Comparison of stand structure and growth between artificial and natural forests ofPinus sylvestiris var.mongolica on sandy land

Abstract

Mongolian pine (Pinus sylvestiris Linnaeus var.mongolica Litvinov) as a valuable conifer tree species has been broadly introduced to the sandy land areas in “Three North” regions (North, northwest and northeast of China), but many problems occurred in the earliest Mongolian pine plantations in Zhanggutai, Zhangwu County, Liaoning Province (ZZL). In order to clarify the reason, comprehensive investigations were carried out on differences in structure characteristics, growth processes and ecological factors between artificial stands (the first plantation established in ZZL in 1950s) and natural stands (the origin forests of the tree species in Honghuaerji, Inner Mongolia) on sandy land. The results showed that variation of diameter-class distributions in artificial stands and natural stands could be described by Weibull and Normal distribution models, respectively. Chapman-Richards growth model was employed to reconstruct the growth process of Mongolian pine based on the data from field investigation and stem analysis. The ages of maximum of relative growth rate and average growth rate of DBH, height, and volume of planted trees were 11, 22 years, 8, 15 years and 35, 59 years earlier than those of natural stand trees, respectively. In respects of the incremental acceleration of volume, the artificial and natural stands reached their maximum values at 14 years and 33 years respectively. The quantitative maturity ages of artificial stands and natural stands were 43 years and 102 years respectively. It was concluded that the life span of the Mongolian pine trees in natural stands was about 60 years longer than those in artificial stands. The differences mentioned above between artificial and natural Mongolian pine forests on sandy land were partially attributed to the drastic variations of ecological conditions such as latitude, temperature, precipitation, evaporation and height above sea level. Human beings’ disturbances and higher density in plantation forest may be ascribed as additional reasons. Those results may be potentially useful for the management and afforestation of Mongolian pine plantations on sandy land in arid and semi-arid areas.

Keywords

Pinus sylvestiris var.mongolica / Mongolian pine / Sandy land / Comparison / Growth model / S791.253 / A

References

[1] Bailey R.L., Dell T.R. Quantifying diameter distributions with the Weibull function [J]. For. Sci., 1973, 19: 97-104.

[2] Bailey R.L. Individual tree growth derived from diameter distribution models [J]. For. Sci., 1980, 26: 626-632.

[3] Bolstad P.V., Lee A.H. Height and diameter growth response in Loblolly pine stands following fertilization [J]. For. Sci., 1987, 34: 644-652.

[4] Bredenkamp B.V., Gregoire T.G. A forestry application of Schnute’s generalized growth function [J]. For. Sci., 1988, 34: 790-797.

[5] Dyer M.E., Bailey R.L. A test of six methods for estimating true tree heights from stem analysis data For. Sci., 1987, 33: 1-13.

[6] Fabbio G., Frattegiani M. Height estimation in stem analysis using second differences spatial autocorrelation of D & H increment predictions from, two stand simulations for Loblolly pine [J]. For. Sci., 1994, 40: 329-340.

[7] Immel M.J., Rumsey R.L., Carpenter S.B. Comparative growth responses of northern red oak and chestnut oak seedlings to varying photoperiods [J]. For. Sci., 1978, 24: 554-560.

[8] Fengqi Jiang, Dehui Zeng, Jiaojun Zhu Fundamentals and technical strategy of sand-fixation forest management [J]. Chin. J. Desert, 1997, 17: 250-254. (in Chinese with English abstract)

[9] Fengqi Jiang, Jiaojun Zhu Investigation on the occurrence of extraordinary serious sand storm in Ningxia Hui Nationality and Nei Mongol Autonomous regions [J]. Chin. J. Appll. Ecol., 1993, 4: 343-352. (in Chinese with English abstract)

[10] Fengqi Jiang, Jiaojun Zhu Development and utilization of sand land resource from ecological view [J]. Chin. J. Ecology, 1993, 12(3): 48-52. (In Chinese with English abstract)

[11] Shuren Jiao Structure and function of Mongolian pine plantation for sand fixation in Zhanggutai[M], 1989 Shenyang: Science and Technology Pressof Liaoning Province 1 36 (in Chinese)

[12] Kershaw J.A.J., Mayurie D.A. Crown structure in Western hemlock, Douglas fir and Grand fir in Western Washington: horizontal distribution of foliage within branches [J]. Cana. J. For. Res., 1996, 26: 128-142.

[13] Parker A.J. Stand structure in subalpine forests of Yosemite National Park, California [J]. For. Sci., 1988, 34: 1047-1058.

[14] Pienaar L.V., Turnbull K.J. The Champan-Richards generation of Von Bertalanffy’s growth model for basal area growth and yield in even-aged stands [J]. For. Sci., 1973, 19: 2-22.

[15] Shiver B.D. Samples sizes and estimation methods for the Weibull function [J]. For. Sci., 1988, 34: 809-814.

[16] Strub M.R., Vasey R.B., Burkhart H.E. Comparison of diameter growth and crown competition factor in Loblolly pine plantations [J]. For. Sci., 1975, 21: 424-431.

[17] Vanday J.K. Synthesis- growth models for tropical forests, a synthesis of models and method [J]. For. Sci., 1995, 41: 7-42.

[18] Hong Wang Method for soil analysis [M], 1991 Shenyang: Liaoning University Press 1-120.

[19] Wang L.H., Huang R.F. Afforestation ofPinus sylvestris var.mongolica in China [J]. Sand Dune Res., 1996, 43(2): 36-40. (In Japanese with English abstract)

[20] Yang Y.C., Chao S.L. Comparison of volume growth calculation methods for remeasured horizontal line sampling [J]. For. Sci., 1987, 33: 1062-1067.

[21] Dehui Zeng, Fengqi Jiang, Zhiping Fan, Jiaojun Zhu Fengqi Jiang Stability of Mongolian pine (Pinus sylvestris var.mongolica) on sandy land [C] Proceedings of Rational management and improvement techniques for protective forests, 1996 Beijing: Chinese Forestry Press 104 113 (In Chinese with English abstract)

[22] Dehui Zeng, Fengqi Jiang, Zhiping Fan, Jiaojun Zhu Fengqi Jiang Rational density of Mongolian pine on sandy land from the view of water balance [C] Proceedings of Rational management and improvement techniques for protective forests, 1996 Beijing: Chinese Forestry Press 114 119 (In Chinese with English abstract)

[23] Jiaojun Zhu, Fengqi Jiang, Fenggin Li Analysis on desertification [J]. Sci. Techno. Protective For., 1994, 3: 3-8. (In Chinese)