Extraction of Nb, Ta, Zr and Hf from tin slags originating from cassiterite beneficiation

Abstract

Tin slag is a problematic residue with high economic value that is produced during the refining process of crude tin. Due to the highly refractory nature of these materials, the industrial extraction of the metals contained in the matrix depends on leaching with hydrofluoric acid, which poses problems in the handling and safety of materials. To minimize the effects related to the processing of these materials, a theoretical and experimental investigation was carried out to develop a process through thermal treatment, followed by aqueous or oxidative leaching to obtain a Pregnant Leach Solution (PLS) with the target metals. Here, an approach based on a thermodynamic simulation model is proposed to evaluate the optimal conditions for the maximum extraction of the Nb–Ta and Zr–Hf systems. The experimental results revealed that thermodynamic simulations allowed the identification of the ideal conditions for the formation of sulfates at 200°C, with a slag–H₂SO₄ ratio (g/mL) of 1:4 in a treatment time of 6 h, followed by two leaching routes. Aqueous leaching with a solid–liquid (S/L) ratio (g/mL) of 1:10 at 90°C for 2 h resulted in a recovery of 97% Nb, 61% Ta, 62% Zr, and 75% Hf. Meanwhile, oxidative leaching with a 0.5 M concentration, S/L ratio of 1:10 at 90°C for 2 h, resulted in a recovery of 81% Nb, 99% Ta, 98% Zr, and 99% Hf, confirming the efficiency of the process. This study highlights the importance of thermal treatment, thermodynamic modeling, water content, and the addition of oxidants in effective extraction, providing a pathway to optimize the recovery of economically valuable metals from tin slags.

Keywords

tin slag / niobium / tantalum / zirconium / hafnium

References

[1] Shen HT, Forssberg E. An overview of recovery of metals from slags. Waste Manage., 2003, 23(10): 933.

[2] Research and Markets. Mining Waste Management Market Report by Mining Type, Mineral/Metal, Waste Type, and Region 2025–2033, 2025. [2026-05-13].

[3] O.A. Marín, A. Kraslawski, and L.A. Cisternas, Estimating processing cost for the recovery of valuable elements from mine tailings using dimensional analysis, Miner. Eng., 184(2022), art. No. 107629.

[4] Damm S. DERA Rohstoffinformationen 31, 2018. Berlin, German Mineral Resources Agency (DERA)

[5] Anes IA, Garjulli F, de Carvalho M S, Tenório JAS, Espinosa DCR, Coleti JL. Extraction of niobium in one step from tin slag by NH₄F–HCl leaching process. Can. J. Chem. Eng., 2024, 102(1): 168.

[6] Brocchi EA, Moura FJ. Chlorination methods applied to recover refractory metals from tin slags. Miner. Eng., 2008, 21(2): 150.

[7] Clemente DM, da Silva CA, Peixoto JJM, de Oliveira JR, de Souza RM. Investigation of the presence of metallic phases in Brazilian tin-slags. J. Mater. Res. Technol., 2023, 24: 6861.

[8] Habashi F. Principles of Extractive Metallurgy, 1969. Amsterdam, Gordon and Breach

[9] D.M. Cheje Machaca, T.C. de Carvalho, J.A. Soares Tenório, and D.C. Romano Espinosa, Advancements in the extraction of niobium and tantalum: Innovative strategies in hydrometallurgical processes, Miner. Eng., 222(2025), art. No. 109125.

[10] Y.Q. Ma, S. Stopic, X.W. Wang, K. Forsberg, and B. Friedrich, Basic sulfate precipitation of zirconium from sulfuric acid leach solution, Metals, 10(2020), No. 8, art. No. 1099.

[11] European Commission. Study on the Critical Raw Materials for the EU 2023 – Final Report, 2023. Brussels, European Commission. [2025-10-18].

[12] Office of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy. U.S. Department of Energy Releases 2023 Critical Materials Assessment to Evaluate Supply Chain Security for Clean Energy Technologies, 2023. [2025-09-28].

[13] Mills K. The Southern African Institute of MiningMetallurgy. The estimation of slag properties. Southern African Pyrometallurgy, 201135

[14] Agulyansky A. Chemistry of Tantalum and Niobium Fluoride Compounds, 2004. Amsterdam, Elsevier

[15] Ma YQ, Stopic S, Gronen L, Friedrich B. Recovery of Zr, Hf, Nb from eudialyte residue by sulfuric acid dry digestion and water leaching with H₂O₂ as a promoter. Hydrometallurgy, 2018, 181: 206.

[16] Davidson CF, Crane SR. Dobby GS, Rao SR. Hydrofluoric and sulphuric acid leaching of tantalite. Processing of Complex Ores, 1989. Oxford, Pergamon Press: 507.

[17] Htwe HH, Lwin KT. Study on extraction of niobium oxide from columbite-tantalite concentrate. Int. J. Chem. Mol. Eng., 2008, 2(10): 235

[18] Dibrov IA, Chirkst DE, Litvinova TE. Experimental study of zirconium(IV) extraction from fluoride-containing acid solutions. Russ. J. Appl. Chem., 2002, 75(2): 195.

[19] Steinberg EP. The Radiochemistry of Zirconium and Hafnium, 1960.

[20] Guo X, Li QJ, Wang D. The mechanism of selective dissolution reaction of columbite with H₂SO₄. Min. Metall. Explor., 2023, 40(5): 1695

[21] Aspart A, Antoine CZ. Study of the chemical behavior of hydrofluoric, nitric and sulfuric acids mixtures applied to niobium polishing. Appl. Surf. Sci., 2004, 227(1–4): 17.

[22] Terry B. The acid decomposition of silicate minerals part I. Reactivities and modes of dissolution of silicates. Hydrometallurgy, 1983, 10(2): 135.

[23] Hoar TP, Mears DC, Rothwell GP. The relationships between anodic passivity, brightening and pitting. Corros. Sci., 1965, 5(4): 279.

[24] El-Hussaini OM, Mahdy MA. Sulfuric acid leaching of Kab Amiri niobium–tantalum bearing minerals, Central Eastern Desert, Egypt. Hydrometallurgy, 2002, 64(3): 219.

[25] Yang XL, Zhang JW, Fang XH, Qiu TS. Kinetics of pressure leaching of niobium ore by sulfuric acid. Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard Mater., 2014, 45: 218.

[26] Zhang B, Liu CJ, Li CL, Jiang MF. A novel approach for recovery of rare earths and niobium from Bayan Obo tailings. Miner. Eng., 2014, 65: 17.

[27] Gao WC, Wen JK, Wu B, Shang H. Extraction of niobium, yttrium, and cerium from a low-grade niobium-bearing ore by roasting (NH₄)₂SO₄-Na₂SO₄-H₂SO₄ system. Rare Met., 2014, 33(6): 754.

[28] Wu B, Shang H, Gao WC, Wen JK. Leaching of niobium from low-grade refractory ore using H₂SO₄ roast system. Adv. Mater. Res., 2014, 997: 651.

[29] Zakharov VI, Maiorov DV, Alishkin AR, Matveev VA. Causes of insufficient recovery of zirconium during acidic processing of lovozero eudialyte concentrate. Russ. J. Non-Ferrous Metals, 2011, 52(5): 423.

[30] de Oliveira JM. Estudo de Rota Hidrometalórgica Para Extração de Nióbio e Tantalo Contidos na Escória de Estanho, 2022. São Paulo, University of São Paulo

[31] El-Hazek MN, Amer TE, Abu El-Azm MG, Issa RM, El-Hady SM. Liquid–liquid extraction of tantalum and niobium by octanol from sulfate leach liquor. Arab. J. Chem., 2012, 5(1): 31.

[32] Ding XX, Jiang JX, Zhao YF, Dong ZC, Wang LY, Liu Y. The recovery of sulfuric acid in the presence of Zr(IV) and Hf(IV) by solvent extraction with TEHA and its mixtures. Processes, 2024, 12(5): 940.

[33] Holappa L, Kaçar Y. Reddy RG, Chaubal P, Pistorius PC, Pal P. Slag formation—Thermodynamic and kinetic aspects and mechanisms. Advances in Molten Slags, Fluxes, and Salts, 2016. Cham, Springer: 1017.

[34] M. Huang, Y.J. Shao, X. Li, et al., Process mineralogical study of U/Th occurrence states and the carrier minerals in refractory tantalum slag, Miner. Eng., 205(2024), art. No. 108496.

[35] M. Huang, K. Hu, X. Li, et al., Mineralogical properties of a refractory tantalum-niobium slag and the effect of roasting on the leaching of uranium–thorium, Toxics, 10(2022), No. 8, art. No. 469.

[36] Conrado da Luz V. Extração de Nióbio e Tântalo Contidos na Escória da Produção de Estanho por Lixiviação em Ácido Oxálico, 2023. São Paulo, University of São Paulo

[37] Strydom CA, Pretorius G. The thermal decomposition of zirconium sulphate hydrate. Thermochim. Acta, 1993, 223: 223.

[38] Land JE, Sanchez-Caldas JR. The niobium(V) sulfato species. J. Less Common Met., 1967, 13(2): 233.

[39] Wu B, Shang H, Wen JK. Sulfuric acid leaching of low-grade refractory tantalum–niobium and associated rare earths minerals in Panxi area of China. Rare Met., 2015, 34(3): 202.

[40] Ryabchikov DI, Marov IN, Ermakov AN, Belyaeva VK. Stability of some inorganic and organic complex compounds of zirconium and hafnium. J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem., 1964, 26(6): 965.

[41] El-Hazek MN, Amer TE, Issa RM, Abu El-Azm MG, Omar SA, El-Hady SM. Characterization and breakdown of south gabal EL A’urf polymineralized ore material. Eurasian Chem. Technol. J., 2009, 11(2): 149.

[42] Amer TE, El Assay IE, Rezk AA, El Kammar AM, El Manawi AW, Abu Khoziem HA. Geometallurgy and processing of North Ras Mohamed poly-mineralized ore materials, South Sinai, Egypt. Int. J. Miner. Process., 2014, 129: 12.

[43] Kalaji A, Skanthakumar S, Kanatzidis MG, Mitchell JF, Soderholm L. Changing hafnium speciation in aqueous sulfate solutions: A high-energy X-ray scattering study. Inorg. Chem., 2014, 53(12): 6321.

[44] Ekberg C, Källvenius G, Albinsson Y, Brown PL. Studies on the hydrolytic behavior of zirconium(IV). J. Solution Chem., 2004, 33(1): 47.

[45] Asselin E, Ahmed TM, Alfantazi A. Corrosion of niobium in sulphuric and hydrochloric acid solutions at 75 and 95°C. Corros. Sci., 2007, 49(2): 694.

[46] Sulyma CM, Pettit CM, Surisetty CVVS, Babu SV, Roy D. Electrochemical investigation of the roles of oxyanions in chemical-mechanical planarization of tantalum and tantalum nitride. J. Appl. Electrochem., 2011, 41(5): 561.

[47] Sorensen E, Bjerre AB. On the stabilization of niobium(V) solutions by zirconium(IV) and hafnium(IV). Talanta, 1992, 39(5): 529.

[48] Johnson JS, Kraus KA. Hydrolytic behavior of metal ions. VI. ultracentrifugation of zirconium(IV) and hafnium(IV); effect of acidity on the degree of Polymerization. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1956, 78(16): 3937.

[49] International Atomic Energy Agency. Fundamental Safety Principles: Safety Fundamentals, 2006. Vienna, International Atomic Energy Agency. SF-1

[50] Amaral JCBS, Sa MLCG, Morais CA. Recovery of uranium, thorium and rare earth from industrial residues. Hydrometallurgy, 2018, 181: 148.

[51] X.J. Yang, Z.F. Zhang, S.T. Kuang, et al., Removal of thorium and uranium from leach solutions of ion-adsorption rare earth ores by solvent extraction with Cextrant 230, Hydrometallurgy, 194(2020), art. No. 105343.

[52] A.H. Orabi, B.T. Mohamed, D.A. Ismaiel, and S.S. Elyan, Sequential separation and selective extraction of uranium and thorium from monazite sulfate leach liquor using dipropylamine extractant, Miner. Eng., 172(2021), art. No. 107151.

[53] Deblonde GJP, Bengio D, Beltrami D, Bélair S, Cote G, Chagnes A. A fluoride-free liquid-liquid extraction process for the recovery and separation of niobium and tantalum from alkaline leach solutions. Sep. Purif. Technol., 2019, 215: 634.

[54] B.A.J. Lister and L.A. McDonald, 827. Some aspects of the solution chemistry of zirconium, J. Chem. Soc., (1952), art. No. 4315.

[55] Dinpajooh M, Hightower GL, Overstreet RE, et al.. On the stability constants of metal-nitrate complexes in aqueous solutions. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2025, 27(18): 9350.

[56] Pourbaix M. Atlas of Electrochemical Equilibria in Aqueous Solutions, 1966. Houston, NACE

[57] J. Pellé, N. Gruet, B. Gwinner, M.L. Schlegel, and V. Vivier, On the role of Fe(III) ions on the reduction mechanisms of concentrated nitric acid, Electrochim. Acta, 335(2020), art. No. 135578.

[58] Babko AK, Lukachina VV, Nabivanets BI. Solubility and acid-base properties of tantalum and niobium hydroxides. Russ. J. Inorg. Chem., 1963, 8(8): 957

[59] Argus Media Group. Argus Non-Ferrous Markets, 2025. London, Argus Media Group

[60] U.S. Geological Survey. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2025, 2025. Reston, VA, U.S. Geological Survey

[61] Saklatvala E. The Niche Minerals Now Surging in Price as Defence Spending Booms, 2025. London, Financial Times. [2025-07-20].

[62] Strategic Metals Invest. Hafnium Prices, 2025. [2025-07-21].

[63] ChemAnalyst. Nitric Acid Price Trend and Forecast, 2023

[64] Globe Metals & Mining Ltd. Carbochlorination Vs HF/SX: The Impact On The Environment, 2023. [2024-05-13].

[65] Polyakov EG, Polyakova LP. Current trends in the production of tantalum and niobium. Metallurgist, 2003, 47(1): 33.

[66] Procurement Resource. Sulfuric Acid Price Trend and Forecast, 2025. [2025-11-18].

[67] D.M. Cheje Machaca, R.B. Juyo Salazar, T.C. de Carvalho, D.C. Romano Espinosa, and J.A. Soares Tenório, Recovery of niobium and tantalum from tin slags: An alternative approach using acid roasting and oxalic leaching, Miner. Eng., 232(2025), art. No. 109564.

[68] Jamrack WD. R.M.E. by C.E.T.. Ore breakdown processes. International Series of Monographs in Chemical Engineering, 1963. Oxford, Pergamon Press: 4

[69] Terry B. The acid decomposition of silicate minerals part II. Hydrometallurgical applications. Hydrometallurgy, 1983, 10(2): 151.

[70] King MJ, Davenport WG, Moats MS. King MJ, Davenport WG, Moats MS. Minimizing sulfur emissions. Sustainable Metals and Materials Processing, 2013. Oxford, Elsevier: 341

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s)