In-situ environmental monitoring for deep-sea polymetallic nodule mining: Status, challenges, and future directions

Abstract

The prospective mining of deep-sea polymetallic nodules, a source of strategic critical metals, could cause irreversible damage to fragile deep-sea ecosystems, sparking global scientific, political, and ethical controversies. Consequently, establishing a scientific, credible, and efficient in-situ environmental monitoring system is a core prerequisite for achieving sustainable resource development and effective environmental regulation. This paper reviews the latest progress in in-situ environmental monitoring for polymetallic nodule mining (PNM). First, integrating future commercial mining workflows with current pilot-scale engineering practices, this paper outlines the multi-source environmental disturbances of PNM. The review then analyses impact mechanisms and monitoring strategies for five key areas: physical oceanography, marine chemistry, geology, marine biology, and sediment plumes. Finally, by assessing typical international monitoring campaigns, the paper distils key scientific findings and identifies core challenges. In-situ monitoring indicates that under the specific environmental conditions of PNM areas, mining plumes primarily propagate as near-bottom gravity currents, and that damage to benthic habitats can persist for decades. However, significant technical bottlenecks and scientific uncertainties remain in quantifying micro-scale processes, conducting continuous long-term observation of ecological recovery, and enabling real-time fusion of multi-platform data.

Keywords

Deep-sea mining / Plumes / Monitoring / In-situ technologies / Ecological impacts

References

[1] Koschinsky A, Heinrich L, Boehnke K, Cohrs JC, Markus T, Shani M, et al. Deep—sea mining: Interdisciplinary research on potential environmental, legal, economic, and societal implications. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2018; 14(6):672-91.

[2] Liu ZH, Liu K, Chen XG, Ma ZK, Lv R, Wei CY, et al. Deep—sea rock mechanics and mining technology: state of the art and perspectives. Int J Min Sci Technol 2023; 33(9):1083-115.

[3] Zhang FP, Chen XG, Wei JK, Zhang YY, Xu WK, Li H. Experimental investigation of the inhibition of deep—sea mining sediment plumes by polyaluminum chloride. Int J Min Sci Technol 2024; 34(1):91-104.

[4] Unleashing america’s offshore critical minerals and resources, The White House, 2025.

[5] Orcutt BN. I’ve witnessed the wonders of the deep sea Mining could destroy them. Nature 2023; 619(7971):673.

[6] Sumaila UR, Alam L, Pradhoshini K, Onifade TT, Karuaihe ST, Singh P, et al. To engage in deep—sea mining or not to engage: what do full net cost analyses tell us? npj Ocean Sustain 2023; 2:19.

[7] Van Dover CL, Ardron JA, Escobar E, Gianni M, Gjerde KM, Jaeckel A, et al. Biodiversity loss from deep—sea mining. Nature Geosci 2017; 10(7):464-5.

[8] Woodwell GM. Curb deep—sea mining now. Nature 2011; 471(7336):36.

[9] Crane R, Laing C, Littler K, Moore K, Roberts C, Thompson K, et al. Deep—sea mining poses an unjustifiable environmental risk. Nat Sustain 2024;7(7):836-8.

[10] Feichtner I, Ginzky H. The struggle at the International Seabed Authority over deep sea mineral resources. npj Ocean Sustain 2024; 3:63.

[11] Van Dover CL. Tighten regulations on deep—sea mining. Nature 2011; 470(7332):31-3.

[12] Willaert K. Regulating deep sea mining: A myriad of legal frameworks. Cham: Springer International Publishing; 2021.

[13] Chen CZ. China’s domestic law on the exploration and development of resources in deep seabed areas. The Law of the Seabed 2020:335-70.

[14] Shen H. Towards an integrated legal regime for data and sample regulation under China’s deep seabed mining law. Asia—Pac J Ocean Law Policy 2024; 9(1):46-64.

[15] Caruso F, Alonge G, Bellia G, De Domenico E, Grammauta R, Larosa G, et al. Long—term monitoring of dolphin biosonar activity in deep pelagic waters of the Mediterranean Sea. Sci Rep 2017; 7:4321.

[16] Aguzzi J, Chatzievangelou D, Marini S, Fanelli E, Danovaro R, Flögel S, et al. New high—tech flexible networks for the monitoring of deep—sea ecosystems. Environ Sci Technol 2019; 53(12):6616—31.

[17] Haalboom S, de Stigter HC, Mohn C, Vandorpe T, Smit M, de Jonge L, et al. Monitoring of a sediment plume produced by a deep—sea mining test in shallow water, Málaga Bight, Alboran Sea (southwestern Mediterranean Sea). Mar Geol 2023; 456:106971.

[18] De Hoog E, Van Wijk JM, Wijnands JTM, Talmon AM. Degradation of polymetallic nodules during hydraulic transport under influence of particle—wall and particle—particle interaction. Miner Eng 2020; 155:106415.

[19] Kang YJ, Liu SJ. The development history and latest progress of deep—sea polymetallic nodule mining technology. Minerals 2021; 11(10).

[20] Sitlhou L, Chakraborty P. Comparing deep—sea polymetallic nodule mining technologies and evaluating their probable impacts on deep—sea pollution. Mar Pollut Bull 2024; 206:116762.

[21] Van Wijk JM, De Hoog E. Size reduction of CCZ polymetallic nodules under repeated impact fragmentation. Results Eng 2020; 7:100154.

[22] Wegorzewski AV, Köpcke M, Kuhn T, Sitnikova MA, Wotruba H. Thermal pre—treatment of polymetallic nodules to create metal (Ni, Cu, co)—rich individual particles for further processing. Minerals 2018; 8(11):523.

[23] Vonnahme TR, Molari M, Janssen F, Wenzhöfer F, Haeckel M, Titschack J, et al. Effects of a deep—sea mining experiment on seafloor microbial communities and functions after 26 years. Sci Adv 2020; 6(18):eaaz5922.

[24] Gazis IZ, de Stigter H, Mohrmann J, Heger K, Diaz M, Gillard B, et al. Monitoring benthic plumes, sediment redeposition and seafloor imprints caused by deep—sea polymetallic nodule mining. Nat Commun 2025; 16:1229.

[25] Volz JB, Haffert L, Haeckel M, Koschinsky A, Kasten S. Impact of small—scale disturbances on geochemical conditions, biogeochemical processes and element fluxes in surface sediments of the eastern Clarion—Clipperton Zone Pacific Ocean. Biogeosciences 2020; 17(4):1113-31.

[26] Sha F, Xi MS, Wen ZJ, Chen XG, Zuo YH, Xu JZ, et al. A review on plumes generation and evolution mechanism during deep—sea polymetallic nodules mining. Ocean Eng 2024; 298:117188.

[27] Helmons R, de Wit L, de Stigter H, Spearman J. Dispersion of benthic plumes in deep—sea mining: What lessons can be learned from dredging? Front Earth Sci 2022; 10:868701.

[28] Williams R, Erbe C, Duncan A, Nielsen K, Washburn T, Smith C. Noise from deep—sea mining may span vast ocean areas. Science 2022; 377(6602):157—8.

[29] Muñoz—Royo C, Peacock T, Alford MH, Smith JA, Le Boyer A, Kulkarni CS, et al. Extent of impact of deep—sea nodule mining midwater plumes is influenced by sediment loading, turbulence and thresholds. Commun Earth Environ 2021; 2:148.

[30] Oebius HU, Becker HJ, Rolinski S, Jankowski JA. Parametrization and evaluation of marine environmental impacts produced by deep—sea manganese nodule mining. Deep Sea Res Part II Top Stud Oceanogr 2001; 48(17—18):3453-67.

[31] Christiansen B, Denda A, Christiansen S. Potential effects of deep seabed mining on pelagic and benthopelagic biota. Mar Policy 2020; 114:103442.

[32] Gillard B, Purkiani K, Chatzievangelou D, Vink A, Iversen MH, Thomsen L. Physical and hydrodynamic properties of deep sea mining—generated, abyssal sediment plumes in the Clarion Clipperton Fracture Zone (eastern—central Pacific). Elem Sci Anth 2019; 7:5.

[33] Amon DJ, Gollner S, Morato T, Smith CR, Chen C, Christiansen S, et al. Assessment of scientific gaps related to the effective environmental management of deep—seabed mining. Mar Policy 2022; 138:105006.

[34] Guo XS, Fan N, Liu YH, Liu XL, Wang ZK, Xie XT, et al. Deep seabed mining: Frontiers in engineering geology and environment. Int J Coal Sci Technol 2023; 10(1):23.

[35] Spearman J, Taylor J, Crossouard N, Cooper A, Turnbull M, Manning A, et al. Measurement and modelling of deep sea sediment plumes and implications for deep sea mining. Sci Rep 2020; 10:5075.

[36] Haalboom S. Monitoring strategies of suspended matter after natural and deep—sea mining disturbances. Utrecht University Library; 2024.

[37] Aleynik D, Inall ME, Dale A, Vink A. Impact of remotely generated eddies on plume dispersion at abyssal mining sites in the Pacific. Sci Rep 2017; 7(1):16959.

[38] von Appen WJ. Correction of ADCP compass errors resulting from iron in the instrument’s vicinity. J Atmos Ocean Technol 2015; 32(3):591-602.

[39] Haffert L, Haeckel M, de Stigter H, Janssen F. Assessing the temporal scale of deep—sea mining impacts on sediment biogeochemistry. Biogeosciences 2020; 17(10):2767-89.

[40] Fan ZH, Zhu XM, Xu HB, Sun ZW, Zhang H, Bi XB, et al. A new method for long—term in situ monitoring of seabed interface evolution: A self—potential probe. Ocean Eng 2023; 280:114917.

[41] Jeong H, Ra K, Araújo DF, Yoo CM, Hyeong K, Park SJ. Zinc and copper isotope fractionation in metal leaching from hydrothermal ore deposits: environmental implications for deep—sea mining. Sci Total Environ 2024; 948:174833.

[42] Martins I, Guerra A, Azevedo A, Harasse O, Colaço A, Xavier J, et al. A modelling framework to assess multiple metals impacts on marine food webs: Relevance for assessing the ecological implications of deep—sea mining based on a systematic review. Mar Pollut Bull 2023; 191:114902.

[43] Hein JR, Koschinsky A, Kuhn T. Deep—ocean polymetallic nodules as a resource for critical materials. Nat Rev Earth Environ 2020; 1(3):158-69.

[44] Wang JW, Feng YL, Li HR, Yao YS, Liu MY, Cui YF, et al. Fixation behavior of oceanic manganese nodule—sodium alginate composite microspheres for heavy metal release during manganese nodule mining. Environ Pollut 2024; 363:125120.

[45] Zhu N, Fan Z, Guo X, Jia Y, Zhu X, Liu X, et al. Characterization of the engineering properties of deep—sea sediments in the western Pacific polymetallic nodule region. Acta Geotech 2026.

[46] Schmidt K, Paul SAL, Achterberg EP. Assessing the availability of trace metals including rare earth elements in deep ocean waters of the Clarion Clipperton Zone, NE Pacific: application of an in situ DGT passive sampling method. TrAC Trends Anal Chem 2022; 155:116657.

[47] Fuchida S, Yokoyama A, Fukuchi R, Ishibashi JI, Kawagucci S, Kawachi M, et al. Leaching of metals and metalloids from hydrothermal ore particulates and their effects on marine phytoplankton. ACS Omega 2017; 2(7):3175-82.

[48] Porcile G, Enrile F, Besio G, Bolla PM. Hydrostatic vs. non—hydrostatic modelling of density currents developing two dimensionally on steep and mild slopes. Appl Ocean Res 2022; 121:103085.

[49] Li BW, Jia YG, Fan ZH, Li K, Shi XF. Impact of the mining process on the near—seabed environment of a polymetallic nodule area: A field simulation experiment in a western Pacific area. Sensors 2023; 23(19):8110.

[50] Li BW, Jia YG, Fan ZH, Li K. The profile of sound speed and dissolved oxygen in the polymetallic nodules depositional area in the Western Pacific. J Oceanol Limnol 2023; 41(6):2090—100.

[51] Martini M, Butman B, Mickelson MJ. Long—term performance of aanderaa optodes and sea—bird SBE—43 dissolved—oxygen sensors bottom mounted at 32 m in Massachusetts Bay. J Atmos Ocean Technol 2007; 24(11):1924-35.

[52] Boetius A, Haeckel M. Mind the seafloor. Science 2018; 359(6371):34-6.

[53] Smith CR, Tunnicliffe V, Colaço A, Drazen JC, Gollner S, Levin LA, et al. Deep—sea misconceptions cause underestimation of seabed—mining impacts. Trends Ecol Evol 2020; 35(10):853-7.

[54] Levin LA, Wei CL, Dunn DC, Amon DJ, Ashford OS, Cheung WWL, et al. Climate change considerations are fundamental to management of deep—sea resource extraction. Glob Chang Biol 2020; 26(9):4664-78.

[55] Jones CS, Li TY, Sukalski A, Thompson DA, Cwiertny DM. Use of real—time sensors for compliance monitoring of nitrate in finished drinking water. Water Sci Technol 2020; 82(12):2725-36.

[56] Pinto AMF, von Sperling E, Moreira RM. Chlorophyll—a determination via continuous measurement of plankton fluorescence: Methodology development. Water Res 2001; 35(16):3977-81.

[57] Sun ZW, Jia YG, Shan HX, Fan ZH, Song XS, Xue L, et al. Monitoring and early warning technology of hydrate—induced submarine disasters. IOP Conf Ser: Earth Environ Sci 2020; 570(6):062030.

[58] Sha F, Xi MS, Chen XG, Liu XL, Niu HY, Zuo YH. A recent review on multi—physics coupling between deep—sea mining equipment and marine sediment. Ocean Eng 2023; 276:114229.

[59] Bosler RM, Rønne S, Furmidge D, Waeroe A, Rangua J, Ferguson C. Efficient survey tools for an improved understanding of deep seabed minerals. Offshore Technology Conference. May 1—4, 2023. Houston, Texas, USA. OTC, 2023: D021S021R002.

[60] Zhang N, Zhai WK, Yin SY, Chen XG, Xia JX, Luan LB, et al. Deep—sea soft soil and deep—sea mining vehicle interaction: from soil properties to locomotion performance. Appl Ocean Res 2025; 154:104372.

[61] Marsh L, Huvenne VAI, Jones DOB. Geomorphological evidence of large vertebrates interacting with the seafloor at abyssal depths in a region designated for deep—sea mining. R Soc Open Sci 2018; 5(8):180286.

[62] Martí A, Portell J, Amblas D, de Cabrera F, Vilà M, Riba J, et al. Compression of multibeam echosounders bathymetry and water column data. Remote Sens 2022; 14(9):2063.

[63] An C, Cai C, Zheng Y, Meng LS, Liu P. Theoretical solution and applications of ocean bottom pressure induced by seismic seafloor motion. Geophys Res Lett 2017; 44(20):10,272-10,281.

[64] Tikhotskiy S, Bayuk I, Dubinya N. On the possibility of detecting pore pressure changes in marine sediments using bottom seismometer data. J Mar Sci Eng 2023; 11(9):1803.

[65] Liu XL, Wang YY, Zhang H, Guo XS. Susceptibility of typical marine geological disasters: An overview. Geoenviron Disasters 2023;10(1):10.

[66] Clare MA, Vardy ME, Cartigny MJB, Talling PJ, Himsworth MD, Dix JK, et al. Direct monitoring of active geohazards: emerging geophysical tools for deep—water assessments. Surf Geophys 2017; 15(4):427-44.

[67] Jones DOB, Kaiser S, Sweetman AK, Smith CR, Menot L, Vink A, et al. Biological responses to disturbance from simulated deep—sea polymetallic nodule mining. PLoS One 2017; 12(2):e0171750.

[68] Danovaro R, Fanelli E, Aguzzi J, Billett D, Carugati L, Corinaldesi C, et al. Ecological variables for developing a global deep—ocean monitoring and conservation strategy. Nat Ecol Evol 2020; 4(2):181-92.

[69] Tunnicliffe V, Sánchez LE, Mudd GM, Amon DJ, Levin LA, Lily H, et al. Metal mining on land versus the ocean in the context of the current Biodiversity Crisis. npj Ocean Sustain 2025; 4:7.

[70] Stenvers VI, Hauss H, Bayer T, Havermans C, Hentschel U, Schmittmann L, et al. Experimental mining plumes and ocean warming trigger stress in a deep pelagic jellyfish. Nat Commun 2023; 14(1):7352.

[71] Marassi R, Pinheiro M, Caetano M, Raimundo J, Oliveira R, Martins I, et al. Deep—sea mining: using hyperbaric conditions to study the impact of sediment plumes in the subtidal clam Spisula solida. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int 2023; 30(48):105675-84.

[72] He YM, Zhou L, Wang MX, Zhong ZS, Chen H, Lian C, et al. Integrated transcriptomic and metabolomic approaches reveal molecular response and potential biomarkers of the deep—sea mussel Gigantidas platifrons to copper exposure. J Hazard Mater 2024; 473:134612.

[73] Sousa CSV, Sun J, Mestre NC. Potential biomarkers of metal toxicity in deep—sea invertebrates—a critical review of the omics data. Sci Total Environ 2024; 951:175628.

[74] Martins I, Guerra A, Vale CG, Xavier C, Martins I, Pinheiro M, et al. Developing a dynamic energy budget model to project potential effects of deep—sea mining plumes on the Atlantic deep—sea mussel. Bathymodiolus azoricus Ecol Inform 2024; 83:102803.

[75] Gallego R, Arias MB, Corral—Lou A, Díez—Vives C, Neave EF, Wang C, et al. North Atlantic deep—sea benthic biodiversity unveiled through sponge natural sampler DNA. Commun Biol 2024; 7(1):1015.

[76] Laroche O, Kersten O, Smith CR, Goetze E. Environmental DNA surveys detect distinct metazoan communities across abyssal Plains and seamounts in the western Clarion Clipperton Zone. Mol Ecol 2020; 29(23):4588-604.

[77] McClenaghan B, Fahner N, Cote D, Chawarski J, McCarthy A, Rajabi H, et al. Harnessing the power of eDNA metabarcoding for the detection of deep—sea fishes. PLoS One 2020; 15(11):e0236540.

[78] Suarez—Bregua P, Álvarez—González M, Parsons KM, Rotllant J, Pierce GJ, Saavedra C. Environmental DNA (eDNA) for monitoring marine mammals: challenges and opportunities. Front Mar Sci 2022; 9:987774.

[79] Drazen JC, Smith CR, Gjerde KM, Haddock SHD, Carter GS, Choy CA, et al. Opinion: Midwater ecosystems must be considered when evaluating environmental risks of deep—sea mining. PNAS 2020; 117(30):17455—60.

[80] Runwal P. Stressed out jellyfish. C&EN Glob Enterp 2023; 101(39):6.

[81] Santillan SN, Leitner AB, Reisenbichler KR, Sherlock RE, Robison BH. The effects of deep sea mining on midwater organisms, 2022.

[82] Katona S, Paulikas D, Ali S, Clarke M, Ilves E, Lovejoy TE, et al. Land and deep—sea mining: the challenges of comparing biodiversity impacts. Biodivers Conserv 2023; 32(4):1125-64.

[83] Liu SH, Yang JM, Lu HN, Sun PF, Zhang B. A numerical investigation of the dynamic interaction between the deep—sea mining vehicle and sediment plumes based on a small—scale analysis. J Mar Sci Eng 2023; 11(7):1458.

[84] Mingotti N, Woods AW. Dynamics of sediment—laden plumes in the ocean. Flow 2022; 2:E26.

[85] Peacock T, Ouillon R. The fluid mechanics of deep—sea mining. Annu Rev Fluid Mech 2023; 55:403—30.

[86] Muñoz—Royo C, Ouillon R, El Mousadik S, Alford MH, Peacock T. An in situ study of abyssal turbidity—current sediment plumes generated by a deep seabed polymetallic nodule mining preprototype collector vehicle. Sci Adv 2022; 8(38):eabn1219.

[87] Ouillon R, Muñoz—Royo C, Alford MH, Peacock T. Advection—diffusion settling of deep—sea mining sediment plumes. Part 2. Collector plumes. Flow 2022; 2: E23.

[88] Ali W, Enthoven D, Kirichek A, Chassagne C, Helmons R. Effect of flocculation on turbidity currents. Front Earth Sci 2022; 10:1014170.

[89] Zhang FP, Chen XG, Liu JZ, Zhang YY. A new countermeasure to deep—sea mining sediment plumes: using flocculant to enhance particles settling. Appl Ocean Res 2024; 142:103811.

[90] El Mousadik S, Ouillon R, Muñoz—Royo C, Slade W, Pottsmith C, Leeuw T, et al. In situ optical measurement of particles in sediment plumes generated by a pre—prototype polymetallic nodule collector. Sci Rep 2024; 14(1):23894.

[91] Van Smirren J, Banks A, Foster T, Clarke M, Marsh L, Allen K. Observing deep water sediment plumes using mobile and seabed deployed instrumentation. Offshore Technology Conference. May 6—9, 2024. Houston, Texas, USA. OTC, 2024: D021S023R006.

[92] Zhang YX, Li SY. Dynamic boundary estimation of suspended sediment plume benefit by the autonomous underwater vehicle sensing. Sensors 2024;24(24):8182.

[93] Schoening T, Bodur Y, Köser K, Automated Image Analysis to Map the Extent of Deep—Sea Mining Plumes Reveals a Larger Impacted Area Compared to Manual Analysis, 2021.

[94] Bakker J, Wangensteen OS, Baillie C, Buddo D, Chapman DD, Gallagher AJ, et al. Biodiversity assessment of tropical shelf eukaryotic communities via pelagic eDNA metabarcoding. Ecol Evol 2019; 9(24):14341—55.

[95] Morato T, Juliano M, Pham CK, Carreiro—Silva M, Martins I, Colaço A. Modelling the dispersion of seafloor massive sulphide mining plumes in the mid Atlantic ridge around the Azores. Front Mar Sci 2022; 9:910940.

[96] Aguzzi J, Thomsen L, Flögel S, Robinson NJ, Picardi G, Chatzievangelou D, et al. New technologies for monitoring and upscaling marine ecosystem restoration in deep—sea environments. Engineering 2024; 34:195-211.

[97] Du ZF, Zhang X, Lian C, Luan ZD, Xi SC, Li LF, et al. The development and applications of a controllable lander for in—situ, long—term observation of deep sea chemosynthetic communities. Deep Sea Res Part I Oceanogr Res Pap 2023; 193:103960.

[98] Liu LJ, Liao ZB, Chen CY, Chen JL, Niu J, Jia YG, et al. A seabed real—time sensing system for in—situ long—term multi—parameter observation applications. Sensors 2019; 19(5):1255.

[99] Graber HC, Terray EA, Donelan MA, Drennan WM, Van Leer JC, Peters DB. ASIS: A new air—sea interaction spar buoy: design and performance at sea. J Atmos Oceanic Tech 2000; 17(5):708—20.

[100] Global Sea Mineral Resources NV, Environmental Impact Statement: Small—Scale Testing of Nodule Collector Components on the Seafloor of the Clarion—Clipperton Fracture Zone and its Environmental Impact. Tech. Rep. Global Sea Mineral Resources NV., 2018.

[101] Thomas P. The GSR Patania II Expedition: Technical Achievements & Scientific Learnings, 2023.

[102] The Metals Company, Collector Test Study Environmental Management and Monitoring Plan, 2022.

[103] O’Malley BJ, Schwing PT, Chernoch SK, Larson RA, Clarke M, Marsh LM, et al. Thorium—234 as a tracer for deep—sea mining sediment plume deposition. Nat Commun 2025; 16(1):10633.

[104] TMC, NORI—D Environment Program Update, 2023.

[105] China Minmetals Corporation, Environmental Impact Statement Testing of Polymetallic Nodule Collector Vehicle in the Block A—5 of the Minmetals Contract Area, 2024.

[106] Beijing Pioneer Hi—Tech Development Corporation, Environmental Impact Statement of Seabed Collection and Relay Linkage Test in Beijing Pioneer Polymetallic Nodules Contract Area, 2024.

[107] Haalboom S, Schoening T, Urban P, Gazis IZ, de Stigter H, Gillard B, et al. Monitoring of anthropogenic sediment plumes in the clarion—clipperton zone, NE equatorial Pacific Ocean. Front Mar Sci 2022; 9:882155.

[108] Jin S, Chen XG, Liu XX, Zhang X, Xie AQ, Yan JH. Research on benthic plume sedimentation characteristics and temperature effect in deep—sea nodule mining operation. Mar Geol 2023; 464:107141.

[109] Gollner S, Haeckel M, Janssen F, Lefaible N, Molari M, Papadopoulou S, et al. Restoration experiments in polymetallic nodule areas. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2022; 18(3):682-96.

[110] Simon—Lledó E, Bett BJ, Huvenne VAI, Schoening T, Benoist NMA, Jones DOB. Ecology of a polymetallic nodule occurrence gradient: implications for deep—sea mining. Limnol Oceanogr 2019; 64:1883-94.

[111] Washburn TW, Iguchi A, Yamaoka K, Nagao M, Onishi Y, Fukuhara T, et al. Impacts of the first deep—sea seafloor massive sulfide mining excavation tests on benthic communities. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 2023; 712:1-19.

[112] Washburn TW, Simon—Lledó E, Soong GY, Suzuki A. Seamount mining test provides evidence of ecological impacts beyond deposition. Curr Biol 2023; 33(14):3065-71.e3.

[113] Wurz E, Olsen LMB, Busch K, Ulvatn T, Rapp HT, Osinga R, et al. Adverse effects of crushed seafloor massive sulphide deposits on the boreal deep—sea sponge Geodia barretti Bowerbank, 1858 and its associated fauna. Deep Sea Res Part I Oceanogr Res Pap 2024; 208:104311.

[114] Jones DOB, Arias MB, Van Audenhaege L, Blackbird S, Boolukos C, Bribiesca—Contreras G, et al. Long—term impact and biological recovery in a deep—sea mining track. Nature 2025; 642(8066):112-8.

[115] Stratmann T, Lins L, Purser A, Marcon Y, Rodrigues CF, Ravara A, et al. Abyssal plain faunal carbon flows remain depressed 26 years after a simulated deep—sea mining disturbance. Biogeosciences 2018; 15(13): 4131-45.

[116] Deberdt R, James CBG. Self—governance at depth: the international seabed authority and verification culture of the deep—sea mining industry. Resour Policy 2024; 89:104577.

[117] Pickens C, Lily H, Harrould—Kolieb E, Blanchard C, Chakraborty A. From what—if to what—now: Status of the deep—sea mining regulations and underlying drivers for outstanding issues. Mar Policy 2024; 169:105967.

[118] Kung A, Svobodova K, Lèbre E, Valenta R, Kemp D, Owen JR. Governing deep sea mining in the face of uncertainty. J Environ Manag 2021; 279:111593.

[119] Macchi C. Corporate responsibility and deep seabed mining: the limits of due diligence. Bus And Hum Rights J 2025; 10(1):122-46.

[120] Strehse C, Langosch H, Lenz OJ, Schacht S, Schütt C, Kosleck S. Prototyping and evaluation of an open—source based tailor—made turbidity monitoring system for deep—sea mining application. OCEANS 2023 — Limerick. June 5—8, 2023, Limerick, Ireland. IEEE, 2023:1-6.

[121] Ma CY, Li X, Li YJ, Tian XL, Wang YC, Kim H, et al. Visual information processing for deep—sea visual monitoring system. Cogn Robot 2021; 1:3-11.

[122] El Hiouile L, Errami A, Azami N. Towards mine 4.0: A proposed multi—layered architecture for real—time surveillance and anomaly detection in an open—pit phosphate mine. Mining 2024; 4(3):672-86.

[123] Chang ZQ, Liu SB, Xiong XX, Cai ZH, Tu GQ. A survey of recent advances in edge—computing—powered artificial intelligence of things. IEEE Internet Things J 2021; 8(18):13849-75.

[124] Cacciuttolo C, Guzmán V, Catriñir P, Atencio E, Komarizadehasl S, Lozano—Galant JA. Low—cost sensors technologies for monitoring sustainability and safety issues in mining activities: Advances, gaps, and future directions in the digitalization for smart mining. Sensors 2023; 23(15):6846.

[125] Alhaddad S, Mehta D, Helmons R. Mining of deep—seabed nodules using a Coanda˘—effect—based collector. Results Eng 2023; 17:100852.

[126] Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources, Environmental Impact Statement: For small—scale testing of an AI—controlled nodule harvester in the eastern BGR contract area for the exploration of polymetallic nodules (Clarion—Clipperton Zone), 2025.