Assessing Multidimensional Vulnerability of Rural Areas to Flooding: An Index-Based Approach

Abstract

Vulnerability assessment is essential for understanding and launching effective flood risk reduction strategies. This study aimed to examine the vulnerability of flood-prone rural communities in southern Punjab, Pakistan to external shocks. The concept of vulnerability encompasses a range of dimensions, including physical, social, institutional, environmental, economic, and attitudinal. Using a composite index method, indices were developed for each dimension and combined to create a multidimensional measure of vulnerability. A sample of 365 communities was selected using the Yamane sampling technique, and data were collected through a questionnaire containing 65 indicators across all dimensions. Descriptive statistics and ANOVA tests were used to analyze the data. The results show that communities near the Chenab River had higher attitudinal and institutional vulnerability compared to other communities. High attitudinal vulnerabilities were associated with poorly perceived flood risks and low preparedness measures, whereas institutional vulnerabilities were driven by conventional flood protection strategies, lack of institutional trust, and lack of flood risk awareness. This research provides insights into the various components of vulnerability in flood-prone rural communities in Pakistan and demonstrates a useful methodology that can be applied to other disasters at different spatial scales.

Keywords

Chenab River / Flood hazard / Indus River / Pakistan / Rural areas / Vulnerability to flooding

References

[] Adger WN. Vulnerability. Global Environmental Change, 2006, 16(3): 268-281.

[] Adger, W.N., and M. Agnew. 2004. New indicators of vulnerability and adaptive capacity. Norwich: Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research.

[] Adger WN, Kelly PM. Social vulnerability to climate change and the architecture of entitlements. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change, 1999, 4(3): 253-266.

[] Ahsan MN, Warner J. The socioeconomic vulnerability index: A pragmatic approach for assessing climate change led risks – A case study in the south-western coastal Bangladesh. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2014, 8:32-49.

[] Appleby-Arnold S, Brockdorff N, Jakovljev I, Zdravković S. Applying cultural values to encourage disaster preparedness: Lessons from a low-hazard country. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2018, 31:37-44.

[] Armaş I, Avram E. Perception of flood risk in Danube Delta. Romania. Natural Hazards, 2009, 50(2): 269-287.

[] Balica S. Approaches of understanding developments of vulnerability indices for natural disasters. Environmental Engineering and Management Journal, 2012, 11(5): 963-974.

[] Balica SF, Wright NG, Van der Meulen F. A flood vulnerability index for coastal cities and its use in assessing climate change impacts. Natural Hazards, 2012, 64(1): 73-105.

[] Becker, J.S. 2007. Flood risk perceptions, education and warning in four communities in New South Wales, Australia: Results of a questionnaire survey, November 2005. Auckland: GNS Science.

[] Bell, H.M. 2007. Situating the perception and communication of flood risk: Components and strategies. USF Tampa graduate theses and dissertations. University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, USA.

[] Bergstrand K, Mayer B, Brumback B, Zhang Y. Assessing the relationship between social vulnerability and community resilience to hazards. Social Indicators Research, 2015, 122(2): 391-409.

[] Birkmann J. Risk and vulnerability indicators at different scales: Applicability, usefulness and policy implications. Environmental Hazards, 2007, 7(1): 20-31.

[] Birkmann J, Cardona OD, Carreño ML, Barbat AH, Pelling M, Schneiderbauer S, Kienberger S, Keiler M, et al. Framing vulnerability, risk and societal responses: The MOVE framework. Natural Hazards, 2013, 67(2): 193-211.

[] Bollin C, Hidajat R, Birkmann J. Birkmann J. Community-based risk index: Pilot implementation in Indonesia. Measuring vulnerability to natural hazards: Towards disaster resilient societies, 2006 New York UN University Press 383-400.

[] Botzen WJW, Van Den Bergh JC. Monetary valuation of insurance against flood risk under climate change. International Economic Review, 2012, 53(3): 1005-1026.

[] Botzen WJ, Aerts J, van den Bergh JC. Dependence of flood risk perceptions on socioeconomic and objective risk factors. Water Resources Research, 2009.

[] Botzen WJ, Aerts JC, van den Bergh JC. Willingness of homeowners to mitigate climate risk through insurance. Ecological Economics, 2009, 68(8–9): 2265-2277.

[] Brenkert AL, Malone EL. Modeling vulnerability and resilience to climate change: A case study of India and Indian states. Climatic Change, 2005, 72(1): 57-102.

[] Browne MJ, Hoyt RE. The demand for flood insurance: Empirical evidence. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 2000, 20(3): 291-306.

[] Burdge RJ. The focus of impact assessment (and IAIA) must now shift to global climate change!. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2008, 28(8): 618-622.

[] Carreño ML, Cardona OD, Barbat AH. A disaster risk management performance index. Natural Hazards, 2007, 41(1): 1-20.

[] Carter JG, White I, Richards J. Sustainability appraisal and flood risk management. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2009, 29(1): 7-14.

[] Climent-Gil E, Aledo A, Vallejos-Romero A. The social vulnerability approach for social impact assessment. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2018, 73:70-79.

[] Cornia A, Dressel K, Pfeil P. Risk cultures and dominant approaches towards disasters in seven European countries. Journal of Risk Research, 2016, 19(3): 288-304.

[] Cutter SL, Boruff BJ, Shirley WL. Social vulnerability to environmental hazards. Social Science Quarterly, 2003, 84(2): 242-261.

[] Cutter SL, Mitchell JT, Scott MS. Revealing the vulnerability of people and places: A case study of Georgetown County, South Carolina. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2000, 90(4): 713-737.

[] Dao, Q.-H., and P. Peduzzi. 2004. Global evaluation of human risk and vulnerability to natural hazards. In Proceedings of the Enviroinfo 2004 Conference, 21–23 October 2004, Geneva, 435–466.

[] de Guzman, E.M., and A.D.R. Unit. 2003. Towards total disaster risk management approach. Kenya: UN Environment Programme.

[] de Loyola Hummell BM, Cutter SL, Emrich CT. Social vulnerability to natural hazards in Brazil. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2016, 7(2): 111-122.

[] de Sherbinin A, Bardy G. Social vulnerability to floods in two coastal megacities: New York City and Mumbai. Vienna Yearbook of Population Research, 2015, 13:131-165.

[] Douglas J. Physical vulnerability modelling in natural hazard risk assessment. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2007, 7(2): 283-288.

[] Duzgun H, Yucemen M, Kalaycioglu H, Celik K, Kemec S, Ertugay K, Deniz A. An integrated earthquake vulnerability assessment framework for urban areas. Natural Hazards, 2011, 59(2): 917-947.

[] Działek J, Biernacki W, Bokwa A. Neef A, Shaw R. Impact of social capital on local communities’ response to floods in southern Poland. Risks and conflicts: Local responses to natural disasters, 2014 Leeds Emerald Group Publishing Limited 185-205.

[] Fedeski M, Gwilliam J. Urban sustainability in the presence of flood and geological hazards: The development of a GIS-based vulnerability and risk assessment methodology. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2007, 83(1): 50-61.

[] Fekete, A. 2010. Assessment of social vulnerability for river-floods in Germany. https://bonndoc.ulb.uni-bonn.de/xmlui/handle/20.500.11811/4190. Accessed 13 Jan 2024.

[] Field CB, Barros V, Stocker TF, Dahe Q. Managing the risks of extreme events and disasters to advance climate change adaptation: Special report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2012 Cambridge Cambridge University Press

[] Fischer TB. Editorial – Evolution, revolution, climate change and current EIA. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2019, 37(5): 369-370.

[] Flanagan BE, Gregory EW, Hallisey EJ, Heitgerd JL, Lewis B. A social vulnerability index for disaster management. Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management, 2011.

[] Fuchs S. Susceptibility versus resilience to mountain hazards in Austria-paradigms of vulnerability revisited. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2009, 9(2): 337-352.

[] Gain AK, Mojtahed V, Biscaro C, Balbi S, Giupponi C. An integrated approach of flood risk assessment in the eastern part of Dhaka City. Natural Hazards, 2015, 79(3): 1499-1530.

[] Gallopín GC. Linkages between vulnerability, resilience, and adaptive capacity. Global Environmental Change, 2006, 16(3): 293-303.

[] Geneletti D. Environmental assessment of spatial plan policies through land use scenarios. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2012, 32(1): 1-10.

[] Grothmann T, Reusswig F. People at risk of flooding: Why some residents take precautionary action while others do not. Natural Hazards, 2006, 38(1): 101-120.

[] Hahn MB, Riederer AM, Foster SO. The livelihood vulnerability index: A pragmatic approach to assessing risks from climate variability and change – A case study in Mozambique. Global Environmental Change, 2009, 19(1): 74-88.

[] Hamidi, A.R., Z. Zeng, and M.A. Khan. 2020. Household vulnerability to floods and cyclones in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 46: Article 101496.

[] Ho MC, Shaw D, Lin S, Chiu YC. How do disaster characteristics influence risk perception?. Risk Analysis, 2008, 28(3): 635-643.

[] Houze R, Rasmussen K, Medina S, Brodzik S, Romatschke U. Anomalous atmospheric events leading to the summer 2010 floods in Pakistan. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 2011, 92(3): 291-298.

[] Ippolito A, Sala S, Faber J, Vighi M. Ecological vulnerability analysis: A river basin case study. Science of the Total Environment, 2010, 408(18): 3880-3890.

[] Jamshed, A., I.A. Rana, U.M. Mirza, and J. Birkmann. 2019. Assessing relationship between vulnerability and capacity: An empirical study on rural flooding in Pakistan. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 36: Article 101109.

[] Jiricka A, Formayer H, Schmidt A, Völler S, Leitner M, Fischer TB, Wachter TF. Consideration of climate change impacts and adaptation in EIA practice – Perspectives of actors in Austria and Germany. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2016, 57:78-88.

[] Jongman B, Hochrainer-Stigler S, Feyen L, Aerts JC, Mechler R, Botzen WW, Bouwer LM, Pflug G, et al. Increasing stress on disaster-risk finance due to large floods. Nature Climate Change, 2014, 4(4): 264-268.

[] Kaly, U., L. Briguglio, H. McLeod, S. Schmall, C. Pratt, and R. Pal. 1999. Environmental vulnerability index (EVI) to summarise national environmental vulnerability profiles. SOPAC Technical Report 275. Fiji: South Pacific Applied Geoscience Commission.

[] Kappes MS, Keiler M, von Elverfeldt K, Glade T. Challenges of analyzing multi-hazard risk: A review. Natural Hazards, 2012, 64(2): 1925-1958.

[] Kates RW, Travis WR, Wilbanks TJ. Transformational adaptation when incremental adaptations to climate change are insufficient. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2012, 109(19): 7156-7161.

[] Kaźmierczak A, Cavan G. Surface water flooding risk to urban communities: Analysis of vulnerability, hazard and exposure. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2011, 103(2): 185-197.

[] Kelly PM, Adger WN. Theory and practice in assessing vulnerability to climate change and facilitating adaptation. Climatic Change, 2000, 47(4): 325-352.

[] Khalid Z, Meng X-M, Khalid A. A qualitative insight into gendered vulnerabilities: A case study of the Shishper GLOF in Hunza Valley, Pakistan. Sustainability, 2021.

[] Khan AN. Analysis of 2010-flood causes, nature and magnitude in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan.. Natural Hazards, 2013, 66(2): 887-904.

[] Khan S. Vulnerability assessments and their planning implications: A case study of the Hutt Valley, New Zealand. Natural Hazards, 2012, 64(2): 1587-1607.

[] Kienzler S, Pech I, Kreibich H, Müller M, Thieken AH. After the extreme flood in 2002: Changes in preparedness, response and recovery of flood-affected residents in Germany between 2005 and 2011. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2015, 15:505-526.

[] King D. You’re on your own: Community vulnerability and the need for awareness and education for predicatable natural disasters. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 2000, 8(4): 223-228.

[] Kircher CA, Whitman RV, Holmes WT. HAZUS earthquake loss estimation methods. Natural Hazards Review, 2006, 7(2): 45-59.

[] Kirsch, T.D., C. Wadhwani, L. Sauer, S. Doocy, and C. Catlett. 2012. Impact of the 2010 Pakistan floods on rural and urban populations at six months. PLoS Currents 4: Article e4fdfb212d2432.

[] Koks EE, Jongman B, Husby TG, Botzen WJ. Combining hazard, exposure and social vulnerability to provide lessons for flood risk management. Environmental Science & Policy, 2015, 47:42-52.

[] Krellenberg K, Welz J. Assessing urban vulnerability in the context of flood and heat hazard: Pathways and challenges for indicator-based analysis. Social Indicators Research, 2017, 132(2): 709-731.

[] Kron, W. 2014. Flood risk – A global problem. In Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Hydroscience & Engineering (ICHE), 28 September–2 October 2014, Hamburg, Germany.

[] Lagomarsino S, Giovinazzi S. Macroseismic and mechanical models for the vulnerability and damage assessment of current buildings. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 2006, 4(4): 415-443.

[] Ledda, A., E.A. Di Cesare, G. Satta, G. Cocco, and A. De Montis. 2021. Integrating adaptation to climate change in regional plans and programmes: The role of strategic environmental assessment. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 91: Article 106655.

[] Lee Y-J. Social vulnerability indicators as a sustainable planning tool. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2014, 44:31-42.

[] Lindell MK, Hwang SN. Households’ perceived personal risk and responses in a multihazard environment. Risk Analysis, 2008, 28(2): 539-556.

[] López-Martínez F, Gil-Guirado S, Pérez-Morales A. Who can you trust? Implications of institutional vulnerability in flood exposure along the Spanish Mediterranean coast. Environmental Science & Policy, 2017, 76:29-39.

[] Mazzorana B, Simoni S, Scherer C, Gems B, Fuchs S, Keiler M. A physical approach on flood risk vulnerability of buildings. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 2014, 18(9): 3817-3836.

[] Miceli R, Sotgiu I, Settanni M. Disaster preparedness and perception of flood risk: A study in an alpine valley in Italy. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2008, 28(2): 164-173.

[] Mileti D. Disasters by design: A reassessment of natural hazards in the United States, 1999 Washington Joseph Henry Press

[] Milly PCD, Wetherald RT, Dunne K, Delworth TL. Increasing risk of great floods in a changing climate. Nature, 2002, 415(6871): 514-517.

[] Mwale F, Adeloye A, Beevers L. Quantifying vulnerability of rural communities to flooding in SSA: A contemporary disaster management perspective applied to the Lower Shire Valley, Malawi. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2015, 12:172-187.

[] Nasiri H, Yusof MJM, Ali TAM. An overview to flood vulnerability assessment methods. Sustainable Water Resources Management, 2016, 2(3): 331-336.

[] Nhuan MT, Tue NT, Hue NTH, Quy TD, Lieu TM. An indicator-based approach to quantifying the adaptive capacity of urban households: The case of Da Nang City, Central Vietnam. Urban Climate, 2016, 15:60-69.

[] Norris FH, Stevens SP, Pfefferbaum B, Wyche KF, Pfefferbaum RL. Community resilience as a metaphor, theory, set of capacities, and strategy for disaster readiness. American Journal of Community Psychology, 2008, 41(1): 127-150.

[] O’Brien K, Leichenko R, Kelkar U, Venema H, Aandahl G, Tompkins H, Javed A, Bhadwal S, et al. Mapping vulnerability to multiple stressors: Climate change and globalization in India. Global Environmental Change, 2004, 14(4): 303-313.

[] Papathoma-Köhle, M., T. Thaler, and S. Fuchs. 2021. An institutional approach to vulnerability: Evidence from natural hazard management in Europe. Environmental Research Letters 16(4): Article 044056.

[] Peng Y. Regional earthquake vulnerability assessment using a combination of MCDM methods. Annals of Operations Research, 2015, 234(1): 95-110. 3406306

[] Phung D, Rutherford S, Dwirahmadi F, Chu C, Do CM, Nguyen T, Duong NC. The spatial distribution of vulnerability to the health impacts of flooding in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam. International Journal of Biometeorology, 2016, 60(6): 857-865.

[] Polastro R, Nagrah A, Steen N, Zafar F. Inter-agency real time evaluation of the humanitarian response to Pakistan’s 2010 flood crisis, 2011 Madrid DARA

[] Pomeroy RS, Ratner BD, Hall SJ, Pimoljinda J, Vivekanandan V. Coping with disaster: Rehabilitating coastal livelihoods and communities. Marine Policy, 2006, 30(6): 786-793.

[] Pörtner, H.-O., D.C. Roberts, H. Adams, I. Adelekan, C. Adler, R. Adrian, P. Aldunce, E. Ali, et al. 2022. Technical summary. In Climate change 2022: Impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, ed. H.-O. Pörtner, D.C. Roberts, E.S. Poloczanska, K. Mintenbeck, M. Tignor, A. Alegría, M. Craig, and S. Langsdorf. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

[] Qasim S, Khan AN, Shrestha RP, Qasim M. Risk perception of the people in the flood prone Khyber Pukhthunkhwa Province of Pakistan. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2015, 14:373-378.

[] Qurratulain S, Munazza F. An overview of damages, mitigation and reduction efforts in district Muzaffargrah, Pakistan after floods, 2010. International Research Journal of Environment Science, 2014, 3:102-107.

[] Rana IA, Routray JK. Multidimensional model for vulnerability assessment of urban flooding: An empirical study in Pakistan. International Journal of Disaster Risk Science, 2018, 9(3): 359-375.

[] Rana, I.A., A. Jamshed, Z.I. Younas, and S.S. Bhatti. 2020. Characterizing flood risk perception in urban communities of Pakistan. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 46: Aritcle 101624.

[] Rana, I.A., L. Sikander, Z. Khalid, A. Nawaz, F.A. Najam, S.U. Khan, and A. Aslam. 2022. A localized index-based approach to assess heatwave vulnerability and climate change adaptation strategies: A case study of formal and informal settlements of Lahore, Pakistan. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 96: Article 106820.

[] Räsänen, A., H. Lein, D. Bird, and G. Setten. 2020. Conceptualizing community in disaster risk management. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 45: Article 101485.

[] Roy DC, Blaschke T. Spatial vulnerability assessment of floods in the coastal regions of Bangladesh. Geomatics, Natural Hazards and Risk, 2015, 6(1): 21-44.

[] Scolobig A, Prior T, Schröter D, Jörin J, Patt A. Towards people-centred approaches for effective disaster risk management: Balancing rhetoric with reality. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2015, 12:202-212.

[] Shabir O. A summary case report on the health impacts and response to the Pakistan floods of 2010. PLoS Currents, 2013.

[] Shah AA, Ye J, Abid M, Khan J, Amir SM. Flood hazards: Household vulnerability and resilience in disaster-prone districts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province, Pakistan. Natural Hazards, 2018, 93(1): 147-165.

[] Shah, A.A., J. Ye, R. Shaw, R. Ullah, and M. Ali. 2020. Factors affecting flood-induced household vulnerability and health risks in Pakistan: The case of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) Province. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 42: Article 101341.

[] Siegrist M, Gutscher H. Flooding risks: A comparison of lay people’s perceptions and expert’s assessments in Switzerland. Risk Analysis, 2006, 26(4): 971-979.

[] Siegrist M, Gutscher H. Natural hazards and motivation for mitigation behavior: People cannot predict the affect evoked by a severe flood. Risk Analysis, 2008, 28(3): 771-778.

[] Smit B, Wandel J. Adaptation, adaptive capacity and vulnerability. Global Environmental Change, 2006, 16(3): 282-292.

[] Smit B, Burton I, Klein RJ, Wandel J. Kane SM, Yohe GW. An anatomy of adaptation to climate change and variability. Societal adaptation to climate variability and change, 2000 Heidelberg Springer 223-251.

[] Smith K. Environmental hazards: Assessing risk and reducing disaster, 2013 New York Routledge

[] Srinivas H, Nakagawa Y. Environmental implications for disaster preparedness: Lessons learnt from the Indian Ocean Tsunami. Journal of Environmental Management, 2008, 89(1): 4-13.

[] Sullivan-Wiley K, Gianotti AS. Risk perception in a multi-hazard environment. World Development, 2017.

[] Takao K, Motoyoshi T, Sato T, Fukuzondo T, Seo K, Ikeda S. Factors determining residents’ preparedness for floods in modern megalopolises: The case of the Tokai flood disaster in Japan. Journal of Risk Research, 2004, 7(7–8): 775-787.

[] Terpstra T, Gutteling JM. Households’ perceived responsibilities in flood risk management in the Netherlands. International Journal of Water Resources Development, 2008, 24(4): 555-565.

[] Turner BL, Kasperson RE, Matson PA, McCarthy JJ, Corell RW, Christensen L, Eckley N, Kasperson JX, et al. A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2003, 100(14): 8074-8079.

[] Ullah, F., S.A. Ali Shah, S.E. Saqib, M. Yaseen, and M.S. Haider. 2021. Households’ flood vulnerability and adaptation: Empirical evidence from mountainous regions of Pakistan. International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction 52: Article 101967.

[] UNISDR (United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction). 2009. 2009 UNISDR terminology on disaster risk reduction. https://reliefweb.int/report/world/2009-unisdr-terminology-disaster-risk-reduction?gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQiAoKeuBhCoARIsAB4WxtfwNRIW7DAKOulIu1CoWDUUcoFAGRI_nayzgQLlB3QOu1_9oHpEsEwaAoNMEALw_wcB. Accessed 12 Feb 2024.

[] United Nations. 2022. Pakistan 2022 floods response plan interim report: Sep–Nov 2022 (Issued 09 Dec 2022). https://reliefweb.int/report/pakistan/pakistan-2022-floods-response-plan-interim-report-sep-nov-2022-issued-09-dec-2022. Accessed 12 Feb 2024.

[] Winsemius HC, Jongman B, Veldkamp TI, Hallegatte S, Bangalore M, Ward PJ. Disaster risk, climate change, and poverty: Assessing the global exposure of poor people to floods and droughts. Environment and Development Economics, 2018, 23(3): 328-348.

[] Wisner B, Blaikie P, Cannon T, Davis I. At risk: natural hazards, people’s vulnerability and disasters, 2004 2 London Routledge

[] Yamane T. Statistics: An introductory analysis, 1967 2 New York Harper and Row

[] Yu H, Wang B, Zhang Y-J, Wang S, Wei Y-M. Public perception of climate change in China: Results from the questionnaire survey. Natural Hazards, 2013, 69(1): 459-472.

[] Zhou Y, Liu Y, Wu W, Li N. Integrated risk assessment of multi-hazards in China. Natural Hazards, 2015, 78(1): 257-280.