An integrated historical study on human–tiger interactions in China

Abstract

Tigers (Panthera tigris), as apex predators, play a crucial role in maintaining ecological functions within their ecosystems. Human–wildlife conflicts, particularly human–tiger conflicts (HTCs), have been a prevalent and severe issue in tiger-range countries from ancient times to the present day, with various regional characteristics. This article discusses human–tiger interactions in China, including different types of HTCs throughout history and the various measures implemented to promote human–tiger coexistence. Employing a historiographic approach, this study is based on case studies. It relies on historical documentation as its primary source, using methods such as literature analysis, digital humanities techniques, and field investigations. The results reveal various forms of direct negative human–tiger interactions, ranging from mild to intense HTCs, as well as other interactions such as tiger trade, medicinal use of tiger parts, and tiger habitat loss and fragmentation due to deforestation and urbanization, all of which have led to reductions in tiger populations. Meanwhile, the study also identifies different conceptions and measures for human–tiger coexistence amidst conflicts, including animal protection and tiger worship in China’s history, and modern conservation efforts such as the inclusion of tigers on protection lists, bans on tiger medicine and trade, and the establishment of nature reserves and national parks to protect tiger habitats.

Keywords

China / historical study / human–tiger coexistence / human–tiger conflict (HTC) / human–tiger interaction

References

[1] Changjixian Xiangtu Tuzhi 昌吉县乡土图志. (Ed.) (1908) Center for China’s borderland history and geography studies of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. In: Xinjiang Xiangtu Zhigao 新疆乡土志稿 (1990). China National Microfilming Center for Library Resources, pp. 118–119, 125–126.

[2] China Biodiversity Conservation and Green Development Foundation. (2022) Preliminary investigation report on the current status of tigers in China. BioGreen-Biodiversity Conservation and Green Development, 1(8), 89–106.

[3] Chinese Archaeology Society. (1997a) Yearbook of Chinese Archaeology 1994. Cultural Relics Press, p. 6.

[4] Chinese Archaeology Society. (1997b) Yearbook of Chinese Archaeology 1994. Cultural Relics Press, p. 173.

[5] Chinese Eastern Railway Company. (1933) Heilongjiang 黑龙江. Shanghai Commercial Press, pp. 302–304.

[6] Chouksey, S., & Singh, S., (2018) Assessments on the impact of human-tiger conflict and community-based conservation in Bandhavgarh Tiger Reserve, Madhya Pradesh, India. Journal of Threatened Taxa, 10(7), 11844–11849.

[7] Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity. (2022) Kunming-Montreal global biodiversity framework.

[8] Dahal, S., Thanet, D.R. & Gautam D. (2020) Assessment of human-tiger conflict and its community based mitigation efforts in madi valley of Chitwan District, Nepal. Journal of Forest and Natural Resource Management, 2(1), 37–49.

[9] Excavation Team of Gezidong Site. (1975) Report of relic of paleolithic period in gezidong site, Liaoning. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 2, 122–136.

[10] Gao, Y., & Clark, S.G. (2023) An interdisciplinary conception of human-wildlife coexistence. Journal for Nature Conservation, 73, 126370.

[11] Goodrich, J., Wibisono, H., Miquelle, D., Lynam, A.J., Sanderson, E., Chapman, S. et al. (2022) Panthera tigris. The IUCN Red List of threatened species.

[12] Guangxu Sanxing Xianzhi 光绪三姓县志. (1890) Harbin: Heilongjiang Provincial Library’s lithographic print edition, 1960.

[13] Guo, P., (1989) Tale of King Mu 穆天子传 Siku Congkan Chubian 四库丛刊初编, vol. 5. Shanghai Bookstore.

[14] Guoqin, Q., (1989) Mammalian fauna of quaternary period in Northern China. In: W. Rukang (Ed.) Palaeoanthropology in China. China Science Press, pp. 277–377.

[15] Hedin, S., (1940) The Wandering Lake. Xinjiang Renmin Press, p. p146.

[16] Jianzhong, S., Yuzhuo, W., & Jiang, P., (1981) A paleolithic site at Zhou-jia-you-fang in Yushu County Jilin Province. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 19(3), 281–291. Available from: https://doi.org/10.19615/j.cnki.1000-3118.1981.03.013

[17] Jinfeng, Z., Qinqin, A., Huo, W., Ming, Zh., Yilin, L., Yanjun, X. et al. (2022) A preliminary report on tiger status in China. BioGreen Biodiversity Conservation and Green Development, 1(8), 89–106.

[18] Jingxi, X., Zengyu, L., & Tingshu, S., (1751) Qianlong Fuzhou Fuzhi 乾隆福州府志. Shanghai Bookstore & Shanghai Century Publishing (Group) Co. Ltd., p. 150.

[19] Joint Jin-Niu-Shan Excavation Team. (1976) Mammalian fauna of quaternary period in Jin-niu-shan of Yingkou, Jilin. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 2, 120–127.

[20] Juanli, C., & Jiang, S., (2020) New compilation textbook of the animal protection law. China University of Political Science and Law Press.

[21] Li, X.Y., Hu, W.Q., Wang, H.J. & Jiang, X.L. (2023) Tiger reappearance in Medog highlights the conservation values of the region for this apex predator. Zoological Research, 44(4), 747–749. Available from:

[22] Liangxue, C., (1998) Huguang immigration and the development of Southern Shaanxi 湖广移民与陕南开发. Sanqin Publishing House.

[23] Liqi, W., (2010) Fengsu Tongyi Jiaozhu 风俗通义校注. Zhonghua Book Company.

[24] Luo, R., (1443) Liaodong Zhi辽东志. Qing-era Lead Printing Edition.

[25] Mai, H., (2006) Yijianzhi 夷坚志. Zhonghua Book Company.

[26] Ministry of Ecology and Environment of the People’s Republic of China, Chinese Academy of Sciences. (2023) China’s Red List of biodiversity: volume on vertebrates. Government Announcement 2023, No.15, p. 2.

[27] National Forestry of China. (2017) Overall plan for Northeast China Tiger and Leopard National Park.

[28] Nikolay Przhevalsky From Kulja, Across the Tian Shan to Lop Nor. (1879) Huang Jianmin. Xinjiang Renmin Press, 1999. pp. 141–143, 232–237.

[29] Nyhus, P.J. (2016) Human–wildlife conflict and coexistence. Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 41, 143–171.

[30] Peng, J., (1975) Cave deposits of late pleistocene epoch in Antu, Jilin. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 3, 197–198.

[31] Peng, J., (1982) A fossil human tooth from Jilin Province. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 20(1), 65–70.

[32] Qiaosong, Z., (1927) Minguo Yongchun Xianzhi 民国永春县志. Zhonghua Book Company.

[33] Qinding Shengjing Tongzhi. (1965) 钦定盛京通志. In: L. Yushu & S. Yunlong (Eds.) Zhongguo Bianjiang Congshu 中国边疆丛书, 27. Wenhai Publishing House, pp. 1347–1352.

[34] Qizhi, Z., (2008) Shisanjing Zhushu-Liji Zhengyi 十三经注疏·礼记正义. Shanghai Classics Publishing House, p. 1071.

[35] Ruyu, Y., & Bingran, Z., (1813) Hannan Xüxiu Junzhi 汉南续修郡志 Zhongguo Fangzhi Congshu. Chengwen Co. Ltd.

[36] Seidensticker, J., (2010) Saving wild tigers: a case study in biodiversity loss and challenges to be met for recovery beyond 2010. Integrative Zoology, 5(4), 285–299.

[37] Shen, M., (2014) (713–741) Shiliao Bencao 食疗本草 (Materia Medica of Food Therapy). In: Peiran Q. et al. proofed Zhonghua Yidian 中华医典. Hunan: Electronic and Audio-visual Publishing House.

[38] Shenwei, T., (1108) Zhenglei Bencao 证类本草, Wenyuan ge Siku Quanshu.

[39] Shizun, Z., (2005) The distribution of amur tiger in the southern part of northeast China in the 21st year of the Kangxi Emperor’s Reign. Manchu Minority Research, 2(96–100), 121.

[40] Shunan, W., Tingxie, W., & Yufu, J., (1934) Fengtian Tongzhi 奉天通志. Editorial Committee of Northeast China’s Literature and History Series, 1983. pp. 2597–2598.

[41] Tinghuai, Z., (1828) Daoguang Xixiang Xianzhi 道光西乡县志 Zhongguo Fangzhi Congshu. Chengwen Co. Ltd.

[42] Tuotuo . (1974) Liao Shi 辽史. Zhonghua Book Company, p. 247.

[43] Tuotuo . (1975) Jin Shi 金史. Zhonghua Book Company, p. 2627.

[44] Villalva, P., & Moracho, E., (2019) Tiger trade threatens big cats worldwide. Science, 364, 743.

[45] Weiqing, L., Zhiyan, Z., Baoshu, L., & Zaiguan, Q., (1935) Minguo Lianjiang Xianzhi 民国连江县志 Zhongguo Difangzhi Jicheng. Shanghai Bookstore & Shanghai Century Publishing (Group) Co. Ltd, p. 150.

[46] Wenyin, C., (1986) Dajin Guozhi jiaozheng 大金国志校证. Zhonghua Book Company, p. 19.

[47] Xiaochen, Y., Jingsheng, L., Zongan, S., Dongjun, H., & Xinshengfang, X., (2000) Current situation and conservation management suggestions for tigers in China. Quarterly of Forest By Product and Speciality in China, 53(2), 36–38. Available from: https://doi.org/10.13268/j.cnki.fbsic.2000.02.032

[48] Xijue, H., & Mingshu, L., (1930) Minguo Huanren Xianzhi 民国桓仁县志. In: Zhongguo Difangzhi Jicheng 中国地方志集成. Shanghai Bookstore & Shanghai Century Publishing (Group) Co. Ltd., pp. 159–160.

[49] Xingliang, L., (2009) A study on tiger disaster and interrelated problems in Jiangxi during the Ming and Qing Dynasties. Ancient and Modern Agriculture, 80(2), 64–71.

[50] Xinxue, Z., Yufeng, S., & Jiamao, W., (1984) A new mammalian fauna found in Gulongshan, Dalian. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 2, 151–155.

[51] Xuefei, X.I.N. (2018) Tiger totem worship in hongshan culture. Journal of Jilin Normal University (Humanities & Social Science Edition), 46(1), 50–57, 88.

[52] Xueshi, H., & Guanfu, Z., (1973) Cave deposits of late Pleistocene Epoch in Benxi, Liaoning. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 2, 211–214.

[53] Ye, F., (1959) Hou Hanshu 后汉书. Zhonghua Book Company, p. 2982.

[54] Yi, P., & Sunyi, Z., (1870) Qingjiang Xianzhi 清江县志 Zhongguo Fangzhi Congshu. Chengwen Co. Ltd., pp. 1505–1506.

[55] Yi Zhou Shu 逸周书. (1999) Wenyuan ge Siku Quanshu (Electronic Edition). Shanghai Renmin Press & Dizhi Digital Co. Ltd.

[56] Yu, T., Jianguo, W., Xiaojun, K., Zhongwen, L., Tianming, W., Pu, M. et al. (2009) Spatiotemporal pattern and major causes of the Amur tiger population dynamics. Biodiversity Science, 17(3), 211–225.

[57] Yuanjun, L., (1979) Shuoyuan Jinzhu Jinyi 说苑今注今译. The Commercial Press (Taiwan), Ltd., p. 25.

[58] Zhenhong, Z., Bao ku, Z., & Likai, Z., (1980) The discovery of Fossil Mammals at Anping, Liaoning. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 2, 154–161.

[59] Zhenhong, Z., (1981) The human and the culture of the paleolithic period from liaoning district. Vertebrata Palasiatica, 2, 184–192.

[60] Zhenhong, Z., Renyi, F., Baofeng, C., Jingyu, L., Mingye, Z., Hongkuan, W. et al. (1985) A preliminary report on the excavation of paleolithic site at Xiaogushan of Haicheng, Liaoning province. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 1, 70–79.

[61] Zhihong, C., (2010) Chapter 1: Chinese culture of tiger. In: Y. Hong (Ed.) Chinese national geography: walking with the tiger. Encyclopedia of China Publishing House, pp. 4–52.

[62] Zhiyi, W., (1842) Zhandao Chutian 栈道出田 He Zhongjian. Dao Guang Liuba Tingzhi, from Zhongguo Xibei Wenxian Congshu. Lanzhou Classics Publishing House, p. 403.

[63] Zhonghuang, T., (1926) Chongxiu Zhen’an Xianzhi 重修镇安县志, photocopy version in the 15th year of Republic of China. In: Editorial Committee of the Northwest China Literature Series (1990). Northwest China Literature Series: Rare Local Chronicles Literature of Northwest China. Lanzhou Ancient Books Bookstore.

[64] Zhongwen, L., Jianguo, W., Xiaojun, K., Yu, T., Tianming, W., Pu, M. et al. (2009) Land use pattern and its dynamic changes in Amur tiger distribution region. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 20(3), 713–724.

[65] Zhuchen, T., (1947) Study on the problem of paleolithic period sites in Northeast China. Annals of Committee of Shenyang Museum.

[66] Zhuowei, T., Saihong, L., Zerong, L., & Han, L., (2003) The Late Pleistocene Fauna from Dabusu of Qian’an in Jilin Province. Vertebrata Palasiatica, (2), 137–146.

[67] Zixian, X., (1972) Book of Southern Qi 南齐书, 59. Zhonghua Book Company.

[68] Zuo Zhuan 左传, Yingong wu nian·隐公五年. (1999) Wenyuan ge Siku Quanshu (Electronic Edition) 四库全书 (电子版). Shanghai Renmin Press & Dizhi Digital Co. Ltd.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). Integrative Conservation published by John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd on behalf of Xishuangbanna Tropical Botanical Garden (XTBG).