Concentrations and human exposure to hexabromocyclododecane and tetrabromobisphenol A from the indoor environment in Bangkok metropolitan area, Thailand

Abstract

Aim: This study investigated hexabromocyclododecane (HBCDD) and tetrabromobisphenol A (TBBPA) concentrations in indoor dust from houses, offices, and cars and estimated toddler and adult exposure to HBCDD and TBBPA through dust ingestion.

Methods: The concentrations of HBCDD and TBBPA were measured in 47 indoor dust samples collected from the Bangkok metropolitan area, Thailand. All samples were analyzed for HBCDD and TBBPA using LC-MS/MS. The estimated daily intake (EDI) through dust ingestion was calculated from the median and 95th percentile concentrations of HBCDD and TBBPA.

Results: HBCDD was detected in 47% of samples, and TBBPA was detected in all samples. The median concentrations of HBCDD were 6.7 ng g^-1, <0.7 ng g^-1, and <0.7 ng g^-1 in cars, houses, and offices, respectively. The isomer composition of ∑HBCDD in dust was: α-HBCDD (40%-54%), γ-HBCDD (19%-40%), and β-HBCDD (17%-28%). In contrast, TBBPA was observed at higher concentrations, with median values of 674, 67, and 22 ng g^-1 in offices, houses, and cars, respectively. Under a median exposure scenario, toddlers were exposed to 0.05 ng kg^-1 bw day^-1 for HBCDD and 0.25 ng kg^-1 bw day^-1 for TBBPA, with adults exposed to 0.01 and 0.06 ng kg^-1 bw day^-1 for HBCDD and TBBPA respectively.

Conclusion: Concentrations of HBCDD in dust from Thai cars, homes, and offices are lower than those of TBBPA following the listing of HBCDD in the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants and limited use of HBCDD in Thailand in applications such as building insulation foam. Concentrations of TBBPA in office dust significantly exceeded (P < 0.05) those in house and car dust owing to the greater number of electronic appliances and poor natural ventilation in offices. EDIs for Thai toddlers exceeded those of adults under both median and high-end exposure scenarios. However, EDIs of HBCDD and TBBPA for the general Thai population were below the corresponding oral reference dose guidelines.

Keywords

Hexabromocyclododecane / tetrabromobisphenol A / indoor environment / houses / offices / cars / daily intake / human exposure

References

[1] Kurt-karakus PB,Jantunen L.Polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) and alternative flame retardants (NFRs) in indoor and outdoor air and indoor dust from Istanbul-Turkey: levels and an assessment of human exposure.Atmospheric Pollution Research2017;8:801-15

[2] Melymuk L,Jílková SR.Indoor dust and associated chemical exposures.2020;15:1-6

[3] Liu D,Zhao N.Differences of bisphenol analogue concentrations in indoor dust between rural and urban areas.Chemosphere2021;276:130016

[4] Al-Harbi M,Al-Mutairi H.Human health risks from brominated flame retardants and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in indoor dust.Chemosphere2021;282:131005

[5] Abdallah MA,Oluseyi T.Hexabromocyclododecane and tetrabromobisphenol-A in indoor dust from France, Kazakhstan and Nigeria: implications for human exposure.Emerging Contaminants2016;2:73-9

[6] Barghi M,Kim JC,Chang YS.Human exposure to HBCD and TBBPA via indoor dust in Korea: estimation of external exposure and body burden.Sci Total Environ2017;593-594:779-86

[7] Wang J,Shi Z,Sun Z.Legacy and novel brominated flame retardants in indoor dust from Beijing, China: occurrence, human exposure assessment and evidence for PBDEs replacement.Sci Total Environ2018;618:48-59

[8] Fromme H,Kopp E,Völkel W.Polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs), hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) and “novel” brominated flame retardants in house dust in Germany.Environ Int2014;64:61-8

[9] Li F,Tan D.Hexabromocyclododecane and tetrabromobisphenol A in sediments and paddy soils from Liaohe River Basin, China: Levels, distribution and mass inventory.J Environ Sci (China)2016;48:209-17

[10] U.S. EPA. Flame retardant alternatives for hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD). Available from: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2014-06/documents/hbcd_draft.pdf [Last accessed on 18 Apr 2022]

[11] Abafe OA.Determination and human exposure assessment of polybrominated diphenyl ethers and tetrabromobisphenol A in indoor dust in South Africa.Environ Sci Pollut Res Int2016;23:7038-49

[12] Abdallah M. Environmental occurrence, analysis and human exposure to the flame retardant tetrabromobisphenol-A (TBBP-A)-A review.Environ Int2016;94:235-50

[13] Malkoske T,Xu W,Wang H.A review of the environmental distribution, fate, and control of tetrabromobisphenol A released from sources.Sci Total Environ2016;569-570:1608-17

[14] Wu Y,Kang D.Tetrabromobisphenol A and heavy metal exposure via dust ingestion in an e-waste recycling region in Southeast China.Sci Total Environ2016;541:356-64

[15] Hassan Y.Levels of polybrominated diphenyl ethers and novel flame retardants in microenvironment dust from Egypt: an assessment of human exposure.Sci Total Environ2015;505:47-55

[16] Corsolini S,Baroni D.Legacy and novel flame retardants from indoor dust in Antarctica: sources and human exposure.Environ Res2021;196:110344

[17] Abdallah MA,Covaci A.Hexabromocyclododecanes and tetrabromobisphenol-A in indoor air and dust in Birmingham, U.K: implications for human exposure.Environ Sci Technol2008;42:6855-61

[18] Besis A,Poma G,Samara C.Legacy and novel brominated flame retardants in interior car dust - implications for human exposure.Environ Pollut2017;230:871-81

[19] Peng C,Guo Y,Chen D.Emerging and legacy flame retardants in indoor dust from East China.Chemosphere2017;186:635-43

[20] Yadav IC,Singh VK,Zhang G.Measurement of legacy and emerging flame retardants in indoor dust from a rural village (Kopawa) in Nepal: implication for source apportionment and health risk assessment.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf2019;168:304-14

[21] Drage DS,Harrad S,Boontanon SK.Temporal trends in concentrations of legacy and novel brominated flame retardants in house dust from Birmingham in the United Kingdom.Emerging Contaminants2020;6:323-9

[22] Allgood JM,McClaskey CM.Ogunseitan O.A. potential human exposure to halogenated flame-retardants in elevated surface dust and floor dust in an academic environment.Enviro Res2017;153:55-62.

[23] Harrad S,Desborough J,Roosens L.Dust from U.K. primary school classrooms and daycare centers: the significance of dust as a pathway of exposure of young U.K. children to brominated flame retardants and polychlorinated biphenyls.Environ Sci Technol2010;44:4198-202

[24] Shen M,Lam JCW,Li J.Occurrence of two novel triazine-based flame retardants in an E-waste recycling area in South China: implication for human exposure.Sci Total Environ2019;683:249-57

[25] Li W,Deng M,Zeng L.Benzotriazoles and benzothiazoles prevail in indoor dust from an E-waste dismantling area in South China: elevated concentrations and implication for human exposure.Sci Total Environ2020;723:137979

[26] Deng M,Ge J.Prevalence of phthalate alternatives and monoesters alongside traditional phthalates in indoor dust from a typical e-waste recycling area: Source elucidation and co-exposure risk.J Hazard Mater2021;413:125322

[27] Gwon HR,Chang KH.Occurrence, distribution, and potential exposure risk of organophosphate flame retardants in house dust in South Korea.Sci Total Environ2021;770:144571

[28] Stapleton HM,Keller A.Identification of flame retardants in polyurethane foam collected from baby products.Environ Sci Technol2011;45:5323-31 PMCID:PMC3113369

[29] Kweon D,Zoh K.Distribution of brominated flame retardants and phthalate esters in house dust in Korea.Environmental Engineering Research2018;23:354-63

[30] Thailand National Metal and Materials Technology Center (MTEC), National Science and Technology Development Agency (NSTDA). Thailand’s POPs Inventory Assessment Report (Part 2: Thailand’s 2019 POPs industrial chemicals inventory). 1st ed (ISBN 978-616-12-0616-1). MTEC & NSTDA Pub; 2021. p. 63-73. Available from: https://www.mtec.or.th/annual-report2021/th/ [Last accessed on 18 Apr 2022]

[31] Kalachova K,Lankova D,Pulkrabova J.Occurrence of brominated flame retardants in household and car dust from the Czech Republic.Sci Total Environ2012;441:182-93

[32] Dodson RE,Covaci A.After the PBDE phase-out: a broad suite of flame retardants in repeat house dust samples from California.Environ Sci Technol2012;46:13056-66 PMCID:PMC3525011

[33] US-NRC (US-National Research Council). Toxicological risks of selected flame-retardant chemicals. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK225647/pdf/Bookshelf_NBK225647.pdf [Last accessed on 18 Apr 2022]

[34] Zeller H. Hexabromocyclododecane: 90-day feeding trials eith rats. 1970. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK225647/pdf/Bookshelf_NBK225647.pdf [Last accessed on 20 Apr 2022]

[35] Ali N,Van den Eede N.Occurrence of alternative flame retardants in indoor dust from New Zealand: indoor sources and human exposure assessment.Chemosphere2012;88:1276-82

[36] Wikoff D,Perry C.Development of toxicity values and exposure estimates for tetrabromobisphenol A: application in a margin of exposure assessment.J Appl Toxicol2015;35:1292-308 PMCID:PMC6681068

[37] Yao L,Shi J.Toxicity of tetrabromobisphenol A and Its derivative in the mouse liver following oral exposure at environmentally relevant levels.Environ Sci Technol2021;55:8191-202

[38] Sun J,Zhou H,Qi H.Levels, occurrence and human exposure to novel brominated flame retardants (NBFRs) and Dechlorane Plus (DP) in dust from different indoor environments in Hangzhou, China.Sci Total Environ2018;631-632:1212-20