] Liu YX. Northeast China wood properties and uses manual, 2004, Beijing: Chemical Industry Press 87 88

[35] Martínez JE, Jiménez-Franco MV, Zuberogoitia I, León-Ortega M, Calvo JF. Assessing the short-term effects of an extreme storm on Mediterranean forest raptors. Acta Oecol, 2013, 48: 47-53.

[36] Mayer P, Brang P, Dobbertin M, Hallenbarter D, Rennaud JP, Walthert L, Zimmermann S. Forest storm damage is more frequent on acidic soils. Ann For Sci, 2005, 62: 303-311.

[37] McCarthy JK, Hood IA, Brockerhoff EG, Carlson CA, Pawson SM, Forward M, Walbert K, Gardner JF. Predicting sapstain and degrade in fallen trees following storm damage in a Pinus radiata forest. For Ecol Manag, 2010, 260: 1456-1466.

[38] Nykänen ML, Peltola H, Quine C, Kellomäki S, Broadgate M. Factors affecting snow damage of trees with particular reference to European conditions. Silva Fenn, 1997, 31: 193-213.

[39] Päätalo ML, Peltola H, Kellomäki S. Modeling the risk of snow damage to forests under short-term snow loading. For Ecol Manag, 1999, 116: 51-70.

[40] Peltola H, Kellomäi S, Hassinen A, Lemettinen M, Aho J. Swaying of trees as caused by wind: analysis of field measurement. Silva Fenn, 1993, 27: 113-126.

[41] Peltola H, Kellomäki S, Väisänen H. Model computations on the impacts of climatic change on soil frost with implications for windthrow risk of trees. Clim Change, 1997, 41: 17-36.

[42] Peltola H, Kellomäki S, Väisänen H, Ikonen VP. A mechanistic model for assessing the risk of wind and snow damage to single trees and stands of Scots pine, Norway spruce, and birch. Can J For Res, 1999, 29: 647-661.

[43] Peltola H, Kellomäkiv S, Kolström T, Lässig R, Moor J, Quine C, Ruel JC. Wind and other abiotic risks to forests. For Ecol Manag, 2000, 135: 1-2.

[44] Peterson CJ. Within-stand variation in wind-throw in southern boreal forests of Minnesota: is it predictable?. Can J For Res, 2004, 34: 365-375.

[45] Peterson CJ, Pickett STA. Treefall and resprouting following catastrophic windthrow in an old growth hemlock-hardwoods forest. For Ecol Manag, 1991, 42: 205-217.

[46] Peterson CJ, Pickett STA. Forest reorganization: a case study in an old-growth forest catastrophic blowdown. Ecology, 1995, 76: 763-774.

[47] Petty JA, Worrell R. Stability of coniferous tree stems in relation to damage by snow. Forestry, 1981, 54: 115-128.

[48] Putz FE, Sharitz RR. Hurricane damage to old-growth forest in Congaree Swamp National Monument, South Carolina, U.S.A.. Can J For Res, 1991, 21: 1765-1770.

[49] Quine CP, Gardiner BA. Johnson EA, Miyanishi K. Understanding how the interaction of wind and trees results in windthrow, stem breakage, and canopy gap formation. Plant disturbance ecology—the process and the response, 2007, Amsterdam: Elsevier 103 155

[50] Ren XW. Dendrology, 1997, Beijing: China Forestry Publishing House 382 387

[51] Schaetzl RJ, Burns SF, Johnson DL, Small TW. Tree uprooting: review of impacts on forest ecology. Plant Ecol, 1989, 79: 165-176.

[52] Song HC, Chen LH, Lv CJ, Wang PH. Root morphology of four common tree species in rocky mountain area of northern China. J Arid Land Resour Environ, 2012, 26: 194-199.

[53] Teste FP, Lieffers VJ. Snow damage in lodgepole pine stands brought into thinning and fertilization regimes. For Ecol Manag, 2011, 261: 2096-2104.

[54] Valinger E, Fridman J. Models to assess the risk of snow and wind damage in pine, spruce, and birch forests in Sweden. Environ Manag, 1999, 24: 209-217.

[55] Valinger E, Lundqvist L. The influence of thinning and nitrogen fertilization on the frequency of snow and wind induced stand damage in forests. Scott For, 1992, 46: 311-320.

[56] Veblen TT, Kulakowski D, Eisenhart KS, Baker WL. Subalpine forest damage from a severe windstorm in northern Colorado. Can J For Res, 2001, 31: 2089-2097.

[57] Vlinger E, Fridman J. Modelling probability of snow and wind damage in Scots pine stands using tree characteristics. For Ecol Manag, 1997, 97: 215-222.

[58] Vyse A, Ferguson C, Huggard DJ. Wind and snow damage nine years following four harvest treatments in a subalpine fir-Engelmann spruce forest at Sicamous Creek in southern interior British Columbia, Canada. For Chron, 2008, 84: 401-409.

[59] Webb SL. Windstorm damage and microsite colonization in two Minnesota forests. Can J For Res, 1988, 18: 1186-1195.

[60] Xu YW, Wu KK, Zhu LR, Lin ZG, Peng SL. A review of freezing rain and snow impacts on forests in southern China. Ecol Environ Sci, 2010, 19: 1485-1494.

[61] Yan T, Lü XT, Yang K, Zhu JJ. Leaf nutrient dynamics and nutrient resorption: a comparison between larch plantations and adjacent secondary forests in Northeast China. J Plant Ecol, 2016, 9: 165-173.

[62] Yang K, Zhu JJ. The effects of N and P additions on soil microbial properties in paired stands of temperate secondary forests and adjacent larch plantations in Northeast China. Soil Biol Biochem, 2015, 90: 80-86.

[63] Yang FW, Lu SW, Wang B. Value estimation of service function of forest ecosystem damaged by frozen rain and snow in the South China. Sci Silvae Sin, 2008, 44: 101-110.

[64] Zhang F, Hu WL, Tan XR, Kong XW. Conservation and sustainable management of original secondary forests in mountainous areas of eastern Liaoning. J Liaoning For Sci Technol, 2003, 3: 5-8.

[65] Zhang ZX, Liu P, Qiu ZJ, Liu CS, Chen WX, Li CH, Liao JP, Li HJ. Factors influencing ice and snow damage to Pinus taiwanensis in Jiulongshan Nature Reserve, China. Chin J Plant Ecol, 2010, 34: 223-232.

[66] Zhu JJ. A review on fundamental studies of secondary forest management. Chin J Appl Ecol, 2002, 13: 1689-1694.

[67] Zhu JJ, Li XF, Liu ZG, CaoW Gonda Y, Matsuzaki T. Factors affecting the snow and wind induced damage of a montane secondary forest in Northeastern China. Silva Fenn, 2006, 40: 37-51.

[68] Zhu JJ, Yang K, Yan QL, Liu ZG, Yu LZ, Wang HX. Feasibility of implementing thinning in even-aged Larix olgensis plantations to develop uneven-aged larch-broadleaved mixed forests. J For Res, 2010, 15: 71-80.