Optimization-based design exploration of building massing typologies-EvoMass and a typology-oriented computational design optimization method for early-stage performance-based building massing design

Abstract

In the past decade, there has been an increasing recognition of the role of computational design optimization in early-stage performance-based architectural design exploration. However, it remains challenging for designers to apply such optimization-based design explorations in practice. To address this issue, this paper introduces a design tool, called EvoMass, and an associated design method that facilitates design exploration for building massing typologies in performance-based design tasks. EvoMass is capable of offering architects design options reflecting performance-related building massing typologies for the design task, without necessitating advanced computational design skills. More importantly, it can provide architects with insights into the underlying performance implications, thereby enhancing early-stage performance-based design exploration. EvoMass and its associated design method overcome the limitation in the conventional typology-first-optimization-second design procedure adopted by most existing tools, and it promotes a typology-oriented design exploration method of using computational optimization in performance-based architectural design. To demonstrate the efficacy of EvoMass, case studies derived from architectural design studio tasks, incorporating daylighting, solar exposure, and subjective design intents, and the result of a user survey are presented, which highlights how EvoMass and the performance-based design optimization and exploration can enable architects to achieve a more performance-aware design.

Keywords

Computational design / Design optimization / Design exploration / Design process / Building typology / Building massing

References

[1] Agrawal, A. , Lu, J. , Antol, S. , Mitchell, M. , Batra, D. , Zitnick, C.L. , Parikh, D. , 2015. VQA: visual question answering. In: Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Computer Vision, 2015 Inter, pp. 2425-2433.

[2] Bradner, E. , Iorio, F. , Davis, M. , 2014. Parameters tell the design story: ideation and abstraction in design optimization. In: 2014 Proceedings of the Symposium on Simulation for Architecture & Urban Design, pp. 172-197.

[3] Brown, N.C. , Mueller, C.T. , 2019. Quantifying diversity in parametric design: a comparison of possible metrics. AI EDAM (Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.) 33 (1), 40- 53.

[4] Caldas, L. , 2008. Generation of energy-efficient architecture solutions applying GENE_ARCH: an evolution-based generative design system. Adv. Eng. Inf. 22 (1), 59- 70.

[5] Chaszar, A. , Joyce, S.C. , 2016. Generating freedom: questions of flexibility in digital design and architectural computation. Int. J. Architect. Comput. 14 (2), 167- 181.

[6] Chen, K.W. , Choo, T.S. , Norford, L. , 2019. Enabling algorithm-assisted architectural design exploration for computational design novices. Computer-Aided Design & Applications 16 (2), 269- 288.

[7] Chen, K.W. , Janssen, P. , Schlueter, A. , 2018. Multi-objective optimisation of building form, envelope and cooling system for improved building energy performance. Autom. ConStruct. 94 (July), 449- 457.

[8] Chen, Y. , Lu, Y. , Gu, T. , Bian, Z., B, L.W. , Tong, Z. , 2022. From separation to incorporation - a full-circle application of computational approaches to performance-based architectural design. In: Proceedings of the 2021 DigitalFUTURES. Springer, Singapore, pp. 189-198.

[9] Ching, F.D.K. , 2007. Architecture: Form, Space, and Order, Third. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

[10] Ciardiello, A. , Rosso, F. , Dell’Olmo, J. , Ciancio, V. , Ferrero, M. , Salata, F. , 2020. Multi-objective approach to the optimization of shape and envelope in building energy design. Appl. Energy 280 (August), 115984.

[11] Coates, P. , Derix, C. , 2014. The deep structure of the picturesque. Architect. Des 84 (5), 32- 37.

[12] Cristie, V. , Joyce, S.C. , 2021. Versioning for parametric design exploration process. Autom. ConStruct. 129 (June), 103802.

[13] Cross, N. , 2021. Engineering Design Methods: Strategies for Product Design, fifth ed. Wiley.

[14] Dino, I.G. , 2016. An evolutionary approach for 3D architectural space layout design exploration. Autom. ConStruct. 69, 131- 150.

[15] Dorst, K. , Cross, N. , 2001. Creativity in the design process: Coevolution of problem-solution. Des. Stud. 22 (5), 425- 437.

[16] Dy, B. , Stouffs, R. , 2018. Combining geometries and descriptions A shape grammar plug-in for grasshopper. ECAADe 2018 2 (September 2018) 499- 508.

[17] Ekici, B. , Cubukcuoglu, C. , Turrin, M. , Sariyildiz, I.S. , 2019. Performative computational architecture using swarm and evolutionary optimisation: a review. Build. Environ. 147 (October 2018) 356- 371.

[18] Estrado, E. , Turrin, M. , Eigenraam, P. , 2023. Optimization of complex-geometry high-rise buildings based on wind load analysis. SIMULATION 99 (11), 1133- 1146.

[19] Gero, J.S. , Kazakov, V.A. , 1996. An exploration-based evolutionary model of a generative design process. Comput. Aided Civ. Infrastruct. Eng. 11 (3), 211- 218.

[20] Zhong, C. , Shi, Y. , Cheung, L.H. , Wang, L. , 2024. AI-enhanced performative building design optimization and exploration: a design framework combining computational design optimization and generative AI. In: Gardner, Nicole, Herr, C.M., Wang, L., Toshiki, H., Khan, S.A. (Eds.), ACCELERATED DESIGN - Proceedings of the 29th CAADRIA Conference, 1. Association for Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research in Asia (CAADRIA), Hong Kong, pp. 59-68.

[21] Greer, E. , & Lucas, R. The Most Timeless Design Differentiator Is Technology.

[22] Harding, J. , 2016. Advances in architectural geometry 2015 - dimensionality reduction for parametric design exploration. In: Advances in Architectural Geometry 2016. vdf Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zürich, pp. 204-221.

[23] Harding, J. , Brandt-Olsen, C. , 2018. Biomorpher : interactive evolution for parametric design. Int. J. Architect. Comput. 16 (June), 144- 163.

[24] Harding, J.E. , Shepherd, P. , 2017. Meta-parametric design. Des. Stud. 52, 73- 95.

[25] Harding, J. , Joyce, S. , Shepherd, P. , Williams, C. , 2013. Thinking topologically at early stage parametric design. In: Advances in Architectural Geometry 2012. Springer, Vienna, pp. 67-76.

[26] Huang, Y.S. , Chang, W.S. , Shih, S.G. , 2015. Building massing optimization in the conceptual design phase. Computer-Aided Design and Applications 12 (3), 344- 354.

[27] Janssen, P. , Bui, T.D.P. , Wang, L. , 2022. Möbius evolver: competitive exploration of urban massing strategies. In: As, I., Basu, P., P, B.T.-A.I., U, P., Talwar, D. (Eds.), Artificial Intelligence in Urban Planning and Design. Elsevier, pp. 293-321.

[28] Ji, Y. , Xu, M. , Zhang, T. , He, Y. , 2023. Intelligent parametric optimization of building atrium design: a case study for a sustainable and comfortable environment. Sustainability 15 (5), 4362.

[29] Jin, J.T. , Jeong, J.W. , 2014. Optimization of a free-form building shape to minimize external thermal load using genetic algorithm. Energy Build. 85, 473- 482.

[30] Joyce, S.C. , Ibrahim, N. , 2017. Exploring the evolution of meta parametric models. In: Disciplines and Disruption - Proceedings Catalog of the 37th Annual Conference of the Association for Computer Aided Design in Architecture, ACADIA 2017, pp. 308-317.

[31] Knowles, R.L. , 2003. The solar envelope: its meaning for energy and buildings. Energy Build. 35 (1), 15- 25.

[32] Koenig, R. , Yufan, M. , Knecht, K. , Aichinger, A. , Konieva, K. , 2020. Integrating urban analysis, generative design, and evolutionary optimization for solving urban design problems. Environ. Plan. B Urban Anal. City Sci. 47 (6), 1- 17.

[33] Konis, K. , Gamas, A. , Kensek, K. , 2016. Passive performance and building form: an optimization framework for early-stage design support. Sol. Energy 125, 161- 179.

[34] Lawson, B. , 1990. How Designers Think: the Design Process Demystified. Elsevier/Architectural.

[35] Li, S. , Liu, L. , Peng, C. , 2020. A review of performance-oriented architectural design and optimization in the context of sustainability: dividends and challenges. Sustainability 12 (4), 1427.

[36] Lin, B. , Chen, H. , Yu, Q. , Zhou, X. , Lv, S. , He, Q. , Li, Z. , 2021. Moosas - a systematic solution for multiple objective building performance optimization in the early design stage. Build. Environ. 200 (January), 107929.

[37] Luca, F. , De, Dogan, T. , Sepúlveda, A. , 2021. Reverse solar envelope method . A new building form-finding method that can take regulatory frameworks into account. Autom. ConStruct. 123 (September 2020) 103518.

[38] Maher, M.L. , 2000. A model of Co-evolutionary design. Eng. Comput. 16 (3-4), 195- 208.

[39] Marsault, X. , Torres, F. , 2019. An interactive and generative ecodesign tool for architects in the sketch phase. J. Phys. Conf. 1343 (1), 012136.

[40] Müller, P. , Wonka, P. , Haegler, S. , Ulmer, A. , Van Gool, L. , 2006. Procedural modeling of buildings. ACM SIGGRAPH 2006 Papers on - SIGGRAPH ’06 1 (212), 614.

[41] Nault, E. , Waibel, C. , Carmeliet, J. , Andersen, M. , 2018. Development and test application of the UrbanSOLve decisionsupport prototype for early-stage neighborhood design. Build. Environ. 137 (March), 58- 72.

[42] Psarras, S. , Kosicki, M. , El-Ashry, K. , Tarabishy, S. , Tsigkari, M. , Davis, A. , Aish, F. , 2020. SandBOX - an intuitive conceptual design system BT - impact: design with all senses. In: Gengnagel, C., Baverel, O., Burry, J., Ramsgaard Thomsen, M., Weinzierl, S. (Eds.), DMSB 2019: Impact: Design with All Senses. Springer International Publishing, pp. 625-635.

[43] RAMBOLL . SiteSolve.

[44] Schön, D.A. , 1992. Designing as reflective conversation with the materials of a design situation. Knowl. Base Syst. 5 (1), 3- 14.

[45] Sheikholeslami, M. , 2010. Design space exploration. In: Woodbury, R. (Ed.), ELEMENTS OF PARAMETRIC DESIGN, first ed. Routledge, pp. 275-287.

[46] Si, B. , Wang, J. , Yao, X. , Shi, X. , Jin, X. , Zhou, X. , 2019. Multiobjective optimization design of a complex building based on an artificial neural network and performance evaluation of algorithms. Adv. Eng. Inf. 40 (April), 93- 109.

[47] Sidewalk Labs . Delve.

[48] Simitch, A. , Warke, V. , 2014. The Language of Architecture: 26 Principles Every Architect Should Know. Rockport Publishers.

[49] Tian, Z. , Zhang, X. , Jin, X. , Zhou, X. , Si, B. , Shi, X. , 2018. Towards adoption of building energy simulation and optimization for passive building design: a survey and a review. Energy Build. 158, 1306- 1316.

[50] Turrin, M. , Von Buelow, P. , Stouffs, R. , 2011. Design explorations of performance driven geometry in architectural design using parametric modeling and genetic algorithms. Adv. Eng. Inf. 25 (4), 656- 675.

[51] Valiyappurakkal, V.K. , Shabarise, Y. , Natawadkar, K. , Misra, K. , 2022. A methodology to assess the constructibility of free-form buildings using building and surface performance indicators: application to a case study. Energy Build. 270, 112303.

[52] Vazquez, E. , 2023. Teaching parametric design: fostering algorithmic thinking through incomplete recipes. Open House Int. 49 (4), 736- 751.

[53] von Richthofen, A. , Knecht, K. , Miao, Y. , König, R. , 2018. The ‘Urban Elements’ method for teaching parametric urban design to professionals. Frontiers of Architectural Research 7 (4), 573- 587.

[54] Wang, L. , 2022a. Understanding the span of design spaces. In: Gerber, D., Pantazis, E., Bogosian, B., Nahmad, A., Miltiadis, C. (Eds.), CAAD Futures 2021: Computer-Aided Architectural Design, Design Imperatives: the Future Is Now, 1465. Springer, Singapore, pp. 288-297.

[55] Wang, L. , 2022b. Optimization-aided design: two approaches for reflective exploration of design search space. Int. J. Architect. Comput. 20 (4), 758- 776.

[56] Wang, L. , 2022. Workflow for applying optimization-based design exploration to early-stage architectural design - case study based on EvoMass. Int. J. Archit. Comput. 20 (1), 41- 60.

[57] Wang, L. , Chen, K.W. , Janssen, P. , Ji, G. , 2020a. Algorithmic generation of architectural massing models for building design optimisation - parametric modelling using subtractive and additive form generation principles. In: RE: Anthropocene, Design in the Age of Humans - Proceedings of the 25th International Conference on Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research in Asia, CAADRIA 2020, 1, pp. 385-394.

[58] Wang, L. , Chen, K.W. , Janssen, P. , Ji, G. , 2020b. Enabling optimisation-based exploration for building massing design - a coding-free evolutionary building massing design toolkit in rhino-grasshopper. In: RE: Anthropocene, Design in the Age of Humans - Proceedings of the 25th International Conference on Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research in Asia, CAADRIA 2020, 1, pp. 255-264.

[59] Wang, L. , Janssen, P. , Bui, T.D.P. , Chen, K.W. , 2023a. Comparing design strategies: a system for optimization-based design exploration. In: HUMAN-CENTRIC, Proceedings of the 28th International Conference of the Association for Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research in Asia (CAADRIA), 1, pp. 221-230.

[60] Wang, L. , Janssen, P. , Chen, K.W. , Tong, Z. , Ji, G. , 2019. Subtractive building massing for performance-based architectural design exploration : a case study of daylighting optimization. Sustainability 11 (24), 6965.

[61] Wang, L. , Janssen, P. , Ji, G. , 2018. Utility of evolutionary design in architectural form finding: an investigation into constraint handling strategies. In: Gero, John S. (Ed.), Design Computing and Cognition, 18. Springer, pp. 177-194.

[62] Wang, L. , Janssen, P. , Ji, G. , 2020. SSIEA: a hybrid evolutionary algorithm for supporting conceptual architectural design. AI EDAM (Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.) 34 (4), 458- 476.

[63] Wang, L. , Janssen, P. , Stouffs, R. , 2023b. Teaching Computational Design Optimization - an experimental course for performance-based building massing exploration. In: Digital Design Reconsidered - Proceedings of the 41st Conference on Education and Research in Computer Aided Architectural Design in Europe (ECAADe 2023), 1, pp. 179-188.

[64] Wang, L. , Luo, T. , Shao, T. , Ji, G. , 2023c. Reverse passive strategy exploration for building massing design-An optimization-aided approach. Int. J. Architect. Comput. 21 (3), 445- 461.

[65] Wang, L. , Tan, Z. , Ji, G. , 2016. Toward the wind-related building performative design. Living Systems and Micro-Utopias: Towards Continuous Designing. In: Proceedings of the 21st International Conference on Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research in Asia (CAADRIA 2016), pp. 109-218.

[66] Woodbury, R.F. , Burrow, A.L. , 2006. Whither design space? AIE EDAM: AI EDAM (Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.) 20 (2), 63- 82.

[67] Woodbury, R. , Mohiuddin, A. , Cichy, M. , Mueller, V. , 2017. Interactive design galleries: a general approach to interacting with design alternatives. Des. Stud. 52, 40- 72.

[68] Wortmann, T. , Nannicini, G. , 2017. Introduction to architectural design optimization. In: Karakitsiou, A., Migdalas, A., Rassia, S.T., Pardalos, P.M. (Eds.), City Networks: Collaboration and Planning for Health and Sustainability. Springer International Publishing, pp. 259-278.

[69] Wu, W.-L. , 2022. Generative Design with Building Performance Optimization in the Initial Stage of Architectural Design Process. Cheng Kung University.

[70] Yi, Y.K. , Malkawi, A.M. , 2012. Site-specific optimal energy form generation based on hierarchical geometry relation. Autom. ConStruct. 26, 77- 91.

[71] Yousif, S. , Yan, W. , 2019. Shape clustering using K-medoids in architectural form finding. In: Communications in Computer and Information Science, CCIS, 1028. Springer, Singapore, pp. 459-473.

[72] Zhang, H. , Wang, L. , Ji, G. , 2021. The Synergy of building massing and facade - an Evo-Devo approach for performance-based design optimization combining facade design with building massing. In: Globa, T.T. S. Lo A., van Ameijde, J., Fingrut, A., Kim, N. (Eds.), Projections - Proceedings of the 26th International Conference of the Association for Computer-Aided Architectural Design Research in Asia, CAADRIA 2021, 1, pp. 451-460.

[73] Zhang, L. , Zhang, L. , Wang, Y. , 2016. Shape optimization of freeform buildings based on solar radiation gain and space efficiency using a multi-objective genetic algorithm in the severe cold zones of China. Sol. Energy 132, 38- 50.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi Communications Co. Ltd.