Comparison of water resources management between China and the United States

Abstract

As the world's top two economies, the United States (U.S.) and China face a number of similar water resources problems. Yet, few studies have been done to systematically compare policies and approaches on water resources management between China and the U.S. This study compares water resources policies of China and the U.S. in the areas of national authority, water supply, water quality, and ecosystem use of the water to draw lessons learned and shed light on water resources management in China, the U.S., and the rest of the world. The lessons learned from the comparison include six aspects. 1) New paradigms of people-water harmony and a water-saving society are urgently needed to address the pressing water crisis and achieve the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs). 2) A comprehensive, consistent, forward-looking national policy is necessary to achieve sustainable use of water resources. 3) Empowerment of river basin commissions with comprehensive authority over the integrative management of air, land, water, and biological resources in the river basin could significantly enhance the benefits and effectiveness of economic development and environmental protection. 4) Expansion of water exchange through market mechanisms among water users promotes efficient and beneficial water uses. 5) Use of water for ecosystem services should be an integral part of water resources management. China has set up a national blueprint for achieving ecological civilization; maintaining appropriate amounts of flow in rivers and lakes for maintenance of wildlife and fisheries and ecosystems should be institutionalized as part of this national strategy as well. 6) By sharing their rich experiences and lessons in water resources management, economic development, and ecological protection with other countries, China and the U.S. can help the world to achieve global human-water harmony and the UN SDGs.

Keywords

Water resources management / Comparative analysis / China / The United States

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgments

This research was a product of the Sino-American Symposium on Future Issues Affecting Quality of Life organized by The Timothy Light Center for Chinese Studies, on Western Michigan University campus, May 4-5, 2019. It is partially funded by the Scherer Endowment Fund of Department of Geography, Western Michigan University. We appreciate the comments and suggestions of Professor Timothy Light at Western Michigan University and three anonymous reviewers to this study. There is no conflict of interest in this study.

References

[1] AghaKouchak, A., Feldman, D., Hoerling, M., Huxman, T., Lund, J., 2015. Water and climate: recognize anthropogenic drought. Nature 524 (7566), 409-411.

[2] American Water Works Association, 2012. Buried no longer: Confronting America’s water infrastructure challenge. http://www.awwa.org/infrastructure. (accessed 12 January 2020).

[3] Bakker, K., 2012. Water security: Research challenges and opportunities Science 337, 914-915.

[4] Brown, T.C., Hobbins, M.T., Ramirez, J.A., 2008. Spatial distribution of water supply in the coterminous United States. J. Am. Water Res. Assoc. 44 (6), 1474-1487.

[5] Christian-Smith, J., Gleick, P.H., Cooley, H., Vanderwarker, A., Allen, L., Berry, K.A., 2012. A Twenty-First Century US Water Policy. Oxford University Press, New York.

[6] Congressional Research Service, 2019. Management of the Colorado River: Water allocations, drought, and the federal role. United States Congress, Washington DC Updated November 25, 2019 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R45546. (accessed 20 January 2020).

[7] Ding, Z.F., 2004. The Blue Book of the Ministry of Water Resources: The 2004 Report of the Development of China Water. China Water Resources Press, Beijing.

[8] Duda, J.J., Wieferich, D.J., Bristol, R.S., Bellmore, J.R., Hutchison, V.B., Vittum, K.M., Craig, Laura, and Warrick, J.A., 2016. Dam Removal Information Portal (DRIP) —A map-based resource linking scientific studies and associated geospatial information about dam removals: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2016-1132. http://dx.doi.org/10.3133/ofr20161132 (accessed 20 January 2020).

[9] Fahrenkamp-Uppenbrink, J., 2015. California drought worst in the past millennium. Science 347 (6222), 624-624.

[10] Famiglietti, J.S., 2014. The global groundwater crisis. Nat. Clim. Change 4 (11), 945-948.

[11] Feng, W., Zhong, M., Lemoine, J.M., Biancale, R., Hsu, H.T., Xia, J., 2013. Evaluation of groundwater depletion in North China using the Gravity Recovery and Climate Experiment (GRACE) data and ground-based measurements. Water Resour. Res. 49 (4), 2110-2118.

[12] Foley, M.M., Bellmore, J.R., O’Connor, J.E., Duda, J.J., East, A.E., Grant, G.E., Anderson, C.W., Bountry, J.A., Collins, M.J., Connolly, P.J., Craig, L.S., Evans, J.E., Greene, S.L., Magilligan, F.J., Magirl, C.S., Major, J.J., Pess, G.R., Randle, T.J., Shafroth, P.B., Torgersen, C.E., Tullos, D., Wilcox, A.C., 2017. Dam removal: Listening in. Water Resour. Res. 53 (7), 5229-5246.

[13] Fu, B., Liu, Y., Lü, Y., He, C., Zeng, Y., Wu, B., 2011. Assessing the soil erosion control service of ecosystems change in the Loess Plateau of China. Ecol. Complex. 8 (4), 284-293.

[14] Gleick, P.H., 2008. Chapter 5:china and Water. In: Gleick P.H., Cohen, J., M., Palaniappan M., Morikawa M., Morrison J., Cooley H. (The World’s Water Eds.), 2008-2009: The biennial Report on Freshwater Resources. Island Press, Washington D.C., pp. 79-100.

[15] Gleick, P.H., 2016. Water strategies for the next administration. Science 354 (6312), 555-556.

[16] Graf, W., 2003. Dam Removal Research: Status and Prospects. Proceedings of the Heinz Center’s Dam Removal Research Workshop, October 23-24, 2002. http://www.riversimulator.org/Resources/NGO/DamResearchFullReport.pdf (accessed 20 January 2020).

[17] Gleick, P.H., Allen, L., Christian-Smith, J., Cohen, M.J., Cooley, H., Heberger, M., Morrison, J., Palaniappan, M., Schulte, P., 2012. The World’s Water Volume 7:The biennial Report On Freshwater Resources. Island Press, Washington D.C., p. 440.

[18] Grafton, R.Q., Libecap, G., McGlennon, S., Landry, C., O’Brien, B., 2011. An integrated assessment of water markets: A cross-country comparison. Rev. Environ. Econ. Pol. 5 (2), 219-239.

[19] Grafton, R.Q., Pittock, J., Davis, R., Williams, J., Fu, G., Warburton, M., Udall, B., McKenzie, R., Yu, X., Che, N., Connell, D., Jiang, Q., Kompas, T., Lynch, A., Norris, R., Possingham, H., Quiggin, J., 2013. Global insights into water resources, climate change and governance. Nat. Clim. Change 3 (4), 315-321.

[20] Hansen, M.H., Li, H., Svarverud, R., 2018. Ecological civilization: Interpreting the Chinese past, projecting the global future. Global Environ. Change 53, 195-203.

[21] He, C., 2012. Water resource management and watershed science. Adv. Earth Sci. 27 (7), 705-711. (in Chinese)

[22] He, C., 2016. Quantifying drivers of the sediment load reduction in the Yellow River Basin. Nat. Sci. Rev. 3 (2), 155-156.

[23] He, C., Cheng, S.K., Luo, Y., 2005. Desiccation of the Yellow River and the south water northward transfer project. Water Int. 30 (2), 261-268.

[24] He, C., Croley, T.E., 2010. Hydrological Resource Sheds and the U.S. Great Lakes Applications. J. Resour. Ecol. 1 (1), 25-30.

[25] He, C., Fu, B., 1998. The Development of water resources policy and management in the United States. Resour. Sci. 20 (1), 71-77. (in Chinese)

[26] He, C., Fu, B., Chen, L., 1998. Nonpoint source pollution control and management in the United States. Environ. Sci. 19 (5), 101-106. (in Chinese)

[27] He, C., He, X., Fu, L., 2010. China’s South ‐to ‐North water transfer project: Is it needed? Geogr. Compass 4 (9), 1312-1323.

[28] He, C., Malcolm, S.B., Dahlberg, K.A., Fu, B., 2000. A conceptual framework for integrating hydrological and biological indicators into watershed management. Landsc. Urban Plan. 49 (1-2), 25-34.

[29] He, C., Zhang, L., Zhang, X., Eslamian, S., 2014. Water security:Concept, measurement, and operationalization. In: Saeid E. (ed),Handbook of Engineering Hydrology. CRC Press, New York, pp. 544-555.

[30] Hering, J.G., Ingold, K.M., 2012. Water resources management: What should be integrated? Science 336 (6086), 1234-1235.

[31] Ho, M., Lall, U., Allaire, M., Devineni, N., Kwon, H.H., Pal, I., Raff, D., Wegner, D., 2017. The future role of dams in the United States of America. Water Resour. Res. 53 (2), 982-998.

[32] Hoornbeek, J.A., 2004. Policy-making institutions and water policy outputs in the European Union and the United States: A comparative analysis. J. Eur. Public Pol. 11 (3), 461-496.

[33] Johnson, N., Revenga, C., Echeverria, J., 2001. Managing water for people and nature. Science 292 (5519), 1071-1072.

[34] Kauffman, G., 2015. Governance, policy, and economics of intergovernmental river basin management. Water Resour. Manag. 29 (15), 5689-5712.

[35] Keiser, D.A., Shapiro, J.S., 2019. Consequences of the Clean Water Act and the demand for water quality. Quart. J. Econ. 134 (1), 349-396.

[36] Kline, B., 2011. First Along the river: A brief History of the U.S. Environmental Movement, 4th ed. Rowan & Littlefield Publishers, Lanham.

[37] Linard, J.I., Schaffrath, K.R., 2014. Regression Models for Estimating Salinity and Selenium Concentrations at Selected Sites in the Upper Colorado River Basin, Colorado, 2009-2012. U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2014-2015 http://dx.doi.org/10.3133/ofr20141015.

[38] Liu, J., Yang, W., 2012. Water Sustainability for China and Beyond. Science 337 (6095), 649-650.

[39] Liu, Y., Wen, C., Liu, X., 2013b. China’s food security soiled by contamination. Science 339 (6126), 1382-1383.

[40] Liu, J., Zang, C., Tian, S., Liu, J., Yang, H., Jia, S., You, L., Liu, B., Zhang, M., 2013a. Water conservancy projects in China: Achievements, challenges and way forward. Global Environ. Change 23 (3), 633-643.

[41] Lu, Y., Jenkins, A., Ferrier, R.C., Bailey, M., Gordon, I.J., Song, S., Huang, J., Jia, S., Zhang, F., Liu, X., Feng, Z., Zhang, Z., 2015. Addressing China’s grand challenge of achieving food security while ensuring environmental sustainability. Sci. Adv. 1 (1) e1400039.

[42] Maggioni, E., 2015. Water demand management in times of drought: What matters for water conservation. Water Resour. Res. 51 (1), 125-139.

[43] MEE, 2019. China’s ecology and environment bulletin 2018. Ministry of Ecology and Environment, China. http://www.mee.gov.cn/hjzl/ (accessed 11 January 2020).

[44] Milly, P.C.D., Dunne, K.A., 2020. Colorado River flow dwindles as warming-driven loss of reflective snow energizes evaporation. Science 367 (6483), 1252-1255.

[45] MWR, 2017. China Water Development Report 2017. Ministry of Water Resources, China.. China Water and Power Press, Beijing, p. 397. (in Chinese)

[46] National Academy of Science, 2007. Colorado River Basin Water Management:Evaluating and Adjusting to Hydroclimatic Variability. National Academy of Science Press, Washington DC. https://www.nap.edu/read/11857/chapter/5.

[47] NRC National, Research Council, 1999. New Strategies For America’s watersheds. The National Academy Press, Washington, D. C..

[48] NRC (National Research Council), 2005. The Science of Instream flows: A review of the Texas Instream Flow program. The National Academies Press, Washington, DC..

[49] O’Connor, J. E., Duda, J. J., Grant, G. E., 2015. 1000 dams down and counting. Science 348 (6234), 496-497.

[50] Overpeck, J., Udall, B., 2010. Dry times ahead. Science 328 (5986), 1642-1643.

[51] Palmer, M., Ruhi, A., 2019. Linkages between flow regime, biota, and ecosystem processes: Implications for river restoration. Science 365 (6459),eaaw2087.

[52] Poff, N.L., Olden, J.D., 2017. Can dams be designed for sustainability? Science 358 (6368), 1252-1253.

[53] Pontius, D., 1997. Colorado River Basin study: Report to the Western Water Policy Review Advisory Commission. National Technical Information Service, Springfield, p. 132.

[54] Pulido-Velazquez, M., Ward, F.A., 2017. Comparison of water management institutions and approaches in the United States and Europe —What can we learn from each other? In: Ziolkowska, J.R., Peterson, J.M. (Eds.), Competition for water resources: Experiences and management approaches in the US and Europe. Elsevier Inc, Amsterdam, pp. 423-441.

[55] Qian, Z., Zhang, G., 2001. Strategies on Sustainable Development of China’s Water Resources, Vol. I. China Water and Power Press, Beijing, China. (in Chinese)

[56] Shiklomanov, I.A., Rodda, J.C., 2003. World Water Resources at the Beginning of the Twenty-First Century. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[57] Shi, J., 1996. Comprehensive Use of Water Resources. China Water and Power Press, Beijing, p. 376. (in Chinese)

[58] Stokstad, E., 2014. U.S. and Mexico Unleash a Flood Into Colorado Delta. Science 343 (6177), 1301.

[59] Talpos, S., 2019. They persisted. Science 364, 622-626.

[60] Tarhule, A., 2017. The future of water:prospects and challenges for water management in the 21st century. In: Ziolkowska, J.R., Peterson, J.M. (Eds.), Competition for water resources: Experiences and management approaches in the US and Europe. Elsevier Inc, Amsterdam, pp. 442-454.

[61] The Global Water Partnership, 2004. Catalyzing change:A handbook for developing integrated water resources management (IWRM) and water efficiency strategies. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, New York.

[62] The World Economic Forum,2013. The Global Risks 2013, Eighth Edition. Geneva, Switzerland. https://reports.weforum.org/global-risks-2013/ (accessed 11 January 2020).

[63] Udall, B., Overpeck, J., 2017. The twenty ‐first century Colorado River hot drought and implications for the future Water Resour. Res. 53, 2404-2418.

[64] UN, 2010. Resolution Adopted by the General Assembly on 17 December 2010. 70/169. The human rights to safe drinking water and sanitation. United Nations, New York. https://www.un.org/en/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol = A/RES/70/169 (accessed 20 January 2020).

[65] UN, 2019. The Sustainable Development Goals Report. United Nations, New York. http://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment (accessed 11 January 2020).

[66] USACE, 2012. Water in the U.S. American West: 150 years of adaptive strategies, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. http://naturalresourcespolicy.org/docs/water-inthe-west.pdf (accessed 11 January 2020).

[67] USBR, 2013. Quality of water Colorado River Basin Progress Report No. 24. Upper Colorado Region, Colorado. https://www.usbr.gov/uc/progact/salinity/pdfs/PR24final.pdf (accessed 20 January 2020).

[68] USEPA, 1999. Protocol for Developing Nutrient TMDLs. Report No EPA 841-B-99-007, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Washington, DC.

[69] Wang, S., Fu, B., Piao, S., Lü, Y., Ciais, P., Feng, X., Wang, Y., 2016. Reduced sediment transport in the Yellow River due to anthropogenic changes. Nat. Geosci. 9 (1), 38-41.

[70] Weatherford, G.D., Brown, F.L., 1986. New Courses for the Colorado River. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.

[71] Wigginton, N.S., 2016. Drinking water —and what else? Science 353 (6303), 1001-1002.

[72] WWAP, 2017. The United Nations World Water Development Report 2017. Wastewater: The Untapped Resource. United Nations World Water Assessment Programme, UNESCO, Paris.

[73] WWAP (United Nations World Water Assessment Programme), 2019. The United Nations World Water Development Report 2019:Leaving No One Behind. UNESCO, Paris.

[74] Wittwer, S., Yu, Y., Sun, H., Wang, L., 1987. Feeding a billion:Frontiers of Chinese agriculture. Michigan State University Press, East Lansing, p. 462.

[75] Worster, D., 2011. The Flow of Empire: Comparing Water Control in the United States and China doi: 10.5282/rcc/5586.

[76] Xia, J., 2012. Science & technology for sustainable water in China: A perspective of the IAC Water Program and studies in China. Bull. Chin. Acad. Sci. 26, 1-12. (in Chinese)

[77] Xu, Y.D., Fu, B.J., He, C.S., 2013. Assessing the hydrological effect of the check dams in the Loess Plateau, China, by model simulations. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. 17 (6), 2185-2193.

[78] Yang, X., Xu, J., Donzier, J., Noel, C., 2013. A comparison of the water management systems in France and China Front. Environ. Sci. Eng. 7, 721-734.