Landscape transparency: An approach to elucidating and harmonizing contradictions in contemporary landscape design

Abstract

The concept of “transparency” has evolved from a spatial aesthetic to a spatial property that describes the underlying organization of things and derives its “contradiction” from the combination of “orderliness” and “polysemy”. This contradiction arises from the unity of opposites between synchrony and diachrony in modernity—where the rational logic of synchrony pursues “orderliness”, while the concept of mobility in diachrony is oriented towards “polysemy”. The path to linguistic transparency can be summarized in three dimensions: distortion of morpheme, recomposition of phraseme, and double-entendre of semanteme. Due to the shared symbolic meaning between language and graphics, the framework of graphic language can be employed to analyze the evolution and variation of transparency’s essential feature across painting, architecture, and landscape. Landscape transparency shares commonalities with painting and architecture regarding morphemes, phraseme, and semanteme; however, as landscape expands in scope, its transparent representations exhibit gradual synthesis and complexity. The synthesis and complexity can be decomposed into three unique endogenous contradictions within landscapes: “dynamic growth”, “multiscale nesting”, and “spatiotemporal overlapping”. These characteristics have led to the expanded expression of landscape transparency that differs from painting and architecture on three levels: morpheme usage, phraseme construction, and semanteme interpretation. Consequently, this breakthrough transcends geometric two-dimensional compositions and three-dimensional spatial organizations, enabling future-oriented landscape design to embrace pluralism and inter-adaptability.

Keywords

Transparency / Modernity / Contradiction / Graphic language / Landscape

References

[1] Acquisto, J. , 2022. The dissonance of modernity: on Baudelaire and Adorno. Br. J. Aesthet. 62 (1), 101- 114.

[2] Apostolou, M. , 2016. Phenomenal transparency in architecture: the case of victor Horta. Thessaloniki, Greece ICTA 2016: International Conference on Transparency and Architecture-Emerging Complexities, pp. 310-319.

[3] Charles, W. , 2006. The Landscape Urbanism Reader. Princeton Architectural Press, Princeton.

[4] Chen, B. , 2010. Bring transparency abstract design sketch teaching. Art Des. 211 (11), 143- 144.

[5] Cheng, Y. , Yuan, Y. , Cheng, S. , 2013. The strategy of minimization design in landscape based on the coupling method. Chinese Landscape Architecture 29 (8), 9- 12.

[6] Cui, L. , Li, X. , 2014. Research enlightenment of synchronic and diachronic space-time in landscape architecture design. Chinese Landscape Architecture 30 (9), 63- 66.

[7] Hu, L. , 2014. Negative Art: a Study of Theodor W. Adorno’s Theory of Modernity in Art. Art Magazine, pp. 132-135, 6.

[8] Jin, Q. , 2020. Facing the wall and breaking the wall extended reflections on Colin Rowe’s transparency. Architectural Journal (5), 116- 123.

[9] Jurgen, H. , 1990. In: Lawrence, Frederick G. (Ed.), The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity: Twelve Lectures (Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought). The MIT Press translator. Cambridge.

[10] Laszlo, M. , 1969. Vision in Motion, 350. Paul Theobald and Company.

[11] Le Corbusier , 1985. Towards a New Architecture. Dover Publications, pp. 40-42.

[12] Li, H. , Qian, Y. , Bian, S. , et al., 2022. Landscape architecture design approaches based on landscape process: a case study of chengdu international horticultural exposition park. Chinese Landscape Architecture 38 (7), 56- 61.

[13] Liu, T. , Jiao, C. , 2020. The cognitive motivation of synesthesia in graphic language. Journal of Changsha University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition) 35 (5), 42- 38.

[14] Liu, F. , Wang, K. , Tang, Y. , et al., 2019. A study of renewal strategies for old industrial building skin based on transparency theory. Ind. Constr. 49 (4), 69- 75.

[15] Norbert, E. , 2009. The Symbol Theory. Sage Publications, London, pp. 97-120.

[16] Rosales, C. , 2022. Spatial Transparency in Architecture: Light, Layering, and Porosity. Routledge, pp. 1-5.

[17] Rowe, C. , Slutzky, R. , 1997. Transparency. Birkhäuser Architecture, Basel, pp. 16-97.

[18] Rudolf, A. , 2004. Art and visual perception. Second ed A Psychology of the Creative Eye, 64. University of California Press, Berkeley.

[19] Saussure, F. , 1959. Course in General Linguistics. The Philosophical Library, New York.

[20] Shi, Z. , Xiang, M. , 2015. The "transparency" of Chinese classical gardens - interpreting the prototype of suzhou garden structure from the "transparency". Art Critic. 136 (3), 110- 113.

[21] Tan, Y. , Chen, P. , 2018. Data, graphics, and analysis: three methods of construction of urban landscape network information map. Chinese Landscape Architecture 34 (10), 88- 92.

[22] Tang, K. , 2021. Architecture creates time. Journal of Arts Management (3), 126- 135.

[23] Venturi, R. , 1977. Complexity and contradiction in architecture. The Museum of Modern Art 32-34.

[24] Wang, J. , 2006. The subject of Landscape Architecture. Chinese Society of Landscape Architecture. Selected papers on the history and development of landscape architecture. Chinese Landsc. Architect. 1, 9- 14.

[25] Wang, X. , 2017a. Modernity, modernism and post-modernism: to clarify the concepts. J. Huazhong Univ. Sci. Technol. 31 (5), 1- 8.

[26] Wang, X. , 2017b. Contradictory modernity. Changbai Journal (5), 51- 57.

[27] Wang, G. , 2023. On the concept of mordenity and its philosophical confirmation: based on the perspective of system philosophy. Chinese Journal of Systems Science (3), 11-15+46.

[28] Wei, F. , 2020. Between the differences: presentation and construction of thickness, interstice and porosity in contemporary landscape design. Landscape Architecture 27 (6), 30- 36.

[29] Wei, F. , Zhu, Y. , 2019. Urban landscape reproduction: from spatial analysis to design approaches. Landscape Architecture 26 (7), 45- 50.

[30] Zeng, Yin , 2015. From harvard Bauhaus to the Texas: rangers the legacy of Colin Rowe. Architect (4), 36- 47.

[31] Zhai, J. , 2010. Scape city on the basis of landscape urbanism. Architectural Journal (11), 6- 11.

[32] Zhao, S. , Wu, D. , Zhou, K. , 2021. Infiltrate and appear: binary discrimination of landscape realistic space and consciousness space from the transparency perspective. Landscape Architecture 28 (6), 114- 120.

[33] Zhou, X. , Liu, Z. , Shi, J. , 2022. Evaluation on visual landscape perception under the support of digital footprint: a case study of historic urban landscape of the Qinhuai river area. Landscape Architecture 9, 18- 25.

RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS

2024 The Author(s). Publishing services by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Higher Education Press and KeAi.

审图号：GS京（2025）0467号