Big Disaster from Small Watershed: Insights into the Failure and Disaster-Causing Mechanism of a Debris Flow on 25 September 2021 in Tianquan, China

Abstract

The occurrence of debris flow events in small-scale watersheds with dense vegetation in mountainous areas that result in significant loss of life and missing individuals challenges our understanding and expertise in investigating and preventing these disasters. This has raised concerns about the occurrence of large debris flow disasters from small watersheds. This study focused on a catastrophic debris flow that took place in Longtou Gully (0.45 km²) in Tianquan County, Ya’an City on 25 September 2021, which resulted in 14 deaths and missing individuals. Through comprehensive field investigations, high-precision remote sensing data analyses, and numerical simulations, we analyzed the triggering mechanisms and dynamic processes of this event. Our results indicate that the convergence hollow at the channel head exhibited higher hydraulic conditions during rainfall compared to gentle slopes and convex terrains, leading to the instability of colluvial soil due to the expansion of the saturated zone near the soil–bedrock interface. The entrainment of material eroded from the channel resulted in an approximately 4.7 times increase in volume, and the channel scarp with a height of about 200 m amplified the destructive power of the debris flow. We emphasize the need to take seriously the possibility of catastrophic debris flows in small-scale watersheds, with colluvial deposits in hollows at the channel head under vegetation cover that serve as precursor material sources, and the presence of channel scarps formed by changes in the incision rate of the main river, which is common in the small watershed on both sides. This study provides insights for risk assessment of debris flows in small-scale catchments with dense vegetation cover in mountainous areas, highlighting the importance of vigilance in addressing disasters in small-scale catchments, particularly in regions with increasing human–environment conflicts.

Keywords

China / Colluvial soil / Low-frequency debris flows / Risk reduction / Topographic hollows

References

[] Abbate A, Papini M, Longoni L. Analysis of meteorological parameters triggering rainfall-induced landslide: A review of 70 years in Valtellina. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2021, 21: 2041-2058,

[] Alvioli M, Baum RL. Parallelization of the TRIGRS model for rainfall-induced landslides using the message passing interface. Environmental Modelling & Software, 2016, 81: 122-135,

[] Aubertin M, Mbonimpa M, Bussière BR, Chapuis R. A model to predict the water retention curve from basic geotechnical properties. Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 2003, 40: 1104-1122,

[] Benda, L., and T. Dunne. 1987. Sediment routing by debris flow (Transport des sédiments par les coulées clastiques). In Erosion and sedimentation in the Pacific Rim: Proceedings of the Corvallis Symposium, 213–223. Wallingford, CT: International Association of Hydrological Sciences.

[] Bordoni M, Meisina C, Valentino R, Lu N, Bittelli M, Chersich S. Hydrological factors affecting rainfall-induced shallow landslides: From field monitoring to a simplified slope stability analysis. Engineering Geology, 2015, 193: 19-37,

[] Chen, N., P. Cui, Z. Liu, and F. Wei. 2003. Calculation of debris flow bulk density based on clay particle content. Scientia Sinica Technologica 33(s1): 164–174 (in Chinese).

[] Chen N, Tian S, Zhang Y, Wang Z. Soil mass domination in debris-flow disasters and strategy for hazard mitigation. Earth Science Frontiers, 2021, 28: 337-348

[] Cui P, Zhou GGD, Zhu XH, Zhang JQ. Scale amplification of natural debris flows caused by cascading landslide dam failures. Geomorphology, 2013, 182: 173-189,

[] D’Odorico P, Fagherazzi S. A probabilistic model of rainfall-triggered shallow landslides in hollows: A long-term analysis. Water Resources Research, 2003, 39(9): Article 126

[] Dietrich, W.E., T. Dunne, N.F. Humphrey, and L.M. Reid. 1982. Construction of sediment budgets for drainage basins. In Sediment Budgets and Routing in Forested Drainage Basins: Proceedings of the Symposium, 31 May–1 June 1982, Corvallis, Oregon, 5–23.

[] Dowling CA, Santi PM. Debris flows and their toll on human life: A global analysis of debris-flow fatalities from 1950 to 2011. Natural Hazards, 2014, 71: 203-227,

[] Fan X, Scaringi G, Domènech G, Yang F, Guo X, Dai L, He C, Xu Q, et al.. Two multi-temporal datasets that track the enhanced landsliding after the 2008 Wenchuan Earthquake. Earth System Science Data, 2019, 11: 35-55,

[] Frank F, McArdell BW, Huggel C, Vieli A. The importance of entrainment and bulking on debris flow runout modeling: Examples from the Swiss Alps. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2015, 15: 2569-2583,

[] Frank F, McArdell BW, Oggier N, Baer P, Christen M, Vieli A. Debris-flow modeling at Meretschibach and Bondasca catchments, Switzerland: Sensitivity testing of field-data-based entrainment model. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2017, 17: 801-815,

[] Gao YC, Chen NS, Hu GS, Deng MF. Magnitude-frequency relationship of debris flows in the Jiangjia Gully, China. Journal of Mountain Science, 2019, 16: 1289-1299,

[] Grabs T, Seibert J, Bishop K, Laudon H. Modeling spatial patterns of saturated areas: A comparison of the topographic wetness index and a dynamic distributed model. Journal of Hydrology, 2009, 373: 15-23,

[] Griffiths PG, Webb RH, Melis TS. Frequency and initiation of debris flows in Grand Canyon, Arizona. Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface, 2004, 109: Article F04002,

[] Guo X, Cui P, Li Y, Ma L, Ge Y, Mahoney WB. Intensity-duration threshold of rainfall-triggered debris flows in the Wenchuan Earthquake affected area, China. Geomorphology, 2016, 253: 208-216,

[] Hales TC, Scharer KM, Wooten RM. Southern Appalachian hillslope erosion rates measured by soil and detrital radiocarbon in hollows. Geomorphology, 2012, 138: 121-129,

[] Han, M. 2018. Hazard mechanism research of wide-gentle and narrow-steep channels debris flow in Wenchuan Earthquake region. PhD dissertation. Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu, China.

[] He J, Zhang L, Fan R, Zhou S, Luo H, Peng D. Evaluating effectiveness of mitigation measures for large debris flows in Wenchuan, China. Landslides, 2022, 19: 913-928,

[] Hungr O, Evans SG. Entrainment of debris in rock avalanches: An analysis of a long run-out mechanism. GSA Bulletin, 2004, 116: 1240-1252,

[] Hussin HY, Quan Luna B, van Westen CJ, Christen M, Malet JP, van Asch TW. Parameterization of a numerical 2-D debris flow model with entrainment: A case study of the Faucon catchment, Southern French Alps. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2012, 12: 3075-3090,

[] Iverson RM. The physics of debris flows. Reviews of Geophysics, 1997, 35: 245-296,

[] Kiefer C, Oswald P, Moernaut J, Fabbri SC, Mayr C, Strasser M, Krautblatter M. A 4000-year debris flow record based on amphibious investigations of fan delta activity in Plansee (Austria, Eastern Alps). Earth Surface Dynamics, 2021, 9: 1481-1503,

[] Lanni C, McDonnell J, Hopp L, Rigon R. Simulated effect of soil depth and bedrock topography on near-surface hydrologic response and slope stability. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 2013, 38: 146-159,

[] Li Y, Liu J, Su F, Xie J, Wang B. Relationship between grain composition and debris flow characteristics: A case study of the Jiangjia Gully in China. Landslides, 2015, 12: 19-28,

[] Liang W-L, Uchida T. Effects of topography and soil depth on saturated-zone dynamics in steep hillslopes explored using the three-dimensional Richards’ equation. Journal of Hydrology, 2014, 510: 124-136,

[] Liang W-L, Uchida T. Performance and topographic preferences of dynamic and steady models for shallow landslide prediction in a small catchment. Landslides, 2022, 19: 51-66,

[] Liu C, Yu Z, Zhao S. A coupled SPH-DEM-FEM model for fluid-particle-structure interaction and a case study of Wenjia Gully debris flow impact estimation. Landslides, 2021, 18: 2403-2425,

[] Lu N, Godt J. Infinite slope stability under steady unsaturated seepage conditions. Water Resources Research, 2008, 44: Article W11404,

[] Lu N, Godt JW, Wu DT. A closed-form equation for effective stress in unsaturated soil. Water Resources Research, 2010, 46: W05515,

[] Marotti JC, Gomes GJC, Velloso RQ, Vargas Júnior EA, Nunes RS, Fernandes NF. Exploring extreme rainfall-triggered landslides using 3D unsaturated flow, antecedent moisture and spatially distributed soil depth. CATENA, 2023, 229: Article 107241,

[] Meunier PC. Recognition, classification and mechanical description of debris flows. Earth-Science Reviews, 1996, 40(3–4): 209-227

[] Montgomery DR. Road surface drainage, channel initiation, and slope instability. Water Resources Research, 1994, 30: 1925-1932,

[] Montgomery DR, Dietrich WE. A physically-based model for the topographic control on shallow landsliding. Water Resources Research, 1994, 30: 1153-1171,

[] Penserini BD, Roering JJ, Streig A. A morphologic proxy for debris flow erosion with application to the earthquake deformation cycle, Cascadia Subduction Zone, USA. Geomorphology, 2017, 282: 150-161,

[] Pérez FL. Matrix granulometry of catastrophic debris flows (December 1999) in central coastal Venezuela. CATENA, 2001, 45: 163-183,

[] Prancevic JP, Lamb MP, McArdell BW, Rickli C, Kirchner JW. Decreasing landslide erosion on steeper slopes in soil-mantled landscapes. Geophysical Research Letters, 2020, 47: Article e2020GL087505,

[] Reneau SL, Dietrich WE. Erosion rates in the southern Oregon Coast Range: Evidence for an equilibrium between hillslope erosion and sediment yield. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 1991, 16: 307-322,

[] Reneau SI, Dietrich WE, Donahue DJ, Jull AJT, Rubin M. Late Quaternary history of colluvial deposition and erosion in hollows, central California coast ranges. Geological Society of America Bulletin, 1990, 102: 969-982,

[] Reneau SL, Dietrich WE, Dorn RI, Berger CR, Rubin M. Geomorphic and paleoclimatic implications of latest Pleistocene radiocarbon-dates from colluvium-mantled hollows, California. Geology, 1986, 14: 655-658,

[] Reneau SL, Dietrich WE, Rubin M, Donahue DJ, Jull AJT. Analysis of hillslope erosion rates using dated colluvial deposits. The Journal of Geology, 1989, 97: 45-63,

[] Rigon R, Bertoldi G, Over TM. GEOtop: A distributed hydrological model with coupled water and energy budgets. Journal of Hydrometeorology, 2006, 7: 371-388,

[] Saulnier GM, Beven K, Obled C. Including spatially variable effective soil depths in TOPMODEL. Journal of Hydrology, 1997, 202: 158-172,

[] Schürch P, Densmore AL, Rosser NJ, Lim M, McArdell BW. Detection of surface change in complex topography using terrestrial laser scanning: Application to the Illgraben debris-flow channel. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 2011, 36: 1847-1859,

[] Schürch P, Densmore AL, Rosser NJ, McArdell BW. Dynamic controls on erosion and deposition on debris-flow fans. Geology, 2011, 39: 827-830,

[] Segoni S, Rossi G, Catani F. Improving basin-scale shallow landslide modelling using reliable soil thickness maps. Natural Hazards, 2012, 61: 85-101,

[] Simoni S, Zanotti F, Bertoldi G, Rigon R. Modelling the probability of occurrence of shallow landslides and channelized debris flows using GEOtop-FS. Hydrological Processes, 2008, 22: 532-545,

[] Song D-B, Yin Z-Y, Li P-L, Yin J-H. One-dimensional elastic viscoplastic finite strain consolidation model for soft clay with uncertainty. Acta Geotechnica, 2023, 18: 4671-4686,

[] Thouret JC, Antoine S, Magill C, Ollier C. Lahars and debris flows: Characteristics and impacts. Earth-Science Reviews, 2020, 201: Article 103003,

[] Tian S, Chen N, Rahman M, Hu G, Peng T, Zhang Y, Liu M. New insights into the occurrence of the catastrophic Zhaiban slope debris flow that occurred in a dry valley in the Hengduan Mountains in southwest China. Landslides, 2022, 19: 647-657,

[] Tian S, Hu G, Chen N, Rahman M, Han Z, Somos-Valenzuela M, Habumugisha JM. Effects of tectonic setting and hydraulic properties on silent large-scale landslides: A case study of the Zhaobishan Landslide, China. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2023, 14(4): 600-617,

[] Tian S, Hu G, Chen N, Rahman M, Ni H, Somos-Valenzuela M, Habumugisha JM. Extreme climate and tectonic controls on the generation of a large-scale, low-frequency debris flow. Catena, 2022, 212: Article 106086,

[] Tufano R, Formetta G, Calcaterra D, De Vita P. Hydrological control of soil thickness spatial variability on the initiation of rainfall-induced shallow landslides using a three-dimensional model. Landslides, 2021, 18: 3367-3380,

[] van Genuchten MT. A closed-form equation for predicting the hydraulic conductivity of unsaturated soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 1980, 44: 892-898,

[] Verstraeten G, Rommens T, Peeters I, Poesen J, Govers G, Lang A. A temporarily changing Holocene sediment budget for a loess-covered catchment (central Belgium). Geomorphology, 2009, 108: 24-34,

[] Xiong J, Tang C, Gong L, Chen M, Li N, Shi Q, Zhang X, Chang M, Li M. How landslide sediments are transferred out of an alpine basin: Evidence from the epicentre of the Wenchuan Earthquake. CATENA, 2022, 208: Article 105781,

[] Xiong J, Tang C, Tang H, Chen M, Zhang X, Shi Q, Chang M, Gong L, et al.. Long-term hillslope erosion and landslide-channel coupling in the area of the catastrophic Wenchuan Earthquake. Engineering Geology, 2022, 305: Article 106727,

[] Xue Y, Miao F, Wu Y, Dias D, Li L. Combining soil spatial variation and weakening of the groundwater fluctuation zone for the probabilistic stability analysis of a riverside landslide in the Three Gorges Reservoir area. Landslides, 2023, 20: 1013-1029,

[] Ye T, Shi P, Cui P. Integrated disaster risk research of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau under climate change. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2023, 14(4): 507-509,

[] Zhang Y, Chen N, Liu M, Wang T, Deng M, Wu K, Khanal BR. Debris flows originating from colluvium deposits in hollow regions during a heavy storm process in Taining, southeastern China. Landslides, 2020, 17: 335-347,

[] Zhao S, Chigira M, Wu X. Gigantic rockslides induced by fluvial incision in the Diexi area along the eastern margin of the Tibetan Plateau. Geomorphology, 2019, 338: 27-42,

[] Zheng H, Shi Z, Hanley KJ, Peng M, Guan S, Feng S, Chen K, Chen K. Deposition characteristics of debris flows in a lateral flume considering upstream entrainment. Geomorphology, 2021, 394: Article 107960,

[] Zhou W, Qiu H, Wang L, Pei Y, Tang B, Ma S, Yang D, Cao M. Combining rainfall-induced shallow landslides and subsequent debris flows for hazard chain prediction. CATENA, 2022, 213: Article 106199,