Impact of initial water saturation on pore structure and fluid infiltration during hydraulic fracturing mapped by real-time nuclear magnetic resonance

Abstract

Although hydraulic fracturing of water-bearing tight sandstone gas reservoirs has been extensively investigated, little attention has been paid to the influence of water saturation (w_s) on pore structure and fluid infiltration behavior during the fracturing process. To address this gap, hydraulic fracturing experiments were conducted on sandstone specimens with different water saturations (w_s = 0, 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100%) using a real-time nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) system. Results show that increasing w_s reduces both breakdown pressure and breakdown time. Fluid injection promotes progressive micropores dilation and their transformation into mesopores and macropores at w_s = 0–50%, while higher saturation enhances macropores modification by coalescence of pre-existing smaller pores. Capillary tension at dry-wet interfaces and clay mineral dissolution are suggested as dominant mechanisms governing pore-scale damage at low and high w_s, respectively. Fluid infiltration is enhanced at low w_s due to improved pore connectivity and strong water absorption effect, but is suppressed at high w_s owing to water-locking effects. An apparent transition in mesopore evolution and preferential infiltration direction is observed between w_s = 50% and 75%. These findings provide mechanistic insights into the role of w_s in hydraulic fracturing of water-bearing tight sandstone gas reservoirs.

Keywords

Water saturation / Pore structure evolution / Fluid infiltration / Real-time NMR / Hydraulic fracturing / Sandstone

References

[1] Jia AL, Wei YS, Guo Z, Wang GT, Meng DW, Huang SQ. Development status and prospect of tight sandstone gas in China. Nat Gas Ind B 2022; 9(5):467-76.

[2] Zhang YF, Long AF, Zhao Y, Zang A, Wang CL. Mutual impact of true triaxial stress, borehole orientation and bedding inclination on laboratory hydraulic fracturing of Lushan shale. J Rock Mech Geotech Eng 2023; 15(12):3131—47.

[3] Meng DW, Jia AL, Ji G, He DB. Water and gas distribution and its controlling factors of large scale tight sand gas fields: A case study of western Sulige gas field, Ordos Basin. NW China Petrol Explor Dev 2016; 43(4):663-71.

[4] Erguler ZA, Ulusay R. Water—induced variations in mechanical properties of clay—bearing rocks. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2009; 46(2):355-70.

[5] Widarsono B, Muladi A, Saptono F. The influence of variations in porosity and water saturation on the success of hydraulic fracturing: A semi—theoretical analysis. SPE Asia Pacific Oil and Gas Conference and Exhibition. April 17—19, 2001. Jakarta, Indonesia. Richardson: Society of Petroleum Engineers,2001: SPE 68657—MS.

[6] Li XY, Lei XL, Li Q. Injection—induced fracturing process in a tight sandstone under different saturation conditions. Environ Earth Sci 2016; 75(23):1466.

[7] Zhuang L, Kim KY, Diaz M, Yeom S. Evaluation of water saturation effect on mechanical properties and hydraulic fracturing behavior of granite. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2020; 130:104321.

[8] Shevtsova A, Stanchits S, Filev E, Karamov T, Stukachev V, Spasennykh M. Assessment of saturation effect on hydraulic fracturing in sandstone and thermally treated granite. Minerals 2023; 13(6):777.

[9] Wang HS, Bi J, Zhao Y, Wang CL, Ma JB. NMR—based analysis of the effect of moisture migration on sandstone pore structure under alternating wetting and drying conditions. Int J Min Sci and Technol 2024; 34(8):1135—50.

[10] Fu TF, Xu T, Heap MJ, Meredith PG, Yang TH, Mitchell TM, et al. Analysis of capillary water imbibition in sandstone via a combination of nuclear magnetic resonance imaging and numerical DEM modeling. Eng Geol 2021; 285:106070.

[11] Xu YL, Li XL, Wu XK, Zheng W, Zhou B, Tong J. Experimental study on pore fluid characteristics of fractured sandstone based on nuclear magnetic resonance technology. J Petrol Sci Eng 2022; 214:110408.

[12] Zhang C, Wang XJ, Han PH, Zhang T, Zhang L, Wang FT. Acoustic emission and splitting surface roughness of sandstone in a Brazilian splitting test under the influence of water saturation. Eng Geol 2024; 329:107369.

[13] Long AF, Zhang YF, Zhao Y, Wu SF. Damage evolution characteristics caused by fluid infiltration across diverse injection rates: Insights from integrated NMR and hydraulic fracturing experiments. J Rock Mech Geotech Eng 2025; 17(9):5753-67.

[14] Wu SF, Zhang YF, Zhao Y, Wang CL, Bi J, Long AF, et al. Real—time NMR investigation of water infiltration mechanisms and pore structure evolution in fractured sandstone near—wellbore regions. Petrol Sci 2025; 22(10):4195-210.

[15] Zhang YF, Long AF, Zang A, Zhao Y. Pore—scale damage evolution in sandstone induced by fluid infiltration under various stress conditions. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2025; 193:106181.

[16] Nie RS, Zhou J, Chen ZX, Liu JC, Pan Y. Pore structure characterization of tight sandstones via a novel integrated method: A case study of the Sulige gas field, Ordos Basin (Northern China). J Asian Earth Sci 2021; 213:104739.

[17] He MC, Sun XM, Zhao J. Advances in interaction mechanism of water (gas) on clay minerals in China. Int J Min Sci and Technol 2014; 24(6):727—35.

[18] Jia YZ, Song CP, Wang JH, Gan Q. The breakdown process of low—permeable shale and high—permeable sandstone rocks due to non—aqueous fracturing: the role of fluid infiltration. J Nat Gas Sci Eng 2021; 89:103873.

[19] Zhang DC, Lu GJ, Wu J, Nie W, Ranjith PG. Effects of ultralow temperature and water saturation on the mechanical properties of sandstone. Rock Mech Rock Eng 2023; 56(5):3377—97.

[20] Liu YZ, Cai YT, Huang SG, Guo YL, Liu GF. Effect of water saturation on uniaxial compressive strength and damage degree of clay—bearing sandstone under freeze—thaw. Bull Eng Geol Environ 2020; 79(4):2021-36.

[21] Jia HL, Ding S, Wang Y, Zi F, Sun Q, Yang GS. An NMR—based investigation of pore water freezing process in sandstone. Cold Reg Sci Technol 2019; 168:102893.

[22] Su EL, Liang YP, Chen XJ, Wang ZF, Ni XM, Zou QL, et al. Relationship between pore structure and mechanical properties of bituminous coal under sub—critical and super—critical CO₂ treatment. Energy 2023; 280:128155.

[23] Zhang XL, Jin JX, Liu XL, Wang YK, Li YH. Study on the influence of saturation on freeze—thaw damage characteristics of sandstone. Materials 2023; 16(6):2309.

[24] Pan JN, Du XT, Wang XL, Hou QL, Wang ZZ, Yi JL, et al. Pore and permeability changes in coal induced by true triaxial supercritical carbon dioxide fracturing based on low—field nuclear magnetic resonance. Energy 2024; 286:129492.

[25] Li M, Lim VWS, Al Ghafri SZ, Ling N, Adebayo AR, May EF, et al. Minimum miscibility pressure of CO₂ and oil evaluated using MRI and NMR measurements. J Petrol Sci Eng 2022; 214:110515.

[26] Wang FL, Li XF, Couples G, Shi JT, Zhang JF, Tepinhi Y, et al. Stress arching effect on stress sensitivity of permeability and gas well production in Sulige gas field. J Petrol Sci Eng 2015; 125:234—46.

[27] Ning L, Bi J, Zhao Y, Wang CL, Zhang YF, Li Y, et al. Revealing the effect of pore size distribution characteristics on macroscopic properties of red sandstone under instantaneous high temperature through the lens of Shannon entropy theory. Rock Mech Rock Eng 2025; 58(5):4879-97.

[28] Xi Y, Xing JH, Jiang HL, Chen YC, Li J, Fan LF. Experimental study on pore characteristics evolution and rock damage mechanism of thermal—cooling treated sandstone. Constr Build Mater 2024; 440:137498.

[29] Zhou HW, Liu ZL, Zhong JC, Chen BC, Zhao JW, Xue DJ. NMRI online observation of coal fracture and pore structure evolution under confining pressure and axial compressive loads: A novel approach. Energy 2022; 261:125297.

[30] Huang JC, Luo Y, Si XF, Lin F, Wang K, Qiu JD, et al. Failure characteristics and mechanisms of uniaxial compressed red sandstone in non—uniform water distribution environment: Effects of immersion height and duration. Int J Min Sci and Technol 2025; 35:1809-91826.

[31] Baud P, Zhu WL, Wong TF. Failure mode and weakening effect of water on sandstone. J Geophys Res Solid Earth 2000; 105(B7):16371-89.

[32] Haimson B, Fairhurst C. Initiation and extension of hydraulic fractures in rocks. Soc Pet Eng J 1967; 7(3):310-8.

[33] Ha SJ, Yun TS. Experimental and numerical investigation of time—delayed pressurization for the manipulation of breakdown pressure and acoustic emissions during hydraulic stimulation. Eng Fract Mech 2020; 231:107005.

[34] Fan L, Chang YK, Peng K, Bai YS, Luo K, Wu T, et al. Research progress on the mechanisms and control methods of rockbursts under water—rock interactions. Appl Sci 2024; 14(19):8653.

[35] Ding S, Tang SB, Jia HL, Li YB. The influence of water on the failure characteristics of sandstone under uniaxial compression conditions by acoustic emission and NMR observation. Eng Geol 2023; 322:107173.

[36] Kim J, Moridis GJ. Numerical analysis of fracture propagation during hydraulic fracturing operations in shale gas systems. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2015; 76:127—37.

[37] Shao JX, Kang YL, You LJ, Chen MJ. Effect of dry—wet alternations on the mechanical strength of deep tight sandstone. J Petrol Sci Eng 2021; 204:108750.

[38] Yang ZR, Wang CL, Zhao Y, Bi J. Microwave fracturing of frozen coal with different water content: Pore—structure evolution and temperature characteristics. Energy 2024; 294:130938.

[39] Tang SB. The effects of water on the strength of black sandstone in a brittle regime. Eng Geol 2018; 239:167-78.

[40] Berkowitz B, Hansen DP. A numerical study of the distribution of water in partially saturated porous rock. Transp Porous Medium 2001; 45(2):301-17.

[41] Wdowin M, Tarkowski R, Franus W. Determination of changes in the reservoir and cap rocks of the Chabowo Anticline caused by CO₂—brine—rock interactions. Int J Coal Geol 2014; 130:79-88.

[42] Zhang J, Li XZ, Shen WJ, Gao SS, Liu HX, Ye LY, et al. Study of the effect of movable water saturation on gas production in tight sandstone gas reservoirs. Energies 2020; 13(18):4645.

[43] Zhou ZL, Cai X, Ma D, Cao WZ, Chen L, Zhou J. Effects of water content on fracture and mechanical behavior of sandstone with a low clay mineral content. Eng Fract Mech 2018; 193:47-65.

[44] Wang S, Zhou J, Zhang LQ, Han ZH, Kong YL. Numerical insight into hydraulic fracture propagation in hot dry rock with complex natural fracture networks via fluid—solid coupling grain—based modeling. Energy 2024; 295:131060.

[45] Zhang W, Bi J, Zhao Y, Zhang YF, Wang CL, Pan Y. An improved fluid flow algorithm for hydraulic fracturing: Optimizing domain volume and crack pressure update strategies. Int J Min Sci and Technol 2025; 35(4):639—57.

[46] Huang SG, Yu SL. Effect of water saturation on the strength of sandstones: experimental investigation and statistical analysis. Bull Eng Geol Environ 2022; 81(8):323.

[47] Weng L, Wu ZJ, Chu ZF, Lu HF, Xu XY, Liu QS. Evolution of the unfrozen water content for partially—saturated sandstones and the critical degree of saturation. Rock Mech Rock Eng 2023; 56(1):1-18.

[48] Lan XD, Chen SW, Zhu YH, Zheng KX, Wu RY, Wang J. Online measurement of water transportation in typical rock based on low—field nuclear magnetic resonance monitoring. Rock Mech Rock Eng 2026.

[49] Wei JG, Fu P, Yang Y, Shang DM, Liang S, Shen AQ. Online NMR quantification of pore—scale imbibition and oil recovery in shale reservoirs. Energy Fuels 2025; 39(51):24152-61.

[50] Lu YY, Wang L, Ge ZL, Zhou Z, Deng K, Zuo SJ. Fracture and pore structure dynamic evolution of coals during hydraulic fracturing. Fuel 2020; 259:116272.