A review of the formulation and application of the spatial equilibrium models to analyze policy

Abstract

This paper reviews alternative market equilibrium models for policy analysis. The origin of spatial equilibrium models and their application to wood and wood-processing industries are described. Three mathematical programming models commonly applied to solve spatial problems — namely linear programming, non-linear programming and mixed complementary programming — are reviewed in terms of forms of objective functions and constraint equalities and inequalities. These programming are illustrated with numerical examples. Linear programming is only applied in transportation problems to solve quantities transported between regions when quantities supplied and demanded in each region are already known. It is argued that linear programming can be applied in broader context to transportation problems where supply and demand quantities are unknown and are linear. In this context, linear programming is seen as a more convenient method for modelers because it has a simpler objective function and does not require as strict conditions, for instance the equal numbers of variables and equations required in mixed complementary programming. Finally, some critical insights are provided on the interpretation of optimal solutions generated by solving spatial equilibrium models.

Keywords

simplex method / reduced-gradient / linear programming / nonlinear programming / mixed complementary programming

References

[1] ACI Vietnam Livestock Spatial Equilibrium Model (VILASEM). 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam: Document for a Training Course at the Informatics and Statistics Centre for Agriculture and Rural Development (ICARD), Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD)

[2] Adams D.M., Haynes R.W.. The 1980 Softwood timber assessment market model: structure, projections, and policy simulations. Journal of Forest Science. 1980, Maryland: Society of American Foresters

[3] Alkaya D., Vasantharajan S., Biegler L.T.. Successive quadratic programming: applications in the process industry. Encyclopedia of Optimization, 2001, 5: 400-413.

[4] Benjamin H.M.K.. General Equilibrium Theory, its history and its relation (if any) to the Market Economy. 2005, New York: .New School for Social Research, New School University

[5] Bintang C.H., Simangunsong B.C.H., Joseph B.. International demand equations for forest products: a comparison of methods. Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research, 2001, 16(2): 155-172.

[6] Chiang A.C.. Fundamental Methods of Mathematical-economics, 1974 2nd edn. New York: McGraw-Hill

[7] Debreu G.. Economic theory in the mathematical model. 1983, San Crux, California: Department of Economics, University of California

[8] Devadoss S., Angel H.A., Steven R.S., Jim A.. A spatial equilibrium analysis of U.S.-Canadian disputes on the world softwood lumber market. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 2005, 53(2–3): 177-192.

[9] GAMS GAMS — The Solver Manuals. 2008, Washington, DC: GAMS Development Corporation

[10] Goletti F., Raisuddin A., Minot N., Berry P., Romeo B., Nguyen V.H., Nguyen T.B.. Rice Market Monitoring and Policy Options Study. 1996, Hanoi: Asian Development Bank

[11] Hall H.H., Heady E.O., Stoecker A., Sposito V.A.. Spatial equilibrium in U.S. Agriculture: a quadratic programming analysis. SIAM Review, 1975, 17(2): 323-338.

[12] Hassan R., Greg H., James K.A.B.. Depletion of forest resources in Sudan: intervention options for optimal control. Journal of Energy Policy, 2009, 37(4): 1195-1203.

[13] Hseu J.S., Joseph B.. Output supply and input demand in the pulp and paper industry: a nonparametric model for the United States and Canada. Journal of Forest Science, 1997, 43(1): 297-308.

[14] Jae K.S.. A spatial equilibrium analysis of southern pine lumber pricing and allocation. Journal of the Annals of Regional Science, 1984, 19(1): 61-76.

[15] Jakfar F.. A general equilibrium analysis of the economic aspects of the imposition of an export tax on the plywood sector in Indonesia. Journal of Forest Research, 2007, 6(2): 73-80.

[16] James RGM, Karen PW. (2000), An Input Factor Demand Model for the Sawmilling Industry of the Lake States, the paper presented at the Western Agriculture Economics Association Annual Meetings, Vancouver, British Columbia, http://ageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/36355/1/sp00mc03.pdf, accessed 24 April 2009.

[17] Judge G.G., Wallace T.D.. Estimation of spatial price equilibrium models. Journal of Farm Economics, 1958, 40(4): 801-820.

[18] Kangas K, Anders B. 2003. Modeling and Projections of Forest Products Demand, Supply and Trade in Europe, A study prepared for the European Forest Sector Outlook Study (EFSOS), United Nations, http://www.unece.org/timber/docs/efsos/03-sept/dp-30.pdf, accessed 24 April 2009.

[19] Luppold WG. 1983. The Effect of Changes in Lumber and Furniture Prices on Wood Furniture Manufacturers’ Lumber Usage, Research Paper NE-514, United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), http://www.treesearch.fs.fed.us/pubs/15066, accessed 24 April 2009.

[20] Mansfield E.. Microeconomics, 1996 9th Edn. New York and London: Norton & Company

[21] McCarl BA, Spreen TH. 2002. Applied Mathematical Programming Using Algebraic System, Department of Agricultural Economics, Texas A&M University. http://agecon2.tamu.edu/people/faculty/mccarl-bruce/books.htm, accessed 24 April 2009.

[22] McCarthy P, Lei L. 2007. Regional Demands for Pulp and Paper Products, Working Paper, the Center for Paper Business and Industry Studies (CPBIS), http://www.cpbis.com/research/findings/070604%20app_demand_draft.pdf, accessed 24 April 2009.

[23] MoF Forestry Terms. 1996, Hanoi: Agriculture Publishing House, Hanoi

[24] Sohngen B. 1998. An Assessment of Four Large-scale Timber Market Models. Department of Agricultural Economics, Ohio State University

[25] Stennes B., Bill W.. An analysis of lumber trade restrictions in north America: application of spatial equilibrium model. Canadian Journal of Forest Policy and Economics, 2005, 7(3): 297-308.

[26] Takayama T., Judge G.G.. Spatial equilibrium and quadratic programming. Journal of Farm Economics, 1964, 46(1): 67-93.

[27] Todaro M.P.. Economic Development, 1994 5th edn. New York: Longman Publishing House

[28] Tramel T.E., Seale A.D.. Reactive programming of supply and demand relations: applications to fresh vegetables. Journal of Farm Economics, 1959, 41(5): 1012-022.

[29] Tsunemasa K., Nobuhiro S., Harry M.K.. A spatial equilibrium model for imperfectly competitive milk markets. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1997, 79(3): 851-859.

[30] Uri N.D.. A spatial equilibrium model for electrical energy in United States. Journal of Regional Science, 1975, 15(3): 323-333.

[31] Weber EJ. nd. Optimal Control Theory for Undergraduates Using the Microsoft Excel Solver Tool. University of Western Australia

[32] Yoshimoto A., Yukutake K.. Japanese forest sector modeling through a partial equilibrium model. Forest Resource Use vs. Environmental Policy and Timber Trade, 2002, 7(1): 41-48.