Questioning the appropriateness of sieving for processing indoor settled dust samples

Abstract

Dust is a widely-used matrix for estimating human exposure to chemicals or as a screening tool for the identification of indoor chemicals of concern. As dust sampling became more common in exposure assessment, techniques used in processing soil have been adapted to dust samples, and separation of dust particles by sieving is common practice. However, there are no defined pore sizes, which results in inconsistent or difficult data interpretation and exposure estimates. Moreover, dust consists of more particle types than soil, particularly fibers, which behave differently during the sieving process. In this study, composite samples from seven microenvironments (homes, apartments, kindergartens, schools, public spaces, offices, and cars) were used to investigate the impact of the separation of dust by sieving on the observed chemical distributions. Dust was sieved to four particle size fractions (1-2 mm, 0.5-1 mm, 0.25-0.5 mm, and < 0.25 mm) and each fraction was analyzed for organic carbon content and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and images of dust samples were taken by optical microscope. We identified irregular distributions across size fractions for carbon and PAHs as well as for fibrous particles. Based on the combination of chemical analyses and microscopy, we recommend careful consideration of pre-processing of dust samples to limit bias in dust exposure assessments, and sieving should be used only when necessary.

Keywords

Indoor dust / size fractions / dust exposure / polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons / dust composition

References

[1] Melymuk L,Riddell N,Vojta Š.Challenges in the analysis of novel flame retardants in indoor dust: results of the INTERFLAB 2 interlaboratory evaluation.Environ Sci Technol2018;52:9295-303

[2] Rostkowski P,Aalizadeh R.The strength in numbers: comprehensive characterization of house dust using complementary mass spectrometric techniques.Anal Bioanal Chem2019;411:1957-77 PMCID:PMC6458998

[3] Jílková S,Vojta Š,Bohlin-Nizzetto P.Small-scale spatial variability of flame retardants in indoor dust and implications for dust sampling.Chemosphere2018;206:132-41

[4] Al-Omran LS.Influence of sampling approach on concentrations of legacy and “novel” brominated flame retardants in indoor dust.Chemosphere2017;178:51-8

[5] Harrad S,Covaci A.Causes of variability in concentrations and diastereomer patterns of hexabromocyclododecanes in indoor dust.Environ Int2009;35:573-9

[6] Allgood JM,McClaskey CM.Potential human exposure to halogenated flame-retardants in elevated surface dust and floor dust in an academic environment.Environ Res2017;153:55-62

[7] Björklund JA,de Wit CA,Lignell S.Comparisons of polybrominated diphenyl ether and hexabromocyclododecane concentrations in dust collected with two sampling methods and matched breast milk samples.Indoor Air2012;22:279-88

[8] Wilson R,Petrovic S.Revisiting dust and soil ingestion rates based on hand-to-mouth transfer.Hum Ecol Risk Asse2012;19:158-88

[9] Cao ZG,Chen YS.Particle size: a missing factor in risk assessment of human exposure to toxic chemicals in settled indoor dust.Environ Int2012;49:24-30

[10] Calabrese EJ,Barnes R.Methodology to estimate the amount and particle size of soil ingested by children: implications for exposure assessment at waste sites.Regul Toxicol Pharmacol1996;24:264-8

[11] Hee SS,Clark C,Bornschein RL.Evolution of efficient methods to sample lead sources, such as house dust and hand dust, in the homes of children.Environmental Research1985;38:77-95

[12] Driver JH,Whitmyre GK.Soil adherence to human skin.Bull Environ Contam Toxicol1989;43:814-20

[13] Edwards RD.The EL sampler: a press sampler for the quantitative estimation of dermal exposure to pesticides in housedust.J Expo Anal Environ Epidemiol1999;9:521-9

[14] Cao Z,Chen Y.Mechanisms influencing the BFR distribution patterns in office dust and implications for estimating human exposure.J Hazard Mater2013;252-253:11-8

[15] Latif MT,Saad A.Composition of heavy metals in indoor dust and their possible exposure: a case study of preschool children in Malaysia.Air Qual Atmos Health2014;7:181-93

[16] Rasmussen PE,Chénier M.Canadian house dust study: lead bioaccessibility and speciation.Environ Sci Technol2011;45:4959-65

[17] Rasmussen PE,Chénier M,Jones-Otazo H.Canadian house dust study: population-based concentrations, loads and loading rates of arsenic, cadmium, chromium, copper, nickel, lead, and zinc inside urban homes.Sci Total Environ2013;443:520-9

[18] He CT,Yan X.Organic contaminants and heavy metals in indoor dust from e-waste recycling, rural, and urban areas in South China: Spatial characteristics and implications for human exposure.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2017;140:109-15

[19] Xu F,Wang J.Characterization of heavy metals and brominated flame retardants in the indoor and outdoor dust of e-waste workshops: implication for on-site human exposure.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2015;22:5469-80

[20] Yang Q,Li B.Source identification and health risk assessment of metals in indoor dust in the vicinity of phosphorus mining, Guizhou Province, China.Arch Environ Contam Toxicol2015;68:20-30

[21] Hoffman K,Birnbaum LS.Monitoring indoor exposure to organophosphate flame retardants: hand wipes and house dust.Environ Health Perspect2015;123:160-5 PMCID:PMC4314253

[22] Bennett DH,Wu XM.Polybrominated diphenyl ether (PBDE) concentrations and resulting exposure in homes in California: relationships among passive air, surface wipe and dust concentrations, and temporal variability.Indoor Air2015;25:220-9 PMCID:PMC5137191

[23] Hassan Y.Levels of polybrominated diphenyl ethers and novel flame retardants in microenvironment dust from Egypt: an assessment of human exposure.Sci Total Environ2015;505:47-55

[24] Chow K,Zuber M,Mueller JF.Evaluation of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) in matched cat sera and house dust samples: investigation of a potential link between PBDEs and spontaneous feline hyperthyroidism.Environ Res2015;136:173-9

[25] Venier M,Vojta Š.Brominated flame retardants in the indoor environment - Comparative study of indoor contamination from three countries.Environ Int2016;94:150-60

[26] Stubbings WA,Romanak K.Flame retardants and plasticizers in a Canadian waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE) dismantling facility.Sci Total Environ2019;675:594-603

[27] Fromme H,Kraft M.Organophosphate flame retardants and plasticizers in the air and dust in German daycare centers and human biomonitoring in visiting children (LUPE 3).Environ Int2014;71:158-63

[28] Ait Bamai Y,Saito I.Exposure to house dust phthalates in relation to asthma and allergies in both children and adults.Sci Total Environ2014;485-486:153-63

[29] Rauert C,Suzuki G,Uchida N.Test chamber and forensic microscopy investigation of the transfer of brominated flame retardants into indoor dust via abrasion of source materials.Sci Total Environ2014;493:639-48

[30] Rauert C.Mass transfer of PBDEs from plastic TV casing to indoor dust via three migration pathways-A test chamber investigation.Sci Total Environ2015;536:568-74

[31] Webster TF,Millette JR.Identifying transfer mechanisms and sources of decabromodiphenyl ether (BDE 209) in indoor environments using environmental forensic microscopy.Environ Sci Technol2009;43:3067-72 PMCID:PMC2722073

[32] Zhou L.Distributions of organophosphate flame retardants (OPFRs) in three dust size fractions from homes and building material markets.Environ Pollut2019;245:343-52

[33] Guo H,Ru S,Mai B.Size-dependent concentrations and bioaccessibility of organophosphate esters (OPEs) in indoor dust: A comparative study from a megacity and an e-waste recycling site.Sci Total Environ2019;650:1954-60

[34] Cao Z,Li W.Seasonal and particle size-dependent variations of hexabromocyclododecanes in settled dust: implications for sampling.Environ Sci Technol2015;49:11151-7

[35] Al-Omran LS.Distribution pattern of legacy and “novel” brominated flame retardants in different particle size fractions of indoor dust in Birmingham, United Kingdom.Chemosphere2016;157:124-31

[36] Cao Z,Covaci A.Distribution patterns of brominated, chlorinated, and phosphorus flame retardants with particle size in indoor and outdoor dust and implications for human exposure.Environ Sci Technol2014;48:8839-46

[37] Caban M.Determination of bisphenol A in size fractions of indoor dust from several microenvironments.Microchem J2020;153:104392

[38] Liu R,Cui X.Impact of particle size on distribution, bioaccessibility, and cytotoxicity of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in indoor dust.J Hazard Mater2018;357:341-7

[39] Cao Z,Chen Q.Spatial, seasonal and particle size dependent variations of PAH contamination in indoor dust and the corresponding human health risk.Sci Total Environ2019;653:423-30

[40] Lanzerstorfer C.Variations in the composition of house dust by particle size.J Environ Sci Health A Tox Hazard Subst Environ Eng2017;52:770-7

[41] Rasmussen PE,Nugent M,Lanouette M.Influence of matrix composition on the bioaccessibility of Copper, Zinc, and Nickel in urban residential dust and soil.Hum Ecol Risk Assess2008;14:351-71

[42] Richman KE,Young CJ.Size-resolved particle measurements of polybrominated diphenyl ethers indoors: implications for sources and human exposure.Environ Toxicol Chem2018;37:481-90

[43] Wei H,Cali S,Erdal S.Particle size fractionation and human exposure of polybrominated diphenyl ethers in indoor dust from Chicago.J Environ Sci Health A Tox Hazard Subst Environ Eng2009;44:1353-61

[44] Wang W,Huang MJ,Cheung KC.Size fraction effect on phthalate esters accumulation, bioaccessibility and in vitro cytotoxicity of indoor/outdoor dust, and risk assessment of human exposure.J Hazard Mater2013;261:753-62

[45] Lewis RG,Willis RD,Antley JT.Distribution of pesticides and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in house dust as a function of particle size.Environ Health Perspect1999;107:721-6 PMCID:PMC1566465

[46] Wang W,Zheng JS,Wong MH.Exposure assessment and distribution of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) contained in indoor and outdoor dusts and the impacts of particle size and bioaccessibility.Sci Total Environ2013;463-464:1201-9

[47] Zhang Q,Du F,Wang G.Microplastic fallout in different indoor environments.Environ Sci Technol2020;54:6530-9

[48] Wang M,Lee SH,Fang M.Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in indoor environments are still imposing carcinogenic risk.J Hazard Mater2021;409:124531

[49] Kang Y,Li N.Cancer risk assessment of human exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) via indoor and outdoor dust based on probit model.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2015;22:3451-6

[50] Oliveira M,Delerue-Matos C,Morais S.Assessment of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in indoor and outdoor air of preschool environments (3-5 years old children).Environ Pollut2016;208:382-94

[51] Demirtepe H,Codling G.Targeted and suspect screening of plasticizers in house dust to assess cumulative human exposure risk.Sci Total Environ2021;781:146667

[52] Ma Y.Spatiotemporal analysis and human exposure assessment on polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in indoor air, settled house dust, and diet: A review.Environ Int2015;84:7-16

[53] Salthammer T.Application of the Junge- and Pankow-equation for estimating indoor gas/particle distribution and exposure to SVOCs.Atmospheric Environment2015;106:467-76

[54] Chrysikou LP,Samara CA.Wintertime size distribution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) in the urban environment: Street- vs rooftop-level measurements.Atmospheric Environ2009;43:290-300

[55] Degrendele C,Melymuk L.Size specific distribution of the atmospheric particulate PCDD/Fs, dl-PCBs and PAHs on a seasonal scale: Implications for cancer risks from inhalation.Atmospheric Environ2014;98:410-6

[56] Lammel G,Ilić P.Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in air on small spatial and temporal scales - I. Levels and variabilities.Atmospheric Environ2010;44:5015-21

[57] Hunt A.Suspension and resuspension of dry soil indoors following track-in on footwear.Environ Geochem Health2012;34:355-63

[58] Morawska L.Sampling of surface dust in buildings. Indoor environment: airborne particles and settled dust.Indoor environment: airborne particles and settled dust2003:82-104

[59] Rasmussen P,Jessiman B.A multi-element profile of house dust in relation to exterior dust and soils in the city of Ottawa, Canada.Sci Total Environ2001;267:125-40

[60] Jones RJA,Rusco E,Montanarella L.Estimating organic carbon in the soils of Europe for policy support. Eur J Soil Sci 2005;56:655-71.

[61] Demirtepe H,Diamond ML.Linking past uses of legacy SVOCs with today’s indoor levels and human exposure.Environ Int2019;127:653-63

[62] Marcinekova P,Melymuk L,Klánová J.Air pollution in schools and kindergartens is dominated by indoor sources. prep.

[63] Deziel NC,Colt JS.Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in residential dust and risk of childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia.Environ Res2014;133:388-95 PMCID:PMC4119528

[64] Al-Harbi M,Whalen JK.Health risks associated with the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in indoor dust collected from houses in Kuwait.Environ Pollut2020;266:115054

[65] Gevao B,Zafar J,Helaleh M.Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in indoor air and dust in Kuwait: implications for sources and nondietary human exposure.Arch Environ Contam Toxicol2007;53:503-12

[66] Lim H,de Oliveira Galvão MF,Dreij K.Polycyclic aromatic compounds in particulate matter and indoor dust at preschools in Stockholm, Sweden: Occurrence, sources and genotoxic potential in vitro.Sci Total Environ2021;755:142709

[67] Aquilina NJ,Benowitz NL.Tobacco-specific and combustion pollutants in settled house dust in Malta.J Environ Expo Assess2022;1:7 PMCID:PMC9056077

[68] Wang B,Zhang X.Levels and neurodevelopmental effects of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in settled house dust of urban dwellings on preschool-aged children in Nanjing, China.Atmospheric Pollu Res2014;5:292-302

[69] Qi H,Zhu NZ.Concentrations and sources of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in indoor dust in China.Sci Total Environ2014;491-492:100-7

[70] Peng H,Liu M.PAHs in indoor dust samples in Shanghai’s universities: levels, sources and human exposure.Environ Geochem Health2012;34:587-96

[71] Wang XQ,Yang YY.Source, Characterization of Indoor Dust PAHs and the Health Risk on Chinese Children.Curr Med Sci2021;41:199-210

[72] Čupr P,Franců J,Klánová J.Mineralogical, chemical and toxicological characterization of urban air particles.Environ Int2013;54:26-34

[73] Chrysikou LP.Seasonal variation of the size distribution of urban particulate matter and associated organic pollutants in the ambient air.Atmospheric Environ2009;43:4557-69

[74] Lammel G,Ilić P.Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in air on small spatial and temporal scales - II. Mass size distributions and gas-particle partitioning.Atmospheric Environ2010;44:5022-7

[75] Zhang J,Zhang X,Cao P.Vehicular contribution of PAHs in size dependent road dust: A source apportionment by PCA-MLR, PMF, and Unmix receptor models.Sci Total Environ2019;649:1314-22

[76] Zhang J,Hua P.The qualitative and quantitative source apportionments of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in size dependent road deposited sediment.Sci Total Environ2015;505:90-101

[77] Lorenzi D,Cave M.Determination of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in urban street dust: implications for human health.Chemosphere2011;83:970-7

[78] Müller S,Kanchanakool N.Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) in particle-size separates of urban soils in Bangkok, Thailand.Soil Sci2000;165:412-9.

[79] Yang Y,Pies C,Hofmann T.Occurrence of coal and coal-derived particle-bound polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in a river floodplain soil.Environ Pollut2008;151:121-9

[80] Lanzerstorfer C.The upper size limit of the dust samples in road dust heavy metal studies: Benefits of a combined sieving and air classification sample preparation procedure.Environ Pollut2019;245:1079-85

[81] Gustafsson Å,Gorzsás A,Gerde P.Isolation and characterization of a respirable particle fraction from residential house-dust.Environ Res2018;161:284-90