Evidences on adaptive mechanisms for cardiorespiratory diseases regarding extreme temperatures and air pollution: A comparative systematic review

Abstract

The negative cardiorespiratory health outcomes due to extreme temperatures and air pollution are widely studied, but knowledge about the effectiveness of the implementation of adaptive mechanisms remains unclear. The objective of this paper is to explore the evidence of adaptive mechanisms for cardiorespiratory diseases regarding extreme temperatures and air pollution by comparing the results of two systematic literature review (SLR) processes sharing the same initial research question but led by two research groups with different academic backgrounds working in the same multidisciplinary team. We start by presenting the methodological procedures and the results of the SLR triggered by the research group mainly composed by researchers with a background in geography (named geographical strategy). We then compare these results with those achieved in the SLR led by the research group with a background in epidemiology (named epidemiological strategy). Both SLR were developed under the EU Horizon 2020 Project “EXHAUSTION”. The results showed: 1) the lack of evidence regarding the effectiveness of adaptation measures, namely due to the limited number of studies about the topic, the preponderance of studies dedicated to heat extremes or the unbalance between different adaptation measures; 2) that the choice of search terms in the geographical strategy, despite being more comprehensive at first sight, ended up retrieving less results, but it brought new studies that can complement the results of the epidemiological strategy. Therefore, it is suggested that to strengthen the empirical evidence of the effectiveness of adaptation measures, powerful multidisciplinary teams should work together in the preparation of SLR in topics of great complexity, such as the one presented in this paper.

Keywords

Cardiopulmonary diseases / Extreme temperatures / Air pollution / Adaptation / Planning / Systematic literature review (SLR)

Acknowledgments

This research was conducted in the framework of the EXHAUSTION project. The project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Program (Grant No. 820655).

Supplementary materials

Supplementary material associated with this article can be found, in the online version, at doi:10.1016/j.geosus.2021.08.001.

References

[1] Abrantes, P., Silveira, H., 2009. Climate change in Europe: effect on human parasitic diseases. Port. J. Public Health 27, 71-86.(in Portuguese)

[2] Aggarwal, P., Jain, D.S., 2015. Impact of air pollutants from surface transport sources on human health: A modeling and epidemiological approach. Environ. Int. 83, 146-157.

[3] Alberini, A., Gans, W., Alhassan, M., 2011. Individual and public-program adaptation: Coping with Heat Waves in five cities in Canada. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 8, 4679-4701.

[4] Ban, J., Zhou, L., Zhang, Y., Brooke Anderson, G., Li, T., 2017. The health policy implications of individual adaptive behavior responses to smog pollution in urban China. Environ. Int. 106, 144-152.

[5] Belur, J., Tompson, L., Thornton, A., Simon, M., 2018. Interrater reliability in systematic review methodology: Exploring variation in coder decision-making. Sociol. Method. Res. 50, 837-865.

[6] Bernard, S.M., Samet, J.M., Grambsch, A., Ebi, K.L., Romieu, I., 2001. The potential impacts of climate variability and change on air pollution-related health effects in the United States. Environ. Health Perspect. 109 (Suppl 2), 199-209.

[7] Biagini, B., Bierbaum, R., Stults, M., Dobardzic, S., McNeeley, S.M., 2014. A typology of adaptation actions: A global look at climate adaptation actions financed through the Global Environment Facility. Global Environ. Change 25, 97-108.

[8] Blazejczyk, A., Blazejczyk, K., Baranowski, J., Kuchcik, M., 2018. Heat stress mortality and desired adaptation responses of healthcare system in Poland. Int. J. Biometeorol. 62, 307-318.

[9] Bobb, J.F., Peng, R.D., Bell, M.L., Dominici, F., 2014. Heat-related mortality and adaptation to heat in the United States. Environ. Health Perspect. 122, 811-816.

[10] Boeckmann, M., Rohn, I., 2014. Is planned adaptation to heat reducing heat-related mortality and illness? A systematic review. BMC Public Health 14, 1112.

[11] Cao, B., Shang, Q., Dai, Z., Zhu, Y., 2013. The impact of air-conditioning usage on sick building syndrome during summer in China. Indoor Built Environ. 22, 490-497.

[12] Carmona, R., Díaz, J., Miron, I., C, O., Luna, M.Y., Linares, C., 2016. Mortality attributable to extreme temperatures in Spain: A comparative analysis by city. Environ. Int. 91, 22-28.

[13] Davis, R.E., Knappenberger, P.C., Michaels, P.J., Novicoff, W.M., 2003. Changing heat-related mortality in the United States. Environ. Health Perspect. 111, 1712-1718.

[14] Deschenes, O., 2014. Temperature, human health, and adaptation: A review of the empirical literature. Energ. Econ. 46, 606-619.

[15] Ebi, K.L., Semenza, J.C., Rocklöv, J., 2016. Current medical research funding and frameworks are insufficient to address the health risks of global environmental change. Environ. Health 15, 108.

[16] Fumiaki, F., Jun, M., Hideto, S., 2020. Spatial variability of municipality-wise heat and cold mortality in Japan with respect to temperature and economic states. Geogr. Rev. Jpn., Ser. B 92, 72-83.

[17] Gronlund, C.J., Berrocal, V.J., White-Newsome, J.L., Conlon, K.C., O’Neill, M.S., 2015. Vulnerability to extreme heat by socio-demographic characteristics and area green space among the elderly in Michigan, 1990-2007. Environ. Res. 136, 449-461.

[18] Gronlund, C.J., Zanobetti, A., Wellenius, G.A., Schwartz, J.D., O’Neill, M.S., 2016. Vulnerability to renal, heat and respiratory hospitalizations during extreme heat among U.S. elderly. Clim. Change 136, 631-645.

[19] Hansen, A., Bi, P., Pisaniello, D., Nitschke, M., Tucker, G., Newbury, J., Kitson, A., Dal Grande, E., Avery, J., Zhang, Y., Kelsall, L., 2015. Heat-health behaviours of older people in two Australian states. Australas. J. Ageing 34, E19-E25.

[20] Heo, S., Nori-Sarma, A., Lee, K., Benmarhnia, T., Dominici, F., Bell, M.L., 2019. The use of a quasi-experimental study on the mortality effect of a heat wave warning system in Korea. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 16, 2245.

[21] Herrmann, A., Sauerborn, R., 2018. General practitioners’ perceptions of heat health impacts on the elderly in the face of climate change —A qualitative study in Baden-Wurttemberg, Germany. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 15, 843.

[22] Johnson, M.M., Williams, R., Fan, Z., Lin, L., Hudgens, E., Gallagher, J., Vette, A., Neas, L., Özkaynak, H., 2010. Participant-based monitoring of indoor and outdoor nitrogen dioxide, volatile organic compounds, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons among MICA-Air households. Atmos. Environ. 44, 4927-4936.

[23] Kim, H., Kim, H., Byun, G., Choi, Y., Song, H., Lee, J.T., 2019. Difference in temporal variation of temperature-related mortality risk in seven major South Korean cities spanning 1998-2013. Sci. Total Environ. 656, 986-996.

[24] Louis, V.R., Phalkey, R.K., 2016. Health impacts in a changing climate -An overview. Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 225, 429-441.

[25] Low, J., Ross, J.S., Ritchie, J.D., Gross, C.P., Lehman, R., Lin, H., Fu, R., Stewart, L.A., Krumholz, H.M., 2017. Comparison of two independent systematic reviews of trials of recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2): The Yale Open Data Access Medtronic Project. Syst. Rev. 6, 28.

[26] Ma, W., Zeng, W., Zhou, M., Wang, L., Rutherford, S., Lin, H., Liu, T., Zhang, Y., Xiao, J., Zhang, Y., Wang, X., Gu, X., Chu, C., 2015. The short-term effect of heat waves on mortality and its modifiers in China: An analysis from 66 communities. Environ. Int. 75, 103-109.

[27] Martínez-Solanas, È., Basagaña, X., 2019. Temporal changes in temperature-related mortality in Spain and effect of the implementation of a Heat Health Prevention Plan. Environ. Res. 169, 102-113.

[28] Masselot, P., Chebana, F., Lavigne, E., Campagna, C., Gosselin, P., Ouarda, T., 2019. Toward an improved air pollution warning system in Quebec. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 16, 2095.

[29] McCall, T., Beckmann, S., Kawe, C., Abel, F., Hornberg, 2019. Climate change adaptation and mitigation-a hitherto neglected gender-sensitive public health perspective. Clim. Dev. 11, 735-744.

[30] Medina-Ramon, M., Schwartz, J., 2007. Temperature, temperature extremes, and mortality: A study of acclimatisation and effect modification in 50 US cities. Occup. Environ. Med. 64, 827-833.

[31] Monteiro, A., Madureira, H., De’Donato, F., Sario, M., Sousa, C., Pacheco, M., Aunan, K., Gasparrini, A., 2020. Exhaustion project deliverable 4.1: exposure to heat and air pollution in Europe -cardiopulmonary impacts and benefits of mitigation and adaptation. European Commission.

[32] Ng, C.F.S., Boeckmann, M., Ueda, K., Zeeb, H., Nitta, H., Watanabe, C., Honda, Y., 2016. Heat-related mortality: Effect modification and adaptation in Japan from 1972 to 2010. Global Environ. Change 39, 234-243.

[33] Nitschke, M., Tucker, G., Hansen, A., Williams, S., Zhang, Y., Bi, P., 2016. Evaluation of a heat warning system in Adelaide, South Australia, using case-series analysis. BMJ Open 6, e012125.

[34] O’Neill, M., Carter, R., Kish, J., Gronlund, C., White-Newsome, J., Manarolla, X., Zanobetti, A., Schwartz, J., 2009. Preventing heat-related morbidity and mortality: New approaches in a changing climate. Maturitas 64, 98-103.

[35] Oliver, S., Garner, P., Heywood, P., Jull, J., Dickson, K., Bangpan, M., Ang, L., Fourman, M., Garside, R., 2017. Transdisciplinary working to shape systematic reviews and interpret the findings: Commentary. Environ. Evid. 6, 28.

[36] Racioppi, F., Martuzzi, M., Matić, S., Braubach, M., Morris, G., Krzy ż anowski, M., Jarosińska, D., Schmoll, O., Adamonyt ė, D., 2020. Reaching the sustainable development goals through healthy environments: Are we on track? Eur. J. Public Health 30, i14-i18.

[37] Sandelowski, M., 2008. Reading, writing and systematic review. J. Adv. Nurs. 64, 104-110.

[38] Scells, H., Zuccon, G., Koopman, B., Clark, J., 2020. A computational approach for objectively derived systematic review search strategies. In: Jose J.M., Yilmaz E., Magalhães J., Castells P., Ferro N., Silva M.J., Martins F. (Advances in information retrieval.Eds.), Springer International Publishing, pp. 385-398.

[39] Schuster, C., Honold, J., Lauf, S., Lakes, T., 2017. Urban heat stress: novel survey suggests health and fitness as future avenue for research and adaptation strategies. Environ. Res. Letters 12, 044021.

[40] Tan, H., Xu, J., 2019. Differentiated effects of risk perception and causal attribution on public behavioral responses to air pollution: A segmentation analysis. J. Environ. Psychol. 65, 101335.

[41] Thompson, R.L., Bandera, E.V., Burley, V.J., Cade, J.E., Forman, D., Freudenheim, J.L., Greenwood, D., Jacobs, D.R., Kalliecharan, R.V., Kushi, L.H., McCullough, M.L., Miles, L.M., Moore, D.F., Moreton, J.A., Rastogi, T., Wiseman, M.J., 2008. Reproducibility of systematic literature reviews on food, nutrition, physical activity and endometrial cancer. Public Health Nutr. 11, 1006-1014.

[42] Toloo, G., FitzGerald, G., Aitken, P., Verrall, K., Tong, S., 2013. Are heat warning systems effective? Environ. Health 12, 27.

[43] United, Nations, 2015. Transforming our world: The 2030 agenda for sustainable development. United Nations, New York.

[44] Vasconcelos, J., Freire, E., Morais, J., MacHado, J.R., Santana, P., 2011. The health impacts of poor housing conditions and thermal discomfort. Procedia Environ. Sci. 4, 158-164.

[45] Villaseñor, E., Ortiz, E., Navas, G., Alemón, E., 2001. Naturation of Mexico City: cost benefit analysis of an air quality improvement proposal. Environ. Health Risk 5, 43-51.

[46] Watts, N., Adger, W.N., Agnolucci, P., Blackstock, J., Byass, P., Cai, W., Chaytor, S., Colbourn, T., Collins, M., Cooper, A., Cox, P.M., Depledge, J., Drummond, P., Ekins, P., Galaz, V., Grace, D., Graham, H., Grubb, M., Haines, A., Hamilton, I., Hunter, A., Jiang, X., Li, M., Kelman, I., Liang, L., Lott, M., Lowe, R., Luo, Y., Mace, G., Maslin, M., Nilsson, M., Oreszczyn, T., Pye, S., Quinn, T., Svensdotter, M., Venevsky, S., Warner, K., Xu, B., Yang, J., Yin, Y., Yu, C., Zhang, Q., Gong, P., Montgomery, H., Costello, A., 2015. Health and climate change: Policy responses to protect public health. Lancet 386, 1861-1914.

[47] Weilnhammer, V., Schmid, J., Mittermeier, I., Schreiber, F., Jiang, L., Pastuhovic, V., Herr, C., Heinze, S., 2021. Extreme weather events in europe and their health consequences - A systematic review. Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health 233, 113688.

[48] Williams, K., Gupta, R., Hopkins, D., Gregg, M., Payne, C., Joynt, J.L.R., Smith, I., Bates-Brkljac, N., 2013a. Retrofitting England’s suburbs to adapt to climate change. Build. Res. Inf. 41, 517-531.

[49] Williams, S., Bi, P., Newbury, J., Robinson, G., Pisaniello, D., Saniotis, A., Hansen, A., 2013b. Extreme heat and health: Perspectives from health service providers in rural and remote communities in South Australia. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 10, 5565-5583.

[50] World Health Organization, 2021. Heat and health in the WHO European Region: Updated evidence for effective prevention. WHO Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen.

[51] Xiong, J., Lian, Z., Zhang, H., Yoshino, H., 2017. Correlation between health discomforts and temperature steps in winter of China. Build. Environ. 114, 387-396.

[52] Yu, X., Lei, X., Wang, M., 2019. Temperature effects on mortality and household adaptation: Evidence from China. J. Environ. Econ. Manage. 96, 195-212.

[53] Zanobetti, A., O’Neill, M.S., Gronlund, C.J., Schwartz, J.D., 2012. Summer temperature variability and long-term survival among elderly people with chronic disease. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 109, 6608-6613.

[54] Zoumakis, M., Kassomenos, P., Zoumakis, N., Papadakis, N., Vosniakos, F., Staliopoulou, M., Efstathiou, G., Kelessis, A., Papapreponis, P., Bournis, N., Petrakakis, M., Koziraki, T., 2011. Human discomfort due to environmental conditions in urban Thessaloniki, Greece. Part V. Adaptation to local climate (preliminary results). J. Environ. Prot. Ecol. 12, 921-929.