A journey towards shared governance: status and prospects for collaborative management in the protected areas of Bangladesh

Abstract

Establishment of Protected Areas (PAs), in the face of rapid deforestation, forest degradation and climate change has been one of the key efforts in conservation of biodiversity worldwide in recent times. While Bangladesh has gained a degree of prominence in the world for its successful social forestry programs, the concept of collaborative protected area management is rather new in the country, initiated in 2004 by the Bangladesh Forest Department in five PAs with financial assistance from USAID. Based on empirical evidence from three of the pilot PAs, we examined the achievements and associated challenges and prospects for co-management. Our fieldwork revealed a number of challenges faced by co-management institutions: (1) institutions were dominated by the elite group, overshadowing the voice of the community people; (2) mutual trust and collective performance are key to good governance but had not taken root in the PAs; (3) encroachment onto forest land and subsequent conversion to agriculture remained a serious problem that discouraged forest-dependent people from participating actively in co-management initiatives; (4) legal provisions (including acts, rules and policies) were not clearly and adequately disseminated and understood at the community level; (5) there remained a degree of ambiguity regarding the roles and responsibilities of forest department (FD) and co-management committees (CMC) in field operations, and this was not enhancing transparency and accountability of the overall initiative; (6) the long-term sustainability of co-management institutions was another major concern, as the local intuitional structure was still in a nascent stage, and provisioning of resources (either internally or externally) remained somewhat uncertain. We offer recommendations for improvement.

Keywords

protected area / co-management / Nishorgo / IPAC / governance

References

[1] Appanah S, Ratnam L. The importance of forest biodiversity to developing countries in Asia. Journal of Tropical Forest Science, 1992, 5(2): 201-215.

[2] Balloffet NM, Balloffet, Marin, Angela S. Governance trends in protected areas-experiences from the Parks in Peril Program in Latin America and the Caribbean (The Nature Conservancy, USAID), 2007 46.

[3] Bangladesh Forest Department. 2011. Available at: http://www.bforest.gov.bd/conservation.php [accessed on 8 February, 2012].

[4] Berkes F. Community conserved areas: policy issues in historic and contemporary context. Conservation Letters, 2009, 2(1): 20-25.

[5] Biswas G, Chowdhury AM. Protected area co-management lessons learned: co-management organization (CMO) perspective (Paper presented in the 1^st Bangladesh Forestry Congress, held in 19–21 April, 2011, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 2011

[6] Borrini-Feyerabend G. Indigenous and local communities and protected areas: rethinking the relationship. Parks, 2002, 12(2): 5-15.

[7] Borrini-Feyerabend G. Governance of protected areas-innovation in the air. Policy Matters, 2003, 12: 92-101.

[8] Castro AP, Nielsen E. Indigenous people and co-management: implications for conflict management. Environmental Science and Policy, 2001, 4(4-5): 229-239.

[9] Chape S, Blyth S, Fish L, Fox P, Spalding M. United Nations list of protected areas. 2003, Cambridge, UK: The World Conservation Union (IUCN)

[10] Craig D. Recognizing indigenous rights through co-management regimes: Canadian and Australian experiences. New Zealand Journal of Environmental Law, 2002, 6: 199-254.

[11] Cunningham EJ, Chassels M, Fox J, Mustafa MG, et al. Fox J, et al. Introduction: Tailoring Collaborative Conservation in Bangladesh. Rural Livelihood and Protected Landscapes: Co-management in the Wetlands and Forest of Bangladesh. 2011, Nishorgo Network: USAID, 204.

[12] DeFries R, Hansen A, Turner BL, Reid R, Liu J. Land use change around protected areas: management to balance human needs and ecological function. Ecological Application, 2007, 17(4): 1031-1038.

[13] Dudley N, Parish J. Closing the gap-creating ecologically representative protected area system (CBD Technical Series: 24). 2006, Montreal, Canada: SCBD

[14] Dudley N. Guidelines for applying protected area management categories, 2008

[15] Ferrari MF. Rediscovering community conserved areas in south-east Asia: people’s initiative to reverse biodiversity loss. Parks, 2006, 16(1): 43-48.

[16] Fisher RJ. Innovations, Persistence and Change: Reflections on the State of Community Forestry. The Community forestry current innovations and experiences. 2003, Bangkok, Thailand: Regional Community Forestry Training Center (RECOFTC) and FAO-Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific (FAO-RAP), 16 29

[17] FoodAgriculture Organization of the United Nations FAO. State of the World’s Forests 2009. 2009, Rome, Italy: FAO

[18] Ghimire KB. Parks and people: livelihood issues in national parks management in Thailand and Madagascar. Development and Change, 1994, 25(1): 195-229.

[19] Glasbergen P. Glasbergen P, Biermann F, Mol A P J. Setting the scene: The partnership paradigm in the making. Partnerships, governance and sustainable development-reflection on theory and practice, 2007 314.

[20] Government of Bangladesh GoB. Bangladesh Gazette No. pabama/parisha-4/nishorgo/105/sting/2006/398 dated November 11, 2009, 2009

[21] Institute on Governance. Governance principles for protected areas in the 21st century. Discussion paper, Institute on Governance, 2002 29.

[22] IUCN. Guidelines for protected area management categories. 1994, Cambridge, UK: IUCN

[23] Jeanrenaud S. People-oriented approaches in global conservation: is the leopard changing its spots?. 2002, London, UK: International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED)

[24] Kaimowitz D, Sheil D. Conserving what and for whom? Why conservation should help meet basic human needs in the tropics. Biotropica, 2007, 39(5): 567-574.

[25] Kothari A, Pathak N, Vania F. Where Communities Care: community-based wildlife and ecosystem management in South Asia. 2000, Pune, India: Kalpavriksh

[26] Kothari A, Singh N, Saloni S. People and protected areas: towards participatory conservation in India. 1996, New Delhi: SAGE Publications, 276.

[27] Koziell I, Saunders J. Living off biodiversity: exploring livelihoods and biodiversity. 2001, London, UK: IIED

[28] Lockwood M. Good governance for terrestrial protected areas: A framework, principles and performance outcomes. Journal of Environmental Management, 2001, 91(3): 754-766.

[29] Mazumder AH, DeCosse P, Sharma R, Ahmad IU. Forest conservation in Bangladesh: tracing its ebb and flow in recent decades, with observation for the future, 2007

[30] McNeely J, Scherr S. Eco-agriculture: strategies to feed the world and conserve wild biodiversity. 2003, Washington DC USA: Island Press

[31] Mukul SA, Quazi SA. Communities in Conservation: Changing protected area management and enhanced conservation in Bangladesh. Leslie RN (ed.). Proceedings of the international conference; ‘The Future of Forests in Asia and the Pacific: Outlook for 2020’ held in October 16–18, 2007 at Chiang Mai, Thailand, 2009 143 159

[32] Mukul SA, Rashid AZMM, Quazi SA, Uddin MB, Fox J. Local peoples’ responses to co-management regime in protected areas: A cases study from Satchari National Park, Bangladesh. Forest, Trees and Livelihoods, 2012, 21(1): 16-29.

[33] Mukul SA, Uddin MB, Rashid AZMM, Fox J. Integrating livelihoods and conservation in protected areas: understanding role and stakeholders’ views on the prospects of non-timber forest products, A Bangladesh case study. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology, 2010, 17(2): 180-188.

[34] Mukul SA, Uddin MB, Uddin MS, Khan MASA, Marzan B. Protected areas of Bangladesh: current status and efficacy for biodiversity conservation. Proceedings of the Pakistan Academy of Sciences, 2008, 45(2): 59-68.

[35] Nagothu US. Local people’s attitudes towards conservation and wildlife tourism around Sariska Tiger Reserve, India. Journal of Environmental Management, 2003, 69(4): 339-347.

[36] Nepal SK, Weber KE. Managing resources and resolving conflicts: national parks and local people. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology, 1995, 2(1): 11-25.

[37] Nishorgo Support Project NSP. Protected Areas of Bangladesh: A visitor’s guide. 2006, Dhaka, Bangladesh: NSP

[38] Nishorgo Support Project NSP. Restoration of degraded forest habitat: Monitoring report Lawachara National Park, 2007

[39] Orlovic-Lovren V. The role of education in protected area sustainable governance. Management of Environmental Quality, 2011, 22(1): 48-58.

[40] Ormsby A, Kaplin BA. A framework for understanding community resident perceptions on Masoala National Park, Madagascar. Environmental Conservation, 2005, 32(2): 156-164.

[41] Pimbert MP, Pretty JN. Parks, people and professionals: putting participation into protected area management, 1995 49.

[42] Poffenberger M. Communities and forest management in South Asia: A regional profile of WG-CIFM the Working Group on Community Involvement in Forest Management, 2000 161.

[43] Quazi SA, Bushley BR, Miles WB, et al. Fox J, et al. Introduction: participation and the collaborative management of protected areas in Bangladesh. Connecting Communities and Conservation: Collaborative Management of Protected Areas in Bangladesh, 2008 282.

[44] Roy MK, DeCosse P. Managing demand for protected areas in Bangladesh: poverty alleviation, illegal commercial use and nature recreation. Policy Matters, 2006 94 102

[45] Scherr SJ, White A, Kaimowitz D. A new agenda for forest conservation and poverty reduction-making markets work for low-income producers. 2004, Washington DC, USA: Forest Trends

[46] Sharma R, DeCosse P, Khan M, Mazumder A. Co-management of protected areas in South Asia with special reference to Bangladesh. 2005, Dhaka, Bangladesh: Nishorgo Support Project

[47] WCPA World Commission on Protected Areas. WCPA strategic plan 2005–2012. 2005, Cambridge, UK: IUCN

[48] Wells MP, Mcshane TO. Integrating protected area management with local needs and aspirations. Ambio, 2004, 33(8): 513-519.

[49] World Resources Institute WRI. Earth trends: the environmental information portal, 2007

[50] Zashimuddin M. Sim HC, Appanah S, Lu WM. Community forestry for poverty reduction in Bangladesh. Forests for Poverty Reduction: Can Community Forestry Make Money?. 2004, Bangkok, Thailand: FAO-RAP, 81 94