Health risk assessment of BTEX exposure at roadside and on-road traveling route in Bangkok Metropolitan Region

Abstract

Exposure to high levels of benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylenes (BTEX) poses health risks in high-traffic urban areas. BTEX exposure at two microenvironments, the roadside and along the traveling routes, within urban and suburban areas of the Bangkok Metropolitan Region was examined to assess cancer and noncancer risks. The lifetime cancer risk (LCR) for benzene and noncancer hazard index (HI) for all BTEX compounds were evaluated for adult male and female groups (drivers, passengers, and street vendors) in two scenarios: average case and worst case. With the assumption of negligible exposure outside the two considered microenvironments, the pickup drivers had the highest LCR and HI. Higher exposure risks were found in urban areas than in the suburbs and among men than females. Higher toluene levels were found at all monitoring sites in two microenvironments, but benzene was the most important in causing noncancer risk. The HI for all target groups ranged from 8.5E-03 to 4.0E-01, indicating a low noncancer risk from BTEX exposure (HI < 1). The LCR caused by benzene exposure ranged from 1.7E-06 to 7.2E-05, which is higher than the United States EPA most health-protective limit (1E-06). Further research should include other microenvironments by assessing the 24-hour exposure of all considered groups.

Keywords

Exposure / BTEX / cancer risk / hazard quotient / traffic / Bangkok

References

[1] World Health Organization. Compendium of WHO and other UN guidance on health and environment, 2022 update. Available from: https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/352844 [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[2] Alford KL.Pulmonary health effects of indoor volatile organic compounds-a meta-analysis.Int J Environ Res Public Health2021;18:1578 PMCID:PMC7914726

[3] Maung TZ,Holt E,Pfrang C.Indoor air pollution and the health of vulnerable groups: a systematic review focused on particulate matter (pm), volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and their effects on children and people with pre-existing lung disease.Int J Environ Res Public Health2022;19:8752 PMCID:PMC9316830

[4] Montero-Montoya R,Arellano-Aguilar O.Volatile organic compounds in air: sources, distribution, exposure and associated illnesses in children.Ann Glob Health2018;84:225-38 PMCID:PMC6748254

[5] International Agency for Research on Cancer. Benzene Volume 120. Available from: https://publications.iarc.fr/576 [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[6] U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Toxicological Review of Toluene. Available from: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2014-03/documents/toluene_toxicology_review_0118tr_3v.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[7] United States Environmental Protection Agency. Chemical assessment summary- ethylbenzene; CASRN 100-41-4. Available from: https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/iris/iris_documents/documents/subst/0051_summary.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[8] United States Environmental Protection Agency. Chemical assessment summary-xylenes; CASRN 1330-20-7. Available from: https://iris.epa.gov/static/pdfs/0270_summary.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[9] World Health Organization. Air quality guidelines for Europe (Second edition). Available from: https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/107335 [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[10] Loren Raun. Benzene Risk: Determining carcinogenic health risk concentration levels for benzene in ambient air at EPA, TCEQ and the City of Houston. Available from: http://www.greenhoustontx.gov/reports/benzenerisk.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[11] Moolla R,Knight J.Occupational exposure of diesel station workers to BTEX compounds at a bus depot.Int J Environ Res Public Health2015;12:4101-15 PMCID:PMC4410235

[12] Rostami R,Babaei-Pouya A.Exposure to BTEX concentration and the related health risk assessment in printing and copying centers.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2021;28:31195-206

[13] Heibati B,Karimi A.BTEX exposure assessment and quantitative risk assessment among petroleum product distributors.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2017;144:445-9

[14] Dehghani M,Sorooshian A.Characteristics and health effects of BTEX in a hot spot for urban pollution.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2018;155:133-43

[15] Kermani M,Gholami M.Occurrence, spatial distribution, seasonal variations, potential sources, and inhalation-based health risk assessment of organic/inorganic pollutants in ambient air of Tehran.Environ Geochem Health2021;43:1983-2006

[16] Latif MT,Ahamad F.BTEX compositions and its potential health impacts in Malaysia.Chemosphere2019;237:124451

[17] Dörter M,Döğeroğlu T.An assessment of spatial distribution and atmospheric concentrations of ozone, nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylenes: ozone formation potential and health risk estimation in Bolu city of Turkey.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2022;29:53569-83

[18] Alahabadi A,Rakhshani MH,Alidadi H.Spatial distribution and health risk of exposure to BTEX in urban area: a comparison study of different land-use types and traffic volumes.Environ Geochem Health2021;43:2871-85

[19] Phuc NH.Determining factors for levels of volatile organic compounds measured in different microenvironments of a heavy traffic urban area.Sci Total Environ2018;627:290-303

[20] Mohammadi A,Löwner MO.Spatial analysis and risk assessment of urban BTEX compounds in Urmia, Iran.Chemosphere2020;246:125769

[21] Chaiklieng S.Risk assessment of workers’ exposure to BTEX and hazardous area classification at gasoline stations.PLoS One2021;16:e0249913 PMCID:PMC8049477

[22] Yimrungruang D,Boonphakdeeb T,Helander HF.Characterization and health risk assessment of volatile organic compounds in gas service station workers.Environmentasia2008;2:21-9

[23] Tunsaringkarn T,Rungsiyothin A.Occupational exposure of gasoline station workers to BTEX compounds in Bangkok, Thailand.Int J Occup Environ Med2012;3:117-25

[24] Pollution Control Department. Summary of the situation of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in 2019 (in Thai). Available from: https://www.pcd.go.th/maptapoot/page/9 [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[25] Songpun N,Preuktharatikul V.Comparison of benzene exposure among occupations at gasoline service stations in Khon Kaen province (in Thai).PHJBUU2020;15:26-35.

[26] Kim Oanh N,Hang N.Characterization of gaseous pollutants and PM2.5 at fixed roadsides and along vehicle traveling routes in Bangkok Metropolitan Region.Atmospheric Environment2013;77:674-85

[27] Wikimedia Commons contributors. File:Thailand Bangkok and vicinity.svg. Available from: https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Thailand_Bangkok_and_vicinity.svg&oldid=679850278

[28] Department of Provincial Administration. Official statistics registration systems (in Thai). Available from: https://stat.bora.dopa.go.th/stat/statnew/statMONTH/statmonth/#/view [Last accessed on 23 Dec 2022]

[29] Pollution Control Department. The state of air and noise pollution in Thailand 2021 (in Thai). Available from: https://www.pcd.go.th/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/pcdnew-2022-11-01_07-34-54_842781.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Dec 2022]

[30] Narita D,Sato K,Permadi DA,Ratanajaratroj T.Pollution characteristics and policy actions on fine particulate matter in a growing asian economy: the case of Bangkok Metropolitan Region.Atmosphere2019;10:227

[31] Chirasophon S.The Long-term Characteristics of PM10 and PM2.5 in Bangkok, Thailand.Asian J Atmos Environ2020;14:73-83

[32] The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Hydrocarbons aromatic 1501. Available from: https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2003-154/pdfs/1501.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[33] Oanh N, Martel M, Pongkiatkul P, Berkowicz R. Determination of fleet hourly emission and on-road vehicle emission factor using integrated monitoring and modeling approach.Atmos Res2008;89:223-32

[34] Badjagbo K,Moore S,Sauvé S.BTEX Exposures among Automobile Mechanics and Painters and Their Associated Health Risks.Hum Ecol Risk Assess16:301-16

[35] U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Risk assessment guidance for superfund volume i human health evaluation manual (part A). Available from: https://epa-prgs.ornl.gov/radionuclides/HHEMA.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[36] Road Safety Research Center. Working hours analysis on Labor’s work in the New Year’s tragedy (in Thai). Available from: https://www.roadsafetythai.org/content/doc_20181211170426.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[37] Kannikar Saengsurisri. Consumers' Attitudes and Behavior toward the Transit Van Service of Bangkok Mass Transit of Authority (BMTA). A Case Study of Victory Monument Area: Srinakharinwirot University; 2003 (in Thai). Available from: http://thesis.swu.ac.th/swuthesis/Mark/Kannikar_S.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[38] National Science and Technology Development Agency. Size Thailand (in Thai). Available from: http://waa.inter.nstda.or.th/stks/pub/2012/20120417-SizeThailand.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[39] National Statistical Office. Report on population characteristics, the 2015-2016 survey of population change (in Thai). Available from: http://www.nso.go.th/sites/2014/DocLib13/Forms/AllItems.aspx [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[40] Thailand Development Research Institute. TDRI report (in Thai). Available from: https://tdri.or.th/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/wb152.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[41] U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Chemical assessment summary-benzene; CASRN 71-43-2. Available from: https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/iris/iris_documents/documents/subst/0276_summary.pdf [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[42] Durmusoglu E,Karademir A.Health risk assessment of BTEX emissions in the landfill environment.J Hazard Mater2010;176:870-7

[43] U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. IRIS Assessments. Available from: https://iris.epa.gov/AtoZ/?list_type=alpha [Last accessed on 23 Feb 2023]

[44] Masekameni MD,Gulumian M.Risk Assessment of Benzene, Toluene, Ethyl Benzene, and Xylene Concentrations from the Combustion of Coal in a Controlled Laboratory Environment.Int J Environ Res Public Health2018;16:95 PMCID:PMC6339150

[45] Mehta D,Srivastava A.Diurnal variation of BTEX at road traffic intersection points in Delhi, India: source, ozone formation potential, and health risk assessment.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2020;27:11093-104

[46] Ulutaş K,Demir S,Pekey H.Assessment of H₂S and BTEX concentrations in ambient air using passive sampling method and the health risks.Environ Monit Assess2021;193:399

[47] Miri M,Ghaffari HR.Investigation of outdoor BTEX: concentration, variations, sources, spatial distribution, and risk assessment.Chemosphere2016;163:601-9

[48] Liu R,Chen D.Human exposure to BTEX emitted from a typical e-waste recycling industrial park: External and internal exposure levels, sources, and probabilistic risk implications.J Hazard Mater2022;437:129343

[49] Fandi NFM,Latif MT,Awang MF.BTEX exposure assessment and inhalation health risks to traffic policemen in the Klang Valley Region, Malaysia.Aerosol Air Qual Res2020;20:1922-37

[50] Amodio M,Marzocca A,Tutino M.Assessment of impacts produced by anthropogenic sources in a little city near an important industrial area (Modugno, Southern Italy).Sci World J2013;2013:150397 PMCID:PMC3582101

[51] Dutta C,Chatterjee A,Jana TK.Mixing ratios of carbonyls and BTEX in ambient air of Kolkata, India and their associated health risk.Environ Monit Assess2009;148:97-107

[52] Qin N,Zhong Y.External exposure to BTEX, internal biomarker response, and health risk assessment of nonoccupational populations near a coking plant in southwest China.Int J Environ Res Public Health2022;19:847 PMCID:PMC8775548

[53] Gong Y,Cheng J,Chen L.Health risk assessment and personal exposure to Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) in metro carriages - a case study in Shanghai, China.Sci Total Environ2017;574:1432-8

[54] Wickliffe JK,Howard JL.Increased long-term health risks attributable to select volatile organic compounds in residential indoor air in southeast Louisiana.Sci Rep2020;10:21649 PMCID:PMC7730171

[55] Mokammel A,Niazi S,Fazlzadeh M.BTEX levels in rural households: Heating system, building characteristic impacts and lifetime excess cancer risk assessment.Environ Pollut2022;298:118845