Review of precipitation strengthening in ultrahigh-strength martensitic steel

Abstract

Martensite is an important microstructure in ultrahigh-strength steels, and enhancing the strength of martensitic steels often involves the introduction of precipitated phases within the martensitic matrix. Despite considerable research efforts devoted to this area, a systematic summary of these advancements is lacking. This review focuses on the precipitates prevalent in ultrahigh-strength martensitic steel, primarily carbides (e.g., MC, M₂C, and M₃C) and intermetallic compounds (e.g., NiAl, Ni₃X, and Fe₂Mo). The precipitation-strengthening effect of these precipitates on ultrahigh-strength martensitic steel is discussed from the aspects of heat treatment processes, microstructure of precipitate-strengthened martensite matrix, and mechanical performance. Finally, a perspective on the development of precipitation-strengthened martensitic steel is presented to contribute to the advancement of ultrahigh-strength martensitic steel. This review highlights significant findings, ongoing challenges, and opportunities in the development of ultrahigh-strength martensitic steel.

Keywords

ultrahigh-strength martensitic steel / precipitation strengthening / mechanical property / carbide / intermetallic compound

References

[1] Dong H, Lian XT, Hu CD, et al. . High performance steels: The scenario of theory and technology. Acta Metall. Sin.. 2020, 56(4): 558

[2] Nedelcu I, Carceanu I. Some aspects concerning the mechanism of hardening of maraging 300 steel. Metall. Int.. 2013, 18: 95

[3] A.K. da Silva, I.R.S. Filho, W. Lu, et al., A sustainable ultrahigh strength Fe18Mn3Ti maraging steel through controlled solute segregation and α-Mn nanoprecipitation, Nat. Commun., 13(2022), No. 1, art. No. 2330.

[4] D.P.M. da Fonseca, A.L.M. Feitosa, L.G. de Carvalho, R.L. Plaut, and A.F. Padilha, A short review on ultra-high-strength maraging steels and future perspectives, Mater. Res., 24(2021), No. 1, art. No. e20200470.

[5] Alves TJB, Nunes GCS, Tupan LFS, et al. . Aging-induced transformations of maraging-400 alloys. Metall. Mater. Trans. A. 2018, 49(8): 3441

[6] Viswanathan UK, Dey GK, Asundi MK. Precipitation hardening in 350 grade maraging steel. Metall. Trans. A. 1993, 24(11): 2429

[7] He Y, Yang K, Qu WS, Kong FY, Su GY. Strengthening and toughening of a 2800-MPa grade maraging steel. Mater. Lett.. 2002, 56(5): 763

[8] He Y, Yang K, Sha W, Cleland DJ. Microstructure and mechanical properties of a 2000 MPa Co-free maraging steel after aging at 753 K. Metall. Mater. Trans. A. 2004, 35(9): 2747

[9] Xu W, Rivera-Díaz-del-Castillo PEJ, Wang W, et al. . Genetic design and characterization of novel ultra-high-strength stainless steels strengthened by Ni₃Ti intermetallic nanoprecipitates. Acta Mater.. 2010, 58(10): 3582

[10] Zhang YP, Zhan DP, Qi XW, Jiang ZH. Austenite and precipitation in secondary-hardening ultra-high-strength stainless steel. Mater. Charact.. 2018, 144: 393

[11] H.L. Zhang, G.Q. Zhang, H.C. Zhou, et al., Influence of cooling rate during cryogenic treatment on the hierarchical micro-structure and mechanical properties of M54 secondary hardening steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 851(2022), art. No. 143659.

[12] Li XY, Zhang ZH, Liu LJ, et al. . Structure transformations and mechanical properties of the ultra-high-strength M54 steel produced by spark plasma sintering. Powder Metall. Met. Ceram.. 2022, 61(1): 40

[13] Veerababu R, Balamuralikrishnan R, Karthikeyan S. Nanoscale clusters in secondary hardening ultra-high strength steels with 1 and 3 wt% Mo: An atom probe investigation. J. Mater. Res.. 2020, 35(14): 1763

[14] Veerababu R, Balamuralikrishnan R, Muraleedharan K, Srinivas M. Investigation of clusters in medium carbon secondary hardening ultra-high-strength steel after hardening and aging treatments. Metall. Mater. Trans. A. 2015, 46(6): 2455

[15] Kim YK, Kim KS, Song YB, Park JH, Lee KA. 2.47 GPa grade ultra-strong 15Co–12Ni secondary hardening steel with superior ductility and fracture toughness. J. Mater. Sci. Technol.. 2021, 66: 36

[16] X.Y. Li, Z.H. Zhang, X.W. Cheng, G.J. Huo, Q. Song, and Y. Xu, Direct achievement of ultra-high strength and good ductility for high Co–Ni secondary hardening steel by combining spark plasma sintering and deformation, Mater. Lett., 290(2021), art. No. 129465.

[17] Zhang YP, Zhan DP, Qi XW, Jiang ZH. Effect of solid-solution temperature on the microstructure and properties of ultra-high-strength ferrium S53® steel. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2018, 730: 41

[18] Y.B. Xiong, D.X. Wen, Z.Z. Zheng, and J.J. Li, Effect of inter-layer temperature on microstructure evolution and mechanical performance of wire arc additive manufactured 300M steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 831(2022), art. No. 142351.

[19] Bag A, Delbergue D, Bocher P, Lévesque M, Brochu M. Statistical analysis of high cycle fatigue life and inclusion size distribution in shot peened 300M steel. Int. J. Fatigue. 2019, 118: 126

[20] Torres MAS, Voorwald HJC. An evaluation of shot peening, residual stress and stress relaxation on the fatigue life of AISI 4340 steel. Int. J. Fatigue. 2002, 24(8): 877

[21] Floreen S. The physical metallurgy of maraging steels. Metall. Rev.. 1968, 13(1): 115

[22] Manigandan K, Srivatsan TS, Tammana D, Poorganji B, Vasudevan VK. Influence of microstructure on strain-controlled fatigue and fracture behavior of ultra high strength alloy steel AerMet 100. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2014, 601: 29

[23] Wang XL, Xie ZJ, Li XC, Shang CJ. Recent progress in visualization and digitization of coherent transformation structures and application in high-strength steel. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2024, 31(6): 1298

[24] Lu ZP, Jiang SH, He JY, et al. . Second phase strengthening in advanced metal materials. Acta Metall. Sin.. 2016, 52(10): 1183

[25] Dong J, Zhou XS, Liu YC, Li C, Liu CX, Guo QY. Carbide precipitation in Nb–V–Ti microalloyed ultra-high strength steel during tempering. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2017, 683: 215

[26] Li YF, Cheng X, Liu D, Wang HM. Influence of last stage heat treatment on microstructure and mechanical properties of laser additive manufactured AF1410 steel. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2018, 713: 75

[27] Mondiere A, Déneux V, Binot N, Delagnes D. Controlling the MC and M₂C carbide precipitation in Ferrium® M54® steel to achieve optimum ultimate tensile strength/fracture toughness balance. Mater. Charact.. 2018, 140: 103

[28] X.D. Nong, X.J. Xiong, X. Gu, et al., A novel low-cost ultra-strong maraging steel by additive manufacturing, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 887(2023), art. No. 145747.

[29] D.P.M. da Fonseca, M.V.P. Altoé, B.S. Archanjo, E. Annese, and A.F. Padilha, Influence of Mo content on the precipitation behavior of 13Ni maraging ultra-high strength steels, Metals, 13(2023), No. 12, art. No. 1929.

[30] Zhou M, Wu HH, Wu Y, et al. . Phase field modeling of grain stability of nanocrystalline alloys by explicitly incorporating mismatch strain. Rare Met.. 2024, 43(7): 3370

[31] D.C. Ramachandran, J. Moon, C.H. Lee, et al., Role of bainitic microstructures with M–A constituent on the toughness of an HSLA steel for seismic resistant structural applications, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 801(2021), art. No. 140390.

[32] H.K. Dong, H. Chen, A.R. Khorasgani, et al., Revealing the influence of Mo addition on interphase precipitation in Ti-bearing low carbon steels, Acta Mater., 223(2022), art. No. 117475.

[33] L.Y. Kan, Q.B. Ye, Z.D. Wang, and T. Zhao, Improvement of strength and toughness of 1 GPa Cu-bearing HSLA steel by direct quenching, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 855(2022), art. No. 143875.

[34] C. Ledermueller, H.I. Pratiwi, R.F. Webster, M. Eizadjou, S.P. Ringer, and S. Primig, Microalloying effects of Mo versus Cr in HSLA steels with ultrafine-grained ferrite microstructures, Mater. Des., 185(2020), art. No. 108278.

[35] Z.D. Wang, G.F. Sun, M.Z. Chen, et al., Investigation of the underwater laser directed energy deposition technique for the on-site repair of HSLA-100 steel with excellent performance, Ad-dit. Manuf., 39(2021), art. No. 101884.

[36] J. Lu, H. Yu, and S.F. Yang, Mechanical behavior of multistage heat-treated HSLA steel based on examinations of microstructural evolution, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 803(2021), art. No. 140493.

[37] Cheng Z, Wang SZ, Wu GL, Gao JH, Yang XS, Wu HH. Tribological properties of high-entropy alloys: A review. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2022, 29(3): 389

[38] Vervynckt S, Verbeken K, Lopez B, Jonas JJ. Modern HSLA steels and role of non-recrystallisation temperature. Int. Mater. Rev.. 2012, 57(4): 187

[39] Baker TN. Microalloyed steels. Ironmaking Steelmaking. 2016, 43(4): 264

[40] Wang SZ, Gao ZJ, Wu GL, Mao XP. Titanium mi-croalloying of steel: A review of its effects on processing, microstructure and mechanical properties. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2022, 29(4): 645

[41] Ioannidou C, Arechabaleta Z, Navarro-López A, et al. . Interaction of precipitation with austenite-to-ferrite phase transformation in vanadium micro-alloyed steels. Acta Mater.. 2019, 181: 10

[42] Gong P, Liu XG, Rijkenberg A, Rainforth WM. The effect of molybdenum on interphase precipitation and microstructures in microalloyed steels containing titanium and vanadium. Acta Mater.. 2018, 161: 374

[43] J. Lu, S.Z. Wang, H. Yu, et al., Effect of precipitation on the mechanical behavior of vanadium micro-alloyed HSLA steel investigated by microstructural evolution and strength modeling, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 881(2023), art. No. 145313.

[44] Snir Y, Haroush S, Dannon A, Landau A, Eliezer D, Gelbstein Y. Aging condition and trapped hydrogen effects on the mechanical behavior of a precipitation hardened martensitic stainless steel. J. Alloys Compd.. 2019, 805: 509

[45] Pan GF, Wang FY, Shang CL, et al. . Advances in machine learning- and artificial intelligence-assisted material design of steels. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2023, 30(6): 1003

[46] Sonar T, Lomte S, Gogte C. Cryogenic treatment of metal-A review. Mater. Today Proc.. 2018, 5(11): 25219

[47] Das D, Dutta AK, Ray KK. Influence of varied cryo-treatment on the wear behavior of AISI D2 steel. Wear. 2009, 266(1–2): 297

[48] Z.J. Yan, K. Liu, and J. Eckert, Effect of tempering and deep cryogenic treatment on microstructure and mechanical properties of Cr–Mo–V–Ni steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 787(2020), art. No. 139520.

[49] Yan XG, Li DY. Effects of the sub-zero treatment condition on microstructure, mechanical behavior and wear resistance of W9Mo3Cr4V high speed steel. Wear. 2013, 302(12): 854

[50] Das D, Dutta AK, Ray KK. Inconsistent wear behaviour of cryotreated tool steels: Role of mode and mechanism. Mater. Sci. Technol.. 2009, 25(10): 1249

[51] Mónica P, Bravo PM, Cárdenas D. Deep cryogenic treatment of HPDC AZ91 magnesium alloys prior to aging and its influence on alloy microstructure and mechanical properties. J. Mater. Process. Technol.. 2017, 239: 297

[52] Sonar T, Lomte S, Gogte C, Balasubramanian V. Minimization of distortion in heat treated AISI D2 tool steel: Mechanism and distortion analysis. Procedia Manuf.. 2018, 20: 113

[53] Jaswin MA, Lal DM. Effect of cryogenic treatment on the tensile behaviour of En 52 and 21–4N valve steels at room and elevated temperatures. Mater. Des.. 2011, 32(4): 2429

[54] Yong AYL, Seah KHW, Rahman M. Performance of cryogenically treated tungsten carbide tools in milling operations. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol.. 2007, 32(7): 638

[55] Vadivel K, Rudramoorthy R. Performance analysis of cryo-genically treated coated carbide inserts. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol.. 2009, 42(3): 222

[56] Z.J. Weng, K.X. Gu, K.K. Wang, X.Z. Liu, and J.J. Wang, The reinforcement role of deep cryogenic treatment on the strength and toughness of alloy structural steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 772(2020), art. No. 138698.

[57] Z. Yang, Z.B. Liu, J.X. Liang, Z.Y. Yang, and G.M. Sheng, Elucidating the role of secondary cryogenic treatment on mechanical properties of a martensitic ultra-high strength stainless steel, Mater. Charact., 178(2021), art. No. 111277.

[58] Kimura Y, Inoue T, Yin FX, Tsuzaki K. Inverse temperature dependence of toughness in an ultrafine grain-structure steel. Science. 2008, 320(5879): 1057

[59] He BB, Hu B, Yen HW, et al. . High dislocation density-induced large ductility in deformed and partitioned steels. Science. 2017, 357(6355): 1029

[60] Jiang SH, Wang H, Wu Y, et al. . Ultrastrong steel via minimal lattice misfit and high-density nanoprecipitation. Nature. 2017, 544: 460

[61] J.J. Sun, Y.N. Liu, Y.T. Zhu,et al., Super-strong dislocation-structured high-carbon martensite steel, Sci. Rep., 7(2017), art. No. 6596.

[62] Gao YH, Liu SZ, Hu XB, et al. . A novel low cost 2000 MPa grade ultra-high strength steel with balanced strength and toughness. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2019, 759: 298

[63] M.S. Baek, Y.K. Kim, T.W. Park, J. Ham, and K.A. Lee, Hot-rolling and a subsequent direct-quenching process enable superior high-cycle fatigue resistance in ultra-high strength low alloy steels, Materials, 13(2020), No. 20, art. No. 4651.

[64] Wang YJ, Sun JJ, Jiang T, Sun Y, Guo SW, Liu YN. A low-alloy high-carbon martensite steel with 2.6 GPa tensile strength and good ductility. Acta Mater.. 2018, 158: 247

[65] J.M. Zhu, H.H. Wu, Y. Wu, et al., Influence of Ni₄Ti₃ precipitation on martensitic transformations in NiTi shape memory alloy: R phase transformation, Acta Mater., 207(2021), art. No. 116665.

[66] Z.J. Gao, S.Z. Wang, H.H. Wu, J.Y. Li, and X.P. Mao, Understanding the mismatch strain and orientation of nanoscale second phase on the superelasticity of zirconia, Compos. Commun., 22(2020), art. No. 100521.

[67] Kapoor M, Isheim D, Vaynman S, Fine ME, Chung YW. Effects of increased alloying element content on NiAl-type precipitate formation, loading rate sensitivity, and ductility of Cu- and NiAl-precipitation-strengthened ferritic steels. Acta Mater.. 2016, 104: 166

[68] B.C. Zhou, T. Yang, G. Zhou, H. Wang, J.H. Luan, and Z.B. Jiao, Mechanisms for suppressing discontinuous precipitation and improving mechanical properties of NiAl-strengthened steels through nanoscale Cu partitioning, Acta Mater., 205(2021), art. No. 116561.

[69] Sun WW, Marceau RKW, Styles MJ, Barbier D, Hutchinson CR. G phase precipitation and strengthening in ultrahigh strength ferritic steels: Towards lean ‘maraging’ metallurgy. Acta Mater.. 2017, 130: 28

[70] Millán J, Sandlöbes S, Al-Zubi A, et al. . Designing Heusler nanoprecipitates by elastic misfit stabilization in Fe–Mn maraging steels. Acta Mater.. 2014, 76: 94

[71] Kapoor M, Isheim D, Ghosh G, Vaynman S, Fine ME, Chung YW. Aging characteristics and mechanical properties of 1600MPa body-centered cubic Cu and B2-NiAl precipitation-strengthened ferritic steel. Acta Mater.. 2014, 73: 56

[72] Li Y, Li W, Liu WQ, et al. . The austenite reversion and co-precipitation behavior of an ultra-low carbon medium manganese quenching–partitioning–tempering steel. Acta Mater.. 2018, 146: 126

[73] Jiao ZB, Luan JH, Miller MK, Liu CT. Precipitation mechanism and mechanical properties of an ultra-high strength steel hardened by nanoscale NiAl and Cu particles. Acta Mater.. 2015, 97: 58

[74] X.C. Yang, X.J. Di, Q.Y. Duan, W. Fu, L.Z. Ba, and C.N. Li, Effect of precipitation evolution of NiAl and Cu nanoparticles on strengthening mechanism of low carbon ultra-high strength seamless tube steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 872(2023), art. No. 144939.

[75] Sha W, Ye A, Malinov S, Wilson EA. Microstructure and mechanical properties of low nickel maraging steel. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2012, 536: 129

[76] Qian F, Sharp J, Rainforth WM. Microstructural evolution of Mn-based maraging steels and their influences on mechanical properties. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2016, 674: 286

[77] A. Behravan, A. Zarei-Hanzaki, S.M. Fatemi, H.F.G. De Abreu, and M. Masoumi, The effect of aging temperature on micro-structure and tensile properties of a novel designed Fe–12Mn–3Ni maraging-TRIP steel, Steel Res. Int., 90(2019), No. 2, art. No. 1800282.

[78] K. Li, L. Wei, B. Yu, and R.D.K. Misra, Reverted austenite with distinct characteristics in a new cobalt-free low lattice misfit precipitate-bearing 19Ni3Mo1.5Ti maraging steel, Mater. Lett., 257(2019), art. No. 126692.

[79] Qian F, Rainforth WM. The formation mechanism of reverted austenite in Mn-based maraging steels. J. Mater. Sci.. 2019, 54(8): 6624

[80] Galindo-Nava EI, Rainforth WM, Rivera-Díaz-del-Castillo PEJ. Predicting microstructure and strength of maraging steels: Elemental optimisation. Acta Mater.. 2016, 117: 270

[81] Zhang HL, Sun MY, Ma DP, et al. . Effect of aging temperature on the heterogeneous microstructure and mechanical properties of a 12Cr–10Ni–Mo–Ti maraging steel for cryogenic applications. J. Mater. Sci.. 2021, 56(19): 11469

[82] Bodziak S, Al-Rubaie KS, Valentina LD, et al. . Precipitation in 300 grade maraging steel built by selective laser melting: Aging at 510 °C for 2h. Mater. Charact.. 2019, 151: 73

[83] Jägle EA, Choi PP, Humbeeck JV, Raabe D. Precipitation and austenite reversion behavior of a maraging steel produced by selective laser melting. J. Mater. Res.. 2014, 29(17): 2072

[84] Vasudevan VK, Kim SJ, Wayman CM. Precipitation reactions and strengthening behavior in 18 Wt Pct nickel maraging steels. Metall. Trans. A. 1990, 21(10): 2655

[85] T.Z. Xu, S. Zhang, Y. Du, et al., Development and characterization of a novel maraging steel fabricated by laser additive manufacturing, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 891(2024), art. No. 145975.

[86] Y. Du, T.Z. Xu, S. Zhang, et al., Effect of aging treatment on the microstructure and tribological properties of a new maraging steel manufactured by laser directed energy deposition, Mater. Charact., 209(2024), art. No. 113767.

[87] Pardal JM, Tavares SSM, Terra VF, Silva MRD, Santos DRD. Modeling of precipitation hardening during the aging and overaging of 18Ni–Co–Mo–Ti maraging 300 steel. J. Alloys Compd.. 2005, 393(1–2): 109

[88] J.J.M. da Silva, I.F. de Vasconcelos, F.I.S. da Silva, T.S. Ribeiro, and H.F.G. de Abreu, An atomic redistribution study of the 440°C ageing kinetics in maraging-300 steel, Mater. Res., 22(2019), No. 1, art. No. e20180230.

[89] T.Z. Xu, S. Zhang, L. Wang, et al., Influence of scanning speed on the microstructure, nanoindentation characteristics and tribological behavior of novel maraging steel coatings by laser cladding, Mater. Charact., 205(2023), art. No. 113335.

[90] El-Meligy M, El-Bitar T, Ebied S. Creation of fine lath martensite combined with nano needle like structured carbides in ultra high strength (UHS) military Steel. J. Ultrafine Grained Nanostruct. Mater.. 2023, 56(2): 173

[91] M.J. Yang, C. Huang, Z.F. Yao, et al., Development of a high-strength Fe–12Mn maraging steel via designing lath interfacial and intragranular nanostructures, Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 886(2023), art. No. 145280.

[92] Zhang ZY, Chai F, Luo XB, Chen G, Yang CF, Su H. The strengthening mechanism of Cu bearing high strength steel as-quenched and tempered and Cu precipitation behavior in steel. Acta Metall. Sin.. 2019, 55(6): 783

[93] Gladman T. Precipitation hardening in metals. Mater. Sci. Technol.. 1999, 15(1): 30

[94] Proville L, Bakó B. Dislocation depinning from ordered nanophases in a model fcc crystal: From cutting mechanism to Orowan looping. Acta Mater.. 2010, 58(17): 5565

[95] Fang QH, Li L, Li J, et al. . A statistical theory of probability-dependent precipitation strengthening in metals and alloys. J. Mech. Phys. Solids. 2019, 122: 177

[96] Han P, Liu ZP, Xie ZJ, et al. . Influence of band microstructure on carbide precipitation behavior and toughness of 1 GPa-grade ultra-heavy gauge low-alloy steel. Int. J. Miner. Metall. Mater.. 2023, 30(7): 1329

[97] Xie ZJ, Fang YP, Han G, Guo H, Misra RDK, Shang CJ. Structure-property relationship in a 960MPa grade ultrahigh strength low carbon niobium-vanadium microalloyed steel: The significance of high frequency induction tempering. Mater. Sci. Eng. A. 2014, 618: 112

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

University of Science and Technology Beijing