Theoretical derivation of risk-ratios for assessing wind damage in a coastal forest

Abstract

Based on the discussion of relationships between thinning and wind damage, and published information, a method for estimating risk ratios of wind damage was developed. Estimations of risk-ratio forPinus thunbergii trees and stands were deduced from stem bending theory and coefficients characterizing wind profile, distribution of branches and optical stratification porosity. The results showed that if the value of constant β in the branch distribution-model equals the attenuation coefficient α_s in the wind profile model for a single tree crown, then the parameter H/D_1.3 ³ (height over stem diameter cubed) can be used to compare and evaluate the risk-ratio of wind damage for individual trees. The same method can be applied to stands using the coefficient of wind profile in a stand, i.e. attenuation coefficient α, the coefficient from distributions of optical stratification porosity, i.e. extinction coefficient ν, and the parameter D_1.3 ³. The application of parameter H/D_1.3 ³ and the process of determining risk ratios of wind damage for stands were also given in the paper.

Keywords

Wind damage / Thinning / Pine forest / Risk-ratio / S761.2 / S757.1 / A

References

[1] Amiro B.D. Comparison of turbulence statistics within three boreal forest canopies [J]. Boundary-Layer Meteorology, 1990, 51: 99-121.

[2] Bergen J.D. Vertical profiles of windspeed in a pine stand [J]. Forest Science, 1971, 17: 314-321.

[3] Blackburn P., Petty J.A. An assessment of the static and dynamic factors involved in windthrow [J]. Forestry, 1988, 61: 29-43.

[4] Blackburn P., Petty J.A. Theoretical calculations of the influence of spacing on stand stability [J]. Forestry, 1988, 61: 235-244.

[5] Cremer K.W., Borough C.J., Mckinnell F.H., Carter P.R. Effects of stocking and thinning on wind damage in plantations [J]. New Zealand Journal of Forestry Science, 1982, 12: 244-268.

[6] Deans J.D., Milne R. Effects of respacing on young Sitka spruce crops [J]. Forestry, 1999, 72: 47-57.

[7] Everham E.M. Coutts M.P., Grace J. A comparison of methods for quantifying catastrophic wind damage to forest [C] Wind and Trees, 1995 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 340-357.

[8] Galinski W. A windthrow-risk estimation for coniferous trees [J]. Forestry, 1989, 61: 139-146.

[9] Gardiner B.A. Coutts M.P., Grace J. The interaction of wind and tree movement in forest canopies[C] Wind and Trees, 1995 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 41-59.

[10] Gardiner B.A., Stacy G.R., Belcher R.E., Wood C.J. Field and wind tunnel assessments of the implications of respacing and thinning for tree stability [J]. Forestry, 1997, 70: 233-252.

[11] Godwin, G.E., 1968. The influence of wind on forest management and planning [J]. Forestry,Supplement: 60–66.

[12] Grace J. Plant response to wind [J]. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 1988, 22/23: 71-88.

[13] Hutte, P. 1968. Experiments on windflow and wind damage in Germany; site and susceptibility of spruce forests to storm damage [J]. Forestry,Supplement: 20–27.

[14] Kuraji K., Tanaka N., Shiraki K., Karakama I., Ohta T. Effects of windspeed on stem-flow volume in a matureCryptomeria japonica andChamaecyparis obtusa stand [J]. Journal of the Japanese Forestry Society, 1997, 79: 215-221. (in Japanese with English abstract)

[15] Landsberg J.J., James G.B. Wind profiles in plant canopies: studies on an analytical model [J]. Journal of Applied Ecology, 1971, 8: 729-741.

[16] Matsuzaki T. Impact of wind and snow on forest [C] Proceedings of NAFRO seminar on sustainable forestry and its biological environment, 1994 Tokyo: Japan Society of Forest Planning Press 145-148.

[17] Matsuzaki T., Nakata M. Wind feature of typhoon 19^th in 1991 at Sado Island [J]. Research Bulletin of the Niigata University Forest, 1993, 26: 1-16.

[18] Mayer H. Windthrow [C] Philosophical Transactions of Royal Society of London, Series B, 1989, 324: 267-281.

[19] Mitchell S.J. Stem growth responses in Douglas fir and Skita spruce following thinning: Implications for assessing wind firmness [J]. Forest Ecology and Management, 2000, 135: 105-114.

[20] Moore J., Quine C.P. A comparison of the relative risk of wind damage to planted forests in Border Forest Park, Great Britain, and the Central North Island, New Zealand [J]. Forest Ecology And Management, 2000, 135: 345-353.

[21] Nielsen C.C.N. Coutts M.P., Grace J. Recommendations for stabilisation of Norway spruce stands based on ecological surveys [C] Wind and Trees, 1995 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 424-435.

[22] Peltola H., Kellomaki S. A mechanistic model for calculating windthrow and stem breakage of Scaots pines at stand edge [J]. Silva Fennica, 1993, 27: 99-111.

[23] Peltola H., Kellomaki S., Hassinen A., Lemettinen M., Aho J. Swaying of trees as caused by wind: analysis of field measurement [J]. Silva Fennica, 1993, 27: 113-126.

[24] Peltola H. Swaying of trees in response to wind and thinning in a stand of Scots pine [J]. Boundary-Layer Meteorology, 1996, 77: 285-304.

[25] Peltola H. Model computations on wind flow and turning moment by wind for Scots pines along the margins of clear-cut areas [J]. Forest Ecology and Management, 1996, 83: 203-215.

[26] Peltola H., Kellomaki S., Vaisanen H., Ikonen U.P. A mechanistic model for assessing the risk of wind and snow damage to a single tree and stands of Scots pine, Norway spruce and birch [J]. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 1999, 29: 261-267.

[27] Peltola H., Kellomaki S., Kolstrom T., Lassig R., Moor J., Quine C., Ruel J.C. Wind and other abiotic risks to forests [J]. Forest Ecology and Management, 2000, 135: 1-2.

[28] Perry D.A. Forest ecosystem [M], 1994 Baltimiore and London: The Johns Hapkins University Press 376-425.

[29] Petty J.A., Worrell R. Stability of coniferous tree stems in relation to damage by snow [J]. Forestry, 1981, 54: 115-128.

[30] Petty J.A., Swain C. Factors influencing stem breakage of conifers in high winds [J]. Forestry, 1985, 58: 75-84.

[31] Quine C.P. Coutts M.P., Grace J. Assessing the risk of wind damage to forests: practice and pitfalls [C] Wind and Trees, 1995 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 379-403.

[32] Quine C.P., Humphrey J.W., Ferris R. Should the wind disturbance patterns observed in natural forests be mimicked in planted forests in the British upland [J]. Forestry, 1999, 72: 227-358.

[33] Rollinson T.J. Respacing Sitka spruce [J]. Forestry, 1989, 62: 1-22.

[34] Ruel J.C., Pin D., Cooper K. Effect of topography on wind behavior in a complex terrain [J]. Forestry, 1998, 71: 261-265.

[35] Stokes A., Fitter A.H., Coutts M.P. Coutts M.P., Grace J. Responses of young trees to wind: effects on root growth [C] Wind and Trees, 1995 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 264-275.

[36] Stumbles, R.E. 1968. How wind influences silviculture and management as a district officer sees it [J]. Forestry,Supplement: 45–50.

[37] Telewsiki F.W., Jaffe M.J. Thigmo-morphogenesis: changes in the morphology and chemical composition induced by mechanical perturbation of 6-month-old Pinustaeda seedlings [J]. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 1981, 11: 380-387.

[38] Telewsiki F.W. Coutts M.P., Grace J. Wind-induced physiological and developmental responses in trees [C] Wind and trees, 1995 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 237-263.

[39] Valinger E., Lundqvist L., Bondesson L. Assessing the risk of snow and wind damage from tree physical characteristics [J]. Forestry, 1993, 66: 249-260.

[40] Valinger E., Pettersson N. Wind and snow damage in a thinned and fertilization experiment inPicea abies in southern Sweden [J]. Forestry, 1996, 69: 25-33.

[41] Wenzal A., Kalthoff N., Horlacher V. On the profiles of wind velocity in the roughness sub-layer above a coniferous forest [J]. Boundary-Layer Meteorology, 1997, 84: 219-230.

[42] Zhu J.J., Matsuzaki T., Sakioka K. Windspeeds within a single crown of Japanese black pine (Pinus thunbergii Parl.) [J]. Forest Ecology Management, 2000, 135: 19-31.

[43] Zhu J.J., Matsuzaki T., Gonda Y., Yamamoto M. Estimation of optical stratification porosity (OSP) in a pine coastal forest with different thinning intensities using hemispherical photographic silhouettes [J]. Bulletin of Faculty of Agriculture Niigata University, 2000, 53: 55-70.

[44] Zhu J.J., Matsuzaki T., Gonda Y., Sakioka K., Yamamoto M. Wind profiles within and above a pine littoral forest with thinning and unthinning treatments [J]. Bulletin of Faculty of Agriculture Niigata University, 2001, 53: 159-177.

[45] Zhu J.J., Matsuzaki T., Gonda Y. Wind profiles in a coastal forest of Japanese black pine (Pinus thunbergii Parl.) with different thinning intensities [J]. Journal of Forest Research, 2001, 6: 287-296.

[46] Zhu, J.J., Matsuzaki, T., and Gonda, Y. 2002. Optical stratification porosity as a measure of vertical canopy structure in a Japanese coastal forest [J]. Forest Ecology and management, (in press).