Effects and mechanisms of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ on the flotation of columbite–tantalite in NaOL systems

Abstract

Tantalum (Ta) and niobium (Nb) are key strategic metals used in the aerospace, steel, and chemical industries. Columbite–tantalite is the primary Ta- and Nb-containing mineral. Flotation is an effective and practical approach for preconcentrating columbite–tantalite. However, the inevitable introduction of Ca, Mg, and other ions from process water and mineral dissolution during beneficiation can significantly affect the flotation performance of columbite–tantalite. This study systematically investigated the effects of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ on columbite–tantalite flotation in a sodium oleate (NaOL) system. Flotation experiments revealed that, at pH = 10, the addition of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ markedly suppressed the flotation of columbite–tantalite, reducing the recovery by 94.86% and 92.55%, respectively. Characterization revealed that NaOL forms a hexagonal ring structure with Mn sites on the columbite–tantalite (100) crystal surface. However, Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ ions interfere with the chemical adsorption of NaOL by reacting with it to form oleate precipitates, which subsequently cover the mineral surface. Therefore, excess NaOL did not facilitate the effective flotation of columbite–tantalite. Furthermore, NaOL, as compared with the columbite–tantalite surface, tended to interact with Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ to deactivate the collector. This paper elucidates the inhibitory effects of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ on the flotation of columbite–tantalite. Consequently, the selective removal of metal ions, such as Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺, from the slurry is essential to improve both the flotation efficiency and recovery of columbite–tantalite, particularly when processing ores with high water hardness or containing easily leachable metal ions.

Keywords

calcium ion / magnesium ion / columbite–tantalite flotation / depression mechanism / density functional theory calculation

References

[1] Deblonde GJP, Bengio D, Beltrami D, Bélair S, Cote G, Chagnes A. A fluoride-free liquid–liquid extraction process for the recovery and separation of niobium and tantalum from alkaline leach solutions. Sep. Purif. Technol.. 2019, 215634.

[2] Nguyen TH, Lee MS. A review on the separation of niobium and tantalum by solvent extraction. Miner. Process. Extr. Metall. Rev.. 2019, 404265.

[3] Liu ZR, Xiu TY, Du Y, Wang Y. Leaching characteristics and kinetics of radioactive element uranium and thorium from Ta/Nb tailing. J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem.. 2020, 32331197.

[4] Li JK, Li P, Wang DH, Li XJ. A review of niobium and tantalum metallogenic regularity in China. Chin. Sci. Bull.. 2019, 64151545.

[5] Ungerer MJ, Westhuizen DJVD, Lachmann G, Krieg HM. Comparison of extractants for the separation of TaF₅ and NbF₅ in different acidic media. Hydrometallurgy. 2014, 144195.

[6] Fiege A, Kirchner C, Holtz F, Linnen RL, Dziony W. Influence of fluorine on the solubility of manganotantalite (MnTa₂O₆) and manganocolumbite (MnNb₂O₆) in granitic melts – An experimental study. Lithos. 2011, 1223–4165.

[7] D.K. Rajak, R. Jordaan, A.G. Arias, and W. Purcell, Extractive metallurgy of columbite-tantalite ore: A detailed review, Miner. Eng., 190(2022), art. No. 107917.

[8] Allain E, Kanari N, Diot F, Yvon J. Development of a process for the concentration of the strategic tantalum and niobium oxides from tin slags. Miner. Eng.. 2019, 13497.

[9] Gaballah I, Allain E, Djona M. Extraction of tantalum and niobium from tin slags by chlorination and carbochlorination. Metall. Mater. Trans. B. 1997, 283359.

[10] Rare Metal Manual Preparation Committee. Reral Metal Manual. 1997, Beijing, Metallurgical Industry Press

[11] W.J. Jiang, X. Tong, X. Xie, B.W. Kang, and Y. Zhao, Summary on beneficiation technology of tantalum-niobium ores, Metal Mine, (2019), No. 11, p. 120.

[12] Y. Ghorbani, R. Fitzpatrick, M. Kinchington, G. Rollinson, and P. Hegarty, A process mineralogy approach to gravity concentration of tantalum bearing minerals, Minerals, 7(2017), No. 10, art. No. 194.

[13] Hassan ERE, Mutelet F, Abdel-Khalek NA, Youssef MA, Abdallah MM, El-Menshawy AH. Beneficiation and separation of Egyptian tantalite ore. Key Eng. Mater.. 2020, 835208.

[14] Nete M, Koko F, Theron T, Purcell W, Nel JT. Primary beneficiation of tantalite using magnetic separation and acid leaching. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2014, 21121153.

[15] Nete M, Purcell W. Ramasami P, Gupta Bhowon M, Jhaumeer Laulloo S, Li Kam Wah H. Beneficiation of niobium and tantalum from tantalite ore using physical and chemical processes. Emerging Trends in Chemical Sciences. 2017, Cham, Springer267

[16] Wang RJ, Wang DH, Li JK, Sun Y, Li DX. Rare Earth Mineral Resources and Their Development and Ultization. 2015, Beijing, Geological Publishing House

[17] Menéndez M, Vidal A, Torao J, Gent M. Optimisation of spodumene flotation. Euro. J. Min. Process. Environ. Prot.. 2004, 42130

[18] Tadesse B, Makuei F, Albijanic B, Dyer L. The beneficiation of lithium minerals from hard rock ores: A review. Miner. Eng.. 2019, 131170.

[19] Huang WF, Li XD, Xiao YH, Wen JL, Chen YY. Experimental study on recycling tantalum-niobium from secondary slime. Bull. Chin. Ceram. Soc.. 2013, 321138

[20] Deblonde GJP, Weigel V, Bellier Qet al. . Selective recovery of niobium and tantalum from low-grade concentrates using a simple and fluoride-free process. Sep. Purif. Technol.. 2016, 162180.

[21] Purcell W, Potgieter H, Nete M, Mnculwane H. Possible methodology for niobium, tantalum and scandium separation in ferrocolumbite. Miner. Eng.. 2018, 11957.

[22] M. Cao, H. Bu, and Y.D. Gao, A mixed collector system for columbite–tantalite flotation, Miner. Eng., 161(2021), art. No. 106715.

[23] Bulatovic SM. 23-Flotation of tantalum/niobium ores. Handbook of Flotation Reagents: Chemistry, Theory and Practice. 2010, Amsterdam, Elsevier127.

[24] Zhou SZ, Sun CY. Research progress on beneficiation of tantalum niobium ore. Min. Metall.. 2002, 11175Suppl

[25] Y.D. Gao, N. Zou and T.S. Dong, A new folwsheet to recovery fine tantanlite–columbite, Nonferrous Met. Miner. Process. Sect., (2004), No. 1, p. 30.

[26] J.L. Wu and Y. Fan, Comparative test of slime beneficiation technology of Dajishan tantalum niobium tungsten ore, Mod. Min., (2016), No. 4, p. 100.

[27] Bale MD, May AV. Processing of ores to produce tantalum and lithium. Miner. Eng.. 1989, 23299.

[28] Naufonov TB, Zhou JL. Electric double layer state in flotation of tantalite and some associated minerals. Metallic Ore Dressing Abroad. 1964, 1029

[29] Gao ZY, Jiang ZY, Sun W, Gao YS. Typical roles of metal ions in mineral flotation: A review. Trans. Nonferrous Met. Soc. China. 2021, 3172081.

[30] Ni X, Parrent M, Cao ML, Huang LM, Bouajila A, Liu Q. Developing flotation reagents for niobium oxide recovery from carbonatite Nb ores. Miner. Eng.. 2012, 36111.

[31] Bulatovic SM. 22-Flotation of niobium. Handbook of Flotation Reagents: Chemistry, Theory and Practice. 2010, Amsterdam, Elsevier111.

[32] Zeng QY, Lin ZL, Pan SY, Peng ST. Ore substance composition and ccurrence of songshugang greisenized granite type tantalum-niobium deposit. Miner. Explor.. 2021, 1281765

[33] Zhang Q, Li ZL, Liu S, Li J, Huang P, He DS. Experimental study on magnetic separation of Nb–Ta ore. Nonferrous Min. Metall.. 2020, 36622

[34] Wei MA, Sun CY. Influence of metal cations in pulp to chalcopyrite and galena floatability. Nonferrous Metals. 2008, 60292

[35] J.M. Hao, J. Liu, Y.L. Yu, H.L. Gao, X.Y. Qin, and X. Bai, Depressants for separation of chalcopyrite and molybdenite: Review and prospects, Miner. Eng., 201(2023), art. No. 108209.

[36] Zhang J, Wang WQ, Liu J, Huang Y, Feng QM, Zhao H. Fe(III) as an activator for the flotation of spodumene, albite, and quartz minerals. Miner. Eng.. 2014, 6116.

[37] R.Q. Xie, Y.M. Zhu, J. Liu, and Y.J. Li, Effects of metal ions on the flotation separation of spodumene from feldspar and quartz, Miner. Eng., 168(2021), art. No. 106931.

[38] Liu WJ, Zhang SQ, Wang WQet al. . The effects of Ca(II) and Mg(II) ions on the flotation of spodumene using NaOL. Miner. Eng.. 2015, 7940.

[39] J.D. Gao, W. Sun, and F. Lyu, Understanding the activation mechanism of Ca²⁺ ion in sodium oleate flotation of spodumene: A new perspective, Chem. Eng. Sci., 244(2021), art. No. 116742.

[40] M. Cao, H. Bu, Q.B. Meng, and Y.D. Gao, Effect of surface modification by lead ions on flotation behavior of columbite–tantalite, Colloids Surf. A: Physicochem. Eng. Aspects, 611(2021), art. No. 125827.

[41] W.D. Zhang, Q.L. Ren, R.Y. Tu, et al., The application of a novel amine collector, 1-(dodecylamino)-2-propanol, in the reverse flotation separation of apatite and quartz, J. Mol. Liq., 399(2024), art. No. 124377.

[42] Zheng YL, Liu C, Lei SYet al. . Water quality characteristics of groundwater with high hardness in China and its treatment requirement. China Water Wastewate. 2018, 341812

[43] Y.S. Du, Q.Y. Meng, Z.T. Yuan, L.Q. Ma, X. Zhao, and Y.K. Xu, Study on the flotation behavior and mechanism of ilmenite and titanaugite with sodium oleate, Miner. Eng., 152(2020), art. No. 106366.

[44] Y.J. Hu, G.H. Ye, Q. Zuo, et al., Activation of ilmenite flotation by sodium chlorite in the sodium oleate system, Sep. Purif. Technol., 305(2023), art. No. 122506.

[45] Atanassova E, Dimitrova T, Koprinarova J. AES and XPS study of thin RF-sputtered Ta₂O₅ layers. Appl. Surf. Sci.. 1995, 842193.

[46] Kerrec O, Devilliers D, Groult H, Marcus P. Study of dry and electrogenerated Ta₂O₅ and Ta/Ta₂O₅/Pt structures by XPS. Mater. Sci. Eng. B. 1998, 551–2134.

[47] R. Bi, X. Li, and Q. Zhang, Effect of OHA and OHA combined with sodium linoleate on niobite flotation, Nonferrous Met. Min. Process. Sec., (2021), No.6, p. 107.

[48] Z.K. Cui, T. Wang and F. Jiao, Study on the mechanism of Ca²⁺ selective activation of alkali-corrosion surfaces of spodumene and albite, Appl. Surf. Sci., 684(2025), art. No. 161827.

[49] X. Lin, Z.Y. Zhang, F. Jiao, and Q. Wei, Process and mechanism of recovery of lepidolite and spodumene by flotation with synergistic action of alkali corrosion and Mg(II), Powder Technol., 443(2024), art. No. 119962.

[50] W.B. Liu, T. Zheng, Y.L. Wang, et al., Enhancement mechanism of metal ions on the flotation behavior of muscovite in sodium oleate system, Miner. Eng., 218(2024), art. No. 109035.

[51] R. Xu, Y. Liu, N. Sun, et al., The activation role of Mg²⁺ in the lepidolite flotation using NaOL, Sep. Purif. Technol., 351(2024), art. No. 128035.

[52] E. Muhoza, W.C. Zhang, and S.H. Amini, Systematic investigation on bastnaesite flotation in the presence of dissolved calcium ions using organic acids as chelating agents, Miner. Eng., 218(2024), art. No. 108977.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

University of Science and Technology Beijing