Mental health and legal statuses along the path to citizenship: A qualitative study of minority ethnic urban dwellers in Chiang Mai, Thailand

Abstract

Background: Given the lack of legal status, stateless persons often live in precarious situations that put them at risk of mental health problems, especially in urban settings. Moreover, pathways to citizenship may involve navigating different legal statuses over a lifetime, posing additional challenges. Yet, research on the nexus between legal status and mental health remains scant. This study examines the factors that influence the mental health of persons with different legal statuses in a Thai urban context.
Methods: This study employed a qualitative design. Data were collected through 47 in-depth interviews in Northern Thailand’s largest city in July 2023 using purposive and snowball sampling strategies. The interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim. Thematic analysis, based on a social determinants of mental health framework, was used to analyse the data.
Results: Legal status was related to multiple and interdependent conditions of precarity in the city. Together they created a compounding effect that threatened mental health. The more restricted the rights attached to a legal status, the greater the effect. Past negative life events, adversed employment conditions, and discrimination were key factors that led to mental health challenges. Obtaining permanent legal status, on the other hand, alleviated legal uncertainty and provided immediate benefits by enhancing access to fundamental rights, with positive effects on mental health. Yet, it cannot reverse pernicious long-term effects of past deprivations, such as foregone opportunities for education and employment, as well as past traumatic events on mental health.
Conclusions: The 2024 landmark move of Thailand’s Cabinet to accelerate progress in resolving citizenship problems for almost 500,000 persons should be accompanied by multi-pronged interventions aimed at improving the social determinants of mental health. In addition, access to mental healthcare should be facilitated.

Keywords

Mental health / Urban precarity / Legal status / Ethnic minority groups / Thailand

References

[1] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees . Global trends: Forced displacement in 2023. Geneva; 2024.

[2] Blitz B.K., Lynch M., Lakshman R., Balaton-Chrimes S. The cost of statelessness: A livelihoods analysis 2011 Aug 31. Report No.: PRM-SGP-10-CA-04192010.

[3] Kingston LN, Cohen EF, Morley CP. Debate: limitations on universality: the "right to health" and the necessity of legal nationality. BMC Int Health Hum Rights. 2010; 10(1): 11 (Article).

[4] Miller KE, Rasmussen A. The mental health of civilians displaced by armed conflict: an ecological model of refugee distress. Epidemiol Psychiatr Sci. 2017; 26(2): 129-138.

[5] Riley A, Varner A, Ventevogel P, Taimur Hasan MM, Welton-Mitchell C . Daily stressors, trauma exposure, and mental health among stateless Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh. Transcult Psychiatry. 2017; 54(3): 304-331.

[6] Herberholz C. We are inferior, we have no rights’: statelessness and mental health among ethnic minorities in Northern Thailand. SSM Popul Health. 2022; 19: 101138 (Article).

[7] Blackmore R, Boyle JA, Fazel M, et al. The prevalence of mental illness in refugees and asylum seekers: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLOS Med. 2020; 17(9): e1003337 (Article).

[8] Patanè M, Ghane S, Karyotaki E, et al. Prevalence of mental disorders in refugees and asylum seekers: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Glob Ment Health. 2022; 9: 250-263.

[9] Santambrogio J, Ciscato V, Lorusso O, et al. The challenge of diagnosing cultural syndromes: a narrative review. Int J Soc Psychiatry. 2024; 70(6): 1016-1027.

[10] Santambrogio J, Leon E, Auxilia AM, et al. Clinical and screening tools for psychic illness in asylum seekers and refugees: a narrative review. Riv di Psichiatr. 2025; 60(3): 93-102.

[11] Garcini LM, Murray KE, Zhou A, Klonoff EA, Myers MG, Elder JP. Mental health of undocumented immigrant adults in the United States: a systematic review of methodology and findings. J Immigr Refug Stud. 2016; 14(1): 1-25.

[12] Porter M, Haslam N. Predisplacement and postdisplacement factors associated with mental health of refugees and internally displaced persons: a meta-analysis. JAMA. 2005; 294(5): 602-612.

[13] Santambrogio J, Cimminiello N, Wisidagamage Don P, et al. Influence of post-migration living difficulties on mental health among refugees and asylum seekers: a scoping-review on clinical tools. Int J Soc Psychiatry. 2024; 70(7): 1191-1201.

[14] Wickramage K, Vearey J, Zwi AB, Robinson C, Knipper M. Migration and health: a global public health research priority. BMC Public Health. 2018; 18(1): 987.

[15] World Health Organization . Mental health of refugees and migrants: Risk and protective factors and access to care. 2023. Report No.: Global Evidence Review on Health and Migration (GEHM) series.

[16] Lund C, Stansfeld S, De Silva M . Social determinants of mental health. Global mental health: Principles and practice [Internet] . Oxford University Press; 2013: 116-136. https://doi.org/10.1093/med/9780199920181.003.0007

[17] Steel Z, Chey T, Silove D, Marnane C, Bryant RA, van Ommeren M. Association of torture and other potentially traumatic events with mental health outcomes among populations exposed to mass conflict and displacement: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA. 2009; 302(5): 537-549.

[18] Bogic M, Ajdukovic D, Bremner S, et al. Factors associated with mental disorders in long-settled war refugees: refugees from the former Yugoslavia in Germany, Italy and the UK. Br J Psychiatry. 2012; 200(3): 216-223.

[19] Castañeda H. Illegality as risk factor: a survey of unauthorized migrant patients in a Berlin clinic. Soc Sci Med. 2009; 68(8): 1552-1560.

[20] Fernandez B. Health inequities faced by Ethiopian migrant domestic workers in Lebanon. Health Place. 2018; 50: 154-161.

[21] Heeren M, Wittmann L, Ehlert U, Schnyder U, Maier T, Müller J. Psychopathology and resident status - comparing asylum seekers, refugees, illegal migrants, labor migrants, and residents. Compr Psychiatry. 2014; 55(4): 818-825.

[22] Leiler A, Bjärtå A, Ekdahl J, Wasteson E. Mental health and quality of life among asylum seekers and refugees living in refugee housing facilities in Sweden. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2019; 54(5): 543-551.

[23] Momartin S, Steel Z, Coello M, Aroche J, Silove DM, Brooks R. A comparison of the mental health of refugees with temporary versus permanent protection visas. Med J Aust. 2006; 185(7): 357-361.

[24] Biglia B, Martí JB . Precarity. In: Teo T, ed. Encyclopedia of critical psychology. New York, NY: Springer New York; 2014: 1488-1491.

[25] Kane J, Schuurmans G, Kitamura M. Health care experiences of stateless people in Canada. J Migr Hum Secur. 2023; 11(3): 261-278.

[26] Kasmir S. Precarity. 2018. In: The open Cambridge encyclopedia of anthropology [Internet].

[27] Butler J. Frames of war: when is life grievable? Verso; 2009.

[28] Mendola D, Parroco AM, Li Donni P. We made it to Germany … and now? Interdependent risks of vulnerability for refugees in a high-income country. J Ethn Migr Stud. 2024; 50(4): 1059-1079.

[29] Menjívar C. Liminal legality: Salvadoran and Guatemalan immigrants' lives in the United States. Am J Sociol. 2006; 111(4): 999-1037.

[30] Blitz BK, Otero-Iglesias M . Stateless by any other name: refused asylum-seekers in the United Kingdom. J Ethn Migr Stud. 2011; 37(4): 657-573.

[31] Patler C, Laster Pirtle W. From undocumented to lawfully present: Do changes to legal status impact psychological wellbeing among Latino immigrant young adults? Soc Sci Med. 2018; 199: 39-48.

[32] Refle J-E, Fakhoury J, Burton-Jeangros C, Consoli L, Jackson Y. Impact of legal status regularization on undocumented migrants’ self-reported and mental health in Switzerland. SSM Popul Health. 2023; 22: 101398.

[33] Campbell B, Laheij C. Urban precarity. City Soc. 2021; 33(2): 283-302.

[34] Chacko E, Price M. Un)settled sojourners in cities: the scalar and temporal dimensions of migrant precarity. J Ethn Migr Stud. 2021; 47(20): 4597-4614.

[35] McCay L, Banulescu-Bogdan N. Urbanization and its impact on migrant mental health. In: Bhugra D, Ayonrinde O, Tolentino EJ, Valsraj K, Ventriglio A, Bhugra D, eds. eds. Oxford textbook of migrant psychiatry. Oxford University Press; 2021: 89-96.

[36] Schofield P. Why urban environments matter for refugee mental health. In: Bhugra D, Ventriglio A, Castaldelli-Maia J, McCay L, eds. Urban mental health. Oxford University Press; 2019: 73-82.

[37] Galea S, Vlahov D. Urban health: evidence, challenges, and directions. Annu Rev Public Health. 2005; 26(1): 341-365.

[38] Gruebner O, Rapp MA, Adli M, Kluge U, Galea S, Heinz A. Cities and mental health. Dtsch Ärzteblatt Int. 2017; 114(8): 121-127.

[39] Krabbendam L, van Vugt M, Conus P, et al. Understanding urbanicity: how interdisciplinary methods help to unravel the effects of the city on mental health. Psychol Med. 2021; 51(7): 1099-1110.

[40] Schofield P, Thygesen M, Das-Munshi J, et al. Ethnic density, urbanicity and psychosis risk for migrant groups - a population cohort study. Schizophr Res. 2017; 190: 82-87.

[41] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees . States parties to the 1951 Convention and its 1967 Protocol [updated 17 Apr 2015]. Available from: 〈https://www.unhcr.org/media/states-parties-1951-convention-and-its-1967-protocol〉.

[42] Flaim A. Problems of evidence, evidence of problems: expanding citizenship and reproducing statelessness among highlanders in Northern Thailand. In: Lawrance BN, Stevens J, eds. Citizenship in question: Evidentiary birthright and statelessness. Durham. Duke University Press; 2017: 147-164.

[43] Boonrach G. Statelessness situation and Thailand’s solutions. Legal problems related to nationality and rights of people residing in Thailand conference; July 10; Bangkok. Bangkok: National Human Rights Commission of Thailand, the Ministry of Interior of Thailand, the Thai Committee for Refugees Foundation, the French Embassy Bangkok, and CPG; 2017.

[44] Saisoonthorn PK. Development of concepts on nationality and the efforts to reduce statelessness in Thailand. Refug Surv Q. 2006; 25(3): 40-53.

[45] Apikul C. Education knows no border: A collection of good practices and lessons learned on migrant education in Thailand 2019.

[46] Herberholz C. Protracted statelessness and nationalitylessness among the Lahu, Akha and Tai-Yai in Northern Thailand: problem areas and the vital role of health insurance status. Econ Peace Secur J. 2020; 15(2): 36-52.

[47] Cheva-Isarakul J. Contextualising statelessness: contingent citizenship and the politics of (non)recognition in Thailand. Trans TransReg Natl Stud Southeast Asia. 2024; 12(1): 45-59.

[48] Department of Provincial Administration . Number of aliens by type of identification card as of September 2020. 2020.

[49] Price PJ. Jus soli and statelessness: a comparative perspective from the Americas. In: Lawrance BN, Stevens J, eds. Citizenship in question: Evidentiary birthright and statelessness. Durham. Duke University Press; 2017: 27-42.

[50] Parsons L, Lawreniuk S. Seeing like the stateless: documentation and the mobilities of liminal citizenship in Cambodia. Political Geogr. 2018; 62: 1-11.

[51] Müller TR. Liminal legality and the construction of belonging: aspirations of Eritrean and Ethiopian migrants in Khartoum. J Ethn Migr Stud. 2024: 1-18.

[52] Cheva-Isarakul J. 'Diagnosing' statelessness and everyday state illegibility in Northern Thailand. State Citizsh Rev. 2019; 1(2): 214-238.

[53] Laungaramsri P. Contested citizenship: cards, colors, and the culture of identification. In: Marston JA, ed. Ethnicity, borders, and the grassroots interface with the state. Chiang Mai: Silkworm Books; 2014: 143-162.

[54] Flaim A, Williams LB, Ahlquist DB. How statelessness, citizenship, and out-migration contribute to stratification among rural elderly in the highlands of Thailand. Soc Forces. 2019; 99(1): 333-365.

[55] Morton MF, Baird IG. From hill tribes to indigenous peoples: the localisation of a global movement in Thailand. J Southeast Asian Stud. 2019; 50(1): 7-31.

[56] Amare M., Hohfeld L., Jitsuchon S., Waibel H. Rural-urban migration and employment quality: A case study from Thailand. 2012. Report No.: ADB Economics Working Paper Series No. 309.

[57] Porst L, Sakdapolrak P. Advancing adaptation or producing precarity? The role of rural-urban migration and translocal embeddedness in navigating household resilience in Thailand. Geoforum. 2018; 97: 35-45.

[58] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. UNHCR Handbook on protection of stateless persons under the 1954 Convention relating to the status of stateless persons Geneva: United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees ; 2014.

[59] Lund C, Brooke-Sumner C, Baingana F, et al. Social determinants of mental disorders and the sustainable development goals: a systematic review of reviews. Lancet Psychiatry. 2018; 5(4): 357-369.

[60] Gonzales RG. Learning to be illegal: undocumented youth and shifting legal contexts in the transition to adulthood. Am Sociol Rev. 2011; 76(4): 602-619.

[61] Government Public Relations Department . Thai Cabinet fast-tracks citizenship and legal status for 483,000 long-term residents 2024 Nov 2 [cited 2024 Nov 4]. Available from: 〈https://thailand.prd.go.th/en/content/category/detail/id/2078/iid/336733〉.

[62] Aranda Z, Bonz A, Armijos A, Angulo A, Greene MC. Manifestation, causes and approach to mental distress among the population of migrant and refugee women in Ecuador and Panama: a qualitative study with key informants. Int J Equity Health. 2025; 24(1): 92.

[63] Walther L, Rayes D, Amann J, et al. Mental health and integration: a qualitative study on the struggles of recently arrived refugees in Germany. Front Public Health. 2021; 9: 2021.

[64] Walther L, Amann J, Flick U, Ta TMT, Bajbouj M, Hahn E. A qualitative study on resilience in adult refugees in Germany. BMC Public Health. 2021; 21(1): 828.

[65] Britannica. Chiang Mai Thailand. Encycl Br [Internet]. 2024 Jul 16; 2024 〈https://www.britannica.com/place/Chiang-Mai〉. Available from.

[66] Jirattikorn A. The radio and the non-citizen public sphere: exploring the Shan migrant public sphere in the city of Chiang Mai, Thailand. South East Asia Res. 2016; 24(1): 99-117.

[67] Archavanitkul K. Towards effective management of stateless persons in Thailand. In: Hall A, Archavanitkul K, Suksinchai S, eds. eds. Mahidol Migration Center Newsletter. 2nd ed Nakhon Pathom: Institute for Population and Social Research Mahidol Migration Center; 2011: 3-4.

[68] Flaim A, Feingold D, Ahlquist DB, et al. The UNESCO highland peoples surveys: tracing inequalities in health care access and provision in Northern Thailand. J Health Sci Altern Med. 2021; 3(2): 30-42.

[69] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and Department of Provincial Administration. Important principles regarding nationalitylessness and statelessness [หลักการสำคัญว่าด้วยการมีสัญชาติและความไร้สัญชาติ] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees Representation in Thailand; 2017.

[70] Hennink M, Kaiser BN. Sample sizes for saturation in qualitative research: a systematic review of empirical tests. Soc Sci Med. 2022; 292: 114523.

[71] Haan M, Venema SD. Using a blended approach to thematic analysis: a case study on fatherhood and imprisonment. Public Opin Q. 2025.

[72] United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees . Stateless minorities and their search for citizenship. 2017.

[73] Frounfelker RL, Islam N, Falcone J, et al. Living through war: mental health of children and youth in conflict-affected areas. Int Rev Red Cross. 2019; 101(911): 481-506.

[74] Finkelhor D. Trends in adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) in the United States. Child Abus Negl. 2020; 108: 104641.

[75] Ministry of Labour . Notification of the ministry of labour: prescription of the prohibited occupations for foreigners [unofficial translation]137. The Government Gazette; 2020 (Special Part 92 Ngor).

[76] Bailey CA, Widener K. The nexus between immigration status, policy, and proceedings, and mental health. Curr Opin Psychol. 2022; 47: 101411 (Article).

[77] Ryan D, Tornberg-Belanger SN, Perez G, et al. Stress, social support and their relationship to depression and anxiety among Latina immigrant women. J Psychosom Res. 2021; 149: 110588 (Article).

[78] Price M, Rojas G. The ordinary lives and uneven precarity of the DACAmented: visualising migrant precarity in metropolitan Washington. J Ethn Migr Stud. 2021; 47(20): 4758-4778.

[79] Higuera K, Jiménez TR. Mechanism mapping: a qualitative study of how different forms of instability mediate the relationship between legal status and immigrant mental well-being. Soc Sci Med. 2023; 329: 116034 (Article).

[80] Porthé V, Ahonen E, Vázquez ML, et al. Extending a model of precarious employment: a qualitative study of immigrant workers in Spain. Am J Ind Med. 2010; 53(4): 417-424.

[81] Ermansons G, Kienzler H, Asif Z, Schofield P. Refugee mental health and the role of place in the Global North countries: a scoping review. Health Place. 2023; 79: 102964 (Article).

[82] Koseoglu Ornek O, Waibel J, Wullinger P, Weinmann T. Precarious employment and migrant workers’ mental health: a systematic review of quantitative and qualitative studies. Scand J Work Environ Health. 2022(5): 327-350.

[83] Pesses A. Highland birth and citizenship registration in Thailand. Final report on Karen focus group discussions in Chiang Mai province. Paris; 2007.

[84] Rijken C., Waas Lv, Gramatikov M., Brennan D. The nexus between statelessness and human trafficking in Thailand. Oisterwijk, The Netherlands; 2015 8 July 2019.

[85] Suphanchaimat R, Kantamaturapoj K, Pudpong N, Putthasri W, Mills A. Health insurance for people with citizenship problems in Thailand: a case study of policy implementation. Health Policy Plan. 2016; 31(2): 229-238.

[86] Bécares L, Dewey ME, Das-Munshi J. Ethnic density effects for adult mental health: systematic review and meta-analysis of international studies. Psychol Med. 2018; 48(12): 2054-2072.

[87] Bhui K, Newbury JB, Latham RM, et al. Air quality and mental health: evidence, challenges and future directions. BJPsych Open. 2023; 9(4): e120 (Article).

[88] Al-Hamad A, Yasin YM, Metersky K . Predictors, barriers, and facilitators to refugee women’s employment and economic inclusion: a mixed methods systematic review. PLOS ONE. 2024; 19(7): e0305463.