Ovipositional preference and larval performance of poplar defoliator, Clostera restitura on different poplar clones in north-western India

Abstract

We evaluated ten poplar clones (G-3, G-48, L-50/88, L-154/84, L-156/89, S7C8, S7C15, WSL-22, WSL-29 and Uday) for ovipositional preference and larval performance of Clostera restitura. Female moths did not show any preference with respect to clones for oviposition. Significant differences were observed for number of eggs laid on different plant parts. C. restitura laid eggs in clusters, preferably on upper surface of leaf and size of the egg cluster varied from 15 to 167 eggs. Clones varied for their relative resistance and susceptibility to C. restitura. L-50/88; L-156/89 were identified as most resistant clone based on minimum leaf consumption, whereas S7C15 was found to be most susceptible clone to C. restitura. In multiple choice experiments, no feeding preference by C. restitura larvae was detected amongst different poplar clones. After initial settlement of larvae on a particular clone, the larvae remained confined to that clone and negligible inter-clonal movement was noticed subsequently. The fresh pupal weight was correlated negatively (r = −0.37) with percentage surface leaf area eaten and positively (r = 0.47) with length of larval period, measured on different clones. Relationship between percentage leaf area eaten and length of larval period was negative (r = −0.23). Owing to relative resistance of L-50/88 and L-156/89 against C. restitura, these clones can be recommended for plantation in defoliator prone areas in north-western India.

Keywords

C. restitura / feeding / oviposition / populus deltoids / preference

References

[1] Ahmad M.. Relative resistance in different clones of Populus deltoides to poplar defoliator Clostera cuperata (Lepidoptera: Notodontidae). Ann For, 1993, 1: 1-12.

[2] Allegro G.. Defence against insect pests of poplar: A revised technique. Informatore Agrario, 1989, 45: 93-96.

[3] Augustin S., Courtin C., Delpanque A.. Preferences of Chrysomela (Melasoma) populi L. and Chrysomela tremulae (Coleoptera. Chrysomelidae) for leuce section poplar clones. J Appl Ent, 1993, 115: 370-378.

[4] Gao R.T., Qin X.X., Li J.Z., Hao W.Q., Wang X.Z.. A preliminary study on the relationship between artificial defoliation of poplar trees and their growth. Scientia Sil Sin, 1985, 21: 199-205.

[5] Graysons J., Edmunds M.. Growth, development, mortality and fecundity of the poplar hawk moth (Laothoe populi L.) under laboratory conditions, with a note on the Eyed hawkmoth (Smarinthos ocellata L.). Entomologist’s Gaz, 1989, 40: 214-219.

[6] Ives W.G.H., Wong H.R.. Tree and Shrub Insects of the Prairie Provinces. 1988, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada: North Forestry Centre, Canadian Forestry Service, 327.

[7] Mann G.S.. Pygaera restitura Walker (Notodontidae: Lepidoptera) a pest of poplars at Ludhiana, Punjab. Indian Forester, 1982, 108: 237-238.

[8] Nef L.. Mattson W. L., Levieux J., Bernard-Dagan C.. Interactions between Phyllocnistis suffusella and the poplar leaves. Mechanism of Woody Plants Defenses Against Insect. 1986, ew York, Berlin, Germany: Springer Verlag, 239 251

[9] Reinhenbacker P.R., Schultz R.L., Hart E.R.. Artificial defoliation effect on Populus growth, bio-mass production and total non-structural carbohydrate concentration. Environ Biol, 1996, 25: 632-642.

[10] Sangha K.S., Shera P.S., Makkar G.S.. Biology of leaf defoliator, Clostera restitura (Walker) (Lepidoptera: Notodontidae) on poplar. J Insect Sci, 2005, 18(2): 47-51.

[11] Singh A.P., Bhandari R.S., Verma T.D.. Important insect pests of poplar in agroforestry and strategies for their management in north-western India. Agro-Forestry Syst, 2004, 63: 15-26.

[12] Singh A.P., Pandey R.. Natural resistance of Populus deltoides clones against the defoliator, Clostera cuperata in north-western India-1. Indian Forester, 2000, 126: 619-623.

[13] Singh A.P., Pandey R.. Natural resistance of Populus deltoides clone selection to defoliator Clostera cupreata (Lep., Notodontidae) in northern India: relative pupal weight as an easier criteria for accurate evaluation. J Appl Ent, 2002, 126: 475-480.

[14] Singh A.P.. Relative natural resistance of newly introduced Populus deltoides clones in India against defoliator, Clostera cupreata. Indian Forester, 2002, 128: 307-312.

[15] Singh K.. Bioecology and management of poplar leaf defoliator, Clostera fulgurita (Walker) (Notodontidae: Lepidoptera) on poplar. 2004, Ludhiana: Punjab Agricultural University, 114.

[16] Singh P., Singh S.. Insect Pests and Diseases of Poplars. 1986, Dehra Dun UP, India: FRI and Colleges Publications, 74.

[17] Sohi A.S., Singh H., Sandhu G.S.. Clostera restitura (Walker) (Lepidoptera: Notodontidae) a defoliator of Poplar (Populus sp.) in the Punjab and its chemical control. J Tree Sci, 1987, 6: 30-33.

[18] Thakur M.L.. Insect pest status of poplars in India. Indian Forester, 1999, 125: 866-867.

[19] Wang F.W., Niu Y.Z., Hou L.W., Pi Z.Q., Wang J.H., Cheng Y.H.. Study on the bionomics and control of Clostera anastomosis. Forest Res, 1998, 11: 325-332.