A Methodology for Vulnerability Assessment of Cultural Heritage in Extreme Climate Changes

Abstract

Vulnerability evaluation plays a key role in risk assessment and reduction and is essential for defining strategies for climate change adaptation and mitigation. In dealing with the safeguarding of cultural heritage at risk, we are still far from adopting and applying an agreed methodology for vulnerability assessment. With the aim to support practitioners, heritage managers, and policy and decision makers to undertake actions that address the protection of cultural heritage at risk, the methodology set up in the framework of the Interreg Central Europe STRENCH is illustrated and discussed here. Based on three major requirements (susceptibility, exposure, and resilience) and a continuous consultation with local stakeholders, the proposed methodology is applicable for evaluating the vulnerability of built heritage and cultural landscape exposed to hydrometeorological hazards, such as heavy rains, floods, and droughts. The results obtained through its validation on 15 case studies from seven Central European regions are shown to underline the strengths and limitations of the methodological approach. Iterative consultation with local stakeholders was fundamental for the definition of the criteria/subcriteria and related values for the assessment of the requirements. Application to further sites in other contexts would surely contribute to strengthening the reliability of the methodological approach.

Keywords

Built and natural heritage / Exposure / Heritage vulnerability / Resilience / Risk management / Susceptibility

References

[] Appiotti F, Assumma V, Bottero M, Campostrini P, Datola G, Lombardi P, Rinaldi E. Definition of a risk assessment model within a European Interoperable Database Platform (EID) for cultural heritage. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2020, 46: 268-277,

[] Balica SF, Wright NG, van der Meulen F. A flood vulnerability index for coastal cities and its use in assessing climate change impacts. Natural Hazards, 2012, 64: 73-105,

[] Birkmann J. . Measuring vulnerability to natural hazards – Towards disaster-resilient societies, 2006 Tokyo UNU Press

[] Bohle, H.-G. 2001. Vulnerability and criticality: Perspectives from social geography. IHDP Update 2/2001. Newsletter of the International Human Dimensions Programme on Global Environmental Change.

[] Boix-Cots, D., F. Pardo-Bosch, A. Blanco, A. Aguado, and P. Pujadas. 2022. A systematic review on MIVES: A sustainability-oriented multi-criteria decision-making method. Building and Environment 223: Article 109515.

[] Bonazza A, Sardella A. Climate change and cultural heritage: Methods and approaches for damage and risk assessment addressed to a practical application. Heritage, 2023, 6(4): 3578-3589,

[] Bonazza, A., A. Sardella, A. Kaiser, R. Cacciotti, P. De Nuntiis, C. Hanus, I. Maxwell, T. Drdácký, and M. Drdácký. 2021. Safeguarding cultural heritage from climate change related hydrometeorological hazards in Central Europe. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 63: Article 102455.

[] Bosher L, Kim D, Okubo T, Chmutina K, Jigyasu R. Dealing with multiple hazards and threats on cultural heritage sites: An assessment of 80 case studies. Disaster Prevention and Management, 2019, 29(1): 109-128,

[] Briz E, Garmendia L, Marcos I, Gandini A. Improving the resilience of historic areas coping with natural and climate change hazards: Interventions based on multi-criteria methodology. International Journal of Architectural Heritage, 2023,

[] Cacciotti, R., A. Kaiser, A. Sardella, P. De Nuntiis, M. Drdácký, C. Hanus, and A. Bonazza. 2021. Climate change-induced disasters and cultural heritage: Optimizing management strategies in Central Europe. Climate Risk Management 32: Article 100301.

[] Cardona OD, Van Aalst MK, Birkmann J, Fordham M, Mc Gregor G, Rosa P, Pulwarty RS, Schipper ELF, et al.. Field CB, Barros V, Stocker TF, Qin D, Dokken DJ, Ebi KL, Mastrandrea MD, Mach KJ, et al.. Determinants of risk: Exposure and vulnerability. Managing the risks of extreme events and disasters to advance climate change adaptation: Special report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2012 Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press 65-108,

[] Cinelli M, Coles SR, Kirwan K. Analysis of the potentials of multi criteria decision analysis methods to conduct sustainability assessment. Ecological Indicators, 2014, 46: 138-148,

[] Daly C. A framework for assessing the vulnerability of archaeological sites to climate change: Theory, development, and application. Conservation and Management of Architectural Sites, 2014, 16(3): 268-282

[] Egusquiza, A., D. Lückerath, S. Zorita, S. Silverton, G. Garcia, E. Servera, A. Bonazza, I. Garcia, and A. Kalis. 2023. Paving the way for climate neutral and resilient historic districts. Open Research Europe 3: Article 42.

[] European Commission, Directorate-General for Education, Youth, Sport and Culture. 2022. Strengthening cultural heritage resilience for climate change: Where the European Green Deal meets cultural heritage. Brussels: Publications Office of the European Union

[] Figueiredo R, Romao X, Pauperio E. Flood risk assessment of cultural heritage at large spatial scales: Framework and application to mainland Portugal. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2020, 43: 163-174,

[] Figueiredo, R., X. Romao, and E. Pauperio. 2021. Component-based flood vulnerability modelling for cultural heritage buildings. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 61: Article 102323.

[] Gaddi R, Cacace C, di Bucchianico ADM. The risk assessment of surface recession damage for architectural buildings in Italy. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2022, 57: 118-130,

[] Gandini, A., A. Egusquita, L. Garmendia, and J.T. San-José. 2018. Vulnerability assessment of cultural heritage sites towards flooding events. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 364: Article 012028.

[] Gandini, A., L. Garmendia, I. Prieto, I. Álvarez, and J.-T. San José. 2020. A holistic and multi-stakeholder methodology for vulnerability assessment of cities to flooding and extreme precipitation events. Sustainable Cities and Society 63: Article 102437.

[] Hahn MB, Riederer AM, Foster SO. The livelihood vulnerability index: A pragmatic approach to assessing risks from climate variability and change—A case study in Mozambique. Global and Environmental Change, 2009, 19(1): 74-88,

[] Herva M, Roca H. Review of combined approaches and multi-criteria analysis for corporate environmental evaluation. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2013, 39: 355-371,

[] Huang IB, Keisler J, Linkov I. Multi-criteria decision analysis in environmental sciences: Ten years of applications and trends. Science of the Total Environment, 2011, 409(19): 3578-3594,

[] IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change). 2022. Climate change 2022: Impacts, adaptation and vulnerability. Contribution of working group II to the sixth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

[] Jigyasu, R., M. Murthy, G. Boccardi, C. Marrion, D. Douglas, J. King, G. O’Brien, G. Dolcemascolo, et al. 2013. Heritage and resilience: Issues and opportunities for reducing disaster risks. Fourth session of the Global Platform on Disaster Risk Reduction, ICORP-ICOMOS, UNISDR, UNESCO, ICCROM. Mumbai, India: Design Flyover.

[] Kotova, L., J. Leissner, M. Winkler, R. Kilian, S. Bichlmair, F. Antretter, J. Moßgraber, J. Reuter, et al. 2023. Making use of climate information for sustainable preservation of cultural heritage: Applications to the KERES project. Heritage Sciences 11: Article 18.

[] Malgwi MB, Fuchs S, Keiler M. A generic physical vulnerability model for floods: Review and concept for data-scarce regions. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2020, 20: 2067-2090,

[] Melnick RZ, Kerr NP. Climate change impacts on cultural landscapes: A preliminary analysis in U.S. national parks across the Pacific West. Landscape Architectural Frontiers, 2018, 6: 112-125,

[] Moreira L, de Brito M, Kobiyama M. Review article: A systematic review and future prospects of flood vulnerability indices. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2021, 21: 1513-1530,

[] Munyai, R.B., A. Musyoki, and N.S. Nethengwe. 2019. An assessment of flood vulnerability and adaptation: A case study of Hamutsha-Muungamunwe Village, Makhado Municipality. Jamba: Journal of Disaster Risk Studies 11(2): Article 692.

[] Papathoma-Köhle M, Schlögl M, Fuchs S. Vulnerability indicators for natural hazards: An innovative selection and weighting approach. Scientific Reports, 2019, 9: 1-14,

[] Pons, O., A. de la Fuente, and A. Aguado. 2016. The use of MIVES as a sustainability assessment MCDM method for architecture and civil engineering applications. Sustainability 8: Article 460.

[] Proag V. The concept of vulnerability and resilience. Procedia Economics and Finance, 2014, 18: 369-376,

[] Ravan M, Revez MJ, Pinto IV, Brum P, Birkmann J. A vulnerability assessment framework for cultural heritage sites: The case of the Roman ruins of Tróia. International Journal of Disaster Risk Sciences, 2023, 14(1): 26-40,

[] Reimann L, Vafeidis AT, Brown S, Hinkel J, Tol RSJ. Mediterranean UNESCO World Heritage at risk from coastal flooding and erosion due to sea-level rise. Nature Communication, 2018, 9: 1-11,

[] Roders, A.P. 2013. Monitoring cultural significance and impact assessments. In Proceedings of the 33rd Annual Meeting of the International Association for Impact Assessment (IAIA13), 13–16 May 2013, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.

[] Rosa, A., A. Santangelo, and S. Tondelli. 2021. Investigating the integration of cultural heritage disaster risk management into urban planning tools. The Ravenna case study. Sustainability 13: Article 872.

[] Saaty TL, Kearns KP. Saaty TL, Kearns KP. The analytic hierarchy process. Analytical planning: The organization of systems, 1985 Oxford, UK Pergamon Press 19-62,

[] Sadok W, Angevin F, Bergez JE, Bockstaller C, Colomb B, Guichard L, Reau R, Dor´e T. Lichtfouse E, Navarrete M, Debaeke P, Véronique S, Alberola C. Ex ante assessment of the sustainability of alternative cropping systems: Implications for using multi-criteria decision-aid methods—A review. Sustainable agriculture, 2009 Dordrecht, Netherland Springer 753-767,

[] Sardella, A., E. Palazzi, J. von Hardenberg, C. Del Grande, P. De Nuntiis, C. Sabbioni, and A. Bonazza. 2020. Risk mapping for the sustainable protection of cultural heritage in extreme changing environments. Atmosphere 11(7): Article 700.

[] Sesana E, Gagnon AS, Bonazza A, Hughes JJ. An integrated approach for assessing the vulnerability of World Heritage Sites to climate change impacts. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 2020, 41: 211-224,

[] Tapsell, S., S. McCarthy, H. Faulkner, and M. Alexander. 2010. Social vulnerability and natural hazards. CapHaz-Net WP4 Report. Flood Hazard Research Centre, Middlesex University, London.

[] Thywissen, K. 2006. Core terminology of disaster reduction: A comparative glossary. In Measuring vulnerability to natural hazards—Towards disaster resilient societies, ed. J. Birkmann, 448–497. Tokyo: United Nations University Press

[] Turner BL, Kasperson RE, Matson PA, McCarthy JJ, Corell RW, Christensen L, Eckley N, Kasperson JX, et al.. A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science. PNAS, 2003, 100(14): 8074-8079,

[] UNDDR (United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction). . Report of the open-ended intergovernmental expert working group on indicators and terminology relating to disaster risk reduction, 2016 Geneva UNDRR

[] Valagussa A, Frattini P, Crosta G, Spizzichino D, Leoni G, Margottini C. Multi-risk analysis on European cultural and natural UNESCO heritage sites. Natural Hazards, 2021, 105: 2659-2676,

[] Wang J, Jing YY, Zhang CF, Zhao JH. Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision-making. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2009, 13(9): 2263-2278,