Grain refinement of Ti5321G alloy created by ultrasonic energy field during laser powder direct energy deposition

Abstract

The ultrasonic energy field (UEF)-induced grain refinement mechanisms in laser powder direct energy deposition-manufactured Ti5321G alloys were systematically investigated in this study. This study focused on the interplay between recrystallization in the high-temperature solid deposition layers and the ultrasonic cavitation-acoustic streaming effects during molten pool solidification. A novel experimental design was developed to decouple these mechanisms by creating four distinct UEF action zones (without UEF-N, with UEF-S, with UEF-L, and with UEF-S + L) within a single-pass multilayer sample. This approach enabled the dual effects of UEF (recrystallization in solidified layers and ultrasonic cavitation-acoustic streaming effects in liquid pools) to be directly compared. The UEF significantly refined the microstructures, reducing the average grain size by 64.2% (from (399.6 ± 28.6) to (143.1 ± 16.1) µm) in the with UEF-S + L zone, while promoting columnar-to-equiaxed transition, with the equiaxed grain probability increasing from 11.1% (without UEF) to 53.8%. The texture intensity was reduced by approximately 52.4% and the mechanical properties were enhanced, achieving a 6.2% increase in yield strength ((702.0 ± 10.6) MPa) and 31.7% improvement in elongation. Crucially, this study revealed the synergistic effect of the dual-action mechanisms of UEF, where recrystallization and cavitation-acoustic streaming collectively enabled non-linear grain refinement. This study provides a strategy for microstructural control in additive manufacturing, eliminating the need for complex post-processing and thereby advancing the industrial application of high-performance titanium components.

Keywords

laser powder direct energy deposition / ultrasonic energy field / Ti5321G alloy / grain refinement mechanism / mechanical properties

References

[1] Zong HJ, Kang N, Qin ZH, El Mansori M. A review on the multi-scaled structures and mechanical/thermal properties of tool steels fabricated by laser powder bed fusion additive manufacturing. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2024, 3151048.

[2] D.D. Gu, X.Y. Shi, R. Poprawe, D.L. Bourell, R. Setchi, and J.H. Zhu, Material-structure-performance integrated laser-metal additive manufacturing, Science, 372(2021), No. 6545, art. No. eabg1487.

[3] Weng F, Bi GJ, Chew YXet al. . Robust interface and excellent as-built mechanical properties of Ti–6Al–4V fabricated through laser-aided additive manufacturing with powder and wire. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2025, 321154.

[4] Luo YW, Wang MY, Tu JG, Jiang Y, Jiao SQ. Reduction of residual stress in porous Ti6Al4V by in situ double scanning during laser additive manufacturing. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2021, 28111844.

[5] Lan L, Xin RY, Jin XY, Gao S, He B. Influence of multiple laser shock peening treatments on the microstructure and mechanical properties of Ti–6Al–4V alloy fabricated by electron beam melting. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2022, 2991780.

[6] Wu LZ, Zhang C, Khan DFet al. . Unveiling the cellular microstructure–property relations in martensitic stainless steel via laser powder bed fusion. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2024, 31112476.

[7] Pirro G, Martucci A, Morri A, Lombardi M, Ceschini L. A novel solution treatment and aging for powder bed fusion-laser beam Ti–6Al–2Sn–4Zr–6Mo alloy: Microstructural and mechanical characterization. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2025, 322414.

[8] J. Peng, J. Li, B. Liu, Q.H. Fang, and P.K. Liaw, Origin of thermal deformation induced crystallization and microstructure formation in additive manufactured FCC, BCC, HCP metals and its alloys, Int. J. Plast., 172(2024), art. No. 103831.

[9] Cui QH, Liu XF, Wang WJet al. . Microstructure and forming mechanism of metals subjected to ultrasonic vibration plastic forming: A mini review. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2024, 3161322.

[10] H.F. Lu, W.W. Deng, K.Y. Luo, Y.H. Chen, J. Wang, and J.Z. Lu, Tailoring microstructure of additively manufactured Ti6Al4V titanium alloy using hybrid additive manufacturing technology, Addit. Manuf., 63(2023), art. No. 103416.

[11] J.M. Lv, Y.C. Liang, X. Xu, et al., Performance-control-orientated hybrid metal additive manufacturing technologies: State of the art, challenges, and future trends, Int. J. Extrem. Manuf., 6(2024), No. 3, art. No. 032009.

[12] Ma HY, Wang JC, Qin Pet al. . Advances in additively manufactured titanium alloys by powder bed fusion and directed energy deposition: Microstructure, defects, and mechanical behavior. J. Mater. Sci. Technol.. 2024, 18332.

[13] Chen MM, Shi RH, Liu ZZet al. . Phase-field simulation of lack-of-fusion defect and grain growth during laser powder bed fusion of Inconel 718. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2023, 30112224.

[14] Guo N, Cheng Q, Fu YLet al. . Microstructure and microhardness of aluminium alloy with underwater and in-air wire-feed laser deposition. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2023, 304670.

[15] Yu J, Geng YX, Chen YKet al. . High-strength and thermally stable TiB₂-modified Al–Mn–Mg–E–Zr alloy fabricated via selective laser melting. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2024, 31102221.

[16] Zhang DY, Qiu D, Gibson MAet al. . Additive manufacturing of ultrafine-grained high-strength titanium alloys. Nature. 2019, 576778591.

[17] Li XS, Sukhomlinov D, Que ZQ. Microstructure and thermal properties of dissimilar M300-CuCr1Zr alloys by multimaterial laser-based powder bed fusion. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2024, 311118.

[18] G.H. Zhang, X.F. Lu, J.Q. Li, et al., In-situ grain structure control in directed energy deposition of Ti6Al4V, Addit. Manuf., 55(2022), art. No. 102865.

[19] Long JZ, Zhou C, Wang Get al. . Novel non-equilibrium partitioning model and a developed strong and ductile Al–7.5Mg–0.5Sc–0.3Zr–0.6Si alloy for selective laser melting. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2025, 3271669.

[20] Xu JJ, Ding HL, Lin X, Liu F. Effect of hot isostatic pressure on the microstructure and tensile properties of γ^″-strengthened superalloy fabricated through induction-assisted directed energy deposition. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2024, 3151089.

[21] Chen HY, Gu DD, Ge Qet al. . Role of laser scan strategies in defect control, microstructural evolution and mechanical properties of steel matrix composites prepared by laser additive manufacturing. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2021, 283462.

[22] D. Yuan, S.Q. Shao, C.H. Guo, F.C. Jiang, and J.D. Wang, Grain refining of Ti–6Al–4V alloy fabricated by laser and wire additive manufacturing assisted with ultrasonic vibration, Ultrason. Sonochem., 73(2021), art. No. 105472.

[23] Yang MX, Zheng H, Qi BJ, Yang Z. Effect of arc behavior on Ti–6Al–4V welds during high frequency pulsed arc welding. J. Mater. Process. Technol.. 2017, 2439.

[24] J.K. Huang, G.Y. Liu, X.Q. Yu, et al., Microstructure regulation of titanium alloy functionally gradient materials fabricated by alternating current assisted wire arc additive manufacturing, Mater. Des., 218(2022), art. No. 110731.

[25] C.J. Todaro, M.A. Easton, D. Qiu, et al., Grain structure control during metal 3D printing by high-intensity ultrasound, Nat. Commun., 11(2020), art. No. 142.

[26] D. Yuan, X.J. Sun, L.B. Sun, et al., Improvement of the grain structure and mechanical properties of austenitic stainless steel fabricated by laser and wire additive manufacturing assisted with ultrasonic vibration, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 813(2021), art. No. 141177.

[27] D.J. Wu, C.C. Song, T.D. Di, F.Y. Niu, and G.Y. Ma, Inter-metallic regulation mechanism of inconel 718/Ti6Al4V composite by novel follow-up ultrasonic assisted laser additive manufacturing, Composites Part B: Eng., 235(2022), art. No. 109736.

[28] Li XZ, Fang XW, Zhang MG, Wang BL, Huang K. Enhanced strength-ductility synergy of magnesium alloy fabricated by ultrasound assisted directed energy deposition. J. Mater. Sci. Technol.. 2024, 178247.

[29] K.C. Hu, T.L. Hsieh, and J.Y. Lin, Improving interfacial strength at room and elevated temperatures in ultrasonic welding of pure titanium: Interlayer-induced phase transformation and concentrated plastic deformation, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 902(2024), art. No. 146629.

[30] M.X. Diao, C.H. Guo, Q.F. Sun, et al., Improving mechanical properties of austenitic stainless steel by the grain refinement in wire and arc additive manufacturing assisted with ultrasonic impact treatment, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 857(2022), art. No. 144044.

[31] X. Li, B. Guan, Y.L. Wang, Y.L. Wei, and B. Li, Ascertaining the microstructural evolution and strengthening mechanisms of the gradient nanostructured pure titanium fabricated by ultrasonic surface rolling process, Surf. Coat. Technol., 473(2023), art. No. 130047.

[32] Long AR. The attenuation of high frequency phonons in metals. J. Phys. F: Met. Phys.. 1973, 3122023.

[33] Y. Iijima and N. Kudo, Evaluation of frequency-dependent ultrasound attenuation in transparent medium using focused shadowgraph technique, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 56(2017), No. 7S1, art. No. 07JF13.

[34] G.R. Jiang, Z.B. Chen, C.M. Liu, et al., Recrystallization and twinning enhancing mechanical property of laser directed energy deposited CoCrFeNi high entropy alloys induced by synchronous ultrasonic impact, Addit. Manuf., 93(2024), art. No. 104410.

[35] Z. Wang, F.C. Jiang, C.H. Guo, et al., Effects of ultrasonic vibration on microstructure and mechanical properties of 1Cr12Ni3MoVN alloy fabricated by directed energy deposition, Ultrasonics, 132(2023), art. No. 106989.

[36] Li ZT, Ma SH, Zhao SJet al. . Achieving superb strength in single-phase FCC alloys via maximizing volume misfit. Mater. Today. 2023, 63108.

[37] H. Li, Y. Liu, W.J. Zhao, et al., Deformation mechanism of a strong and ductile maraging steel investigated using in-situ X-ray synchrotron diffraction, Int. J. Plast., 165(2023), art. No. 103612.

[38] Zhao GH, Liang XZ, Kim B, Rivera-Díaz-del-Castillo PEJ. Modelling strengthening mechanisms in beta-type Ti alloys. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2019, 756156.

[39] M.X. Diao, C.H. Guo, S. Wang, et al., Influence of laser power on grain refinement of Ti5321G alloy fabricated by laser powder direct energy deposition assisted with ultrasonic energy field, Adv. Eng. Mater., 27(2025), No. 12, art. No. 2403002.

[40] C.P. Zhou, F.C. Jiang, D. Xu, et al., A calculation model to predict the impact stress field and depth of plastic deformation zone of additive manufactured parts in the process of ultrasonic impact treatment, J. Mater. Process. Technol., 280(2020), art. No. 116599.

[41] Y.H. Chen, M.F. Xu, T.M. Zhang, et al., Grain refinement and mechanical properties improvement of Inconel 625 alloy fabricated by ultrasonic-assisted wire and arc additive manufacturing, J. Alloys Compd., 910(2022), art. No. 164957.

[42] T.Z. Wang, V. Mazánová, and X. Liu, Ultrasonic effects on gas tungsten arc based wire additive manufacturing of aluminum matrix nanocomposite, Mater. Des., 214(2022), art. No. 110393.

[43] A. Vorontsov, S. Astafurov, E. Melnikov, V. Moskvina, E. Kolubaev, and E. Astafurova, The microstructure, phase composition and tensile properties of austenitic stainless steel in a wire-feed electron beam melting combined with ultrasonic vibration, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 820(2021), art. No. 141519.

[44] N. Kang, X. Lin, M. El Mansori, et al., On the effect of the thermal cycle during the directed energy deposition application to the in-situ production of a Ti–Mo alloy functionally graded structure, Addit. Manuf., 31(2020), art. No. 100911.

[45] N. Kang, K. Wu, J. Kang, J.C. Li, X. Lin, and W.D. Huang, Effect of cycling heat treatment on the microstructure, phase, and compression behaviour of directed energy deposited Ti–Mo alloys, Light. Adv. Manuf., 2(2021), No. 2, art. No. 136.

[46] Z.J. Zhang, N.C. Parson, and W.J. Poole, Precipitation on grain boundaries in Al–Mg–Si alloys: The role of grain boundary misorientation, Scripta Mater., 211(2022), art. No. 114494.

[47] Nakanishi D, Kawabata T, Aihara S. Brittle crack propagation resistance inside grain and at high angle grain boundary in 3% Si–Fe alloy. Acta Mater.. 2018, 144768.

[48] C.J. Todaro, M.A. Easton, D. Qiu, M. Brandt, D.H. StJohn, and M. Qian, Grain refinement of stainless steel in ultrasound-assisted additive manufacturing, Addit. Manuf., 37(2021), art. No. 101632.

[49] Liu GZ, Zhao QY, Jia WJet al. . Slip systems of lamellar α and damage tolerance properties in Ti-5321 alloys formed by laser cladding. J. Mater. Res. Technol.. 2024, 31579.

[50] Ren L, Xiao WL, Chang H, Zhao YQ, Ma CL, Zhou L. Microstructural tailoring and mechanical properties of a multi-alloyed near β titanium alloy Ti-5321 with various heat treatment. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2018, 711553.

[51] Song B, An MY, Xi HLet al. . Simultaneous improvement of strength and ductility in near β Ti alloy with (α + β) hybrid structure via intermediate phases transformation. J. Mater. Res. Technol.. 2024, 302576.

[52] G.Z. Liu, Q.Y. Zhao, W.J. Jia, et al., Microscopic crack propagation mechanism and fatigue crack growth behavior of Ti-5321 alloy formed by laser cladding, J. Alloy. Compd., 1026(2025), art. No. 178937.

[53] Song B, Xiao WL, Ma CL, Zhou L. Influence of phase transformation kinetics on the microstructure and mechanical properties of near β titanium alloy. Mater. Charact.. 2019, 148224.

[54] B. Song, Y. Chen, W.L. Xiao, L. Zhou, and C.L. Ma, Formation of intermediate phases and their influences on the microstructure of high strength near-β titanium alloy, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 793(2020), art. No. 139886.

[55] C.F. Li, W.L. Lu, D.Z. Wang, Y.H. Ren, C. Wang, and G. Yang, Selective laser melting of near Ti-5321 β titanium alloy: Microstructure, mechanical properties and deformation mechanism, Intermetallics, 180(2025), art. No. 108688.

[56] B. Song, W.L. Xiao, C.L. Ma, and L. Zhou, Tuning the strength and ductility of near β titanium alloy Ti-5321 by ω and O′ intermediate phases via low-temperature aging, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 855(2022), art. No. 143919.

[57] Yan CK, Feng AH, Qu SJ, Sun JL, Shen J. Hot deformation and grain refinement mechanisms of commercially pure titanium processed via three-directional cryo-compression. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2018, 731266.

[58] Zhou P, Liang ZY, Huang MX. Microstructural evolution of a nanotwinned steel under extremely high-strain-rate deformation. Acta Mater.. 2018, 149407.

[59] Y.Z. Yu, Y. Zhang, S.S. Xu, et al., High–strain–rate deformation of a nanoprecipitate–strengthened dual–phase steel, Int. J. Plast., 173(2024), art. No. 103887.

[60] C.M. Liu, C.H. Guo, T. Dong, et al., An optimization strategy based on critical recrystallization strain to improve the recrystallization rate of ultrasonic impact treatment assisted laser directed energy deposition, J. Mater. Process. Technol., 338(2025), art. No. 118774.

[61] He BL, Xiong L, Jiang MM, Yu YX, Li L. Surface grain refinement mechanism of SMA490BW steel cross joints by ultrasonic impact treatment. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2017, 244410.

[62] Y.L. Wang, Y.L. Zhu, and Z.H. Cai, Gradient layer of ultrafine equiaxed grains produced by ultrasonic energy accelerated dynamic recrystallization, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 795(2020), art. No. 139958.

[63] Yuan T, Kou S, Luo Z. Grain refining by ultrasonic stirring of the weld pool. Acta Mater.. 2016, 106144.

[64] Ning FD, Hu YB, Cong WL. Microstructure and mechanical property of TiB reinforced Ti matrix composites fabricated by ultrasonic vibration-assisted laser engineered net shaping. Rapid Prototyp. J.. 2019, 253581.

[65] Li Q, You GQ, Wang L, Zeng S, Yao FJ, Hou JC. Coupled effect of ultrasonic vibration and post-weld remelting on the porosity and microstructure of die-cast magnesium alloy AZ91D. J. Manuf. Process.. 2022, 83742.

[66] Q.K. Fan, C. Chen, C.L. Fan, et al., Ultrasonic induces grain refinement in gas tungsten arc cladding AlCoCrFeNi high-entropy alloy coatings, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 821(2021), art. No. 141607.

[67] Huang K, Logé RE. A review of dynamic recrystallization phenomena in metallic materials. Mater. Des.. 2016, 111548.

[68] Pinto FC, Aota LS, Souza Filho IR, Raabe D, Sandim HRZ. Recrystallization in non-conventional microstructures of 316L stainless steel produced via laser powder-bed fusion: Effect of particle coarsening kinetics. J. Mater. Sci.. 2022, 57219576.

[69] S.B. Gao, Z. Li, S. Van Petegem, et al., Additive manufacturing of alloys with programmable microstructure and properties, Nat. Commun., 14(2023), No. 1, art. No. 6752.

[70] L. Zhou, S.Y. Chen, M.Z. Ma, J. liang, J.L. Chen, and M. Wang, The dynamic recrystallization mechanism of ultrasonic power on non-contact ultrasonic-assisted direct laser deposited alloy steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 840(2022), art. No. 142971.

[71] W. Woo, Y.S. Kim, H.B. Chae, et al., Competitive strengthening between dislocation slip and twinning in cast-wrought and additively manufactured CrCoNi medium entropy alloys, Acta Mater., 246(2023), art. No. 118699.

[72] Gussev MN, Sridharan N, Thompson Z, Terrani KA, Babu SS. Influence of hot isostatic pressing on the performance of aluminum alloy fabricated by ultrasonic additive manufacturing. Scripta Mater.. 2018, 14533.

[73] Z.C. Yang, L.D. Zhu, J.S. Ning, et al., Revealing the influence of ultrasound/heat treatment on microstructure evolution and tensile failure behavior in 3D-printing of Inconel 718, J. Mater. Process. Technol., 305(2022), art. No. 117574.

[74] L. Zhou, S.Y. Chen, C.Y. Zhang, et al., Microstructure evolution and properties of direct laser deposited 24CrNiMoY alloy steel assisted by non-contact ultrasonic treatment, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 811(2021), art. No. 141088.

[75] Bertsch KM, Meric de Bellefon G, Kuehl B, Thoma DJ. Origin of dislocation structures in an additively manufactured austenitic stainless steel 316L. Acta Mater.. 2020, 19919.

[76] J.P. Li, W.G. Jiang, Y. Zhang, et al., Formation of core-shell nanoprecipitates and their effects on work hardening in an ultrahigh-strength stainless steel, Int. J. Plast., 184(2025), art. No. 104184.

[77] J.P. Li, Y. Zhang, W.G. Jiang, et al., Enhancing work hardening through tuning TRIP by nano-precipitates in maraging stainless steels, Int. J. Plast., 186(2025), art. No. 104265.

[78] Yasi JA, Hector LGJr.Trinkle DR. First-principles data for solid-solution strengthening of magnesium: From geometry and chemistry to properties. Acta Mater.. 2010, 58175704.

[79] J.P. Li, W.G. Jiang, Y. Zhang, et al., Evolution and strengthening of nanoprecipitates in a high strength maraging stainless steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 915(2024), art. No. 147198.

[80] Y. Meng, X.H. Ju, and X.P. Yang, The measurement of the dislocation density using TEM, Mater. Charact., 175(2021), art. No. 111065.

[81] J. Gallet, M. Perez, R. Guillou, et al., Experimental measurement of dislocation density in metallic materials: A quantitative comparison between measurements techniques (XRD, R-ECCI, HR-EBSD, TEM), Mater. Charact., 199(2023), art. No. 112842.

[82] Li XP, Ji G, Chen Zet al. . Selective laser melting of nano-TiB₂ decorated AlSi10Mg alloy with high fracture strength and ductility. Acta Mater.. 2017, 129183.

[83] Toda-Caraballo I, Galindo-Nava EI, Rivera-Díaz-del-Castillo PEJ. Understanding the factors influencing yield strength on Mg alloys. Acta Mater.. 2014, 75287.

[84] Wu D, Zhang JY, Huang JC, Bei H, Nieh TG. Grain-boundary strengthening in nanocrystalline chromium and the Hall–Petch coefficient of body-centered cubic metals. Scripta Mater.. 2013, 682118.

[85] Cordero ZC, Knight BE, Schuh CA. Six decades of the Hall–Petch effect—a survey of grain-size strengthening studies on pure metals. Int. Mater. Rev.. 2016, 618495.

[86] Brinckmann S, Siegmund T, Huang YG. A dislocation density based strain gradient model. Int. J. Plast.. 2006, 2291784.

[87] Satheesh Kumar SS, Pavithra B, Singh V, Ghosal P, Raghu T. Tensile anisotropy associated microstructural and microtextural evolution in a metastable beta titanium alloy. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2019, 7471.

[88] G.H. Zhao, X.Q. Li, and N. Petrinic, Materials information and mechanical response of TRIP/TWIP Ti alloys, npj Comput. Mater., 7(2021), art. No. 91.

[89] S. Li, J.Y. Li, Z.W. Jiang, et al., Controlling the columnar-to-equiaxed transition during directed energy deposition of inconel 625, Addit. Manuf., 57(2022), art. No. 102958.

[90] H. Ning, C. Wang, Y.P. Gao, et al., Understanding the deformation behaviours of Mg alloys with dispersed non-basal grain-embedded orientation heterostructures, Acta Mater., 267(2024), art. No. 119727.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

University of Science and Technology Beijing