Sustainability and virtual water: The lessons of history

Abstract

This article aims to show that virtual water has historically been an adaptation strategy that enabled some arid regions to develop a prosperous economy without putting pressure on their scarce water resources. Virtual water is referred to as the total amount of water that is consumed to produce goods and services. As an example, in arid central Iran, the deficiency in agricultural revenues was offset by more investment in local industries that enjoyed a perennial capacity to employ more workers. The revenues of local industries weaned the population from irrigated agriculture, since most of their raw materials and also food stuff were imported from other regions, bringing a remarkable amount of virtual water. This virtual water not only sustained the region’s inhabitants, but also set the stage for a powerful polity in the face of a rapid population growth between the 13th and 15th centuries AD. The resultant surplus products entailed a vast and safe network of roads, provided by both entrepreneurs and government. Therefore, it became possible to import more feedstock such as cocoons from water-abundant regions and then export silk textiles with considerable value-added. This article concludes that a similar model of virtual water can remedy the ongoing water crisis in central Iran, where groundwater reserves are overexploited, and many rural and urban centers are teetering on the edge of socio-ecological collapse. History holds an urgent lesson on sustainability for our today’s policy that stubbornly peruses agriculture and other high-water-demand sectors in an arid region whose development has always been dependent on virtual water.

Keywords

Proto-industrialization / Water scarcity / Non-hydraulic polity / Virtual water / Political economy

Declaration of Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

We are grateful to University of Oulu that supported and hosted Majid Labbaf Khaneiki through Profi4 ArcI Visit Grant Program from June to September 2022 when this study took shape and developed.

References

[1] Ackerman, P., 1934. A biography of Ghiyath the weaver. Bull. Am. Inst. Persian Art Archaeol. 3 (7), 9-13.

[2] Adim, S.S., Shafiee, M., Mirghafoori, H., 2020. Identifying the solutions for increasing Iran’s capacity to export agricultural products to Russia market. New Res. Approaches Manage Account. 3 (26), 87-106.

[3] Akhondi Khalfi, A., Zare Bidoki, R., Fazeli Attar, S.R., 2020. Simulation of meteorological parameters under influence of climate change for years 2030-2011 and 2065- 2046 in LARS-WG5 software. Environ. Sci. Stud. 5 (3), 2791-2800.

[4] Allan, T., 2011. Virtual Water: Tackling The Threat to Our Planet’s Most Precious Resource. I.B. Tauris & Co. Ltd., London.

[5] Al-Maqdisi, 1982. The Best Divisions in the Knowledge of the Regions. Monzavi, A. (Trans.). Mo’alefan Va Motarjeman Iran, Tehran. (in Persian).

[6] Al-Tha’alibi, 1989. Book of Curious and Entertaining Information. Shahabi Khorasani, A.A. (Trans.). Astan Qods Razavi, Mashhad. (in Persian).

[7] Azari, A., 2007. The disaster of Mongols in the Islamic world. T ārikh 2 (6), 9-22 (in Persian).

[8] Azizi, H., Karimian, H., 2015. Role of merchants in the historic district of Yazd city in the period of Qajar. T ārikh-e Esl ām 16 (1), 231-261 (in Persian).

[9] Bahra, B., Naderi, N., 2020. The changes in physical structure of the historic city of Yazd from the beginning to the Timurid era. Athar 41 (3), 258-278 (in Persian).

[10] Basouli, M., Derakhsh, S., 2021. An investigating of the functions of Iranian caravanserais with a landscape approach. Manzar 13 (54), 28-37.

[11] Blow, D., 2009. Shah Abbas the Ruthless King Who Became an Iran Legend. I.B. Tauris & Co. Ltd., London.

[12] Catheren, O.S., 2008. Protoindustrialization. University of Cambridge, England.

[13] Chapagain, A.K., Hoekstra, A.Y, 2003. Virtual water flows betweennations in relation to trade in livestock and livestock products. Value of Water Research Report Series No. 13. UNESCO-IHE Institute for Water Education, Delft, the Netherlands.

[14] Coco, O., 2021. China’s early industrialization in the age of the European colonial powers: A controversial beginning. Chin. Hist. Rev. 28 (2), 113-137.

[15] Coleman, D.C., 1983. Proto-industrialization: A concept too many. Econ. Hist. Rev. 36 (3), 435-448.

[16] Dehestani, M.J., Tabatabayi, A., Asadi, S., 2011. The study of Yazd’s groundwater resources potential. 5th National Conference on Watershed Management and Soil and Water Resources Management, Iranian Society of Irrigation & Water Engineering. Kerman (in Persian).

[17] Deyon, P., Mendels, F., 1982. Proto-industrialization: Theory and Reality. University of Lille, Lille (in French).

[18] Diamond, J., 2005. Collapse:How societies Choose to Fail or Succeed. Penguin Group, New York.

[19] Dilthey, W., 1996. Hermeneutics and the Study of History. Makkreel, R.A., Rodi, F. (Eds.). PrincetonAcademic Press, Princeton. Economic Research Group, 2015. A Study on Iran’s Steel Industry. Bank-e Kh āvar Miy āneh, Tehran.

[20] Ekhtesasi, M.R., 2018. What is the situation of Yazd province in terms of water footprint? The First Meeting of Water Sciences and Environment Experts. Iran Ministry of Energy, Tehran. (in Persian).

[21] Ekrami, M., Sharifi, Z., Malekinejad, H., Ekhtesasi, M.R., 2011. The trend of qualitative and quantitative changes in Yazd’s groundwater reserves. Toloo’ Behdasht 10 (33), 82-91 (in Persian).

[22] Fallah, G., Rahchamani, M., Bayranvand, F., 2016. Estimating of sesame crop water requirement in Sabzevar climate. Arid Reg. Geographic Stud. 6 (21), 1-14 (in Persian).

[23] FAO, 2022. Trade of Agricultural Commodities 2000-2020: FAOSTAT Analytical Brief Series. FAO, Rome, p. 44.

[24] Graham, N.T., Hejazi, M.I., Kim, S.H., 2020. Future changes in the trading of virtual water. Nat. Commun. 11 (3632), 1-7.

[25] Greif, G., 2022. Merchants, proto-firms, and the German industrialization:The commercial determinants of nineteenth century town growth. In: Prize-winning student working papers(7). London School of Economics and Political Science, London.

[26] Hamzeh, M.A., Mahmudy Gharaie, M., Alizadeh Ketek Lahijani, H., Djamali, M., Moussavi Harami, R., 2016. Holocene hydrological changes in SE Iran, a key region between Indian Summer Monsoon and Mediterranean winter precipitation zones, as revealed from a lacustrine sequence from Lake Hamoun. Quat. Int. 408, 25-39 A, SI.

[27] Hoekstra, A.Y., Hung, P.Q., 2002. Virtual water trade: A quantification of virtual water flows between nations in relation to international crop trade. Value of Water Research Report Series No. 11. IHE Delft Institute for Water Education, Delft, The Netherlands.

[28] Hogeboom, R., Hoekstra, A., 2017. Water and land footprints and economic productivity as factors in local crop choice: The case of silk in Malawi. Water 9 (10), 802.

[29] Hoseini, M., 2004. Economic situation of Yazd at the time of Naser al-Din Shah. In: The Second Iranian Studies National Conference. Bony ād-e Ir ān-shen āsi, Tehran, pp. 137-175 (in Persian).

[30] Howell, D.L., 1992. Proto-industrial origins of Japanese capitalism. Asian Stud. 51 (2), 269-286.

[31] Ibn Balkhi, 1995. The Letters of Persia. Tehrani, S.J. (Ed.). Mehr, Tehran. (in Persian).

[32] Ibn Hawqal, 1966. The Face of the Earth. Sho’ar, J. (Trans.). Bonyad Farhang Iran, Tehran. (in Persian).

[33] Isacsson, M., Magnusson, L., 1987. Proto-Industrialisation in Scandinavia: Craft Skills in the Industrial Revolution. Bloomsbury Academic, London.

[34] Issar, A.S., 1995. Climatic change and the history of the Middle East. Am. Sci. 83 (4), 350-355.

[35] Jeyhani, A., 1989. The Forms of the World. Katib, A. (Trans.). Beh-Nashr, Mashhad (in Persian).

[36] Jones, M., Djamali, M., Stevens, L., Heyvaert, V., Askari, H., Noorollahi, D., Weeks, L., 2013. Mid-Holocene environmental and climatic change in Iran. In: PetrieC.A. (Ed.), Ancient Iran and Its Neighbours: Local Developments and Long-range Interactions in the 4th Millennium BC. Oxbow Books, Barnsley.

[37] Juvayni, A., 2020. The History of the World Conqueror. Negah, Tehran (in Persian).

[38] Kaboli, S., Hekmatzadeh, A.A., Darabi, H., Torabi Haghighi, A., 2021. Variation in physical characteristics of rainfall in Iran, determined using daily rainfall concentration index and monthly rainfall percentage index. Theor. Appl. Climatol. 144, 507-520.

[39] Katib, A.B.H., 2007. The New History of Yazd. Afshar, I. (Ed.), Amir-kabir, Tehran. (in Persian).

[40] Khosrow Beigi, H., Sadeghi Fard, M., Nowroozi, J., 2021. To examine the foundations of al-Muzaffar’s judiciary system. Iran Local Hist. 9 (1), 61-78 (in Persian).

[41] Kriedte, P., Medick, H., Schlumbohm, J., 1981. Industrialization Before Industrialization:Rural Industry in the Genesis of Capitalism. Cambridge University Press, New York.

[42] Labbaf Khaneiki, M., Al-Ghafri, A.S., 2022. The circle of water justice in the history of Iran. Water Secur. 16, 100122.

[43] Labbaf Khaneiki, M., 2019. Qanat and territorial cooperation in Iran. Water Hist. 11 (3-4), 185-206.

[44] Labbaf Khaneiki, M., 2020. Cultural Dynamics of Water in Iranian Civilization. Springer, Switzerland.

[45] Labbaf Khaneiki, M., 2022. Hydro-social cohesion in Iranian local communities. In: SiouiM. (Ed.), Indigenous Water and Drought Management in a Changing World. Elsevier, pp. 243-266.

[46] Langton, J., 2000. Proletarianization in the industrial revolution: Regionalism and kinship in the labour markets of the British coal industry from the seventeenth to the nineteenth centuries. Trans. Inst. Br. Geogr. 25 (1), 31-49.

[47] Le Strange, G., 1966. The Lands of the Eastern Caliphate:Mesopotamia, Persia, and Central Asia, from the Moslem Conquest to the Time of Timur. Barnes & Noble, New York.

[48] Levine, D., 1977. Family Formation in an Age of Nascent Capitalism. Academic Press, London.

[49] Liu, J., Zhao, D., Mao, G., Cui, W., Chen, H., Yang, H., 2020. Environmental sustainability of water footprint in mainland China. Geogr. Sustain. 1 (1), 8-17.

[50] Malek Mohammadi, F., 2018. Yazd at the helm of the production of fifty sesame products in the country. Samt 2277 (959), 3-8.

[51] Maserrat, H., 2016. Yazd a Memorial to History. Daf, Tehran.

[52] Matthee, R.P., 1999. The Politics of Trade in Safavid Iran: Silk for Silver 1600-1730. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[53] McCormick, M., Büntgen, U., Cane, M.A., Cook, E.R., Harper, K., Huybers, P., Litt, T., Manning, S.W., Mayewski, P.A., More, A.F.M., Nicolussi, K., Tegel, W., 2012. Climate change during and after the Roman empire: Reconstructing the past from scientific and historical evidence. J. Interdiscip. Hist. 43 (2), 169-220.

[54] Mendels, F., 1972. Proto-industrialization: The first phase of the industrialization process. J. Econ. Hist. 32 (1), 241-261.

[55] Mirdehqan, S.F., Zareyi, M.E., Noori, J., 2019. The physical-spatial structure of Yazd from the beginning of Islamic period to the Muzaffarid time according to available evidences. Geogr. Reg. Plan. 9 (4), 159-178 (in Persian).

[56] Mirzadeh, S.M.J., Jin, S., Parizi, E., Chaussard, E., Bürgmann, R., Delgado Blasco, J.M., Amani, M., Bao, H., Mirzadeh, S.H., 2021. Characterization of irreversible land subsidence in the Yazd-Ardakan plain, Iran from 2003 to 2020. JGR Solid Earth 126 (11), e2021JB022258.

[57] MohammadMoradi, A., Salehi Kakhki, A., Raie, H., 2017. An inception on the perception of the inhabiting farmsteads in Yazd. JRIA 4 (4), 1-21.

[58] Mohebi, H., Ansari, H., Hajamini, M., 2020. An analysis of the situation of water consumption in Yazd’s industries. Iran’s Econ. Issues Stud. 6 (2), 175-193 (in Persian).

[59] Molle, F., Mollinga, P.P., Wester, P., 2009. Hydraulic bureaucracies and the hydraulic mission: Flows of water, flows of power. Water Altern. 2 (3), 328-349.

[60] Naghdi, V.M., Mahdavinejad, M., 2018. Re -understanding critical circumstances of industrial heritage of Iran. International Congress on Avant-Garde Contemporary Architecture and Urbanism in Islamic Countries. Ferdowsi University of Mashhad.

[61] Narshakhi, A.M., 1984. The History of Bukhara. al-Ghabav ī A. (Trans.), Modarres Taghav ī M.T. (Ed.). Toos Publication, Tehran. (in Persian).

[62] Naẓarī S., 2013. Study of the Timur’s massacre in Sabzevar. Hist. Cult. 44 (2), 85-98 (in Persian).

[63] Ogilvie, S.C., 1993. Proto-industrialization in Europe. Continuity Change 8 (2), 159-179.

[64] Noroozi, J., Sadeghifard, M., 2022. Quality of mutual interactions between Al-Muzaffar and Sufis. Hist. Res. Iran. Islam 15 (29), 434-460 (in Persian).

[65] Ogilvie, S.C., Cerman, M., 1996. The theories of proto-industrialization. In: OgilvieS.C., CermanM. (EuropeanProto-industrialization.Eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[66] Pfister, U., 1992. The protoindustrial household economy: Toward a formal analysis. Family Hist. 17 (2), 201-232.

[67] Pishgar-Komleh, S.H., Omid, M., Heidari, M.D., 2013. On the study of energy use and GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions in greenhouse cucumber production in Yazd province. Energy 59, 63-71.

[68] Pouran, R., Raghfar, H., Ghasemi, A., Bazazan, F., 2017. Calculation of economic value of virtual water from the standpoint of irrigation efficiency. Iran Appl. Econ. Res. J. 6 (21), 189-212 (in Persian).

[69] Prude, J., 1988. Protoindustrialization in the American context: Response to Jean H. Quataert. Int. Labor Work. Class Hist. 33, 23-29.

[70] Qari Yazdi, M. N., 1980. The poetry of clothes. Mo’alefan Va Motarjeman Iran, Tehran. (in Persian).

[71] Radtke, T., 1983. Proletarianization: Past and present. Int. Labor Work. Class Hist. 24, 81-83.

[72] Ravandi, M., 2022. Social History of Iran. Vol. 1. Ketab Corporation, Los Angeles (in Persian).

[73] Roemer, H.R., 1986. Timur in Iran. In: JacksonP., LockhartL. (TheCambridge History of Iran,Eds.), Vol. 6, The Timurid and Safavid Periods. Cambridge University Press, pp. 42-97.

[74] Rzoska, J., 1980. Euphrates and Tigris Mesopotamian Ecology and Destiny. Dr. W. Junk bv Publishers, The Netherlands.

[75] Salim, M., Cheraghchi, Q., 2012. From road guardianship to emirate and the rise of the Muzaffarid kingdom. History 7 (24), 116-132 (in Persian).

[76] Samarqandi, A., 1974. The Rise of the Two Auspicious Constellations and the Confluence of the Two Oceans. Navayi, A. (Ed.). Zaban Va Farhang Iran, Tehran. (in Persian).

[77] Semsar Yazdi, A., Labbaf Khaneiki, M., 2017. Qanat Knowledge: Construction and Maintenance. Springer, the Netherlands.

[78] Sharifi, A., Pourmand, A., Canuel, E.A., Peterson, L.C., Djamali, M., Lahijani, H., Naderi, M., 2013. A high-resolution record of climate variability from Neor lake in NW Iran: Investigating the role of abrupt climate change on human civilization in west Asia. INQUA Quick Lake Workshop on Rapidly Changing Large Lakes and Human Response, Tehran. Somervill, B.A., 2010. Empires of Ancient Mesopotamia. Chelsea House, New York.

[79] Sotoode, M., 1961. Boundaries of the World. University of Tehran, Tehran. (in Persian).

[80] Sotoode, H., 1967. The History of the Muzaffarids. University of Tehran, Tehran (in Persian).

[81] Stampoulis, D., Damavandi, H.G., Boscovic, D., Sabo, J., 2020. Using satellite remote sensing and machine learning techniques towards precipitation prediction and vegetation classification. Environ. Inf. 37 (1), 1-15.

[82] Suarez-Villa, L., 1985. Industrialization in the development world: Process cycles and the new global division of labour. Can. J. Reg. Sci. VIII (3), 307-331.

[83] Talib-poor, F., 2019. Textile industry in the Safavid period. Theor. Fine Arts 6, 123-134 (in Persian).

[84] Tapper, R., McLachlan, K., 2003. Technology, Tradition and Survival: Aspects of Material Culture in the Middle East and Central Asia. Psychology Press.

[85] Tashakori Bafghi, A.A., 2013. An introduction to textile industry in Yazd in the period of Safavids. Soc. Econ. Hist. 2 (1), 51-65 (in Persian).

[86] Tavakoli, A., Dehghani Sanij, J., 2011. Main factors on export development in textile industry (the case of Yazd province textile industry). Monet. Financ. Econ. 17 (31), 59-75.

[87] Ur, J., 2014. Households and the emergence of cities in ancient Mesopotamia. Cambridge Archaeol. J. 24 (2), 249-268.

[88] Wittfogel, K., 1981. Oriental Despotism: A Comparative Study of Total Power. Vintage, USA.

[89] Yazdani, K., Menon, D.M., 2020. Capitalisms:Towards a Global History. Oxford University Press, New Delhi.

[90] Yaqubi, F., Jami alahmadi, M., Bakhshi, M.R., Sayyari, M.H., 2016. Comparison between technical and economic efficiencies of water consumption in wheat and saffron production in Qaenat. Saffron Agron. Technol. 3 (4), 225-236 (in Persian).

[91] Yazdrasa, News Agency, 2015. News No. 16540538, Dated 5 November 2015. http://yazdrasa.ir. (in Persian, accessed 16 June 2019).

[92] Zeinalī B., Pir-Mor ādiy ān, M., 2014. A study of the evolution of Yazd’s local historiography from the beginning to the Safavid period. Iran’s Local Hist. 2 (3), 103-121 (in Persian).