Risk of Secondary Extinction in the Asian Songbird Trade, as Exemplified by the Selling of Crested Jayshrikes as Master Birds

Abstract

The Asian Songbird Crisis—the recognition that trade is the major threat to the conservation of Asian songbirds—has hitherto largely focused on species valued for their singing abilities and those that enter into songbird competitions. To increase the repertoire and variability in the songs of these competition species, competitors use so-called master birds. These are caged near competition birds to train them through vocal mimicry. Here, we focus on one such master bird, the crested jayshrike Platylophus galericulatus. Recognizing the negative effect trade has had on wild populations, the Indonesian government added this species to its list of protected species in 2018. We used data from 21 bird markets surveyed between 2011–2018 (119 surveys) and 2018–2025 (105 surveys) to assess whether this legal protection was effective. We recorded crested jayshrikes openly offered for sale, with most surveys documenting one or two individuals. We found a strong contrast between the brown crested jayshrike P. g. coronatus from Borneo and Sumatra and the Javan crested jayshrike P. g. galericulatus. The former was favored because of its superior singing abilities and more varied, piercing song. Almost three-quarters of individuals traded were brown crested jayshrikes, and they commanded significantly higher prices. Overall, remarkably little change was detected over the 15-year period, and legal protection appears to have had limited effect. We found no significant change in the number of markets offering the species (16 vs. 15), in market-level abundance trends (10 decreases, 5 no change, 6 increases), in temporal patterns, or in prices (brown: US$103 vs. US$110; Javan: US$57 vs. US$41 at the start and end of the study, respectively). The mean abundance decline slightly (1.6 vs. 1.3 birds per survey). Although crested jayshrikes themselves do not enter singing competitions, they are an integral part of the competitive songbird industry as master birds, with thousands caught illegally every year. As a result, they face a risk of extinction driven indirectly by the demand for increasingly complex songs in competing species. These secondary extinctions highlight the need to rethink how best to manage, and where appropriate curb, trade in wild songbirds across Asia.

Keywords

Asian songbird crisis / conservation / Indonesia / masteran / wildlife trade

References

[1] Antara, M., and M. S. Sumarniasih. 2017. “Role of Tourism in Economy of Bali and Indonesia.” Journal of Tourism and Hospitality Management 5: 34–44.

[2] Azizah, H. P. N., I. Nabila, K. Damayanti, et al. 2025. “Bird Identification and Conservation in Semarang Traditional Markets, Indonesia.” Nusantara Bioscience 17: 103–117. https://doi.org/10.13057/nusbiosci/n170111.

[3] Van Balen, S., and V. Nijman. 1996. “Notes on the Breeding of the Crested Jay Platylophus galericulatus.” Bulletin of the British Ornithologists’ Club 116: 173–174.

[4] Basuni, S., and G. Setiyani. 1989. “Studi perdagangan burung di pasar Pramuka, Jakarta dan teknik penangkapan burung di alam.” Media Konservasi 2: 9–18.

[5] BirdLife International. 2019. “Species Factsheet: Crested Jayshrike Platylophus galericulatus.” https://datazone.birdlife.org/species/factsheet/crested-jayshrike-platylophus-galericulatus.

[6] Bušina, T., M. Kouba, and N. Pasaribu. 2021. “What Is the Reliability of Visually Based Animal Trade Census Outcomes? A Case Study Involving the Market Monitoring of the Sumatran Laughingthrush Garrulax bicolor.” Bird Conservation International 31: 326–336.

[7] Chavez, J., M. Campera, L. E. Hensley, et al. 2025. “Illegal Wildlife Trade in a Tourism and Biodiversity Hotspot.” Sustainable Development 33: 9106–9122. https://doi.org/10.1002/sd.70129.

[8] Chng, S. C. L., and J. A. Eaton. 2016. In the Market for Extinction: Eastern and Central Java. TRAFFIC South-East Asia.

[9] Chng, S. C. L., J. A. Eaton, K. Krishnasamy, C. R. Shepherd, and V. Nijman. 2015. In the Market for Extinction: An Inventory of Jakarta's Bird Markets. TRAFFIC South-East Asia.

[10] Chng, S. C. L., M. Guciano, and J. A. Eaton. 2016. “In the Market for Extinction: Sukahaji, Bandung, Java, Indonesia.” BirdingASIA 26: 22–28.

[11] Chng, S. C. L., K. Krishnasamy, and J. A. Eaton. 2018. “In the Market for Extinction: The Cage Bird Trade in Bali.” Forktail 34: 35–41.

[12] Diamond, J. M., K. D. Bishop, and S. Van Balen. 1987. “Bird Survival in an Isolated Javan Woodland: Island or Mirror?” Conservation Biology 1: 132–142. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.1987.tb00022.x.

[13] Djuwantoko . 1986. “Trade Traffic and Management of Wild Birds and Mammals in Semarang and Yogyakarta, Central Java, Indonesia.” Master's thesis, University of the Philippines.

[14] Eaton, J. A., C. R. Shepherd, F. E. Rheindt, et al. 2015. “Trade-Driven Extinctions and Near-Extinctions of Avian Taxa in Sundaic Indonesia.” Forktail 31: 1–12.

[15] Gaudin, J., G. Sangster, and M. D. Bruce. 2021. “A Family Name for the Crested Shrikejay Platylophus galericulatus.” Bulletin of the British Ornithologists’ Club 141, no. 3: 366–368. https://doi.org/10.25226/bboc.v141i3.2021.a12.

[16] Harris, J. B. C., M. W. Tingley, F. Hua, et al. 2017. “Measuring the Impact of the Pet Trade on Indonesian Birds.” Conservation Biology 31: 394–405. https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.12729.

[17] Haryoko, T. 2010. “Komposisi jenis dan jumlah burung liar yang diperdagangkan di Jawa Barat.” Berita Biologi 10: 67294.

[18] Hellebrekers, W. P. J., and A. Hoogerwerf. 1935. “Een Roofridder en zijn Gewoonten.” De Tropische Natuur 24: 194.

[19] Humaero, S., D. A. Candri, and I. W. Suana. 2023. “Status konservasi burung yang diperdagangkan di Pulau Lombok.” Jurnal Bios Logos 13: 180–191. https://doi.org/10.35799/jbl.v13i3.52103.

[20] Imron, M. A., M. Tafrichan, F. E. Nugroho, et al. 2025. “Suitable Habitat of Bulbuls (Pycnonotidae) and Their Prevalence in Songbird Trade in Indonesia.” Biological Conservation 34: 111035. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2025.111035.

[21] Iqbal, M. 2015. “Looking at Online Bird Trading in Indonesia; A Case Study From South Sumatra.” BirdingASIA 24: 132–135.

[22] Iskandar, B. S., J. Iskandar, and R. Partasasmita. 2019. “Hobby and Business on Trading Birds: Case Study in Bird Market of Sukahaji, Bandung, West Java and Splendid, Malang, East Java (Indonesia).” Biodiversitas Journal of Biological Diversity 20: 1316–1332. https://doi.org/10.13057/biodiv/d200522.

[23] Iskandar, J., and B. S. Iskandar. 2015. “Pemanfaatan aneka ragam burung dalam kontes burung kicau dan dampaknya terhadap konservasi burung di alam: Studi kasus di Kota Bandung, Jawa Barat.” Prosiding Seminar Nasional Masyarakat Biodiversitas Indonesia 1: 747–752.

[24] Iskandar, J., B. S. Iskandar, D. Mulyanto, R. L. Alfian, and R. Partasasmita. 2020. “Traditional Ecological Knowledge of the Bird Traders on Bird Species Bird Naming, and Bird Market Chain: A Case Study in Bird Market Pasty Yogyakarta, Indonesia.” Biodiversitas 21: 2586–2602. https://doi.org/10.13057/biodiv/d210631.

[25] IUCN SSC ASTSG. 2025. “Priority Taxa List 2025.” IUCN SSC Asian Songbird Trade Specialist Group. https://www.asiansongbirdtradesg.com/taxa-list.

[26] Jepson, P. 2008. “Orange-Headed Thrush Zoothera citrina and the Avian X-Factor.” BirdingASIA 9: 58–61.

[27] Jepson, P. 2012. “Towards an Indonesian Bird Conservation Ethos: Reflections From a Study of Bird-Keeping in the Cities of Java and Bali.” In Ethno-Ornithology, Birds, Indigenous People, Culture and Society, edited by S. C. Tideman and A. Gosler, 313–330. Routledge.

[28] Jepson, P., and R. J. Ladle. 2005. “Bird-Keeping in Indonesia: Conservation Impacts and the Potential for Substitution-Based Conservation Responses.” Oryx 39: 442–448. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605305001110.

[29] Jepson, P., and R. J. Ladle. 2009. “Governing Bird-Keeping in Java and Bali: Evidence From a Household Survey.” Oryx 43: 364–374. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605309990251.

[30] Jepson, P., R. J. Ladle, and Sujatnika . 2011. “Assessing Market-Based Conservation Governance Approaches: A Socio-Economic Profile of Indonesian Markets for Wild Birds.” Oryx 45: 482–491. https://doi.org/10.1017/S003060531100038X.

[31] Juhardiansyah, H. Erianto, and H. M. Idham. 2019. “Studi jenis burung yang diperdagangkan di kota Ketapang.” Jurnal Hutan Lestari 7: 237–247.

[32] King, W. B. 1974. “Aspects of International Trade in Indonesian Birds.” International Zoo Yearbook 14: 56–61.

[33] Krishna, V. V., K. Darras, I. Grass, et al. 2019. “Wildlife Trade and Consumer Preference for Species Rarity: An Examination of Caged-Bird Markets in Sumatra.” Environment and Development Economics 24: 339–360.

[34] Lee, J. W., and K. Hong. 2012. “Economic Growth in Asia: Determinants and Prospects.” Japan and the World Economy 24: 101–113. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.japwor.2012.01.005.

[35] Lees, A. C., and P. Yuda. 2022. “The Asian Songbird Crisis.” Current Biology 32: R1063–R1064. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2022.08.066.

[36] Leupen, B. T. C., K. Krishnasamy, C. R. Shepherd, et al. 2018. “Trade in White-Rumped Shamas Kittacincla malabarica Demands Strong National and International Responses.” Forktail 34: 1–8.

[37] Leupen, B. T. C., L. Shepherd, C. R. Shepherd, E. Damianou, and V. Nijman. 2022. “Market Surveys in Mataram, Lombok, Illustrate the Expanse of Legal and Illegal Indonesian Bird Trade Networks.” Indonesian Journal of Applied Environmental Studies 3: 42–52. https://doi.org/10.33751/injast.v3i1.5127.

[38] Marsden, S. J., A. R. Junaid, F. Kaprawi, et al. 2023. “Distribution and Abundance of Threatened and Heavily Traded Birds in the Mountains of Western Java.” Bird Conservation International 33: e63. https://doi.org/10.1017/S095927092300014X.

[39] Marshall, H., N. J. Collar, A. C. Lees, A. Moss, P. Yuda, and S. J. Marsden. 2020. “Spatio-Temporal Dynamics of Consumer Demand Driving the Asian Songbird Crisis.” Biological Conservation 241: 108237. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2019.108237.

[40] Marshall, H., G. A. Glorizky, N. J. Collar, et al. 2021. “Understanding Motivations and Attitudes Among Songbird-Keepers to Identify Best Approaches to Demand Reduction.” Conservation Science and Practice 3: 507. https://doi.org/10.1111/csp2.507.

[41] Mirin, B. H., and H. Klinck. 2021. “Bird Singing Contests: Looking Back on Thirty Years of Research on a Global Conservation Concern.” Global Ecology and Conservation 30: e01812. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2021.e01812.

[42] Mulyadi, A., and M. Dede. 2020. “Perdagangan burung di Kota Bandung (antara ekonomi, keanekaragaman hayati, dan konservasi).” Jurnal Geografi Gea 20: 105–112. https://doi.org/10.17509/gea.v20i2.28828.

[43] Nash, S. V. 1993. Sold for a Song: The Trade in Southeast Asian Non-CITES Birds. TRAFFIC International.

[44] Nijman, V. 2022. “Analysis of Trade in Endemic Javan Hill Partridges Over the Last Quarter of a Century Period.” Avian Biology Research 15: 84–92. https://doi.org/10.1177/17581559221086469.

[45] Nijman, V., A. Abdullah, E. Adinda, et al. 2024. “Indonesia's Sustainable Development Goals in Relation to Curbing and Monitoring the Illegal Wildlife Trade.” Sustainable Development 32: 5393–5403.

[46] Nijman, V., A. Ardiansyah, R. Hendrik, et al. 2021. “Trade in a Small-Range Songbird, the Javan Crocias, Gives Insight into the Asian Songbird Crisis.” Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 14: 154–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.japb.2021.01.001.

[47] Nijman, V., A. Ardiansyah, R. Hendrik, M. A. Imron, and K. A. I. Nekaris. 2020. “The Trade in Rufous-Fronted Laughingthrush Garrulax rufifrons in Java, Indonesia.” Forktail 36: 74–78.

[48] Nijman, V., M. Campera, A. Ardiansyah, et al. 2021. “Large-Scale Trade in a Songbird That Is Extinct in the Wild.” Diversity 13: 238. https://doi.org/10.3390/d13060238.

[49] Nijman, V., T. Q. Morcatty, K. Feddema, M. Campera, and K. A. I. Nekaris. 2022. “Disentangling the Legal and Illegal Wildlife Trade—Insights From Indonesian Wildlife Market Surveys.” Animals 12: 628. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani12050628.

[50] Nijman, V., and K. A. I. Nekaris. 2017. “The Harry Potter Effect: The Rise in Trade of Owls as Pets in Java and Bali, Indonesia.” Global Ecology and Conservation 11: 84–94. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2017.04.004.

[51] Nijman, V., C. R. Shepherd, and S. van Balen. 2009. “Declaration of the Javan Hawk Eagle Spizaetus bartelsi as Indonesia's National Rare Animal Impedes Conservation of the Species.” Oryx 43: 122–128. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605307001081.

[52] Okarda, B., U. Muchlish, S. D. Kusumadewi, and H. Purnomo. 2022. “Categorizing the Songbird Market Through Big Data and Machine Learning in the Context of Indonesia's Online Market.” Global Ecology and Conservation 39: e02280.

[53] Prakosa, B. H., and N. Kurniawan. 2015. “Studi burung-burung yang diperdagangkan di pasar burung Splendid Kota Malang.” Jurnal Biotropika 3: 7–11.

[54] Putri, F. K., F. Alicia, H. J. Noven, et al. 2021. “Conservation Implication and Traditional Ecological Knowledge on Trading Bird: A Case Study in Depok Bird Market in Surakarta, Central Java, Indonesia.” Biodiversitas Journal of Biological Diversity 22: 5636–5648. https://doi.org/10.13057/biodiv/d221260.

[55] Rentschlar, K. A., A. E. Miller, K. S. Lauck, et al. 2018. “A Silent Morning: The Songbird Trade in Kalimantan, Indonesia.” Tropical Conservation Science 11: 1940082917753909.

[56] Saputra, A., R. Mauliza, R. B. Naibaho, et al. 2024. “Identification and Conservation Status of Birds Traded in Bird Shops in Kuranji District, Nanggalo District, East Padang District, South Padang District, and Lubuk Begalung District, West Sumatra.” Jurnal Biologi Tropis 24: 534–539.

[57] Shepherd, C. R. 2005. “Indonesia and the Philippines Meet to Curb Trade in Parrots.” Traffic Bulletin 20, no. 2: 54.

[58] Shepherd, C. R. 2006. “The Bird Trade in Medan, North Sumatra: An Overview.” BirdingASIA 5: 16–24.

[59] Shepherd, C. R., B. T. C. Leupen, P. Siriwat, and V. Nijman. 2020. “International Wildlife Trade, Avian Influenza, Organised Crime and the Effectiveness of CITES: The Chinese hwamei as a Case Study.” Global Ecology and Conservation 23: e01185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2020.e01185.

[60] Syaputra, M. 2016. “Kajian perdagangan satwa liar jenis burung di wilayah Mataram dan sekitarnya.” BioWallacea 2: 148–153.

[61] Sykes, B. R. 2017. “The Elephant in the Room: Addressing the Asian Songbird Crisis.” BirdingASIA 27: 35–41.

[62] Widodo, W. 2005. “Perdagangan burung-burung paruh bengkok di Bali.” Berkala Penelitian Hayati 11: 31–37.

[63] Wiedarti, S., Moerfiah , C. Sudrajat, and G. M. Iqbal. 2016. “The Diversity of Bird Species That Are Traded in the Bird Market in the City of Bogor, Indonesia.” AIP Conference Proceedings 1744: 020056. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4953530

[64] Wijaya, C. B., R. D. Nursalzabillah, I. S. Djoemharsjah, R. Ambarwati, and R. Satria. 2021. “Komposisi jenis dan status konservasi burung yang diperdagangkan di Pasar Burung Kota Surabaya, Jawa Timur.” Prosiding Seminar Nasional Biologi 1: 879–888.

[65] Yohanna, M. Irham, and P. T. Kurniawan. 2021. “Monitoring of Songbird Trades in Jambi, Indonesia.” IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 690: 012035. https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/690/1/012035.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2026 The Author(s). Integrative Conservation published by John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd on behalf of Xishuangbanna Tropical Botanical Garden (XTBG).