Absence heritage: A critical analysis for awareness, preservation and resilience

Abstract

Traditionally, absence heritage or heritage of absence has been used for purposeful erasure of tangible and intangible elements related primarily to affective heritage and dark heritage. Current observations, however, have indicated that there is no exact definition of such heritage, persons seem to indicate absence or presence depending on the particular scenario. This limitation arises because there is heritage that is absent purely by accident, there is heritage that is purposefully erased, there is heritage that is forgotten or destroyed by natural, man-made disasters, war, or there is simply heritage that has been modified or rewritten to suit interests, all of which can affect psychology, identity and resilience. These instances of erasure include natural and man-made disasters, climate change, and museum collections held in trust for protection and preservation, to name a few. This paper recommends the extension of the current use and proposition of a definition of absence heritage to provide a more holistic view of the state of affairs. The paper presents an overview of current use, and reasons, using global examples, to aid in formulating a definition and expanding the use with strategies to reduce or mitigate erasure. With this, awareness and resilience can be built in any society.

Keywords

erasure / collective cultural amnesia / cultural resilience / disaster heritage

References

[1] Accardo G., Altieri A., Cacace C., Giani E., & Giovagnoli A. (2003). Risk map: A project to aid decision-making in the protection, preservation and conservation of Italian cultural heritage. Conservation science 2002: Papers from the conference held in Edinburgh, Scotland 22-24 May 2002(pp. 44-49). London, UK: Archetype Publications.

[2] Araujo A. L. (2019). The death of Brazil’s National Museum. The American Historical Review, 124(2), 569-580.

[3] Belford P. (2015). Inhabitants and inhabitance:Archaeology and memory in industrial spaces. In H.Orange (Ed.), Reanimating industrial spaces: Conducting memory work in post-industrial societies (pp. 28-48). California: Left Coast Press.

[4] Bertman S. (2000). Cultural amnesia: America's future and the crisis of memory. Westport: Praeger.

[5] Bimber O., Encarnação L. M., & Schmalstieg D. (2003). The virtual showcase as a new platform for augmented reality digital storytelling. Proceedings of the Workshop on Virtual Environments 2003 (IPT/EGVE ’03)(pp. 87-95). New York: Association for Computing Machinery.

[6] Bindman D. (2017). Representing race in the eighteenth-century Caribbean: Brunias in Dominica and St Vincent. Eighteenth-Century Studies, 51(1), 1-21. Bramall, R. (2007). On cultural amnesia critical theory and contemporary discourses of forgetting. (Doctoral dissertation). University of East London, London.

[7] Bull A. C., & De Angeli D. (2020). Emotions and critical thinking at a dark heritage site: Investigating visitors’ reactions to a First World War Museum in Slovenia. Journal of Heritage Tourism, 16(3), 263-280.

[8] Carcavilla L., Diaz-Martinez E., Garcia-Cortes A., & Vegas J. (2019). Geoheritage and geodiversity (PanAfGeo ed., p. 24 ). Madrid: Instituto Gepologico y Minero de Espana.

[9] Cashman K. V., & Cronin S. J. (2008). Welcoming a monster to the world: Myths, oral tradition, and modern societal response to volcanic disasters. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, 176, 407-418.

[10] Cassan C. (2019). The Sarr-Savoy report & restituting colonial artifacts. Retrieved from https://itsartlaw.org/2019/01/31/the-sarr-savoy-report-restituting-colonial- artifacts/.

[11] Cepeniuk K. (2022). More than an exhibition-Top benefits of AR and VR in museums. Retrieved from https://4experience.co/modern-exhibition-benefits-of-vr-and- ar-in-museums/#:∼:text=They%20can%20see%20the%20paintings,easy%20creation%20of%20virtual%20ones.

[12] Davis L. (2017). Addressing indigenous language loss by unsettling the linguistic hierarchies entrenched in Canada’s language policies. Working Papers of the Linguistics Circle of the University of Victoria, 27(1), 52-78..

[13] De Beer S. F. (2013). Absence, presence, remembrance: A theological essay on frailty, the university and the city. Verbum et Ecclesia, 34(1), 855-863.

[14] Diefendorf J. M. (2009). Reconstructing devastated cities: Europe after World War II and New Orleans after Katrina. Journal of Urban Design, 14(3), 377-397.

[15] Dumas P. E. (2016). Proslavery Britain: Fighting for slavery in an era of abolition. New York: Macmillan.

[16] Gjerde M. (2017). Building back better: Learning from the Christchurch rebuild. Procedia Engineering, 198, 530-540.

[17] Good M. (2016). Shaping Japan’s disaster heritage. In A.Matsuda, & L. E.Mengoni ( Reconsidering cultural heritage in East Asia Eds.), (pp. 139-161). London: Ubiquity Press.

[18] Goulding C. (2000). The commodification of the past, postmodern pastiche, and the search for authentic experiences at contemporary heritage attractions. European Journal of Marketing, 34(7), 835-853.

[19] Goulding C., & Domic D. (2009). Heritage, identity and ideological manipulation: The case of Croatia. Annals of Tourism Research, 36(1), 85-102.

[20] Goulding C., Saren M., & Pressey A. (2018). ‘Presence’ and ‘absence’ in themed heritage. Annals of Tourism Research, 71, 21-38.

[21] Green P. E. (1984). ‘Small settlers’ houses in Chapleton: Microcosm of the Jamaican vernacular. Jamaica Journal, 17(3), 39-45.

[22] Green P. E. (1996). Vernacular architecture:The development of a Jamaican traditional style. In P.Green (Ed.), Monuments and sites: Jamaica (pp. 63-76). Colombo: International Council on Monuments and Sites.

[23] Green P. E. (2000). The architecture of the Caribbean:Colonial, Caribbean and the small-scale architectural pieces. In H. vanHooff (Ed.), Proceedings of the Cultural Heritage of the Caribbean and the World Heritage Convention (pp. 285-304). Paris: UNESCO.

[24] Green P. E. (2022). Creole and vernacular architecture: Embryonic syncretism in Caribbean cultural landscape. The Journal of Architecture, 27(1), 21-43.

[25] Gregory J. (2008). Reconsidering relocated buildings: ICOMOS, authenticity and mass relocation. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 14(2), 112-130.

[26] Gullickson C. (2023). Decolonizing the museum. interventions, 25(8), 1110-1133. https://doi.org/10.1080/1369801X.2022.2161063.

[27] Hamilton D. (2001). Map of Port Royal, Jamaica. In C. J. Manson, & L. Walkling (Eds.), TsuInfoalert. (Vol. 3, p. 21). Washington, DC: Division of Geology and Earth Resources, Washington Department of Natural Resources.

[28] Hamilton D. L. (2006). Port royal, Jamaica:Archaeological past and development potential. In R.Grenier, D.Nutley, & I.Cochran ( Underwater cultural heritage at risk: Managing natural and human impacts Eds.), (pp. 49-52). Paris: ICOMOS.

[29] Harrison R. (2013). Heritage: Critical approaches. New York: Routledge.

[30] Hartog F. (2005). Time and heritage. Museum International, 57(3), 7-18.

[31] Harvey D. C. (2001). Heritage pasts and heritage presents: Temporality, meaning and the scope of heritage studies. International Journal of Heritage Studies, 7(4), 319-338.

[32] Hernandez J. (2022). Fresh banana leaves: Healing indigenous landscapes through indigenous science. Berkeley: North Atlantic Books.

[33] Hofman C. L., Stancioff C. E., Richards A., Auguiste I. N., Sutherland A., & Hoogland M. L. P. (2021). Resilient Caribbean communities: A long-term perspective on sustainability and social adaptability to natural hazards in the Lesser Antilles. Sustainability, 13(17), 9807.

[34] Holtorf C. (2018). Embracing change: How cultural resilience is increased through cultural heritage. World Archaeology, 50(4), 639-650.

[35] Jigyasu R., Murthy M., Boccardi G., Marrion C., Douglas D., King J., … Osihn M. (2013, May). Heritage and resilience: Issues and opportunities for reducing disaster risk. Paper presented at the 4th Session of the Global Platform for Disaster Risk Reduction, Geneva, Switzerland.

[36] Kalmoy A. D. (2018). Decolonizing African art: Colonial heritage and European museums’ gordian knot. Retrieved from https://politicstoday.org/decolonizing-african- art-colonial-heritage-and-european-museums-gordian-knot/.

[37] Kamol E. (2020). Bangladesh heritage sites disappearing in absence of list, conservation. Retrieved from https://www.newagebd.net/article/119172/bangladesh- heritage-sites-disappearing-in-absence-of-list-conservation.

[38] Kassouha Z. A. (2019). Post-conflict tourist landscapes: Between the heritage of conflict and the hybridization of tourism activity: Observations from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Via: Tourism Review, 15(15). https://doi.org/10.4000/viatourism.3984.

[39] Khakzad S. (2015). Integrated approach in management of coastal cultural heritage. (Doctoral Dissertation). Arenberg Doctoral School, Belgium. Ku Leuven.

[40] Komianos V. (2022). Immersive applications in museums: An analysis of the use of XR technologies and the provided functionality based on systematic literature re-view. International Journal on Informatics Visualization, 6(1), 60-73.

[41] Kramarae C., Schulz M., & O’Barr W. M. (1984). Language and power. Beverly Hills, California: Sage Publications. Kushner, J. ( 2022). Kenya wants its treasures back. Replicas could spur their return. Retrieved from https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/kenya-wants-its-stolen-treasures-back-replicas-could-spur-their-return.

[42] Lagomarsino S. (2012). Damage assessment of churches after L’Aquila earthquake (2009). Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 10, 73-92.

[43] Lassonde M., Candel S., Hackler J., Quadrio-Curzio A., Onishi T., Ramakrishnan V., & McNutt M. (2017). Cultural heritage: Building resilience to natural disasters. G7 Academies Joint Statements 23-24 March 2017. Rome: Italy.

[44] Lauter C. (2021). For an earthquake-damaged castle, reality capture helps put the pieces back together. Retrieved from https://www.geoweeknews.com/sponsored/ for-an-earthquake-damaged-castle-reality-capture-helps-put-the-pieces-back-together.

[45] Law A., & Chen X. (2019). ‘Absent-present’ heritage:The cultural heritage of dwelling on the Chang Jiang (Yangtze) River. In C.Hein (Ed.), Adaptive strategies for water heritage: Past, present and future (pp. 272-289). Cham: Springer.

[46] Lewis D. (2015). These Century-Old Stone “Tsunami Stones” Dot Japan’s Coastline “Remember the calamity of the great tsunamis. Do not build any homes below this point.” Smithsonian Magazine. Retrieved from https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/century-old-warnings-against-tsunamis-dot-japans-coastline- 180956448/.

[47] Luongo G., Perrotta A., Scarpati C., De Carolis E., Patricelli G., & Ciarallo A. (2003). Impact of the AD 79 explosive eruption on Pompeii, II. Causes of death of the in- habitants inferred by stratigraphic analysis and areal distribution of the human casualties. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, 126(3-4), 169-200.

[48] MacDonald J. (2018). Brazil’s Museu Nacional was more than just a museum. Retrieved from https://daily.jstor.org/brazils-museu-nacional-was-more-than-just-a- museum/.

[49] Marzeion B., & Levermann A. (2014). Loss of cultural world heritage and currently inhabited places to sea-level rise. Environmental Research Letters, 9(3), 15-21. McClean, R., Cochran, C., Kelly, M., & Greig, K. (2007). Sustainable management of historic heritage guidance series: Assessment of effects on the historic environment. Wellington: New Zealand Historic Places Trust.

[50] Mega E. R. (2020). Second Brazilian Museum fire in two years reignites calls for reform. Nature, 583, 175-176.

[51] Meier L., Frers L., & Sigvardsdotter E. (2013). The importance of absence in the present: Practices of remembrance and the contestation of absences. Cultural Geographies, 20(4), 423-430.

[52] Micieli-Voutsinas J. (2016). An absent presence: Affective heritage at the National September 11th Memorial & Museum. Emotion, Space and Society, 24, 93-104.

[53] Mohammed P. (2001). The emergence of a Caribbean iconography in the evolution of identity. In B.Meeks, & F.Lindahl ( New Caribbean though:Eds.), A reader (pp.232-264). Mona: University of the West Indies Press.

[54] Nakada S., Shimizu H., & Ohta K. (1999). Overview of the 1990-1995 eruption at Unzen Volcano. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research, 89, 1-22.

[55] Németh K., & Gravis I. (2022). Geoheritage and geodiversity elements of the SW Pacific: A conceptual framework. International Journal of Geoheritage and Parks, 10(4), 523-545. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijgeop.2022.09.001.

[56] Nishikawa E. (2018). Earthquake as heritage-examples from Japan. Retrieved from https://www.iccrom.org/news/earthquake-heritage-%E2%80%93-examples-japan.

[57] O’Brien, G., O’Keefe, P., Jayawickrama, J., & Jigyasu, R. (2015). Developing a model for building resilience to climate risks for cultural heritage. Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development, 5(2), 99-114.

[58] Okaro I., & Vlachopoulos D. (2020, March). Exploring the use of mixed reality (MR) in museum education: A systematic literature review. Paper presented at the 14th International Technology, Education and Development conference, Valencia, Spain.

[59] Okubo T., & Izuno K. (2011). Handbook of countermeasures to protect cultural heritages located in foothills from natural disasters. Journal of Disaster Research, 6(1), 142-153.

[60] Oltermann P. (2022). Germany returns 21 Benin bronzes to Nigeria - amid frustration at Britain. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/dec/20/ germany-returns-21-benin-bronzes-to-nigeria-amid-frustration-at-britain.

[61] Papagiannakis G., Geronikolakis E., Pateraki M., López-Menchero V. M., Tsioumas M., Sylaiou S.,... Magnenat-Thalmann N. (2019). Mixed reality, gamified presence, and storytelling for virtual museums. In N.Lee (Ed.), Encyclopedia of computer graphics and games. Cham: Springer.

[62] Pescatore E., Bentivenga M., & Giano S. I. (2023). Geoheritage and geoconservation: Some remarks and considerations. Sustainability, 15(7), 5823. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15075823.

[63] Petronis M. S., Garza D., & Van Wyk de Vries B. (2019). The leaning Puy de Dôme (Auvergne, France) tilted by shallow intrusions. Volcanica, 2(2), 161-186.

[64] Pigou-Dennis E. (2005, October). The Jamaican bungalow, 1914-1950: Repository of social history on contemporary terrain. Paper presented at the 15th ICOMOS General Assembly and International Symposium:Monuments and Sites in Their Setting-Conserving Cultural Heritage in Changing Townscapes and Landscapes, Xi’an, China.

[65] Pigou-Dennis E. (2021). From neighbourhoods to fortified settlements-where is Kingston heading? Retrieved from https://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/commentary/ 20210716/elizabeth-pigou-dennis-neighbourhoods-fortified-settlements-where.

[66] Reading A. (2003). Digital interactivity in public memory institutions: The uses of new technologies in Holocaust museums. Media, Culture and Society, 25(1), 67-85.

[67] Reimann L., Vafeidis A. T., Brown S., Hinkel J., & Tol R. (2018). Mediterranean UNESCO World Heritage at risk from coastal flooding and erosion due to sea-level rise. Nature Communications, 9, 4161. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-06645-9.

[68] Richards A. (2022). The potential effects of climate change on Jamaica’s pre-Columbian archaeological record: Monitor, assess, mitigate and adapt. Journal of Caribbean Archaeology, 22.

[69] Rouquette S., Jacquez L., van Wyk de Vries B., & Franco L. M. (2023). Exploring the best communication channels to inform a local population about volcanic risk. Volcanica, 6(1), 45-62.

[70] Şahin C. Y., & Tutkun M. (2019, April). Guide proposal for relocation practices in conservation of architectural heritage. Paper presented at the International Civil Engi- neering and Architecture Conference, Trabzon, Turkey.

[71] Sarma B. B. (2009). A brief study of heritage issues in Bangladesh, with special reference to Dhaka City. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1433682.

[72] Sarr F., & Savoy B. (2018). The restitution of African cultural heritage: Toward a new relational ethics. Paris: Ministry of Culture.

[73] Satchell V., & Roper S. (2007). The William James foundry 1817-1843: An exposé of local metallurgical enterprise. Industrial Archaeological Review, 29(2), 105-113.

[74] Scarlett J. P., & Reide F. (2019). The dark geocultural heritage of volcanoes: Combining cultural and geoheritage perspectives for mutual benefit. Geoheritage, 11, 1705-1721.

[75] Shoenberger E. (2019). What does it mean to decolonize a museum? Retrieved from https://www.museumnext.com/article/what-does-it-mean-todecolonize-a- museum/.

[76] Silverman H. (2010). Contested cultural heritage:A selective historiography. In H.Silverman (Ed.), Contested cultural heritage (pp. 1-49). New York: Springer.

[77] Song Q., Dong Y., Sun M., Hu X., Chen F., Ji Y., Wang J., Huang Z., & Li H. (2022). The types, grades and distribution features of geoheritage in China: An inventory. International Journal of Geoheritage and Parks, 11(3), 514-526.

[78] Sylaiou S., Kasapakis V., Dzardanova E., & Gavalas G. (2018, September). Leveraging mixed reality technologies to enhance museum visitor experiences. Paper presented at the 2018 International Conference on Intelligent Systems (IS), Madeira, Portugal.

[79] Sylaiou S., Mania K., Karoulis A., & White M. (2010). Exploring the relationship between presence and enjoyment in a virtual museum. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 68(5), 243-253.

[80] Tang Y. (2018). Dark tourism to seismic memorial sites. In P. R.Stone, R.Hartmann, T.Seaton, R. Eds.),Sharpley, & L. White (The palgrave handbook of dark tourism studies (pp. 423-441). London: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-47566-4_18.

[81] Thomas M. (2022). Jamaica’s vanishing legacy of historic buildings. Retrieved from https://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/art-leisure/20221002/jamaicas-vanishing- legacy-historic-buildings.

[82] Thorpe K., & Galassi M. (2014). Rediscovering indigenous languages: The role and impact of libraries and archives in cultural revitalization. Australian Academic and Research Libraries, 45(2), 81-100.

[83] UNESCO (2012). Unzen Volcanic Area UNESCO Global Geopark (Japan). Retrieved from https://en.unesco.org/global-geoparks/unzen-volcanic-area.

[84] UNESCO (2021). Heritage, disaster response and resilience. Retrieved from https://unesco.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Heritage-Disaster-Response-and- Resilience-Report.pdf.

[85] UNESCO World Heritage Convention (2000). Ruins of León Viejo. Retrieved from https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/613/.

[86] Vereb V. (2021). Geoheritage and resilience: Selected studies of volcanic geoheritage areas from different geographical environments and different levels of protection (Doctoral dissertation). EötvösLoránd University, Budapest, Hungary.

[87] Vereb V., Wyk V., de Vries B., Hagos M., & Karátson D. (2020). Geoheritage and resilience of Dallol and the northern Danakil depression in Ethiopia. Geoheritage, 12 (82). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12371-020-00499-8.

[88] Wallace A. (2013). Presenting Pompeii: Steps towards reconciling conservation and tourism at an ancient site. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology, 22, 115-136. https://doi.org/10.5334/pia.406.

[89] Wang J. -J. (2014). Flood risk maps to cultural heritage: Measures and process. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 16(2), 210-220.

[90] Wu C. -C. (2013). Typhoon Morakot: Key findings from the journal TAO for improving prediction of extreme rains at landfall. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 94(2), 155-160.

[91] van Wyk de Vries B., Vereb V., & Karátson D. (2019). Geosite inventories in World Heritage sites: essential for protection and management. Geophysical Research Abstracts, 21 EGU2019-3604.

[92] Yong E. (2018). What was lost in Brazil's devastating museum fire. Retrieved from https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/09/brazil-rio-de-janeiro- museum-fire/569299/.