Effects of acquiring FSC forest management certification for Japanese enterprises using SmartWood Audits

Abstract

We explore the organizational, environmental, and economic effects of sustainable forest management (FM) certification by Smart-Wood (SW), one of the certification bodies accredited by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) to carry out certification in Japan. We closely investigated three enterprises: the Yusuhara Forest Owners’ Cooperative, Yamanashi Prefectural Forest, and Ryujin-mura Forest Owners’ Cooperative. Interviews with representatives of these entities provided crucial empirical information regarding the influence of certification on environmental assessment, rare-species protection, landscape-management planning, management objectives, and forest supervision. Attainment of FM status improved environmental awareness and engendered positive changes in assessing and managing forests and other natural resources but simultaneously imposed heavier economic costs.

Keywords

forest certification / forest management / FSC / required improvements / SmartWood

References

[1] FSC Japan. 2005. Yusuhara Forest Owners’ Cooperative SW-FM/COC-125 FSC—certied forest of the town on clouds. Available at http://www.forsta.or.jp/2_2_fsc_news/series/Series2_YFOC.pdf (final access: June 6, 2011; in Japanese).

[2] Hayami T.. Why and how I challenged the first FSC certification in Japan. Japanese Journal of Forest Planning, 2000, 34: 127-130.

[3] Hayami T.. The effects of FSC certification on forest management. Shinrin-kagaku, 2004, 42: 57-62.

[4] Hubbard S.S., Bowe S.A.. Environmentally certified wood products: Perspectives and experiences of primary wood manufacturers in Wisconsin. Forest Products Journal, 2005, 55: 33-40.

[5] Humphries S., Vlosky R.P., Carter D.. Certified wood-products merchants in the United States: A comparison between 1995 and 1998. Forest Products Journal, 2001, 51: 32-38.

[6] Ikuta T.. Consideration about green market and product brand. Economic Review, 2002, 6: 52-72.

[7] Kishi Y.. Forest management of the Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology certified by the SGS group’s program accredited by the Forest Stewardship Council. Journal of Field Science, 2003, 3: 17-23.

[8] Kishimoto N.. A study on Forest Stewardship Council certification in the Chamaecyparis Obtusa reforestation business: Hayami Forestry case study. Nature restoration and conservation, Japan, 2002, 1: 28-32.

[9] Newsom D., Bahn V., Cashore B.. Does forest certification matter? An analysis of operation-level changes required during the SmartWood certification process in the United States. Forest Policy and Economics, 2006, 9: 197-208.

[10] Nichiura M., Yorimitsu R.. Yorimitsu R.. The reclamation of the Green Dam and regional power: Attempts at Yusuhara Township in the Headwaters area of the Shimanto River. Asian Forests from Destruction to Reclamation. 2003, Tokyo: Nihon Keizai Hyouronsha, 247 284

[11] Ota I.. Possibility of revitalizing Japanese forestry by introducing FSC forest certification as a strategic marketing tool. Forest Economy, 2005, 686: 17-20.

[12] Owari T., Juslin H., Rummukainen A., Yoshimura T.. Strategies, functions, and benefits of forest certification in wood products marketing: Perspectives of Finnish suppliers. Forest Policy and Economics, 2006, 9: 380-391.

[13] Owari T., Sawanobori Y.. Analysis of the certified forest products market in Japan. Holz Rho Werkst, 2007, 65: 113-120.

[14] SmartWood. Forest Management Public Summary for Yusuhara Forest Owners’ Cooperative. 2000, New York: SmartWood

[15] SmartWood. Forest Management Public Summary for Yamanashi Prefectural Government. 2003, New York: SmartWood

[16] SmartWood. Forest Management Public Summary for the Ryujin-mura Forest Owners’ Cooperative. 2003, New York: SmartWood

[17] SmartWood. Forest Management Public Summary for Yusuhara Forest Owners’ Cooperative. 2005, New York: SmartWood

[18] Soil Association. Woodmark Forest Certification Public Report: Yamanashi Prefecture. 2011, Bristol: Soil Association

[19] Sugiura K., Konohira Y.. Features of evaluations of FSC certification bodies: Analysis of certification results of 17 Japanese forests. Journal of the Japanese Forest Society, 2005, 87: 241-246.

[20] Takebe H.. Konohira Y.. Community development in Yusuhara Township, Kochi Prefecture. The Function and Evaluation of Forests. 2005, Tokyo: Japan Forestry Investigation Committee, 201 284

[21] Tomimura S.. The Japanese forest and forestry course: Findings from the FSC forest certification. Mizu-joho, 2003, 23: 13-17.