The NOAEL equivalent for the cumulative body burden of cadmium: focus on proteinuria as an endpoint

Abstract

The risk of developing chronic kidney disease (CKD), signified by a decrease in the estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR), has been linked to long-term exposure to low levels of the metal pollutant cadmium (Cd). Proteinuria is a hallmark of CKD and predicts continued progressive functional decline of the kidney. The aim of this study was to use the extent of proteinuria for Cd health risk assessment. Data were from 405 apparently healthy Thai nationals, of whom 12.6% had an eGFR below 60 mL/min/1.73 m² (low eGFR), and 16.3% and 13.5% had moderate and severe proteinuria. Urinary excretion of Cd (E_Cd) and urinary total protein (E_pro) were measured and normalized to both creatinine clearance (C_cr) and creatinine excretion (E_cr). We found that the risk of having a low eGFR [prevalence odds ratio (POR) = 12.2, P < 0.001] and severe proteinuria [POR = 10.4, P = 0.001) were increased markedly for every ten-fold increase in E_Cd/C_cr. However, when E_Cd was normalized to E_cr, the association between eGFR and E_Cd was found to be insignificant due to non-differential errors introduced by the E_cr-normalization. Respective benchmark dose limit (BMDL) values of E_Cd/E_cr that increased protein excretion by 5% and 10% were 0.0536 and 0.1140 µg/g creatinine. The E_Cd/E_cr at which 5% of the population had Cd-related proteinuria was 1.86 µg/g creatinine, respectively. For the first time, a urinary Cd excretion rate of 0.0536 µg/g creatinine has been derived as a Cd exposure level that produces negligible kidney damage.

Keywords

Assessment imprecision / benchmark dose limit / cadmium / GFR / NOAEL equivalent / proteinuria

References

[1] Satarug S.Dietary cadmium intake and its effects on kidneys.Toxics2018;6:15 PMCID:PMC5874788

[2] Satarug S,Gobe GC.Estimation of health risks associated with dietary cadmium exposure.Arch Toxicol2023;97:329-58

[3] Wong C,Saab IN.Review of regulatory reference values and background levels for heavy metals in the human diet.Regul Toxicol Pharmacol2022;130:105122

[4] Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations/World Health Organization. Summary and Conclusions. In: Proceedings of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives and Contaminants, Seventy-Third Meeting; Geneva, Switzerland; 2011. Available from: https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/44521. [Last accessed on 17 Dec 2024]

[5] European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Scientific opinion: Cadmium in food. 2009. Available from: https://efsa.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.2903/j.efsa.2009.980. [Last accessed on 17 Dec 2024]

[6] European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Scientific opinion: Statement on tolerable weekly intake for cadmium. 2011. Available from: https://efsa.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.2903/j.efsa.2011.1975. [Last accessed on 17 Dec 2024]

[7] Satarug S,Yimthiang S,Gobe GC.The NOAEL equivalent of environmental cadmium exposure associated with GFR reduction and chronic kidney disease.Toxics2022;10:614 PMCID:PMC9607051

[8] Satarug S.Is chronic kidney disease due to cadmium exposure inevitable and can it be reversed?.Biomedicines2024;12:718 PMCID:PMC11048639

[9] Shi Z,Riley M,Liu J.Association between dietary patterns, cadmium intake and chronic kidney disease among adults.Clin Nutr2018;37:276-84

[10] Kudo K,Mashima Y.The association between renal tubular damage and rapid renal deterioration in the Japanese population: the Takahata study.Clin Exp Nephrol2011;15:235-41

[11] Satarug S,Nishijo M,Gobe GC.The inverse association of glomerular function and urinary β2-MG excretion and its implications for cadmium health risk assessment.Environ Res2019;173:40-7

[12] Wei Y,Sun Q.Associations of environmental cadmium exposure with kidney damage: exploring mediating DNA methylation sites in Chinese adults.Environ Res2024;251:118667

[13] Sakuma S,Watanabe Y.Effect of renal tubular damage on non-cancer mortality in the general Japanese population living in cadmium non-polluted areas.J Appl Toxicol2023;43:1849-58

[14] Smereczański NM.Current levels of environmental exposure to cadmium in industrialized countries as a risk factor for kidney damage in the general population: a comprehensive review of available data.Int J Mol Sci2023;24:8413 PMCID:PMC10179615

[15] Tsai HJ,Wang CW.Associations among heavy metals and proteinuria and chronic kidney disease.Diagnostics2021;11:282 PMCID:PMC7918558

[16] Jalili C,Cheng H.Associations between exposure to heavy metals and the risk of chronic kidney disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis.Crit Rev Toxicol2021;51:165-82

[17] Makhammajanov Z,Myngbay A,Aljofan M.Tubular toxicity of proteinuria and the progression of chronic kidney disease.Nephrol Dial Transplant2024;39:589-99

[18] Liu D.New understanding on the role of proteinuria in progression of chronic kidney disease.Adv Exp Med Biol2019:487-500

[19] Sharma S.From proteinuria to fibrosis: an update on pathophysiology and treatment options.Kidney Blood Press Res2021;46:411-20

[20] Slob W.A general theory of effect size, and its consequences for defining the benchmark response (BMR) for continuous endpoints.Crit Rev Toxicol2017;47:342-51

[21] Moffett DB,Sullivan DW.Chapter 13 - General considerations of dose-effect and dose-response relationships. In: Handbook on the Toxicology of Metals (Fifth Edition). Elsevier; 2022. pp. 299-317.

[22] Grandjean P.Total imprecision of exposure biomarkers: implications for calculating exposure limits.Am J Ind Med2007;50:712-9 PMCID:PMC2855962

[23] Satarug S,Ruangyuttikarn W,Ruiz P.Modeling cadmium exposures in low- and high-exposure areas in Thailand.Environ Health Perspect2013;121:531-6 PMCID:PMC3673184

[24] Satarug S,Ujjin P,Moore MR.Cadmium-induced nephropathy in the development of high blood pressure.Toxicol Lett2005;157:57-68

[25] Teeyakasem W,Honda R,Swaddiwudhipong W.Monitoring of cadmium toxicity in a Thai population with high-level environmental exposure.Toxicol Lett2007;169:185-95

[26] Honda R,Nishijo M.Cadmium induced renal dysfunction among residents of rice farming area downstream from a zinc-mineralized belt in Thailand.Toxicol Lett2010;198:26-32

[27] Bloch MJ.Review of recent literature in hypertension: updated clinical practice guidelines for chronic kidney disease now include albuminuria in the classification system.J Clin Hypertens2013;15:865-7 PMCID:PMC8033952

[28] Satarug S,Gobe GC.Chronic exposure to cadmium is associated with a marked reduction in glomerular filtration rate.Clin Kidney J2019;12:468-75 PMCID:PMC6671389

[29] Levey AS, Stevens LA, Schmid CH, et al; CKD-EPI (Chronic Kidney Disease Epidemiology Collaboration). A new equation to estimate glomerular filtration rate. Ann Intern Med 2009;150:604-12. PMCID:PMC2763564

[30] White CA,Akbari A.Comparison of the new and traditional CKD-EPI GFR estimation equations with urinary inulin clearance: a study of equation performance.Clin Chim Acta2019;488:189-95

[31] Levey AS,Inker LA.Glomerular filtration rate and albuminuria for detection and staging of acute and chronic kidney disease in adults: a systematic review.JAMA2015;313:837-46 PMCID:PMC4410363

[32] Phelps KR.A generic method for analysis of plasma concentrations.Clin Nephrol2020;94:43-9

[33] EFSA Scientific Committee; Hardy A, Benford D, Halldorsson T, et al. Update: use of the benchmark dose approach in risk assessment. EFSA J 2017;15:e04658. PMCID:PMC7009819

[34] Slob W.Shape and steepness of toxicological dose-response relationships of continuous endpoints.Crit Rev Toxicol2014;44:270-97

[35] Sand S,Victorin K.Evaluation of the benchmark dose method for dichotomous data: model dependence and model selection.Regul Toxicol Pharmacol2002;36:184-97

[36] Zhu Y,Jelsovsky JZ.Bootstrap estimation of benchmark doses and confidence limits with clustered quantal data.Risk Anal2007;27:447-65

[37] Suwatvitayakorn P,Kim KW.Human health risk assessment of cadmium exposure through rice consumption in cadmium-contaminated areas of the Mae Tao sub-district, Tak, Thailand.Environ Geochem Health2020;42:2331-44

[38] Swaddiwudhipong W,Mahasakpan P,Punta B.Progress in cadmium-related health effects in persons with high environmental exposure in northwestern Thailand: a five-year follow-up.Environ Res2012;112:194-8

[39] Swaddiwudhipong W,Kaewnate Y.Human health effects from cadmium exposure: comparison between persons living in cadmium-contaminated and non-contaminated areas in northwestern Thailand.Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health2015;46:133-42

[40] Byber K,Verougstraete V,Hotz P.Cadmium or cadmium compounds and chronic kidney disease in workers and the general population: a systematic review.Crit Rev Toxicol2016;46:191-240

[41] Doccioli C,Francavilla A,Biggeri A.Association of cadmium environmental exposure with chronic kidney disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis.Sci Total Environ2024;906:167165

[42] Qing Y,Zhu Y.Dose-response evaluation of urinary cadmium and kidney injury biomarkers in Chinese residents and dietary limit standards.Environ Health2021;20:75 PMCID:PMC8247151

[43] Liu C,Zhu C.Benchmark dose for cadmium exposure and elevated N-acetyl-β-D-glucosaminidase: a meta-analysis.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2016;23:20528-38

[44] Leconte S,Bodin L,Carne G.Refinement of health-based guidance values for cadmium in the French population based on modelling.Toxicol Lett2021;340:43-51

[45] Schaefer HR,Crosby LM.Reassessment of the cadmium toxicological reference value for use in human health assessments of foods.Regul Toxicol Pharmacol2023;144:105487

[46] Shi P,Fan X.A benchmark dose analysis for urinary cadmium and type 2 diabetes mellitus.Environ Pollut2021;273:116519

[47] Satarug S,Gobe GC,Buha Đorđević A.Health risk in a geographic area of Thailand with endemic cadmium contamination: focus on albuminuria.Toxics2023;11:68 PMCID:PMC9866753