Post-fire regeneration dynamics in whitebark pine (Pinus albicaulis) forests in Wind River and Absaroka Mountains, Wyoming, USA

Abstract

Whitebark pine (Pinus albicaulis) populations are in decline across the species’ range due to historic wildfire exclusion, mountain pine beetle (Dendroctonus ponderosae, MPB) outbreaks, and an invasive fungal pathogen causing the disease white pine blister rust (Cronartium ribicola, WPBR). Despite reliance on stand-replacing fires, information on whitebark pine regeneration occurrence is limited and the trajectory of future forests is largely unknown in some areas of the range. Regeneration densities were assessed in burned and adjacent non-burned areas at six high elevation locations in northwest Wyoming where stand-replacing fires occurred 8–32 years before the surveys. In these locations at the eastern extent of the species range, we assessed what site factors were associated with regeneration success. Whitebark pine regeneration density was greater and seedlings were older in non-burned compared to burned areas. Within burns, north aspects had more regeneration than south aspects. Potential seed source densities and other species’ regeneration were positively related to whitebark pine regeneration densities in burned areas. South facing slopes or grass covered areas may have either delayed or no regeneration of whitebark pine without the help of artificial planting.

Keywords

Recruitment / Age structure / White pine blister rust / Mountain pine beetle / Restoration

References

[1] Arno SF. Tomback DF, Arno SF, Keane RE. Community types and natural disturbance processes. Whitebark pine communities: ecology and restoration. 2001, Washington: Island Press, 76 88

[2] Arno SF, Hoff R (1990) Pinus albicaulis Engelm. Whitebark pine. In: R.M. Burns, B.H. Honkala, (tech. coords.), Silvics of North America. USDA Forest Service, Agricultural Handbook 654, Washington, pp. 268–279

[3] Barringer LE, Tomback DF, Wunder MB, McKinner ST. Whitebark pine stand condition, tree abundance, and cone production as predictors of visitation by Clark’s nutcracker. PLoS One, 2012, 7 e37663

[4] Büsgen M, Munch E (1929) Life and structure of forest trees (trans: Thomson T) 3rd edn. Wiley, New York, p 436

[5] Casper AM (2012) Restoration planting options for Pinus flexilis James in the southern Rocky Mountains. MS Thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins

[6] Cleaver CM (2014) Limber pine health in the southern and central Rocky Mountains. MS Thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins

[7] Coop JD, Schoettle AW. Regeneration of Rocky Mountain bristlecone pine (Pinus aristata) and limber pine (Pinus flexilis) three decades after stand-replacing fires. For Ecol Manag, 2009, 157: 893-903.

[8] Crone EE, McIntire EJB, Brodie J. What defines mast seeding? Spatio-temporal patterns of cone production by whitebark pine. J Ecol, 2011, 99: 438-444.

[9] Crookston NL (2012) Research on forest climate change: potential effects of global warming on forests and plant climate relationships in Western North America and Mexico. In: Climate data and predictions. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Moscow Forestry Sciences Laboratory, Moscow. <http://forest.moscowfsl.wsu.edu/climate/>. Accessed 4 April 2014

[10] Ellison AM, Bank MS, Clinton BD, Colburn EA, Elliott K, Ford CR, Foster DR, Kloeppe BD, Knoepp JD, Lovett GM, Orwig DA, Rodenhouse NL, Sobczak WV, Stinson KA, Stone JK, Swan CM, Thompson J, Von Holle B, Webster JR. Loss of foundation species: consequences for the structure and dynamics of forested ecosystems. Front Ecol Environ, 2005, 3(9): 479-486.

[11] Furniss MM, Renkin R. Forest entomology in Yellowstone National Park, 1923–1957: a time of discovery and learning to let live. Am Entomol, 2003, 49(4): 198-209.

[12] Geils BW, Hummer KE, Hunt RS. White pines, Ribes, and blister rust: a review and synthesis. For Pathol, 2010, 40: 147-185.

[13] Gibson K, Skov K, Kegley S, Jorgensen C, Smith S, Witcosky J (2008) Mountain pine beetle impacts in high elevation five-needle pines: current trends and challenges. R1-08-020. USDA Forest Service, Forest Health Protection, Missoula

[14] Greene DF, Zasada JC, Sirois L, Kneeshaw D, Morin H, Charron I, Simard M-J. A review of the regeneration dynamics of North American boreal forest tree species. Can J For Res, 1999, 29: 824-839.

[15] Hamann A, Wang T. Potential effects of climate change on ecosystem and tree species distribution in British Columbia. Ecology, 2006, 87(11): 2773-2786.

[16] Hutchins HE, Lanner RM. The central role of Clark’s nutcracker in the dispersal and establishment of whitebark pine. Oecologia, 1982, 55: 192-201.

[17] Izlar DK (2007) Assessment of whitebark pine seedling survival for Rocky Mountain plantings. M.S. thesis, College of Forestry and Conservation, University of Montana, Missoula, 76 p

[18] Keane RE, Arno SF (1996) Whitebark pine (Pinus albicaulis) ecosystem restoration in western Montana. In: Arno SF, Hardy CC (eds), The use of fire in forest restoration, Society of Ecosystem Restoration. USDA Forest Service, Intermountain Research Station, General Technical Report INT-GTR-341, Ogden, pp 51–54

[19] Keane RE, Arno SF. Tomback DF, Arno SF, Keane RE. Restoration concepts and techniques. Whitebark pine communities: ecology and restoration. 2001, Washington: Island Press, 367 400

[20] Keane RE, Parsons RA. Restoring whitebark pine forests of the northern Rocky Mountains, USA. Ecol Restor, 2010, 28: 56-70.

[21] Keane RE, Morgan P, Menakis JP. Landscape assessment of the decline of whitebark pine (Pinus albicaulis) in the Bob Marshall Wilderness Complex, Montana, USA. Northwest Sci, 1994, 68: 213-229.

[22] Keane RE, Gray KL, Dickinson LJ (2007) Whitebark pine diameter growth response to removal of competition. USDA Forest Service Research Note RMRS-RN-32

[23] Kearns HSJ, Jacobi WR. The distribution and incidence of white pine blister rust in central and southeastern Wyoming and northern Colorado. Can J For Res, 2007, 37: 1-11.

[24] Larson ER, Kipfmueller KF. Patterns in whitebark pine regeneration and their relationships to biophysical site characteristics in southwestern Montana, central Idaho, and Oregon, USA. Can J For Res, 2010, 40: 476-487.

[25] Larson ER, Kipfmueller KF. Ecological disaster or the limits of observation? Reconciling modern declines with the long-term dynamics of whitebark pine communities. Geogr Compass, 2012, 6: 189-214.

[26] Larson ER, Van de Gevel SL, Grissino-Mayer HD. Variability in fire regimes of high-elevation whitebark pine communities, western Montana, USA. Écoscience, 2009, 16: 282-298.

[27] Logan JA, Powell JA. Ghost forests, global warming, and the mountain pine beetle (Coleoptera: Scolytidae). Am Entomol, 2001, 47(3): 160-173.

[28] Logan JA, Macfarlane WW, Wilcox L. Whitebark pine vulnerability to climate-driven mountain pine beetle disturbance in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Ecol Appl, 2010, 20(4): 895-902.

[29] Lorenz JT, Sullivan KA. Season differences in space use by Clark’s nutcracker in the Cascade Range. Condor, 2009, 111: 326-340.

[30] Lorenz TJ, Aubry C, Shoal R (2008) A review of the literature on seed fate in whitebark pine and the life history traits of Clark’s nutcracker and pine squirrels. USDA Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, General Technical Report, PNW-GTR-742, p 62

[31] Maher EL, Germino MJ, Hasselquist NJ. Interactive effects of tree and herb cover on survivorship, physiology, and microclimate of conifer seedlings at the alpine tree-line ecotone. Can J For Res, 2005, 35: 567-574.

[32] Maloney PE, Vogler DR, Jensen CE, Delfino Mix A. Ecology of whitebark pine populations in relation to white pine blister rust infection in subalpine forests of the Lake Tahoe Basin, USA: implications for restoration. For Ecol Manag, 2012, 280: 166-175.

[33] Mattson DJ, Reinhart DP. Excavation of red squirrel middens by grizzly bears in the whitebark pine zone. J Appl Ecol, 1997, 34: 926-940.

[34] Mattson DJ, Blanchard BM, Knight RR. Yellowstone grizzly bear mortality, human habituation, and whitebark pine seed crops. J Wildl Manag, 1992, 56: 432-442.

[35] McCaughey W, Scott GL, Izlar KL. Whitebark pine planting guide. West J Appl For, 2009, 24(3): 163-166.

[36] McKinney ST, Tomback DF. The influence of white pine blister rust on seed dispersal in whitebark pine. Can J For Res, 2007, 37: 1044-1057.

[37] McKinney ST, Fielder CE, Tomback DF. Invasive pathogen threatens bird-pine mutualism: implications for sustaining a high-elevation ecosystem. Ecol Appl, 2009, 19(3): 597-607.

[38] Mohatt KR, Cripps CL, Lavin M. Ectomycorrhizal fungi of whitebark pine (a tree in peril) revealed by sporocarps and molecular analysis of mycorrhizae from treeline forests in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Botany, 2008, 86: 14-25.

[39] Morgan P, Bunting SC. Using cone scars to estimate past cone crops of whitebark pine. West J Appl For, 1992, 7: 71-73.

[40] Murray MP, Rasmussen M (2000) Status of whitebark pine in Crater Lake National Park. Unpublished Final Report, Cooperative Cost-Share Agreement No. H9320000035. Copy on file at US Department of Interior, Park Service, Crater Lake National Park, Resource Management Division 13 pp

[41] Niinemets Ü. The controversy over traits conferring shade-tolerance in trees: ontogenic changes revisited. J Ecol, 2006, 94: 464-470.

[42] Perkins JL (2004) Pinus albicaulis seedling regeneration after fire. Ph.D. thesis, Division of Biological Sciences, University of Montana, Missoula, 149 p

[43] Pfister RP, Kovalchik BL, Arno SF, Presby R (1977) Forest habitat types of Montana. USDA Forest Service, Intermountain forest and range experiment station, General Technical Report INT-34, Ogden, p 174

[44] R Development Core Team R: a language and environment for statistical computing. 2008, Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing

[45] Richardson BA, Brunsfeld SJ, Klopfenstein NB. DNA from a bird-dispersed seed and wind-disseminated pollen provides insights into postglacial colonization and population genetic structure of whitebark pine (Pinus albicaulis). Mol Ecol, 2002, 11: 215-227.

[46] Romme WH. Fire and landscape diversity in subalpine forests of Yellowstone National Park. Ecol Monogr, 1982, 52: 199-221.

[47] Schoettle AW, Sniezko RA. Proactive intervention to sustain high-elevation pine ecosystems threatened by white pine blister rust. J For Res, 2007, 12: 327-336.

[48] Schwandt JW (2006) Whitebark pine in peril: a case for restoration. USDA Forest Service Report R1-06-28

[49] Scott GL, McCaughey WW (2006) Whitebark pine guidelines for planting prescriptions. In: Riley LE, Dumroese RK, Landis TD, (tech. coords.) National Proceedings: Forest and Conservation Nursery Associations—2005. Proceedings on RMRS-P-43 U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, p 84–90

[50] Smith CM, Wilson B, Rasheed S, Walker RC, Carolin T, Shepherd B. Whitebark pine and white pine blister rust in the Rocky Mountains of Canada and northern Montana. Can J For Res, 2008, 38: 982-995.

[51] Smith CM, Poll C, Gillies C, Praymak C, Miranda E, Hill J. 2011. Limber pine seed and seedling planting experiment in Waterton Lakes National Park, Canada. In Keane RE, Tomback DF, Murray MP, Smith CM (eds) The future of high-elevation, five-needle white pines in western North America. Proceedings of the high five symposium; 28–30 June 2010; Missoula. Proceedings on RMRS-P-63. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, p 365–374

[52] Tomback DF. Foraging strategies of Clark’s nutcracker. Living Bird, 1978, 16: 123-161.

[53] Tomback DF. Dispersal of whitebark pine seeds by Clark’s nutcracker: a mutualism hypothesis. J Anim Ecol, 1982, 51: 451-467.

[54] Tomback DF. Tomback DF, Arno SF, Keane RE. Clark’s nutcracker: agent of regeneration. Whitebark pine communities: ecology and restoration. 2001, Washington: Island Press, 89 107

[55] Tomback DF, Achuff P. Blister rust and western forest biodiversity: ecology, values and outlook for white pines. For Pathol, 2010, 40: 186-225.

[56] Tomback DF, Kendall KC. Tomback DF, Arno SF, Keane RE. Biodiversity losses: the downward spiral. Whitebark pine communities: ecology and restoration. 2001, Washington: Island Press, 243 262

[57] Tomback DF, Sund SK, Hoffman LA. Post-fire regeneration of Pinus albicaulis: height-age relationships, age structure, and microsite characteristics. Can J For Res, 1993, 23: 113-119.

[58] Tomback DF, Clary JK, Koehler J, Hoff RJ, Arno SF. The effects of blister rust on post-fire regeneration of whitebark pine: the Sundance Burn of Northern Idaho (U.S.A.). Conserv Biol, 1995, 9: 654-664.

[59] Tomback DF, Anderies AJ, Carsey KS, Powell ML, Mellmann-Brown S. Delayed seed germination in whitebark pine and regeneration patterns following the Yellowstone fires. Ecology, 2001, 82(9): 2587-2600.

[60] Tomback DF, Arno SF, Keane RE. Tomback DF, Arno SF, Keane RE. The compelling case for management intervention. Whitebark pine communities: ecology and restoration. 2001, Washington: Island Press, 3 25

[61] USDA Forest Service (2007) Common Stand Exam Users Guide and Appendices, Version 1.7. USDA Forest Service, Natural Resource Information System: Field Sampled Vegetation. Available online at <http://www.fs.fed.us/emc/nris/products/fsveg/index.shtml>

[62] Vander Wall SB, Balda RP. Coadaptations of the Clark’s nutcracker and the piñon pine for efficient seed harvest and dispersal. Ecol Monogr, 1977, 47: 89-111.

[63] Walsh MR (2005) Fire history and stand dynamics of whitebark pine (Pinus albicaulis) communities in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. MS Thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, 48 p

[64] Waring KM, Goodrich BA. Artificial regeneration of five-needled pines of western North America: a survey of current practices and future needs. Tree Plant Notes, 2012, 55: 56-72.