Leveraging heritage conservation for development: A case study of the Tonglushan ancient copper mine site in Daye, Hubei, China

Abstract

The Tonglushan ancient copper mine site, the first mining and smelting archeological site discovered in China, holds significant value as evidence of advanced copper extraction techniques and sophisticated social organization in Chinese Bronze Age civilization, dating back thousands of years. However, its discovery during modern mining operations has raised persistent challenges over the past 50 years regarding the preservation of archeological remains, the methods of protecting them, and their potential utilization to drive coordinated urban and rural development in the region. Drawing on fieldwork conducted between 2016 and 2017 in the Tonglushan area, this study uses the local practice of protecting Tonglushan’s archeological heritage as a lens to explore the relationship between cultural heritage conservation and regional development. By examining the complex process of preserving or relocating archeological remains in situ, this article presents practical considerations within the context of China’s modern industrialization. As mineral resources become increasingly depleted and public interest in cultural heritage grows, the local government has sought to leverage archeological heritage as a catalyst for developing cultural tourism and achieving place-making. This study provides insights into transformation strategies for resource-dependent regions.

Keywords

Tonglushan / Heritage conservation / Industrial transition

Funding

None.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare they have no competing interests.

References

[1] Chen A. (2009). “Copper capital” Daye: Forced mining boss transformation. Oriental Outlook; 2009. Available from: https://news.sina.com.cn/c/sd/2009-04-20/142217647591.shtml [Last accessed on 2018 Oct 23].

[2] Chen A., & Lin Z. (1971). Continued Annals of Daye County, Hubei Province (Based on the Version of 1884). Taiwan: Cheng Wen Publishing Co.

[3] Chen S., & Wu H. (2014). Reflections of landscape and ecological environment construction of mountain Tonglushan heritage park. Journal of Hubei Polytechnic University(Humanities and Social Science), 31(6):17-24. https://doi.org/10.3969/j.ISSN.2095-4662.2014.06.004

[4] China Cultural Relics News. (2024). The 21st (2023) Top Ten Exhibitions of Museums in China. Beijing: China Cultural Relics News, p. 1.

[5] China’s State Council. (1991). Guan yu Hubei Sheng Daye Tonglushan gu Tong Kuang yi Zhi Bao hu Fang an de pi Fu (Approval of the State Council on the Protection Plan of the Tonglushan Ancient Copper Mine Site in Daye, Hubei Province). Available from: https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2010-12/31/content_6026.htm [Last accessed on 2018 Mar 20].

[6] China’s State Council. (2013). Guan yu yin fa Quan Guo zi Yuan Xing Cheng shi ke Chi xu fa Zhan Gui Hua (2013-2020 Nian) de Tong zhi (Notice About the Issuance of the National Sustainable Development Plan for Resource-Based Cities). Available from: https://www.gov.cn/zwgk/2013-12/03/content_2540070.htm [Last accessed on 2019 Mar 06].

[7] DBPA ( The Promotion Association of Daye Bronze Culture. (2003). Zhong guo qing tong zhi yuan Daye (The source of Chinese bronze: Daye). Henan Province: DBPA (The Promotion Association of Daye Bronze Culture.

[8] DLCC (Daye City Local Chronicles Compilation Committee). (2014). Annals of Daye City:1985-2005. Beijing: Chinese Literature and History Press.

[9] DLCC (Daye City Local Chronicles Compilation Committee). (2014). Daye Yearbook 2014. Daye: DLCC (Daye City Local Chronicles Compilation Committee).

[10] Evans H., & Rowlands M. (2014). Reconceptualizing heritage in China:Museums, development and the shifting dynamics of power. In: PBasu and W Modest (eds.). Museums, Heritage and International Development. England, UK: Routledge, p. 272-294. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203069035

[11] Fan S., & Kong X. (1993). Tonglushan kuang ye yi zhi fa xian ji (Report about the discovery of Tonglushan ancient copper mine site). Journal of National Museum of China, 13(1):132-135, 25.

[12] Guo C. (1981). Tonglushan gu kuang ye yi zhi wen wu bao hu di er ci zuo tan hui (The second symposium on the protection of ancient mining and metallurgy sites in Tonglushan). China Mine Engineering, 10(4):65-66.

[13] Harrison R. (2008). The politics of the past: Conflict in the use of heritage in the modern world. In G Fairclough, R Harrison, J Schofield and JH Jameson (eds.). The Heritage Reader. Routledge, p. 177-190.

[14] HBSJ (Hubei Engineering and Design Institute). ( 2017). Planning Project of the Tonglushan Bronze Town, Daye. Wuhan: HBSJ (Hubei Engineering and Design Institute).

[15] Herzfeld M. (1991). A Place in History: Social and Monumental Time in a Cretan Town. United States: Princeton University.

[16] Hsueh M. (2013). Chang’an as a Chessboard: Demystifying the Conservation Process of the Tang Dynasty Daming Palace Heritage Site and the Cultural Renaissance in the Twentieth Century Xi’an City. [Doctoral Dissertation, National Taiwan University]. https://doi.org/10.6342/NTU.2013.02704

[17] Huang R. (1989). Tonglushan gu kuang yi zhi bu ying ban qian (Tonglushan ancient mine site should not be moved). Journal of Hubei Normal University(Philosophy and Social Sciences), 9(4):79-81.

[18] Huangshi City Museum. (1999). Ancient Mining and Smelting Site at Tonglushan. Beijing: Cultural Relics Press.

[19] Hubei Provincial Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology, Protection and Administration Committee of the Ancient Bronze Mining Site in Mt. Tonglv of Daye City. ( 2013). A preliminary excavation report on the lujianao smelting Site of Mt. Tonglu in Daye City. Jianghan Archaeology, 34(2):3-21,133-134.

[20] Hubei Provincial Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology, Protection and Administration Committee of the Ancient Bronze Mining Site in Mt. Tonglv of Daye City. ( 2013). A preliminary excavation report on the yanyinshanjiao site of Mt. Tonglu in Daye City. Jianghan Archaeology, 34(3):7-27,143-145.

[21] Hubei Provincial Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology, Protection and Administration Committee of the Ancient Bronze Mining Site in Mt. Tonglv of Daye City. ( 2015). Report of the first excavation of the sifangtang cemetery in Tonglushan, Daye. Jianghan Archaeology, 36(5):35-44, 129.

[22] Hui X., Pi S., & Wang Z. (2023). This is the “high-tech industrial base” from 2,000 years ago: The rediscovery of the Tonglushan archaeological site. Beijing: Xinhua Daily Telegraph, p. 009.

[23] Law A. M. (2023). Historical imaginaries, historic urban branding, and the local state in China: Rejuvenation discourse, manufactured heritage and simulacrascapes. Built Heritage, 7(1):1-12. https://doi.org/10.1186/s43238-023-00083-3

[24] Lei Y. (2019). The controversy of Daye’s investment promotion reflects the urgent need for transformation in resource-depleted cities. Beijing: China Youth Daily, p. 12.

[25] Leng F. (1999). Analysis on problems and countermeasures facing in Tonglushan mine. Mining Research and Development, 19(3):44-45. https://doi.org/10.13827/j.cnki.kyyk.1999.03.015

[26] Liu Y., Hu B., Hu X., & Chen Z. (2014). Research on formation mechanism of fractures in Tonglvshan ancient copper mine ruins in Daye. Journal of Hubei Polytechnic University(Humanities and Social Science), 31(1):7-14. https://doi.org/10.3969/j.ISSN.2095-4662.2014.01.003

[27] Shi H. (2003). The study on cultural xylo-relics’ preservation in the ruins of the ancient copper mine remains of Tonglushan. Journal of Hubei Normal University(Natural Science), 23(3):47-50.

[28] Shi H., & Wang S. (1994). Prevention and care of the harmful organisms on the rock and earth in copper mine remains. Sciences of Conservation and Archaeology, 6(1):16-21. https://doi.org/10.16334/j.cnki.cn31-1652/k.1994.01.003

[29] Smith L. (2006). Uses of Heritage. England, UK: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203602263

[30] Tao J. (1997). Preliminary research on the ecological environment in the mine area: The case of the surroundings around Daye Tonglu mountains. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Valley, 6(4):355-362.

[31] THUPDI (Beijing Tsinghua Urban Planning and Design Institue). ( 2011). The site Protection Plan of Ancient Copper Mine for TONGLUSHAN in Daye city, Hubei. Beijing: THUPDI (Beijing Tsinghua Urban Planning and Design Institue).

[32] TMC (Tonglushan Mine Chronicles Compilation Committee). ( 1995). Tong lu Shan Kuang Zhi (Chorography of Tonglushan Mine). Hubei province: TMC (Tonglushan Mine Chronicles Compilation Committee).

[33] Wang S. (2015). Constructing an exemplary civilized village in Xiaotun, Anyang Yinxu: Cultural heritage, national narrative and local memory. Taiwan Journal of Anthropology, 13(2):21-66.

[34] Wu S. (2015). The Reconstruction of Living Space in Mining Area of Tonglu Mountain. [Master Degree Thesis, Hubei University of Technology].

[35] Xia N., & Yin W. (1982). Ancient copper mines and smelting furnaces at Tonglushan in Hubei. Acta Archaeologica Sinica, 24(1): 1-14, 137-138.

[36] Zhang Q., & Chen X. L. (2008). Huangshi gu Tong Kuang yi Zhi Yin Luan Wa Jue fa Sheng Chen Jiang yi si yi Bei Tao Kong (The site of Huangshi Ancient Copper Mine is Suspected to Have Been Hollowed out Due to the Settlement Caused by Random Excavation). Chutian Metropolis Daily. Available from: https://www.cnhubei.com/xwzt/2007zt/18wuhan/18news/18zxbd/200803/t254833.shtml [Last accessed on 2024 Aug 06].

[37] Zhao H. (2010). Tong Chou Cheng Xiang fa Zhan bi xu Zhuan Bian Cheng Shi Pian Xiang fa Zhan Zhan Lve (To Coordinate Urban and Rural Development, We Must Change the Strategy of Urban Development). Zhong Guo Xiang Cun Fa Xian (Discovery of Rural China), 5(2):24-27.

[38] Zhou B., Hu Y., & Lu B. (1988). Ancient copper mining and smelting at Tonglushan, Daye. In R. Maddin (ed). The Beginning of the Use of Metals and Alloys: Papers from the Second International Conference on the Beginning of the Use of Metals and Alloys, Zhengzhou, China, 21-26 October 1986. United States: MIT Press, p. 125-129.

[39] Zhou C., Liu Z., & Wang P. (1996). The only option for sustainable mining communities: A case study of Tonglushan mine in Hubei Province. Environmental Science and Technology, 75(4):11-15. https://doi.org/10.19672/j.cnki.1003-6504.1996.04.004

[40] Zhu Y. (2018). Uses of the past: Negotiazting heritage in Xi’an. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 24(2):181-192. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2017.1347886

[41] Zou G. (2009). Huangshi Shi zi Yuan Ku Jie Xing Cheng Shi Chan Ye Zhuan Xing lu Jing tan Tao (Discussion on Industrial Transformation Path of Resource-Depleted Cities in Huangshi City). Contemporary Economics, 22:90-92.