Unveiling the regulatory mechanisms of rock fracture behavior and catastrophic failure predictability: The key role of porosity

Abstract

This study investigates the influence of porosity on the Mode I fracture behavior of granite and the predictability of catastrophic failure. Pores are defined in a broad sense to include intrinsic pores and microcrack-type defect structures that collectively contribute to rock heterogeneity. Granite specimens were heat-treated at ambient temperature, 450 °C, and 900 °C to induce porosity variations, which were quantified using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR). Three-point bending (TPB) tests were conducted with real-time monitoring using Digital Image Correlation (DIC) and Acoustic Emission (AE). The results show that increasing porosity significantly reduces rock strength, fracture toughness, and fracture energy. As porosity increases from 0.68% to 1.33%, the crack initiation and unstable fracture toughness decrease by 94.6% and 87.0%, while crack mouth opening displacement (CMOD), fracture process zone (FPZ) size, and fracture surface roughness increase. AE results indicate that low-porosity specimens exhibit few high-energy events typical of abrupt brittle fracture, whereas high-porosity specimens generate numerous low-energy events associated with distributed microcrack coalescence. Time-Reversed Omori Law (TROL) analysis shows that higher porosity leads to predicted failure times closer to actual collapse, indicating improved predictability. These results demonstrate that pore-related heterogeneity plays a key role in regulating fracture behavior and catastrophic failure predictability.

Keywords

Porosity / Three-point-bending (TPB) / Fracture behavior / Acoustic emission (AE) / Catastrophic failure predictability

References

[1] Dou FK, Wang JG, Zhang XX, Wang HM. Effect of joint parameters on fracturing behavior of shale in notched three—point—bending test based on discrete element model. Eng Fract Mech 2019; 205:40-56.

[2] Le CJ, Ren XH, Wang HJ, Yu SY. Experimental and numerical study on the failure characteristics of brittle solids with a circular hole and internal cracks. Materials 2022; 15(4):1406.

[3] Wu LW, Huang YL, Li JM, Wang GY, Li YS, Li XT, et al. Macro— and micromechanical response and damage mechanism of sandstone under high—temperature conditions. Int J Min Sci Technol 2025; 35(2):265-74.

[4] Qian YN, Liu T, Zhai C, Wen HD, Zhang YB, Zheng MH, et al. Real—time monitoring and analysis of hydraulic fracturing in surface well using microseismic technology: Case insights and methodological advances. Int J Min Sci Technol 2025; 35(4):619—38.

[5] Zou QL, Chen ZH, Zhan JF, Chen CM, Gao SK, Kong FJ, et al. Morphological evolution and flow conduction characteristics of fracture channels in fractured sandstone under cyclic loading and unloading. Int J Min Sci Technol 2023; 33(12):1527—40.

[6] Tutluoglu L, Karatas Batan C, Aliha MRM. Tensile mode fracture toughness experiments on andesite rock using disc and semi—disc bend geometries with varying loading spans. Theor Appl Fract Mech 2022; 119:103325.

[7] Nicksiar M, Martin CD. Factors affecting crack initiation in low porosity crystalline rocks. Rock Mech Rock Eng 2014; 47(4):1165-81.

[8] Liu HY, Roquete M, Kou SQ, Lindqvist PA. Characterization of rock heterogeneity and numerical verification. Eng Geol 2004; 72(1—2):89-119.

[9] Li XF, Li HB, Zhao J. Transgranular fracturing of crystalline rocks and its influence on rock strengths: Insights from a grain—scale continuum—discontinuum approach. Comput Meth Appl Mech Eng 2021; 373:113462.

[10] Bubeck A, Walker RJ, Healy D, Dobbs M, Holwell DA. Pore geometry as a control on rock strength. Earth Planet Sci Lett 2017; 457:38-48.

[11] Wong TF, David C, Zhu WL. The transition from brittle faulting to cataclastic flow in porous sandstones: Mechanical deformation. J Geophys Res 1997; 102(B2):3009—25.

[12] Forbes Inskip ND, Meredith PG. Fracture properties of Nash point limestone and implications for fracturing of layered carbonate sequences. Rock Mech Rock Eng 2021; 54(10):5155-66.

[13] Nasseri MHB, Schubnel A, Young RP. Coupled evolutions of fracture toughness and elastic wave velocities at high crack density in thermally treated Westerly granite. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2007; 44(4):601—16.

[14] McBeck J, Mair K, Renard F. How porosity controls macroscopic failure via propagating fractures and percolating force chains in porous granular rocks. JGR Solid Earth 2019; 124(9):9920—39.

[15] Zhao YQ, Qin WJ, Jin AB, Wu HY, Chen Z. Research and analysis of the impact of the pore structure on the mechanical properties and fracture mechanism of sandstone. Mater Today Commun 2024; 38:107753.

[16] Wong LNY, Maruvanchery V, Liu G. Water effects on rock strength and stiffness degradation. Acta Geotech 2016; 11(4):713—37.

[17] Renard F, Weiss J, Mathiesen J, Ben—Zion Y, Kandula N, Cordonnier B. Critical evolution of damage toward system—size failure in crystalline rock. JGR Solid Earth 2018; 123(2):1969-86.

[18] Borja da Rocha H, Truskinovsky L. Rigidity—controlled crossover: From spinodal to critical failure. Phys Rev Lett 2020; 124:015501.

[19] Zapperi S, Ray P, Stanley HE, Vespignani A. First—order transition in the breakdown of disordered media. Phys Rev Lett 1997; 78(8):1408-11.

[20] Alava MJ, Nukala PKVV, Zapperi S. Statistical models of fracture. Adv Phys 2006; 55(3—4):349-476.

[21] Lei XL, Kusunose K, Nishizawa O, Cho A, Satoh T. On the spatio—temporal distribution of acoustic emissions in two granitic rocks under triaxial compression: The role of pre—existing cracks. Geophys Res Lett 2000; 27(13):1997-2000.

[22] Cartwright—Taylor A, Main IG, Butler IB, Fusseis F, Flynn M, King A. Catastrophic failure: How and when insights from 4—D in situ X—ray microtomography. JGR Solid Earth 2020; 125(8):e2020JB019642.

[23] Liu Q, Pan C, Yan L, Wang XG, Li SJ, Cao JC. Acoustic emission characteristics and damage constitutive model of fractured sandstone under uniaxial compression. Sci Rep 2025; 15:3128.

[24] Zhang Q, Zhang L, Jiang XT. Acoustic emission characteristics and fracture mechanism of sandstone in open—pit mines under different types of cyclic loads. Front Earth Sci 2024; 12:1419604.

[25] Lei RD, Gu QH, Hu C, He P, Zhou LS. Acoustic emission signal characteristics and precursory recognition of rock failure in fractured sandstone. Rock Soil Mech 2025; 46(7):2023-38.

[26] Mandelbrot BB, Passoja DE, Paullay AJ. Fractal character of fracture surfaces of metals. Nature 1984; 308(5961):721—2.

[27] Odling NWA, Elphick SC, Meredith P, Main I, Ngwenya BT. Laboratory measurement of hydrodynamic saline dispersion within a micro—fracture network induced in granite. Earth Planet Sci Lett 2007; 260(3—4):407-18.

[28] Pan JL, Ma YC, Zhang LM, Xi X, Zhang Y, Cai MF. Effect of heat treatment on microcracking behaviors and Mode—I fracture characteristics of granite: An experimental and numerical investigation. Theor Appl Fract Mech 2024; 132:104489.

[29] Blaber J, Adair B, Antoniou A. Ncorr: Open—source 2D digital image correlation Matlab software. Exp Mech 2015; 55(6):1105-22.

[30] Mohnke O, Jorand R, Nordlund C, Klitzsch N. Understanding NMR relaxometry of partially water—saturated rocks. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci 2015; 19(6):2763-73.

[31] Xi Y, Xing JH, Jiang HL, Fan LF, Li J. Pore characteristic evolution and damage deterioration of granite subjected to the thermal and cooling treatments combined with the NMR method. Bull Eng Geol Environ 2023; 82(5):182.

[32] Vashaee S, Marica F, Newling B, Balcom BJ. A comparison of magnetic resonance methods for spatially resolved T₂ distribution measurements in porous media. Meas Sci Technol 2015; 26(5):055601.

[33] Hao JW, Qiao L, Liu ZY, Li QW. Effect of thermal treatment on physical and mechanical properties of sandstone for thermal energy storage: A comprehensive experimental study. Acta Geotech 2022; 17(9):3887-908.

[34] Xu SL, Reinhardt HW. Determination of double—K criterion for crack propagation in quasi—brittle fracture. Part I: Experimental investigation of crack propagation. Int J Fract 1999; 98(2):111-49.

[35] Xu SL, Reinhardt HW. Determination of double—K criterion for crack propagation in quasi—brittle fracture. Part II: Analytical evaluating and practical measuring methods for three—point bending notched beams. Int J Fract 1999; 98(2):151-77.

[36] Xie Q, Liu XL, Li SX, Du K, Gong FQ, Li XB. Prediction of mode I fracture toughness of shale specimens by different fracture theories considering size effect. Rock Mech Rock Eng 2022; 55(11):7289—306.

[37] Xie Q, Liu XL, Fan L, Peng SQ, Zeng Y. Evaluation of equivalent crack propagation length and fracture energy of two commonly used rock fracture toughness test configurations based on Bazant’s size effect law. Eng Fract Mech 2023; 281:109067.

[38] Hu XZ, Wittmann FH. Fracture energy and fracture process zone. Mater Struct 1992; 25(6):319—26.

[39] Guinea GV, Planas J, Elices M. Measurement of the fracture energy using three—point bend tests. Part I: Influence of experimental procedures. Mater Struct 1992; 25(4):212-8.

[40] Xie Q, Chen DL, Liu XL, Zeng Y. Research on the effect of loading rate on the fracture characteristics of granite using cracked straight through Brazilian disc specimens. Theor Appl Fract Mech 2022; 122:103581.

[41] Liu XL, Han MS, He W, Li XB, Chen DL. A new b—value estimation method in rock acoustic emission testing. JGR Solid Earth 2020; 125(12):e2020JB019658.

[42] Chen DL, Liu XL, He W, Xia CG, Gong FQ, Li XB, et al. Effect of attenuation on amplitude distribution and b—value in rock acoustic emission tests. Geophys J Int 2022; 229(2):933—47.

[43] Liu XL, Liu Z, Li XB, Gong FQ, Du K. Experimental study on the effect of strain rate on rock acoustic emission characteristics. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2020; 133:104420.

[44] Du K, Li XF, Tao M, Wang SF. Experimental study on acoustic emission (AE) characteristics and crack classification during rock fracture in several basic lab tests. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 2020; 133:104411.

[45] Voight B. A method for prediction of volcanic eruptions. Nature 1988; 332(6160):125—30.

[46] Yu SY, Ren XH, Zhang JX. Using an improved SPH algorithm to simulate thermo—hydro—mechanical—damage coupling problems in rock masses. Case Stud Therm Eng 2023; 47:103085.

[47] Bell AF, Naylor M, Heap MJ, Main IG. Forecasting volcanic eruptions and other material failure phenomena: An evaluation of the failure forecast method. Geophys Res Lett 2011; 38(15):2011GL048155.

[48] Bell AF, Naylor M, Main IG. The limits of predictability of volcanic eruptions from accelerating rates of earthquakes. Geophys J Int 2013; 194(3):1541—53.