Health risk assessment of humans exposed to soil and dust trace elements from e-waste sites in Bangladesh

Abstract

Elevated levels of trace elements are thought to pose a serious health risk to workers in e-waste recycling facilities. We evaluated the distribution, contamination, and human health risks of trace elements in soil and dust from e-waste exposed and non-exposed sites in Bangladesh. Thirty-one soil (20 exposed; 11 non-exposed) and 31 dust samples (21 exposed; 10 non-exposed) were collected and analyzed for Pb, Cd, Hg, As, Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Zn, Be, Co, Se, and V using ICP-MS. The mean concentrations of Pb, Hg, Cu, and Zn concentrations were significantly higher in soil (587, 25.57, 2,912, 894 mg/kg) and dust (439, 59, 617, 1,201 mg/kg) than in non-exposed soil (15.94, 0.07, 23.71, 121 mg/kg; all P: ≤ 0.001) and dust (15, 3.56, 19, 213 mg/kg; all P: ≤ 0.001). Children were more vulnerable than adults to non-carcinogenic risks from ingestion, while non-carcinogenic risks from dermal and inhalation exposure were negligible. Pb, Hg, and Cu from soil, as well as Pb, Hg, and Cr from dust, showed a hazard index (HI) greater than 1, indicating a risk higher than the acceptable level for children and adults at the exposed sites, while the risk to a reference child and adults was negligible. Cr and Ni contributed to cancer risk only when their concentrations reached their maximum level, exceeding the permissible limit of 1 × 10^-4. This study demonstrates a significant accumulation of trace elements in e-waste recycling sites, where exposure through soil and dust poses environmental and human health risks, particularly for children. This underscores an urgent need for regulatory authorities to implement control measures and deploy awareness programs to limit trace element pollution and mitigate its impacts on the environment and human health.

Keywords

Hazardous waste / environmental risk / geo-accumulation index / exposure pathway / risk assessment / Bangladesh

References

[1] Heacock M,Suk WA.E-waste: the growing global problem and next steps.Rev Environ Health2016;31:131-5

[2] Forti V,Kuehr R. The global e-waste monitor 2020. Available from: https://ewastemonitor.info/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/GEM_2020_def_july1_low.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[3] Parvez SM,Brune MN.Health consequences of exposure to e-waste: an updated systematic review.Lancet Planet Health2021;5:e905-20 PMCID:PMC8674120

[4] Grant K,Sly PD.Health consequences of exposure to e-waste: a systematic review.Lancet Glob Health2013;1:e350-61

[5] Zhuang X.Chapter 14 - Chemical hazards associated with treatment of waste electrical and electronic equipment. In: Electronic waste management and treatment technology. Elsevier; 2019. pp. 311-34.

[6] Chen Y,Liu L.Polybrominated diphenyl ethers fate in China: a review with an emphasis on environmental contamination levels, human exposure and regulation.J Environ Manage2012;113:22-30

[7] Li J,Guo J,Zhou Y.Recycle technology for recovering resources and products from waste printed circuit boards.Environ Sci Technol2007;41:1995-2000

[8] Leung A,Wong MH.Environmental contamination from electronic waste recycling at Guiyu, southeast China.J Mater Cycles Waste Manag2006;8:21-33

[9] Zheng J,Yan X.Heavy metals in food, house dust, and water from an e-waste recycling area in South China and the potential risk to human health.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2013;96:205-12

[10] Pradhan JK.Informal e-waste recycling: environmental risk assessment of heavy metal contamination in Mandoli industrial area, Delhi, India.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2014;21:7913-28

[11] Song Q.Environmental effects of heavy metals derived from the e-waste recycling activities in China: a systematic review.Waste Manag2014;34:2587-94

[12] Dutta D,Kumar S.Health risk assessment for exposure to heavy metals in soils in and around E-waste dumping site.J Environ Chem Eng2022;10:107269

[13] Tran TS,Nguyen TAH.Soil contamination and health risk assessment from heavy metals exposure near mining area in Bac Kan province, Vietnam.Environ Geochem Health2022;44:1189-202

[14] Xu R,Lin Y,Guo Y.Assessment of dust trace elements in an e-waste recycling area and related children’s health risks.Sci Total Environ2021;791:148154

[15] Centre for Environmental and Resource Management. Assessment of generation of e-waste, its impacts on environment and resource recovery potential in Bangladesh. 2018. Available from: https://doe.portal.gov.bd/sites/default/files/files/doe.portal.gov.bd/page/1f58f60a_51d9_46c0_9fa1_79b7b565db05/2020-10-01-13-02-e522e1499ac288d119a6f7ae16c7f7d0.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[16] Mahmud I,Rahman A,Cheng Ling T.E-waste recycling intention paradigm of small and medium electronics store managers in Bangladesh: an S-O-R perspective.Waste Manag Res2020;38:1438-49

[17] Chan JK.A review of environmental fate, body burdens, and human health risk assessment of PCDD/Fs at two typical electronic waste recycling sites in China.Sci Total Environ2013;463-4:1111-23

[18] Parvez SM,Abedin J.Blood lead, cadmium and hair mercury concentrations and association with soil, dust and occupational factors in e-waste recycling workers in Bangladesh.Int J Hyg Environ Health2024;257:114340

[19] Parvez SM,Knibbs LD.Ecological burden of e-waste in Bangladesh - an assessment to measure the exposure to e-waste and associated health outcomes: protocol for a cross-sectional study.JMIR Res Protoc2022;11:e38201 PMCID:PMC9428780

[20] Moniruzzaman M,Saha B,Jawaa ZT.Seasonal changes and respiratory deposition flux of PM_2.5 and PM₁₀ bound metals in Dhaka, Bangladesh.Chemosphere2022;309:136794

[21] Müller G.Index of geoaccumulation in sediments of the Rhine River.J Geol1969;2:108-18Available from: https://www.scienceopen.com/document?vid=4b875795-5729-4c05-9813-64951e2ca488. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[22] Li Z,Li G.Distributions, sources and pollution status of 17 trace metal/metalloids in the street dust of a heavily industrialized city of central China.Environ Pollut2013;182:408-16

[23] USEPA. Update for Chapter 5 of thE Exposure Factors Handbook. Soil and dust ingestion. EPA/600/R-17/384F. 2017. Available from: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2018-01/documents/efh-chapter05_2017.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[24] Liu X,Tang Y.Human health risk assessment of heavy metals in soil-vegetable system: a multi-medium analysis.Sci Total Environ2013;463-4:530-40

[25] Wang X,Xing B.Health risks of heavy metals to the general public in Tianjin, China via consumption of vegetables and fish.Sci Total Environ2005;350:28-37

[26] USEPA. Exposure Factors Handbook (1997, final report). EPA/600/P-95/002F a-c. 1997. Available from: https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/risk/recordisplay.cfm?deid=12464. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[27] Trojanowska M.Investigations of the chemical distribution of heavy metals in street dust and its impact on risk assessment for human health, case study of Radom (Poland).Hum Ecol Risk Assess2020;26:1907-26

[28] Gupta V,Arya AK,Gautam S.Spatially resolved distribution, sources, exposure levels, and health risks of heavy metals in <63 μm size-fractionated road dust from Lucknow City, North India.Int J Environ Res Public Health2022;19:12898 PMCID:PMC9565937

[29] Zhang J,Zhang Y,Fang X.Elemental composition and risk assessment of heavy metals in the PM10 fractions of road dust and roadside soil.Particuology2019;44:146-52

[30] USEPA. Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund Volume I: human health evaluation manual (Part E, Supplemental Guidance for Dermal Risk Assessment). 2004. Available from: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-09/documents/part_e_final_revision_10-03-07.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[31] Rakib MRJ,Enyoh CE.Levels and health risk assessment of heavy metals in dried fish consumed in Bangladesh.Sci Rep2021;11:14642 PMCID:PMC8290005

[32] Akter A,Hossain MA,Mustafa T.Heavy metal concentrations and human health risk assessment of selected wild and cultured fishes of Bangladesh.Bangladesh J Zool2021;49:189-203

[33] Duan Z,Cai X,Xuan B.Spatial distribution and human health risk assessment of heavy metals in campus dust: a case study of the university town of Huaxi.Hum Ecol Risk Assess2020;26:986-99

[34] Musa AA,Kidak R.Street dust heavy metal pollution implication on human health in Nicosia, North Cyprus.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2019;26:28993-9002

[35] Ghanavati N,De Vivo B.Ecological and human health risk assessment of toxic metals in street dusts and surface soils in Ahvaz, Iran.Environ Geochem Health2019;41:875-91

[36] Hini G,Wang W,Li X.Spatial distribution, contamination levels, sources, and potential health risk assessment of trace elements in street dusts of Urumqi city, NW China.Hum Ecol Risk Assess2020;26:2112-28

[37] Wei X,Wang P,Lu J.Pollution characteristics and health risk assessment of heavy metals in street dusts from different functional areas in Beijing, China.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2015;112:186-92

[38] Qadeer A,Ajmal Z.Concentrations, pollution indices and health risk assessment of heavy metals in road dust from two urbanized cities of Pakistan: Comparing two sampling methods for heavy metals concentration.Sustain Cities Soc2020;53:101959

[39] USEPA. Supplemental Guidance for developing soil screening levels for superfund sites. 2002. Available from: https://semspub.epa.gov/work/HQ/175878.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[40] Roy S,Prakash J,Baudh K.Ecological and human health risk assessment of heavy metal contamination in road dust in the National Capital Territory (NCT) of Delhi, India.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2019;26:30413-25

[41] Idris AM,Said TO.Contamination level and risk assessment of heavy metal deposited in street dusts in Khamees-Mushait city, Saudi Arabia.Hum Ecol Risk Assess2020;26:495-511

[42] Li H,Hu W,Gao H.Chemical speciation and human health risk of trace metals in urban street dusts from a metropolitan city, Nanjing, SE China.Sci Total Environ2013;456-7:212-21

[43] Li F,Huang J.Heavy metals in road dust from Xiandao District, Changsha City, China: characteristics, health risk assessment, and integrated source identification.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2016;23:13100-13

[44] USEPA. Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS). Available from: https://www.epa.gov/iris. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[45] USEPA. Guidelines for carcinogen risk assessment. EPA/630/P-03/001F. 2005. Available from: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2013-09/documents/cancer_guidelines_final_3-25-05.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[46] Stewart BW. World Cancer Report 2014. Available from: https://publications.iarc.fr/Non-Series-Publications/World-Cancer-Reports/World-Cancer-Report-2014. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[47] Turekian KK.Distribution of the elements in some major units of the earth’s crust.Geol Soc America Bull1961;72:175

[48] Kinuthia GK,Beti D,Wangila A.Levels of heavy metals in wastewater and soil samples from open drainage channels in Nairobi, Kenya: community health implication.Sci Rep2020;10:8434 PMCID:PMC7242368

[49] Vodyanitskii Y.Standards for the contents of heavy metals in soils of some states.Ann Agrar Sci2016;14:257-63

[50] Crommentuijn T,de Bruijn J,van Leeuwen K.Maximum permissible and negligible concentrations for metals and metalloids in the Netherlands, taking into account background concentrations.J Environ Manage2000;60:121-43

[51] Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment. Canadian soil quality guidelines for the protection of environmental and human health: summary tables. 2007. Available from: https://support.esdat.net/Environmental%20Standards/canada/soil/rev_soil_summary_tbl_7.0_e.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[52] Liu M,Bi X,Sheng G.Heavy metals and organic compounds contamination in soil from an e-waste region in South China.Environ Sci Processes Impacts2013;15:919-29

[53] Akortia E,Daso AP.Soil concentrations of polybrominated diphenyl ethers and trace metals from an electronic waste dump site in the Greater Accra Region, Ghana: implications for human exposure.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2017;137:247-55

[54] Arya S,Chavan D.Evaluation of soil contamination due to crude E-waste recycling activities in the capital city of India.Process Saf Environ2021;152:641-53

[55] Parvez SM,Rahman M.Hormonal, liver, and renal function associated with electronic waste (e-waste) exposure in Dhaka, Bangladesh.Toxicology2024;505:153833

[56] Parvez SM,Rahman M.Hematological, cardiovascular and oxidative DNA damage markers associated with heavy metal exposure in electronic waste (e-waste) workers of Bangladesh.Toxicology2024;509:153978

[57] Mowla M,Islam N.Assessment of heavy metal contamination and health risk from indoor dust and air of informal E-waste recycling shops in Dhaka, Bangladesh.J Hazard Mater2021;4:100025

[58] Zhang XL,Liu HY,Chen SJ.Bioaccumulation of several brominated flame retardants and dechlorane plus in waterbirds from an e-waste recycling region in South China: associated with trophic level and diet sources.Environ Sci Technol2011;45:400-5

[59] Alcántara-Concepción V,Gavilán-García IC.Environmental impacts at the end of life of computers and their management alternatives in México.J Clean Prod2016;131:615-28

[60] Olafisoye OB,Osibote OA.Heavy metals contamination of water, soil, and plants around an electronic waste dumpsite.Pol J Environ Stud2013;22:1431-9Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Otolorin-Osibote-2/publication/281446780_Heavy_Metals_Contamination_of_Water_Soil_and_Plants_around_an_Electronic_Waste_Dumpsite/links/55e7fe0c08ae21d099c15e9c/Heavy-Metals-Contamination-of-Water-Soil-and-Plants-around-an-Electronic-Waste-Dumpsite.pdf. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]

[61] Ye S,Wu H.Biological technologies for the remediation of co-contaminated soil.Crit Rev Biotechnol2017;37:1062-76

[62] Ye S,Wu H.Co-occurrence and interactions of pollutants, and their impacts on soil remediation - a review.Crit Rev Env Sci Tec2017;47:1528-53

[63] Wu Y,Kang D.Tetrabromobisphenol A and heavy metal exposure via dust ingestion in an e-waste recycling region in Southeast China.Sci Total Environ2016;541:356-64

[64] Khoder M,El-abssawy A.An evaluation of loading rate of dust, Pb, Cd, and Ni and metals mass concentration in the settled surface dust in domestic houses and factors affecting them.Indoor Built Environ2010;19:391-9

[65] Huang CL,Luo P,Li SM.Potential health risk for residents around a typical e-waste recycling zone via inhalation of size-fractionated particle-bound heavy metals.J Hazard Mater2016;317:449-56

[66] Nowrouzi M.Application of geoaccumulation index and enrichment factor for assessing metal contamination in the sediments of Hara Biosphere Reserve, Iran.Chem Spec Bioavailab2014;26:99-105

[67] Luo C,Wang Y.Heavy metal contamination in soils and vegetables near an e-waste processing site, South China.J Hazard Mater2011;186:481-90

[68] Adenuga AA,Olajide OD,Idowu OO.Environmental impact and health risk assessment of potentially toxic metals emanating from different anthropogenic activities related to E-wastes.Heliyon2022;8:e10296 PMCID:PMC9449574

[69] Tao XQ,Shentu JL,Feng YJ.Bioaccessibility and health risk of heavy metals in ash from the incineration of different e-waste residues.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2015;22:3558-69

[70] Ackah M.Soil elemental concentrations, geoaccumulation index, non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic risks in functional areas of an informal e-waste recycling area in Accra, Ghana.Chemosphere2019;235:908-17

[71] Masri S,Logue MD.Risk assessment of soil heavy metal contamination at the census tract level in the city of Santa Ana, CA: implications for health and environmental justice.Environ Sci Process Impacts2021;23:812-30 PMCID:PMC8224146

[72] Chonokhuu S,Chuluunpurev B,Dorjsuren B.Contamination and health risk assessment of heavy metals in the soil of major cities in Mongolia.Int J Environ Res Public Health2019;16:2552 PMCID:PMC6678483

[73] Zdrojewicz Z,Winiarski J.Nickel - role in human organism and toxic effects.Pol Merkur Lekarski2016;41:115-8

[74] Son YO.Molecular mechanisms of nickel-induced carcinogenesis.Endocr Metab Immune Disord Drug Targets2020;20:1015-23

[75] Madadi R,Rastegari M.Health risk assessment and source apportionment of potentially toxic metal(loid)s in windowsill dust of a rapidly growing urban settlement, Iran.Sci Rep2022;12:19736 PMCID:PMC9672307

[76] Long Z,Bing H.Contamination, sources and health risk of heavy metals in soil and dust from different functional areas in an industrial city of Panzhihua City, Southwest China.J Hazard Mater2021;420:126638

[77] den Braver-Sewradj SP, van Benthem J, Staal YCM, Ezendam J, Piersma AH, Hessel EVS. Occupational exposure to hexavalent chromium. Part II. Hazard assessment of carcinogenic effects.Regul Toxicol Pharmacol2021;126:105045

[78] Gul HK,Babaei P,Kurt-Karakus PB.Assessment of house dust trace elements and human exposure in Ankara, Turkey.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2023;30:7718-35 PMCID:PMC9428879

[79] Oomen AG,Minekus M.Comparison of five in vitro digestion models to study the bioaccessibility of soil contaminants.Environ Sci Technol2002;36:3326-34

[80] Frederiksen M,Thomsen M.Human internal and external exposure to PBDEs - a review of levels and sources.Int J Hyg Environ Health2009;212:109-34

[81] Rahman M. E-waste management challenges in the country. 2021. Available from: https://today.thefinancialexpress.com.bd/views-opinion/e-waste-management-challenges-in-the-country-1618664674. [Last accessed on 11 Dec 2024]