Vernacular heritage for an underlying principle of unity in the architectural process

Abstract

How to learn from vernacular heritage and apply its lessons to contemporary architecture is not a recent concern. Admiration towards popular buildings can be traced back to key figures of the Modern Movement. Furthermore, later critical stances on the consequences of modernity drew even a closer, though rarely noticed link to this question. Aldo van Eyck's Configurative Discipline, Amos Rapoport's culturally specific design, John F. C. Turner's advocacy for self-construction, Sergio Ferro's Aesthetics of Separation, and Christopher Alexander's Pattern Language, all seemed to seek a sense of unity in the architectural process that could, indeed, be verified in the traditional ways of doing. The revision and comparison of their ideas, in light of the values of vernacular heritage, aims to identify general variables that influence the creation of the environment and whose integral consideration could lead to that underlying principle of unity. As a result, collective predispositions of cultural, political, and material order, or more personal reactions related to emotion, habitability, or economy are distilled to build a preliminary conceptual framework. This framework is coherent with recent findings and current trends in the field and may serve to identify possible paths of action for the future.

Keywords

Vernacular architecture / Aldo van Eyck / Amos Rapoport / John F. C. Turner / Sergio Ferro / Christopher Alexander

References

[1] Aldo van Eyck: writings. In: Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F. (Eds.), 2008. Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed. vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam.

[2] Alexander, Ch , 1964. Notes on the Synthesis of Form. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.

[3] Alexander, Ch , 2019. El modo atemporal de construir [The Timeless Way of Building] (J. Monteverde, Trans.), first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño (Original work published 1979).

[4] AlSayyad, N. , 2006. Foreword. In: Asquith, L., Vellinga, M. (Eds.), Vernacular Architecture in the 21st Century ed. Taylor & Francis, London, pp. xvii-xviii.

[5] Buber, M. , 1984. Yo y tú [Ich und Du]. In: Spanish. Buena Visión, Buenos Aires, first ed. (Original work published 1923).

[6] Correia, M. Dipasquale, L. Mecca, S. (Eds.), 2014. Versus: Heritage for Tomorrow: Vernacular Knowledge for Sustainable Architecture. Firenze University Press, Florence.

[7] Dipasquale, L. Mecca, S. Montoni, L. (Eds.), 2023. Heritage for People. Sharing Vernacular Knowledge to Build the Future, first ed. Firenze University Press, Florence.

[8] Fathy, H. , 1973. Architecture for the Poor. An Experiment in Rural Egypt. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

[9] Fathy, H. , 1981. De l’implicite en architecture. In: Ravéreau, A.(Ed.), Le M’Zab, Une Leçon D’architecture. Editions Sindbad, Paris.

[10] Fassassi, M.A. , 1997. L’architecture en Afrique noire. Cosmoarch-itecture, second ed. L’Harmattan, Paris (Original work published 1978).

[11] Ferro, S. , 2005. Dessin/Chantier [O Canteiro e o Desenho] (C. Simonnet, Trans.), first ed. Éditions de la Villette, Paris (Original work published 1976).

[12] Folkers, A.S. , Van Buiten, B.A.C. , 2019. Modern Architecture in Africa. Practical Encounters with Intricate African Modernity, second ed. Springer, Cham.

[13] Frampton, K. , 2009. Historia crítica de la arquitectura moderna[Modern architecture: A critical history] (J. Sainz, Trans.), fourth ed. Gustavo Gili, Barcelona (Original work published 1980).

[14] Fromm, E. , 1991. Del Tener Al Ser [Vom Haben Zum Sein] (E. Fuente Herrero, Trans.), first ed. Editorial Planeta, Barcelona(Original work published 1989).

[15] Guillaud, H. , Moriset, S. , Sánchez Muñoz, N. , Sevillano Gutiérrez, E. (Eds.), 2014. Versus. Lessons from Vernacular Heritage to Sustainable Architecture, first ed. ENSAG-CRAterre, Grenoble.

[16] ICOMOS , 1999. Charter on the Built Vernacular Heritage.

[17] Joffroy, Th , 1988. De quelques briques à un Labex, vers un renforcement des recherches en architecture liées à l’expérimentation et à la pratique opérationnelle. Architecture, aménagement de l’espace ED 454, vol. 1, pp. 149-153.

[18] Le, Corbusier , 1947. The four routes [Sur les 4 routes]. Dennis Dobson Ltd., London (Original work published 1941).

[19] Mazel, C. , 2019. La médiation en architecture, 308+, p. 44.

[20] Moholy-Nagy, L. , 1956. Vision in Motion. Paul Theobald & Co., Chicago.

[21] Moholy Nagy, S. , 1957. Native Genius in Anonymous Architecture. Horizon Press Inc., New York.

[22] Norberg-Schulz, C. , 1997. L’Art du lieu: Architecture et paysage, permanence et mutations. Le Moniteur, Paris.

[23] Oliver, P. , 1972. Cobijo Y Sociedad [Shelter And Society] (J. Corral, Trans.), first ed. H. Blume Ediciones, Madrid (Original work published 1969).

[24] Rakotomamonjy, B. , Moriset, S. , Sánchez Muñoz, N. (Eds.), 2022. Versus Plus Heritage for People. Educational Tools to Transmit Heritage Values, first ed. ENSAG-CRAterre, Grenoble.

[25] Rapoport, A. , 1969. House, Form and Culture, first ed. Prentice Hall, New Jersey.

[26] Rapoport, A. , 2003. Cultura, Arquitectura Y Diseño, first ed. Culture, Architecture and Design, Barcelona. Edicions UPC.

[27] Ravéreau, A. , 1981. Le M’Zab, Une Leçon D’architecture. Editions Sindbad, Paris.

[28] Ravéreau, A. , Bertaud du Chazaud, V. , Ravéreau, M. , 2007. Du local à l’universel. Éditions du Linteau, Fermanville.

[29] Risselada, M. , 2011. The space between. In: Risselada, M. (Ed.), A Critical Anthology. Allison & Peter Smithson, Polígrafa, Barcelona, pp. 346-353.

[30] Rudofsky, B. , 1964. Architecture without Architects, first ed. Doubleday & Company, New York.

[31] Smithson, A. , Smithson, P. , 2016. The space between. In: Risselada, M. (Ed.), Verlag der Buchhandlung Walther König, first ed. Köln.

[32] Tapie, G. , 2018. La culture architecturale des Français, first ed. DEPS-Ministère de la Culture. Presses de Sciences Po.

[33] Tuan, Y.F. , 2007. Topofilia [Topophilia: A study of environmental perception, attitudes, and values], (F. Durán de Zapata, Trans.), first ed. Editorial Melusina, Santa Cruz de Tenerife(Original work published 1974).

[34] Turner, J.F.C. , 1976. Housing by People. Marion Boyars, London.

[35] Turner, J.F.C. , Fichter, R. , 1972. Freedom to Build. Macmillan Company, New York.

[36] Turner, J.F.C. , Keating Clay, W.P. , 2018. Los Diagramas de Geddes. Notation of Life [The Geddes Diagrams]. In: Golda-Pongratz, K., Oyón, J.L., Zimmermann, V. (Eds.), Autoconstrucción: Por una autonomía del habitar. Escritos sobre vivienda, urbanismo, autogestion y holism, first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño, pp. 25-30 (Original work published 1949).

[37] Turner, J.F.C. , 2018a. Recursos de vivienda en América del Sur [Dwelling resources in South America: Village artisan’s selfbuilt house. The scope of the problem]. In: GoldaPongratz, K., Oyón, J.L., Zimmermann, V. (Eds.), Autoconstrucción: Por una autonomía del habitar. Escritos sobre vivienda, urbanismo, autogestion y holism, first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño, pp. 31-67 (Original work published 1963).

[38] Turner, J.F.C. , 2018b. La Autoconstrucción. In: Golda-Pongratz, K., Oyón, J.L., Zimmermann, V. (Eds.), Autoconstrucción: Por una autonomía del habitar. Escritos sobre vivienda, urbanismo, autogestion y holism, first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño, pp. 69-77 (Original work published 1964).

[39] Turner, J.F.C. , 2018c. Una nueva visión del déficit de vivienda [A new view of the housing deficit]. In: Golda-Pongratz, K., Oyón, J.L., Zimmermann, V. (Eds.), Autoconstrucción: Por una autonomía del habitar. Escritos sobre vivienda, urbanismo, autogestion y holism, first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño, pp. 79-94 (Original work published 1966).

[40] Turner, J.F.C. , 2018d. La vivienda en tres dimensiones [Housing in three dimensions: Terms of reference for the housing question redefined]. In: Golda-Pongratz, K., Oyón, J.L., Zimmermann, V.(Eds.), Autoconstrucción: Por una autonomía del habitar. Escritos sobre vivienda, urbanismo, autogestion y holism, first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño, pp. 143-163 (Original work published 1978).

[41] Turner, J.F.C. , 2018e. Reflexiones sobre escala y subsidiaridad en el desarrollo urbano y en la reducción de la pobreza [Reflections on scale and subsidiarity in urban development and poverty alleviation: A personal view of development by people]. In: Golda-Pongratz, K., Oyón, J.L., Zimmermann, V.(Eds.), Autoconstrucción: Por una autonomía del habitar. Escritos sobre vivienda, urbanismo, autogestion y holism, first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño, pp. 165-191 (Original work published 2002).

[42] Van Eyck, A. , 1961. The medicine of reciprocity tentatively illustrated. Forum 6, 205- 206.

[43] Van Eyck, A. , 2008a. The story of another idea. In: Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F. (Eds.), Aldo Van Eyck: Writings, Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed., vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 221-271 (Original work published 1959).

[44] Van Eyck, A. , 2008b. Is architecture going to reconcile basic values? In: Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F. (Eds.), Aldo Van Eyck: Writings, Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed., vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 202-205 (Original work published 1961).

[45] Van Eyck, A. , 2008c. The medicine of reciprocity tentatively illustrated. In: Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F. (Eds.), Aldo Van Eyck:Writings, Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed., vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 312-323 (Original work published 1961).

[46] Van Eyck, A. , 2008d. The fake client and the great word ‘No’. In:Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F. (Eds.), Aldo Van Eyck: Writings, Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed., vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 324-326 (Original work published 1962).

[47] Van Eyck, A. , 2008e. Steps towards a configurative discipline. In: Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F. (Eds.), Aldo Van Eyck: Writings, Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed., vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 327-343 (Original work published 1962).

[48] Van Eyck, A. , 2008f. The pueblos. In: Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F.(Eds.), Aldo Van Eyck: Writings, Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed., vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 351-370 (Original work published 1962).

[49] Van Eyck, A. , 2008g. A miracle of moderation. In: Ligtelijn, V., Strauven, F. (Eds.), Aldo Van Eyck: Writings, Collected Articles and Other Writings 1947-1998, first ed., vol. 2. SUN Publishers, Amsterdam, pp. 373-415 (Original work published 1962-67).

[50] Vellinga, M. , 2013. The noble vernacular. J. Architect. 18, 570- 590.

[51] Venturi, R. , 1977. Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture, second ed. The Museum of Modern Art, New York (Original work published 1966).

[52] Whyte, W. , 2010. Modernism, modernization and europeanization in west african architecture 1944-94. In: Conway, M., Patel, K.K. (Eds.), Europeanization in the Twentieth Century:Historical Approaches, first ed. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 210-228.

[53] Winnicott, D.W. , 1953. Transitional objects and transitional phenomena. Int. J. Psychoanal. 34 (2), 89- 97.

[54] Wright, F.L. , 1941. In: Gutheim, F., Wright on Architecture, Frank Lloyd (Eds.), Introduction to Ausgeführte Banten Und Entwürte, first ed. Grosset and Dunlap, New York, p. 62. Selected Writings 1894 - 1940.

[55] Zimmermann, V. , 2018. Proceso y actividad. El tema central. In:Golda-Pongratz, K., Oyón, J.L., Zimmermann, V. (Eds.), Autoconstrucción: Por una autonomía del habitar. Escritos sobre vivienda, urbanismo, autogestion y holism, first ed. Pepitas de Calabaza, Logroño, pp. 293-332.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.