In-situ Technologies for Controlling Sediment Phosphorus in Eutrophic Shallow Lakes: A Review

Abstract

Phosphorus (P) is the main limiting factor in eutrophication. Sediment P can be released decades after its accumulation. Lake restoration requires the reduction of internal sediment P loading. Although we tried to provide a comprehensive summary of the state-of-the-art sediment P control technologies, our analyses in this review are focused on the mechanisms, control effects, and application conditions of different in-situ technologies including physical control, chemical control, ecological remediation, and combined control technology. The design principles, feasibility, operation parameters, and pros & cons of these technologies are analyzed and compared. More efforts are needed to improve in-situ sediment P control technologies so as to enhance the interaction between materials and plant communities and promote the adsorption and fixation of active P in sediments. The control materials for internal sediment P loading need to be further studied in terms of their functional properties, pre-evaluation of the P control effect, and engineering applications.

References

[1] Acelas N Y, Martin B D, Lopez D . Selective Removal of Phosphate from Wastewater Using Hydrated Metal Oxides Dispersed within Anionic Exchange Media. Chemosphere, 2015, 119 1353-1360.

[2] Association of American Railroads Railroads and Chemicals, 2018 Washington DC AAR

[3] Berg U, Neumann T, Donnert D . Sediment Capping in Eutrophic Lakes-Efficiency of Undisturbed Calcite Barriers to Immobilize Phosphorus. Applied Geochemistry, 2004, 19(11): 1759-1771.

[4] Brattebo S K, Welch E B, Gibbons H L . Effectiveness of Alum in a Hypereutrophic Lake with Substantial External Loading. Lake and Reservoir Management, 2017, 33(2): 108-118.

[5] Carvalho L, Maberly S, May L Risk Assessment Methodology for Determining Nutrient Impacts in Surface Freshwater Bodies, 2005 Bristol Environment Agency

[6] Chao C X, Wang L G, Li Y . Response of Sediment and Water Microbial Communities to Submerged Vegetations Restoration in a Shallow Eutrophic Lake. Science of the Total Environment, 2021, 801 149701.

[7] Chen M S, Cui J Z, Lin J . Successful Control of Internal Phosphorus Loading after Sediment Dredging for 6 Years: A Field Assessment Using High-Resolution Sampling Techniques. Science of the Total Environment, 2018, 616 927-936

[8] Chen Z Q, Zhao D, Li M L . A Field Study on the Effects of Combined Biomanipulation on the Water Quality of a Eutrophic Lake. Environmental Pollution, 2020, 265 115091.

[9] Daldorph P W G. A Reservoir in Management-Induced Transition between Ecological States. The Ecological Bases for Lake and Reservoir Management, 1999 Dordrecht Springer Netherlands 325-333.

[10] Deng J M, Paerl H W, Qin B Q . Climatically-Modulated Decline in Wind Speed may Strongly Affect Eutrophication in Shallow Lakes. Science of the Total Environment, 2018, 645 1361-1370.

[11] Deng S J, Chen J Q, Chang J J. Application of Biochar as an Innovative Substrate in Constructed Wetlands/Biofilters for Wastewater Treatment: Performance and Ecological Benefits. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2021, 293 126156.

[12] Deppe T, Benndorf J. Phosphorus Reduction in a Shallow Hypereutrophic Reservoir by In-Lake Dosage of Ferrous Iron. Water Research, 2002, 36(18): 4525-4534.

[13] Ding S M, Chen M S, Cui J Z . Reactivation of Phosphorus in Sediments after Calcium-Rich Mineral Capping: Implication for Revising the Laboratory Testing Scheme for Immobilization Efficiency. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2018, 331 720-728.

[14] Dittrich M, Gabriel O, Rutzen C . Lake Restoration by Hypolimnetic Ca(OH)₂ Treatment: Impact on Phosphorus Sedimentation and Release from Sediment. Science of the Total Environment, 2011, 409(8): 1504-1515.

[15] Egemose S, Reitzel K, Andersen F . Chemical Lake Restoration Products: Sediment Stability and Phosphorus Dynamics. Environmental Science & Technology, 2010, 44(3): 985-991.

[16] Egemose S, Wauer G, Kleeberg A. Resuspension Behaviour of Aluminium Treated Lake Sediments: Effects of Ageing and pH. Hydrobiologia, 2009, 636(1): 203-217.

[17] Epe T S, Finsterle K, Yasseri S. Nine Years of Phosphorus Management with Lanthanum Modified Bentonite (Phoslock) in a Eutrophic, Shallow Swimming Lake in Germany. Lake and Reservoir Management, 2017, 33(2): 119-129.

[18] Fan Y, Li Y W, Wu D Y . Application of Zeolite/Hydrous Zirconia Composite as a Novel Sediment Capping Material to Immobilize Phosphorus. Water Research, 2017, 123 1-11.

[19] Fang F, Yang L Y, Gan L . DO, pH, and Eh Microprofiles in Cyanobacterial Granules from Lake Taihu under Different Environmental Conditions. Journal of Applied Phycology, 2014, 26(4): 1689-1699.

[20] Fang T, Bao S P, Sima X F . Study on the Application of Integrated Eco-Engineering in Purifying Eutrophic River Waters. Ecological Engineering, 2016, 94 320-328.

[21] Gibbs M M, Hickey C W, Özkundakci D. Sustainability Assessment and Comparison of Efficacy of Four P-Inactivation Agents for Managing Internal Phosphorus Loads in Lakes: Sediment Incubations. Hydrobiologia, 2011, 658(1): 253-275.

[22] Gibbs M, Özkundakci D. Effects of a Modified Zeolite on P and N Processes and Fluxes across the Lake Sediment-Water Interface Using Core Incubations. Hydrobiologia, 2011, 661(1): 21-35.

[23] Gong Y, Zhao D. Physical-Chemical Processes for Phosphorus Removal and Recovery. Comprehensive Water Quality and Purification, 2014 Amsterdam Elsevier 196-222.

[24] Grisé D, Titus J E, Wagner D J. Environmental pH Influences Growth and Tissue Chemistry of the Submersed Macrophyte Vallisneria americana. Canadian Journal of Botany, 1986, 64(2): 306-310.

[25] Han C, Ren J H, Wang Z D . Characterization of Phosphorus Availability in Response to Radial Oxygen Losses in the Rhizosphere of Vallisneria Spiralis. Chemosphere, 2018, 208 740-748.

[26] Han F, Zhang Y, Liu Z S . Effects of Maifanite on Growth, Physiological and Phytochemical Process of Submerged Macrophytes Vallisneria Spiralis. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 2020, 189 109941.

[27] Han Y Q, Jeppesen E, Lürling M . Combining Lanthanum-Modified Bentonite (LMB) and Submerged Macrophytes Alleviates Water Quality Deterioration in the Presence of Omni-Benthivorous Fish. Journal of Environmental Management, 2022, 314 115036.

[28] Hilt S, Van de Weyer K, Köhler A . Submerged Macrophyte Responses to Reduced Phosphorus Concentrations in Two Peri-Urban Lakes. Restoration Ecology, 2010, 18(s2): 452-461.

[29] Himmelheber D W, Taillefert M, Pennell K D . Spatial and Temporal Evolution of Biogeochemical Processes Following in Situ Capping of Contaminated Sediments. Environmental Science & Technology, 2008, 42(11): 4113-4120.

[30] Horppila J, Nurminen L. Effects of Submerged Macrophytes on Sediment Resuspension and Internal Phosphorus Loading in Lake Hiidenvesi (Southern Finland). Water Research, 2003, 37(18): 4468-4474.

[31] Horppila J, Nurminen L. Effects of Different Macrophyte Growth Forms on Sediment and P Resuspension in a Shallow Lake. Hydrobiologia, 2005, 545(1): 167-175.

[32] Huser B J, Egemose S, Harper H . Longevity and Effectiveness of Aluminum Addition to Reduce Sediment Phosphorus Release and Restore Lake Water Quality. Water Research, 2016, 97 122-132.

[33] Huser B J, Futter M, Lee J T . In-Lake Measures for Phosphorus Control: The Most Feasible and Cost-Effective Solution for Long-Term Management of Water Quality in Urban Lakes. Water Research, 2016, 97 142-152.

[34] Kelly Vargas K G, Qi Z M. P Immobilizing Materials for Lake Internal Loading Control: A Review towards Future Developments. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 2019, 49(6): 518-552.

[35] Kim G, Jung W. Role of Sand Capping in Phosphorus Release from Sediment. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, 2010, 14(6): 815-821.

[36] Kleeberg A, Herzog C, Hupfer M. Redox Sensitivity of Iron in Phosphorus Binding Does Not Impede Lake Restoration. Water Research, 2013, 47(3): 1491-1502.

[37] Kuster A C, Kuster A T, Huser B J. A Comparison of Aluminum Dosing Methods for Reducing Sediment Phosphorus Release in Lakes. Journal of Environmental Management, 2020, 261 110195.

[38] Lampert D J, Sarchet W V, Reible D D. Assessing the Effectiveness of Thin-Layer Sand Caps for Contaminated Sediment Management through Passive Sampling. Environmental Science & Technology, 2011, 45(19): 8437-8443.

[39] Li C J, Yu H X, Tabassum S . Effect of Calcium Silicate Hydrates (CSH) on Phosphorus Immobilization and Speciation in Shallow Lake Sediment. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2017, 317 844-853.

[40] Li C J, Yu H X, Tabassum S . Effect of Calcium Silicate Hydrates Coupled with Myriophyllum Spicatum on Phosphorus Release and Immobilization in Shallow Lake Sediment. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2018, 331 462-470.

[41] Li H F, Li Z J, Qu J H . Combined Effects of Phosphate-Solubilizing Bacterium XMT-5 (Rhizobium Sp.) and Submerged Macrophyte Ceratophyllum Demersum on Phosphorus Release in Eutrophic Lake Sediments. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 2018, 25(19): 18990-19000.

[42] Li X D, Chen J B, Zhang Z Y . Interactions of Phosphate and Dissolved Organic Carbon with Lanthanum Modified Bentonite: Implications for the Inactivation of Phosphorus in Lakes. Water Research, 2020, 181 115941.

[43] Li Y, Wang L G, Chao C X . Submerged Macrophytes Successfully Restored a Subtropical Aquacultural Lake by Controlling Its Internal Phosphorus Loading. Environmental Pollution, 2021, 268 115949.

[44] Libralato G, Minetto D, Lofrano G . Toxicity Assessment within the Application of in Situ Contaminated Sediment Remediation Technologies: A Review. Science of the Total Environment, 2018, 621 85-94.

[45] Lin J W, Li Y, Zhan Y H . Combined Amendment and Capping of Sediment with Ferrihydrite and Magnetite to Control Internal Phosphorus Release. Water Research, 2023, 235 119899.

[46] Lin J W, Xiang W J, Zhan Y H. Comparison of Magnetite, Hematite and Goethite Amendment and Capping in Control of Phosphorus Release from Sediment. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 2023, 30(24): 66080-66101.

[47] Lin J W, Wang H, Zhan Y H . Evaluation of Sediment Amendment with Zirconium-Reacted Bentonite to Control Phosphorus Release. Environmental Earth Sciences, 2016, 75(11): 942.

[48] Lin J W, Zhan Y H, Zhu Z L. Evaluation of Sediment Capping with Active Barrier Systems (ABS) Using Calcite/Zeolite Mixtures to Simultaneously Manage Phosphorus and Ammonium Release. Science of the Total Environment, 2011, 409(3): 638-646.

[49] Lin J, Sun Q, Ding S M . Mobile Phosphorus Stratification in Sediments by Aluminum Immobilization. Chemosphere, 2017, 186 644-651.

[50] Liu Z S, Bai G L, Liu Y L . Long-Term Study of Ecological Restoration in a Typical Shallow Urban Lake. Science of the Total Environment, 2022, 846 157505.

[51] Liu Z S, Zhang Y, Liu B Y . Adsorption Performance of Modified Bentonite Granular (MBG) on Sediment Phosphorus in all Fractions in the West Lake, Hangzhou, China. Ecological Engineering, 2017, 106 124-131.

[52] Liu Z S, Zhang Y, Yan P . Synergistic Control of Internal Phosphorus Loading from Eutrophic Lake Sediment Using MMF Coupled with Submerged Macrophytes. Science of the Total Environment, 2020, 731 138697.

[53] Liu Z S, Zou Y, Liu Y L . Effective Adsorption of Nutrients from Simulated Domestic Sewage by Modified Maifanite. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 2022, 29(17): 25939-25951.

[54] Liu Z Y, Jin Z H, Li Y W . Sediment Phosphorus Fractions and Profile Distribution at Different Vegetation Growth Zones in a Macrophyte Dominated Shallow Wuliangsuhai Lake, China. Environmental Geology, 2007, 52(5): 997-1005.

[55] Lu S Y, Jin X C, Liang L L . Influence of Inactivation Agents on Phosphorus Release from Sediment. Environmental Earth Sciences, 2013, 68(4): 1143-1151.

[56] Mikuniya Corporation Pilot-Scale Treatment of Nakanoumi Lake, Report to Ministry of Construction, 1984 Tokyo Mikuniya Corporation

[57] Miretzky P, Saralegui A, Cirelli A F. Aquatic Macrophytes Potential for the Simultaneous Removal of Heavy Metals (Buenos Aires, Argentina). Chemosphere, 2004, 57(8): 997-1005.

[58] Moore B C, Christensen D, Richter A C. Newman Lake Restoration: A Case Study. Part II. Microfloc Alum Injection. Lake and Reservoir Management, 2009, 25(4): 351-363.

[59] Münch M A, van Kaam R, As K . Impact of Iron Addition on Phosphorus Dynamics in Sediments of a Shallow Peat Lake 10 Years after Treatment. Water Research, 2024, 248 120844.

[60] Murphy T P, Hall K G, Northcote T G. Lime Treatment of a Hardwater Lake to Reduce Eutrophication. Lake and Reservoir Management, 1988, 4(2): 51-62.

[61] Orihel D M, Baulch H M, Casson N J . Internal Phosphorus Loading in Canadian Fresh Waters: A Critical Review and Data Analysis. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2017, 74(12): 2005-2029.

[62] Özkundakci D, Hamilton D P, Gibbs M M. Hypolimnetic Phosphorus and Nitrogen Dynamics in a Small, Eutrophic Lake with a Seasonally Anoxic Hypolimnion. Hydrobiologia, 2011, 661(1): 5-20.

[63] Paice R L, Chambers J M, Robson B J. Outcomes of Submerged Macrophyte Restoration in a Shallow Impounded, Eutrophic River. Hydrobiologia, 2016, 778(1): 179-192.

[64] Pan G, Yang B, Wang D . In-Lake Algal Bloom Removal and Submerged Vegetation Restoration Using Modified Local Soils. Ecological Engineering, 2011, 37(2): 302-308.

[65] Prepas E E, Babin J, Murphy T P . Long-Term Effects of Successive Ca(OH)₂ and CaCO₃ Treatments on the Water Quality of Two Eutrophic Hardwater Lakes. Freshwater Biology, 2001, 46(8): 1089-1103.

[66] Qin B Q, Zhang Y L, Zhu G W . Eutrophication Control of Large Shallow Lakes in China. Science of the Total Environment, 2023, 881 163494.

[67] Qin B Q, Zhu G W, Zhang L . Estimation of Internal Nutrient Release in Large Shallow Lake Taihu, China. Science in China Series D, 2006, 49(1): 38-50.

[68] Reitzel K, Hansen J, Andersen F O . Lake Restoration by Dosing Aluminum Relative to Mobile Phosphorus in the Sediment. Environmental Science & Technology, 2005, 39(11): 4134-4140.

[69] Rooney N, Kalff J, Habel C. The Role of Submerged Macrophyte Beds in Phosphorus and Sediment Accumulation in Lake Memphremagog, Quebec, Canada. Limnology and Oceanography, 2003, 48(5): 1927-1937.

[70] Schindler D W, Hecky R E, Findlay D L . Eutrophication of Lakes Cannot Be Controlled by Reducing Nitrogen Input: Results of a 37-Year Whole-Ecosystem Experiment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2008, 105(32): 11254-11258.

[71] Schulz M, Kozerski H P, Pluntke T . The Influence of Macrophytes on Sedimentation and Nutrient Retention in the Lower River Spree (Germany). Water Research, 2003, 37(3): 569-578.

[72] Smolders A J P, Lamers L P M, Moonen M . Controlling Phosphate Release from Phosphate-Enriched Sediments by Adding Various Iron Compounds. Biogeochemistry, 2001, 54(2): 219-228.

[73] Tang A P, Wan J B, Rong W . Importance of pH, Dissolved Oxygen and Light to Phosphorus Release from Ditch Sediments. Nature Environment and Pollution Technology, 2015, 14 475-484

[74] van Oosterhout F, Yasseri S, Noyma N . Assessing the Long-Term Efficacy of Internal Loading Management to Control Eutrophication in Lake Rauwbraken. Inland Waters, 2022, 12(1): 61-77.

[75] Wang C H, Jiang H L. Chemicals Used for in Situ Immobilization to Reduce the Internal Phosphorus Loading from Lake Sediments for Eutrophication Control. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 2016, 46 947-997.

[76] Wang C, Liu S Y, Jahan T E . Short Term Succession of Artificially Restored Submerged Macrophytes and Their Impact on the Sediment Microbial Community. Ecological Engineering, 2017, 103 50-58.

[77] Wang C, Liu Z S, Zhang Y . Synergistic Removal Effect of P in Sediment of all Fractions by Combining the Modified Bentonite Granules and Submerged Macrophyte. Science of the Total Environment, 2018, 626 458-467.

[78] Wang J F, Chen J G, Yu P P . Oxygenation and Synchronous Control of Nitrogen and Phosphorus Release at the Sediment-Water Interface Using Oxygen Nano-Bubble Modified Material. Science of the Total Environment, 2020, 725 138258.

[79] Wang J J, Gao M M, Yang Y J . Interactions of Vallisneria natans and Iron-Oxidizing Bacteria Enhance Iron-Bound Phosphorus Formation in Eutrophic Lake Sediments. Microorganisms, 2022, 10(2): 413.

[80] Wang J J, Zhang S W, Que T Y . Mitigation of Eutrophication in a Shallow Lake: The Influences of Submerged Macrophytes on Phosphorus and Bacterial Community Structure in Sediments. Sustainability, 2021, 13(17): 9833.

[81] Wang L Z, Wang G X, Ge X G . Influence of Submerged Plants on Phosphorus Fractions and Profiles of Sediments in Gucheng Lake. Soil and Sediment Contamination, 2012, 21(5): 640-654.

[82] Wang S R, Jiao L X, Yang S W . Effects of Organic Matter and Submerged Macrophytes on Variations of Alkaline Phosphatase Activity and Phosphorus Fractions in Lake Sediment. Journal of Environmental Management, 2012, 113 355-360.

[83] Wauer G, Gonsiorczyk T, Casper P . P-Immobilisation and Phosphatase Activities in Lake Sediment Following Treatment with Nitrate and Iron. Limnologica, 2005, 35(1/2): 102-108.

[84] Wei G N, Xu J N, Yang B . Controlling Internal Nutrients Loading at Low Temperature Using Oxygen-Loading Zeolite and Submerged Macrophytes Enhances Environmental Resilience to Subsequent High Temperature. Environmental Research, 2023, 231 116101.

[85] Willenbring P R, Miller M S, Weidenbacher W D. Reducing Sediment Phosphorus Release Rates in Long Lake through the Use of Calcium Nitrate. Lake and Reservoir Management, 1984, 1(1): 118-121.

[86] Wu Z H, Wang S R, Luo J. Transfer Kinetics of Phosphorus (P) in Macrophyte Rhizosphere and Phytoremoval Performance for Lake Sediments Using DGT Technique. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2018, 350 189-200.

[87] Xia L, van Dael T, Bergen B . Phosphorus Immobilisation in Sediment by Using Iron Rich By-Product as Affected by Water pH and Sulphate Concentrations. Science of the Total Environment, 2023, 864 160820.

[88] Xiong C H, Wang D Y, Tam N F . Enhancement of Active Thin-Layer Capping with Natural Zeolite to Simultaneously Inhibit Nutrient and Heavy Metal Release from Sediments. Ecological Engineering, 2018, 119 64-72.

[89] Xu D, Ding S M, Sun Q . Evaluation of in Situ Capping with Clean Soils to Control Phosphate Release from Sediments. Science of the Total Environment, 2012, 438 334-341.

[90] Xu P, Xiao E R, Xu D . Enhanced Phosphorus Reduction in Simulated Eutrophic Water: A Comparative Study of Submerged Macrophytes, Sediment Microbial Fuel Cells, and Their Combination. Environmental Technology, 2018, 39(9): 1144-1157.

[91] Xu X G, Zhou Y W, Han R M . Eutrophication Triggers the Shift of Nutrient Absorption Pathway of Submerged Macrophytes: Implications for the Phytoremediation of Eutrophic Waters. Journal of Environmental Management, 2019, 239 376-384.

[92] Yang M J, Lin J W, Zhan Y H . Immobilization of Phosphorus from Water and Sediment Using Zirconium-Modified Zeolites. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 2015, 22(5): 3606-3619.

[93] Yang Y, Chen W, Yi Z Y . The Integrative Effect of Periphyton Biofilm and Tape Grass (Vallisneria Natans) on Internal Loading of Shallow Eutrophic Lakes. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 2018, 25(2): 1773-1783.

[94] Yin H B, Kong M, Han M X . Influence of Sediment Resuspension on the Efficacy of Geoengineering Materials in the Control of Internal Phosphorous Loading from Shallow Eutrophic Lakes. Environmental Pollution, 2016, 219 568-579.

[95] Yin H B, Ren C, Li W. Introducing Hydrate Aluminum into Porous Thermally-Treated Calcium-Rich Attapulgite to Enhance Its Phosphorus Sorption Capacity for Sediment Internal Loading Management. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2018, 348 704-712.

[96] Yin H B, Yan X W, Gu X H. Evaluation of Thermally-Modified Calcium-Rich Attapulgite as a Low-Cost Substrate for Rapid Phosphorus Removal in Constructed Wetlands. Water Research, 2017, 115 329-338.

[97] Yin H B, Yang C H, Yang P . Contrasting Effects and Mode of Dredging and in Situ Adsorbent Amendment for the Control of Sediment Internal Phosphorus Loading in Eutrophic Lakes. Water Research, 2021, 189 116644.

[98] Yin H, Kong M. Reduction of Sediment Internal P-Loading from Eutrophic Lakes Using Thermally Modified Calcium-Rich Attapulgite-Based Thin-Layer Cap. Journal of Environmental Management, 2015, 151 178-185.

[99] Yu J H, Ding S M, Zhong J C . Evaluation of Simulated Dredging to Control Internal Phosphorus Release from Sediments: Focused on Phosphorus Transfer and Resupply across the Sediment-Water Interface. Science of the Total Environment, 2017, 592 662-673.

[100] Yuan H Z, Cai Y W, Wang H X . How PhoD-Harboring Functional Microbial Populations Trigger the Release Risk of Phosphorus in Water Sediment System of Shijiuhu Lake, China after Experiencing the Transseasonal Shift. Water Research, 2023, 240 120107.

[101] Yun S L, Kim S J, Park Y J . Evaluation of Capping Materials for the Stabilization of Contaminated Sediments. Materials Science Forum, 2007 Stafa Trans Tech Publications Ltd. 565-568

[102] Zamparas M, Deligiannakis Y, Zacharias I. Phosphate Adsorption from Natural Waters and Evaluation of Sediment Capping Using Modified Clays. Desalination and Water Treatment, 2013, 51(13/14/15): 2895-2902.

[103] Zamparas M, Zacharias I. Restoration of Eutrophic Freshwater by Managing Internal Nutrient Loads: A Review. Science of the Total Environment, 2014, 496 551-562.

[104] Zhang C, Zhu M Y, Zeng G M . Active Capping Technology: A New Environmental Remediation of Contaminated Sediment. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 2016, 23(5): 4370-4386.

[105] Zhang F R, Yan J, Fang J L . Sediment Phosphorus Immobilization with the Addition of Calcium/Aluminum and Lanthanum/Calcium/Aluminum Composite Materials under Wide Ranges of pH and Redox Conditions. Science of the Total Environment, 2023, 863 160997.

[106] Zhang L, Wang S R, Jiao L X . Physiological Response of a Submerged Plant (Myriophyllum Spicatum) to Different NH₄Cl Concentrations in Sediments. Ecological Engineering, 2013, 58 91-98.

[107] Zhang X M, Zhen W, Jensen H S . The Combined Effects of Macrophytes (Vallisneria Denseserrulata) and a Lanthanum-Modified Bentonite on Water Quality of Shallow Eutrophic Lakes: A Mesocosm Study. Environmental Pollution, 2021, 277 116720.

[108] Zhang Y, He F, Liu Z S . Release Characteristics of Sediment Phosphorus in all Fractions of West Lake, Hang Zhou, China. Ecological Engineering, 2016, 95 645-651.

[109] Zhang Y, He F, Xia S B . Studies on the Treatment Efficiency of Sediment Phosphorus with a Combined Technology of PCFM and Submerged Macrophytes. Environmental Pollution, 2015, 206 705-711.

[110] Zhou J, Li D P, Chen S T . Sedimentary Phosphorus Immobilization with the Addition of Amended Calcium Peroxide Material. Chemical Engineering Journal, 2019, 357 288-297.

[111] Zhou Y Y, Li J Q, Fu Y Q. Effects of Submerged Macrophytes on Kinetics of Alkaline Phosphatase in Lake Donghu—I. Unfiltered Water and Sediments. Water Research, 2000, 34(15): 3737-3742.

[112] Zhu M Y, Zhu G W, Nurminen L . The Influence of Macrophytes on Sediment Resuspension and the Effect of Associated Nutrients in a Shallow and Large Lake (Lake Taihu, China). PLoS One, 2015, 10(6): e0127915.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

China University of Geosciences (Wuhan) and Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, Part of Springer Nature